The Afghan Conundrum: Examining The Necessity Of War

The war in Afghanistan was America's longest war and lasted for two decades. It began when U.S. and allied forces invaded the country in October 2001, quickly ousting the Taliban regime following its refusal to hand over terrorist leader Osama bin Laden in the wake of al-Qaeda's 9/11 attacks. The U.S. war efforts aimed to eliminate al-Qaeda, decimate the Taliban movement, and deny all terrorist groups a safe haven in Afghanistan. While there were some improvements in areas such as healthcare, maternal health, and education, the war resulted in heavy casualties and a massive economic toll. The U.S. government spent $837 billion on warfighting and $145 billion on reconstruction efforts, while at least 66,000 Afghan troops and more than 48,000 Afghan civilians were killed. As the U.S. withdrew its troops, the Taliban rapidly seized control, leading to concerns about a rollback of human rights and the potential for Afghanistan to once again become a terrorist safe haven.

The Taliban's resurgence and control of Afghanistan

The Taliban, a Sunni Islamic fundamentalist and predominantly Pashtun movement, controlled most of Afghanistan from 1996 to 2001. In October 2001, U.S. and allied forces invaded the country and quickly ousted the Taliban regime following its refusal to hand over terrorist leader Osama bin Laden in the wake of al-Qaeda’s 9/11 attacks. Following the U.S.-led invasion, Taliban leadership relocated to southern Afghanistan and across the border to Pakistan, from where they waged an insurgency against the Western-backed government in Kabul, Afghan national security forces, and international coalition troops.

The Taliban returned to power in Afghanistan in 2021, two decades after their ouster by U.S. troops. Under their harsh rule, they have cracked down on women’s rights and neglected basic services. The Taliban's return to power has also wiped out gains in Afghans' standards of living that were made over the two decades after the U.S. invasion.

The Taliban's resurgence can be attributed to several factors, including:

• The U.S. government's continuous struggle to develop and implement a coherent strategy for what it hoped to achieve in Afghanistan.
• The U.S. government's consistent underestimation of the amount of time required to rebuild Afghanistan, and the creation of unrealistic timelines and expectations that prioritized spending quickly.
• The U.S. government's failure to ensure the sustainability of the institutions and infrastructure projects it built in Afghanistan.
• The U.S. government's inability to get the right people into the right jobs at the right times.
• The absence of violence as a critical precondition for everything U.S. officials tried to do in Afghanistan.
• The U.S. government's lack of understanding of the Afghan context and failure to tailor its efforts accordingly.
• The U.S. government's failure to conduct sufficient monitoring and evaluation to understand the impact of their efforts in Afghanistan.

The human cost of the war for US troops

The human cost of the war in Afghanistan for US troops has been devastating, with thousands of lives lost and many more left with physical and mental injuries. Since the US invaded Afghanistan in 2001, more than 2,400 American service members have been killed and over 20,000 wounded in action. In addition, thousands of US contractors have died, and the true number is unknown as the Pentagon does not track their deaths.

The war has also taken a significant toll on the mental health of US troops, with many returning home with post-traumatic stress and other mental health issues. The stress of combat and the difficulty of readjusting to civilian life have led to high rates of divorce, substance abuse, and suicide among veterans.

Furthermore, the repeated deployments and extended tours of duty have placed a heavy burden on military families, with spouses and children often struggling to cope with the absence of their loved ones. The financial costs of the war have also been substantial, with the US spending over $2 trillion on combat operations and reconstruction efforts. This has contributed to increased government debt and placed a strain on public finances.

The war in Afghanistan has also had a lasting impact on US society as a whole, shaping foreign policy decisions and influencing public perceptions of the military and veterans. The extended conflict has also led to increased government debt and contributed to economic challenges.

The human toll of the war for US troops is not limited to physical injuries and deaths but also includes the invisible wounds of mental health issues, substance abuse, and post-traumatic stress. The war has also disrupted the lives of military families and placed a financial burden on US taxpayers, with the cost of the war exceeding $2 trillion. The true cost of the war for US troops extends beyond the battlefield and encompasses the wider societal impact on veterans, families, and the nation as a whole.

The impact of the war on Afghan civilians

The war in Afghanistan has had a devastating impact on Afghan civilians. The war has led to the deaths of tens of thousands of civilians, with the Costs of War Project at Brown University estimating that 46,319 Afghan civilians have been killed as a result of the conflict. However, the true death toll may be higher due to deaths from disease, lack of access to food, water, infrastructure, and other indirect consequences of the war. According to the United Nations, civilian casualties in Afghanistan reached a record high of 10,993 in 2018, with civilian deaths and injuries exceeding 10,000 for six consecutive years. The war has also caused mass displacement, with 2.7 million Afghans forced to flee the country and an additional four million internally displaced.

The war has also had severe economic and social consequences for Afghan civilians. Afghanistan's economy has been devastated by the conflict, with 92% of the population facing food insecurity and 3 million children at risk of acute malnutrition. The war has disrupted public health, security, and infrastructure, and left the country contaminated with unexploded ordnance and landmines that continue to kill and injure civilians. The war has also exacerbated existing problems such as poverty, malnutrition, and lack of access to healthcare and clean water, leading to elevated rates of disease and premature death.

In addition to the direct impacts of the war, Afghan civilians have also suffered from the breakdown of governance and the rule of law. The war has fueled corruption and weakened state institutions, making it difficult for the government to provide basic services and protect the rights of its citizens. The war has also contributed to a rise in criminal activity and human rights abuses, with armed groups and militias committing serious abuses, including extrajudicial killings of civilians.

The impact of the war on Afghan women and children has been particularly severe. Women and girls have faced restrictions on their rights and freedoms, including access to education and employment. They have also been vulnerable to gender-based violence and discrimination, with women often bearing the brunt of the economic and social consequences of the war. Children have been among the most vulnerable victims of the war, facing death, injury, displacement, and a lack of access to education and healthcare.

Overall, the war in Afghanistan has had a devastating and far-reaching impact on Afghan civilians, causing death, injury, displacement, economic hardship, and a breakdown of governance and the rule of law. The war has disrupted lives, destroyed families, and left deep scars on Afghan society that will take years to heal.

The role of the US in rebuilding Afghanistan

The United States has played a significant role in rebuilding Afghanistan. Here is a summary of the US's involvement in Afghanistan:

• The US has provided over $145 billion in an attempt to rebuild Afghanistan, its security forces, civilian government institutions, economy, and civil society.
• The US has also spent $837 billion on warfighting, during which 2,443 American troops and 1,144 allied troops have been killed, and 20,666 US troops injured.
• The US has helped to establish a democratic government in Afghanistan, with the first democratically elected head of Afghanistan, Hamid Karzai, being elected in 2004.
• The US has helped to train the Afghan National Army and National Police Force.
• The US has helped to rebuild infrastructure in Afghanistan, including roads, schools, and hospitals.
• The US has provided humanitarian assistance to Afghanistan, including emergency food, shelter, and medical care.
• The US has helped to improve access to education and healthcare for women and girls in Afghanistan.
• The US has supported the development of a free and independent media in Afghanistan.
• The US has supported the creation of a constitution for Afghanistan, which includes a strong presidential system and guarantees of individual freedoms, including freedom of worship and rights for women.
• The US has supported the disarmament, demobilization, and reintegration of militia members in Afghanistan.
• The US has supported counter-narcotics efforts in Afghanistan, including the destruction of poppy crops and opium labs.
• The US has supported the development of a private sector in Afghanistan, including the creation of an Afghan Enterprise Fund to promote job creation and private sector development.
• The US has supported the development of a stable financial system in Afghanistan, including the introduction of a new national currency.
• The US has supported the return of Afghan refugees, with over 2.5 million Afghan refugees returning home since March 2002.

The effectiveness of US counterterrorism efforts

One of the main successes of US counterterrorism efforts in Afghanistan has been the elimination of key terrorist leaders. In August 2022, for example, the US conducted a successful counterterrorism operation in Afghanistan that killed Ayman al-Zawahiri, the leader of al-Qaeda. Al-Zawahiri was a key figure in the planning of the 9/11 attacks and had been a target of the US for many years. This operation demonstrated the US's ability to locate and eliminate high-value targets in Afghanistan.

Another success of US counterterrorism efforts in Afghanistan has been the disruption of terrorist groups and the prevention of attacks. According to the US government, the number of al-Qaeda operatives in Afghanistan has decreased since the US withdrawal in August 2021. Additionally, the US has conducted strikes against ISIS-K, the Islamic State's affiliate in Afghanistan, which has resulted in the death of several key leaders and a reduction in their capabilities.

However, there have also been failures and setbacks in US counterterrorism efforts in Afghanistan. One major setback was the fall of the Afghan government and the return to power of the Taliban in August 2021. The Taliban is known to have close links with several terrorist groups, including al-Qaeda, and has allowed them to establish a presence in the country. This has raised concerns that Afghanistan could once again become a safe haven for terrorists.

Another challenge for US counterterrorism efforts in Afghanistan has been the lack of reliable intelligence and the difficulty of conducting operations without a partner force on the ground. The US has had to rely on aerial platforms and satellites to collect intelligence, which has limited their ability to target terrorist groups effectively. Additionally, the US does not have bases in the region to launch strikes, which has further hampered their efforts.

Overall, the effectiveness of US counterterrorism efforts in Afghanistan has been mixed. While there have been some successes, such as the elimination of key terrorist leaders and the disruption of terrorist groups, there have also been failures and setbacks, such as the fall of the Afghan government and the lack of reliable intelligence. The US will need to continue to adapt its counterterrorism strategy in Afghanistan to effectively counter the terrorist threat.

Frequently asked questions