Sanctioning Belarus: Is It Possible And What Are The Implications?

Sanctions are a tool used by governments to apply pressure on a country, entity, or individual to change their behaviour and comply with legal obligations. They can take many forms, including economic, trade, travel, and diplomatic restrictions. Belarus has faced sanctions from the international community, particularly the European Union, the United Kingdom, and the United States, due to various concerns, including human rights abuses, election fraud, and support for Russia's invasion of Ukraine. These sanctions aim to hold the country accountable and promote democratic principles, respect for human rights, and stability in Europe.

EU sanctions on Belarus

The EU has imposed sanctions on Belarus in response to a range of issues, including the country's involvement in Russia's invasion of Ukraine, human rights abuses, and the erosion of democracy. These sanctions aim to hold the Lukashenka regime accountable for its actions and to promote democratic processes and respect for human rights in Belarus.

The EU's sanctions on Belarus include a range of economic and financial measures, as well as visa restrictions on specific individuals and entities. These sanctions have been implemented through a combination of executive orders, public laws, and regulations. One of the key measures is the blocking of property and interests in property of designated persons and entities, aiming to restrict the Lukashenka regime's access to resources.

The EU has also targeted Belarusian state-owned enterprises, government officials, and military support to Russia. This includes restrictions on transactions involving specific entities, such as the Byelorussian Steel Works Management Company and Belavia Belarusian Airlines. The sanctions also address attempts by Belarus to evade restrictions, including through the designation of Belarusian networks and the targeting of revenue generators for the Lukashenka regime.

In addition to economic and financial sanctions, the EU has also imposed restrictions on the export of luxury goods to Belarus and on specific individuals and entities. The EU has issued licenses for certain activities that would otherwise be prohibited under the sanctions, such as transactions related to civil aviation safety. The EU's sanctions on Belarus are part of a coordinated effort with international partners to promote accountability and respect for international norms.

The legal framework for the EU's sanctions on Belarus includes Executive Order 14038, which blocks the property of additional persons contributing to the situation in Belarus, and Executive Order 13405, which targets persons undermining democratic processes or institutions. These executive orders are implemented through regulations such as the Belarus Sanctions Regulations, which are published in the Federal Register and the Code of Federal Regulations. The International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA) and the National Emergencies Act (NEA) provide additional legal authority for the sanctions.

US sanctions on Belarus

The US has imposed sanctions on Belarus in response to its support for Russia's invasion of Ukraine and the Lukashenka regime's acts of repression and disregard for international norms. The US Department of the Treasury's Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) has taken action against individuals, entities, and aircraft pursuant to Belarus-related Executive Orders. These sanctions target persons involved in supporting Russia's war through military resource production, the transshipment of goods to Russia, sanctions evasion, and revenue generation for Belarusian oligarchs.

The US has also targeted Belarusian manufacturers and suppliers that provide components for weapons and military equipment to Russia. For example, Peleng JSC (Peleng), the leading design enterprise in Belarus's optoelectronic industry, has been designated for operating in the defense and security sectors of Belarus. Other designated companies include LLC Laboratory of Additive Technologies (LAT), OOO Ruchservomotor (Ruchservomotor), and several other manufacturers and suppliers.

In addition to these measures, the US has imposed visa restrictions on regime officials and their affiliates for their involvement in undermining democracy in Belarus. The US Department of State has taken steps to promote accountability for the Lukashenka regime's fraudulent elections and human rights abuses.

The US sanctions on Belarus are implemented through a combination of executive orders issued by the President and public laws passed by Congress. These authorities are further codified by OFAC in its regulations, which are published in the Code of Federal Regulations. Modifications to these regulations are posted in the Federal Register.

The ultimate goal of the US sanctions on Belarus is to hold the Lukashenka regime accountable for its attacks on the Belarusian democratic movement, its exploitation of the Belarusian people, and its support for Russia's invasion of Ukraine. The US, in coordination with its allies and partners, remains committed to bringing about a positive change in behavior from the Lukashenka regime.

UK sanctions on Belarus

The UK has imposed a package of trade, financial, and aviation sanctions on Belarus, in response to the continued undermining of democracy and human rights violations by the Lukashenko regime. These sanctions are implemented through the Republic of Belarus (Sanctions) (EU Exit) Regulations 2019, which aim to encourage the Government of Belarus to respect democratic principles, institutions, and human rights, as well as refrain from actions that repress civil society and threaten peace in Europe.

Aviation Measures

The UK has implemented aviation measures to prevent Belarusian air carriers from overflying or landing in the country. Additionally, there is a prohibition on providing technical assistance to President Lukashenko's fleet of luxury aircraft.

Trade Measures

The sanctions include trade measures on potash, petroleum products, interception and monitoring goods, cigarette manufacturing goods, and dual-use goods and technology. These measures aim to reduce the revenue flowing to the Lukashenko regime and limit its access to items that could be used for internal repression.

Financial Measures

Financial measures prohibit purchases of transferable securities and money-market instruments issued by the Belarusian state and its state-owned banks. This includes a prohibition on the provision of loans and insurance/reinsurance to Belarusian state bodies.

Targeted Individuals

The UK has also designated individuals within the Belarusian regime for sanctions. On 21 June 2021, in coordination with the US, Canada, and the EU, the UK imposed sanctions on 7 individuals and 1 entity in response to the detention of journalist Roman Protasevich and Sofia Sapega following the diversion of a Ryanair flight in May 2021. The UK continues to call for their immediate release, along with other political prisoners held in Belarus.

Impact and Response

The UK foreign ministry has stated that these measures are carefully targeted to build pressure on Lukashenko and those around him, while minimising unintended consequences on the wider Belarusian population. However, Lukashenko has responded defiantly, stating that the UK should "choke on" the sanctions.

Sanctions on Belarus and their impact on trade

Sanctions have been imposed on Belarus by the US and the EU. The US sanctions on Belarus are targeted at the Lukashenka regime, with the US citing human rights abuses, undemocratic processes, and military support to Russia as reasons for the sanctions. The US has also urged for increased vigilance for potential Russian and Belarusian export control evasion attempts.

The EU, on the other hand, has imposed sanctions on Belarus in response to its involvement in the Russian military aggression against Ukraine. These sanctions focus on restricting Belarusian trade operations. The EU has prohibited the import of specific products from Belarus, including wood, cement, iron and steel, and rubber products. Additionally, the EU has banned the export of certain equipment, technology, software, and machinery to Belarus. These restrictions aim to prevent the improvement of Belarus's military and technological capabilities and the development of its defense and security sector.

The impact of these sanctions on Belarus's trade is significant. The import and export prohibitions imposed by the EU directly affect Belarus's ability to trade with the Union, which is a crucial market for Belarusian products. The sanctions also target key industries in Belarus, such as wood, iron and steel, and machinery, which are important sources of revenue for the country.

The US sanctions, while not directly targeting trade, can also have an indirect impact on Belarus's economy and trade. For example, the sanctions on individuals and entities within the Lukashenka regime may disrupt the country's trade networks and financial flows. Additionally, the US sanctions on Russian and Belarusian military officials and the call for vigilance against export control evasion attempts can further hinder Belarus's ability to engage in international trade.

Overall, the sanctions imposed by the US and the EU have far-reaching consequences for Belarus's trade and economy. The restrictions disrupt existing trade relationships, limit market access, and target key industries, ultimately affecting Belarus's ability to conduct business and generate revenue.

Sanctions on Belarus and their impact on immigration

Sanctions on Belarus have been implemented by the European Union and the United States, with the former imposing sanctions in response to Belarus's involvement in the war in Ukraine, and the latter targeting the country's support for Russia and the Lukashenka regime.

European Union Sanctions

The European Union's sanctions on Belarus were initially imposed in 2020 following a rigged presidential election and were stepped up in 2021 due to persistent repression, a forced plane landing, and the orchestration of a migration crisis with the EU. The sanctions were further expanded in February 2022, in response to Belarus's growing involvement in the war in Ukraine. These sanctions include individual, financial, and economic measures.

Impact on Immigration

The specific measures implemented by the EU include import bans in key sectors of the Belarusian economy, such as hydrocarbons, potash, transport, and commodities. These sanctions are designed to target the Belarusian regime and disrupt their revenue streams. While the impact of these sanctions on immigration is not explicitly stated, it is possible that they may have indirect effects. For example, by targeting the transport sector, the sanctions could potentially disrupt travel and migration routes, making it more difficult for individuals to enter or exit Belarus. Additionally, economic sanctions that affect the country's financial stability may influence the decisions of potential migrants, who may seek better economic opportunities elsewhere.

US Sanctions

The United States has also imposed sanctions on Belarus, with a focus on promoting accountability for human rights abuses, targeting military support for Russia, and addressing acts of repression and disregard for international norms by the Lukashenka regime. These sanctions include restrictions on transactions with certain individuals and entities, designations of Belarusian networks, and export restrictions.

Impact on Immigration

The US sanctions on Belarus do not appear to have a direct impact on immigration. However, by targeting individuals and entities within the Lukashenka regime, the sanctions may influence the stability and decision-making of the Belarusian government, which could have indirect effects on immigration policies and border control measures. Additionally, the economic sanctions could potentially impact the overall stability of the country, which may, in turn, influence migration patterns.

Frequently asked questions