Market Economy In Belarus: Fact Or Fiction?

Belarus has a mixed economy, with a well-developed manufacturing industry, services sector, and agricultural base. After the collapse of the Soviet Union, Belarus retained its industrial base, which is now outdated, energy inefficient, and heavily dependent on subsidised Russian energy and preferential access to Russian markets. Belarus has pursued a gradual transition path, characterised by limited structural reforms and a modest expansion of the private sector. The country adheres to the concept of a socially-oriented market economy, which has proven its viability and efficiency.

Belarus's mixed economy

Belarus has an upper-middle-income, mixed economy. As a post-Soviet transition economy, Belarus has retained centralised political and economic controls by the state, rejecting most privatisation efforts. It has been described as a welfare state or market socialist. Belarus is the world's 74th-largest economy by GDP and ranks 60th out of 191 countries on the Human Development Index.

The country has a well-developed manufacturing industry, services sector and agriculture. Belarus has an efficient health system, a very low infant mortality rate, a high rate of doctors per capita and a literacy rate of 99%.

Since its independence, Belarus has pursued a gradual transition path, characterised by limited structural reforms and a modest expansion of the private sector. Belarus has retained closer political and economic ties to Russia than other former Soviet republics.

The country's economy is export-oriented, with exports including machinery and equipment, mineral products, chemicals, metals, textiles and foodstuffs. Its main export market is Russia, followed by Ukraine, Poland and Germany.

Belarus has six free economic zones (FEZ) with a simpler and lower tax and regulatory pattern than elsewhere in the country. To become an FEZ resident, an investor needs to make a minimum investment of €1 million, or at least €500,000 over three years, as well as engage in the production of import-substituting products or goods for export.

The country also has a High Technology Park (HTP) with beneficial tax preferences for residents, including exemptions from VAT and corporate profit tax on the sale of goods or services.

The country's export-oriented nature

Belarus is an export-oriented country with a well-developed manufacturing industry, services sector, and agriculture. The country's export-oriented nature is reflected in its economic policies and performance, with exports playing a crucial role in its development and growth. Here are some key aspects of Belarus' export-oriented nature:

Manufacturing and Industrial Base:

Belarus has a relatively well-developed industrial base that contributes significantly to its exports. The country has a history of manufacturing and industrial activity, producing a range of goods such as machinery, tractors, trucks, synthetic fibers, fertilizers, textiles, and household appliances. The manufacturing sector is a key driver of economic growth and a significant source of export revenue.

Agricultural Sector:

Belarus also has a broad agricultural base, which plays a vital role in its export-oriented nature. The country produces and exports various agricultural products, including grain, potatoes, vegetables, sugar beets, flax, beef, and milk. While the agricultural sector faces challenges due to inefficiencies and dependence on government subsidies, it still contributes significantly to the country's exports.

Trade Partners and Export Destinations:

Belarus's export-oriented nature is evident in its trade relationships and export destinations. Russia is the country's largest trading partner and export market, accounting for a significant portion of Belarus's exports. Other important export destinations include Ukraine, the United Kingdom, Germany, and other European and global markets. The country's exports are diverse and cater to a wide range of industries and consumers.

Economic Growth and Development:

The export-oriented nature of Belarus has contributed to its economic growth and development. High rates of economic growth during the 2003–2013 period were accompanied by a reduction in poverty and an increase in household income. Exports, particularly in the manufacturing and agricultural sectors, have been a key driver of this growth. Belarus's exports also helped the country mitigate the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, with relatively less severe economic effects compared to other European countries.

Foreign Investment and Special Economic Zones:

Belarus has recognized the importance of foreign investment in its export-oriented economy. The country has established several special economic zones, such as the China-Belarus "Great Stone" industrial park and six free economic zones across its regions. These zones offer incentives and preferential treatments to attract foreign investment, fostering the development of new industries and promoting exports.

International Trade and Agreements:

Belarus actively engages in international trade and is a member of various economic unions and agreements. It is a part of the Eurasian Economic Union (EAEU) and has preferential trade agreements with other countries. Belarus also participates in organizations like the World Trade Organization (WTO) and the World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO), which facilitate its integration into global markets and promote its export-oriented nature.

The role of the state in the economy

Belarus has a mixed economy, with a strong emphasis on centralised political and economic controls by the state. The country has a highly centralised economy that focuses on full employment and a dominant public sector.

The state plays a significant role in the economy of Belarus, with about 80% of all industries remaining in state hands. The government has rejected most privatisation efforts, instead choosing to maintain control over key industries. State-owned enterprises (SOEs) dominate the economy in terms of value, and the state controls more than 70% of all stocks in the country.

The Belarusian government has implemented policies that favour SOEs, such as providing them with preferential access to government contracts, subsidised credits, and debt forgiveness. Additionally, SOEs have preferential access to land and raw materials, which are often restricted for private enterprises.

The banking sector is also heavily influenced by the state, with state banks accounting for 75% of the industry. The National Bank of Belarus, which is controlled by the government, plays a crucial role in the country's financial system and has been involved in managing the country's foreign exchange rate.

While Belarus does attract foreign direct investment (FDI), the government has implemented laws and regulations that limit foreign control and ownership. The country has a simplified taxation system for foreign-owned businesses, but foreign investors often face discrimination due to the selective application of existing laws and practices.

The government has also implemented policies to attract FDI, such as the establishment of free economic zones (FEZs) and the High Technology Park (HTP). These zones offer tax incentives, simplified procedures for import-export operations, and other benefits to resident companies.

However, the recent political events, including the fraudulent 2020 presidential election and the subsequent repression of human rights, have led to a deterioration in the business and investment climate in Belarus. International firms and investors have left the country, and Belarus has been subjected to numerous rounds of sanctions by the United States, the European Union, and other organisations.

In response to the exodus of foreign companies and capital, the Belarusian government has passed laws that allow for the seizure of private property and legalise violations of intellectual property rights held by citizens of "unfriendly states". The judicial system in Belarus lacks independence and is largely unable to adjudicate cases objectively, which further deters foreign investment.

Overall, the state plays a significant and controlling role in the economy of Belarus, with the government implementing policies that favour state-owned enterprises and limit foreign investment and ownership.

Belarus's transition to a market economy

Belarus has been transitioning from a planned economy to a market economy since its independence in 1991. However, the country has pursued a gradual transition path, characterised by limited structural reforms and a modest expansion of the private sector.

After its independence, Belarus underwent a burst of capitalist reform from 1991 to 1994, including the privatisation of smaller state enterprises and some service sector businesses, the creation of institutions of private property, and the development of entrepreneurship. However, about 80% of all industry remains in state hands, and non-Russian foreign investment has been hindered by a reluctance to welcome private investment without joint ownership or affiliation with the state.

Since the disintegration of the Soviet Union, Belarus has maintained government control over key industries and rejected the large-scale privatisations seen in other former Soviet republics. The country has a highly centralised economy that emphasises full employment and a dominant public sector. It has been described as a welfare state or market socialist.

The period between 1996 and 2000 was characterised by significant financial distress, particularly in 1998 and 1999, due to the financial and economic crisis in Russia, which resulted in a sharp increase in prices and the devaluation of the national currency, among other issues.

From 2001 to 2005, the national economy demonstrated steady and dynamic growth, with GDP growing at an average rate of 7.4%. This growth was mainly due to the performance of the industrial sector. However, in 2011, Belarus faced another financial crisis triggered by government-directed salary hikes, an increased cost of Russian energy inputs, and an overvalued Belarusian ruble, which led to a nearly threefold devaluation of the currency.

In recent years, Belarus has tightened its macroeconomic policies, allowed more flexibility in its exchange rate, taken steps towards price liberalisation, and reduced subsidised government lending to state-owned enterprises. The country has also been working to attract foreign direct investment and improve its business climate.

While Belarus has made progress in its transition to a market economy, it continues to face challenges, including the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, political unrest, international sanctions, and its facilitation of the Russian invasion of Ukraine.

The impact of sanctions on Belarus's economy

Belarus has an upper-middle-income mixed economy, which has been described as a welfare state or market socialist. It is an export-oriented country with a well-developed manufacturing industry, services sector, and agriculture.

Since the disintegration of the Soviet Union, Belarus has maintained government control over key industries and rejected large-scale privatisation. The country has a highly centralised economy that emphasises full employment and a dominant public sector.

In recent years, Belarus has faced sanctions from the EU, the US, and other countries. These sanctions have been imposed in response to the country's involvement in Russia's invasion of Ukraine, as well as human rights abuses and fraudulent elections. The sanctions have targeted individuals, restricted trade, prohibited transactions with certain banks, and limited financial inflows from Belarus to the EU.

The impact of these sanctions on Belarus's economy has been significant. The country has experienced a sharp decline in trade with the EU and Ukraine, resulting in a recession and a drop in GDP. The banking sector has been particularly affected, with Belarus facing difficulties in dealing in hard currency and defaulting on external debts. The country's credit rating has also suffered as a result.

In response to the sanctions, the Belarusian government has passed laws allowing for the seizure of private property and legalising violations of intellectual property rights held by citizens of "unfriendly states". The government has also engaged in a "parallel import" scheme to evade sanctions by transferring controlled goods to Russia without the manufacturer's knowledge or approval.

The sanctions have made Belarus a less attractive destination for foreign direct investment (FDI), and the country has seen an exodus of international companies and capital. The judicial system's lack of independence and corruption remain significant deterrents to attracting foreign investment.

Overall, the sanctions have had a negative impact on Belarus's economy, leading to a decline in trade, investment, and economic growth. The government's response to the sanctions, including the seizure of private property and violations of intellectual property rights, has further worsened the business and investment climate in the country.

Frequently asked questions