Poland-Belarus Conflict: War On The Horizon?

Tensions between Poland and Belarus have been rising in recent years, with both countries deploying troops to their shared border. Poland has accused Belarus of engaging in 'hybrid warfare by sending increasing numbers of migrants to their shared border. In 2022, Poland began constructing a steel wall along the Belarus border, which was completed in June of that year. The crisis has raised concerns among European defense leaders about the potential for military escalation. While there have been no official declarations of war, the situation remains volatile and has the potential to escalate further.

The migrant crisis at the Belarus-Poland border

In November 2021, a migrant crisis emerged at the Belarus-Poland border, with thousands of migrants from the Middle East attempting to cross into Poland from Belarus. This crisis sparked fears of a potential violent conflict, with defence leaders warning of the possibility of escalation.

The Situation at the Border

At the height of the crisis, around 2,000 migrants were camped in freezing temperatures at the Belarus-Poland border, unable to enter Poland and not allowed to turn back. This situation was described by EU officials as a "hybrid attack" against the bloc, combining political and military elements. The migrants were stranded between two borders, enduring freezing weather in makeshift camps. Poland reported at least seven migrant deaths during the crisis, and other migrants expressed fears for their lives.

Regional Tensions and Accusations

The crisis occurred against a backdrop of rising tensions in the region. Lithuania, Estonia, and Latvia accused Belarus of deliberately escalating the situation, posing a serious threat to European security. They warned that the crisis could spill over into the military domain and called for a joint response. In response, Belarus threatened retaliation, including the potential shutdown of the transit of Russian natural gas through its territory.

Polish authorities accused migrants of throwing rocks and branches at border guards and attempting to break down a razor wire fence. Meanwhile, Belarus alleged that there were attempts to transfer weapons to the migrants, although no evidence was provided to support this claim.

International Reactions

The EU accused Belarusian President Alexander Lukashenko of manufacturing the crisis in revenge for earlier sanctions imposed due to a violent crackdown on protests in 2020. Germany's then-Finance Minister Olaf Scholz, who later became chancellor, described Lukashenko as making an "inhumane power play with people." Lukashenko and Russia countered that the EU was not upholding its humanitarian values by preventing migrants from crossing.

The crisis also prompted discussions among European defence leaders about the potential role of NATO in the situation. While some argued that NATO should not get involved due to the risk of escalation, others suggested that the alliance could provide valuable resources and surveillance capabilities.

The possibility of NATO involvement

However, the situation is complicated by the fact that Belarus is closely allied with Russia, which has nuclear capabilities and has previously invaded Ukraine with Belarus's support. In the event of a conflict between Poland and Belarus, there is a risk that Russia could intervene on Belarus's behalf, leading to a larger-scale conflict. This possibility has been acknowledged by both Belarusian and NATO officials, with Belarusian leader Alexander Lukashenko stating that he would request Russian nuclear weapons if NATO moved to bring them to Poland.

The potential for escalation is a significant concern, and some defence officials have cautioned against bringing NATO into the conflict, as it adds a military dimension that could lead to dangerous consequences. Instead, it has been suggested that the focus should be on providing Poland with logistical and resource support, while also imposing sanctions on Belarus to address the migrant crisis.

Overall, while NATO involvement in a conflict between Poland and Belarus is possible, particularly if Poland is attacked, the potential for escalation and the involvement of Russia make this a highly complex and risky scenario.

The threat of global conflict

The migrant crisis at the Belarus-Poland border has led to a tense standoff between the two countries, with thousands of migrants stranded in freezing temperatures, unable to enter Poland and not allowed to turn back. This has been labelled a "hybrid attack" by EU officials, who accuse Belarus of deliberately escalating the situation in retaliation for sanctions. The potential for escalation is extremely high, and while some defence officials believe a low-intensity conflict is more likely, others warn that the involvement of NATO could lead to dangerous territory.

The crisis has also brought Poland and Russia to the brink of conflict, with Russia massing troops and military equipment on its border with Ukraine. Poland, a member of NATO and the EU, has taken an anti-Russian stance, and has been a leading voice in calling for increased defence spending within the alliance. In response, Russia has declared that a new US ballistic missile defence base in Poland will increase the overall level of nuclear danger.

The situation has led to fears of a potential global conflict, with Ukraine's former military chief warning that World War III has already begun, and that Ukraine is now facing not only Russia but also soldiers from North Korea. Serbian President Aleksandar Vucic, an ally of Russian President Vladimir Putin, has added to these concerns by stating that Putin is "not bluffing" about the potential use of nuclear missiles.

With tensions running high and the involvement of multiple countries and alliances, the threat of global conflict is indeed a serious and real concern.

Belarus's retaliation to sanctions

Belarus has been hit with sanctions by the US, the EU, the UK, Canada, and Japan due to its involvement in the Russian invasion of Ukraine. These sanctions have targeted Belarusian military industrial companies and generals, as well as airlines and officials assisting in the migrant scheme.

In retaliation to these sanctions, Belarus has allowed Russia to station nuclear weapons on its territory. In March 2023, Putin announced that Russia would station tactical nuclear weapons in Belarus under a nuclear sharing agreement. This move has been condemned by the Belarusian opposition leader, Sviatlana Tsikhanouskaya, and the Ukrainian president, Volodymyr Zelenskyy.

Additionally, Belarus has continued to support Russia's invasion of Ukraine. In August 2024, Belarus announced the transfer of military equipment and special forces to areas bordering Ukraine. This move was seen as an attempt to help Russia and distract the Ukrainian command. Belarus has also deployed around a third of its army to the border with Ukraine, with additional forces being transferred, including air defence, aircraft, and weapons storage.

Furthermore, Belarus has been accused of involvement in war crimes, particularly in the forced transfers of Ukrainian children to Belarus. These actions have been condemned by the international community, and several individuals and organizations from Belarus have been sanctioned for their involvement in these abuses.

The role of Russia

Russia's role in the ongoing conflict between Poland and Belarus is complex and multifaceted. As a close ally and eastern neighbour of Belarus, Russia has been implicated in the tensions along the Poland-Belarus border. Here is an examination of Russia's role in the conflict:

Military Drills and Border Crisis: Russia has conducted military drills with Belarus near the Ukrainian border, and there are reports of Russian troops remaining in Belarus even after the drills concluded. This has contributed to the border crisis between Poland and Belarus, with Poland accusing Belarus of engaging in hybrid warfare. Russia's presence in Belarus has heightened tensions and raised concerns about a potential military conflict.

Russian Invasion of Ukraine: Russia's invasion of Ukraine has had a significant impact on the dynamics between Poland and Belarus. Belarus allowed Russian forces to use its territory to launch attacks on Ukraine, providing Russia with a strategic advantage. This has strained relations with Poland, a NATO member and strong supporter of Ukraine.

Geopolitical Dynamics: The conflict between Poland and Belarus is influenced by their differing geopolitical alignments. Poland, as a member of NATO and the European Union, has an anti-Russian stance. In contrast, Belarus has long been firmly pro-Russia. This divide has contributed to the deterioration of diplomatic relations between the two countries.

Migration Crisis: The migration crisis at the Belarus-Poland border has been described as a "hybrid attack" by EU officials, with allegations that Belarus is orchestrating the plot to send migrants to the EU's borders. This crisis has further escalated tensions and raised concerns about a potential escalation of violence.

Nuclear Weapons: There are speculations about the presence of Russian nuclear weaponry in Belarus. Belarus revoked its neutral and non-nuclear status in a 2022 constitutional referendum, and there are fears that Russia could station nuclear weapons in Belarus, particularly if NATO moves to bring nuclear weapons to Poland or Lithuania.

Sanctions: Belarus has faced sanctions from Western countries, including the UK, the European Union, the United States, Canada, and Japan, due to its involvement in the Russian invasion of Ukraine and its close alliance with Russia. These sanctions have targeted individuals, entities, and industries in Belarus.

Belarusian Opposition: The Belarusian opposition has been critical of the country's involvement in the Russia-Ukraine conflict and has received support from Poland. This has further strained relations between Poland and Belarus, as President Lukashenko has accused Poland of supporting the opposition.

In summary, Russia's role in the conflict between Poland and Belarus is multifaceted. Russia's military presence in Belarus, its invasion of Ukraine, and its close alliance with Belarus have all contributed to escalating tensions and raising the possibility of a wider conflict. The geopolitical dynamics, migration crisis, nuclear weapons considerations, and sanctions have further complicated the situation.

Frequently asked questions