The Belarus-Poland Border: A Humanitarian Crisis

Thousands of migrants are stranded at the border between Belarus and Poland, trapped in the middle of a diplomatic and humanitarian crisis. The migrants, mostly from the Middle East and Asia, are facing dire conditions, with limited access to food, water, and medical care, as they attempt to cross from Belarus into Poland. The situation has led to a standoff between Europe and Belarus, with accusations that Belarus is turning migrants into pawns in a political game, while Belarus counters that Europe is blocking them from seeking refuge. This crisis has resulted in a humanitarian emergency, with reports of deaths and injuries among the migrants, and tensions continue to escalate between the two sides.

Migrants from the Middle East and Asia are stranded at the Poland-Belarus border

The crisis

The Poland-Belarus border crisis is a diplomatic and humanitarian predicament. It stems from a standoff between Belarus and the EU over the fate of thousands of migrants stranded at the Poland-Belarus border. Tensions between Europe and Belarus are escalating as people try to cross from Belarus into Poland.

The migrants

The impact

The impact of the crisis has been devastating, with at least 13 people reported to have died due to exposure to the cold, including a one-year-old Syrian boy. People have also been injured from being forced over barbed wire fences, and there have been reports of hypothermia and other health issues. The situation is likely to deteriorate further as temperatures drop, making more fatalities extremely likely.

The response

The response to the crisis has been mixed. The EU, Poland, and Belarus have all been criticised for their handling of the situation. The EU and Poland have been accused of denying migrants access to humanitarian aid and legal services, while Belarus has been accused of encouraging migrants to cross the border and using them as pawns in a political game. However, Belarus has denied these accusations.

The way forward

The IRC and other humanitarian organisations have called for immediate action to be taken to help the migrants. They have urged all countries involved to provide food, shelter, and aid, end illegal pushbacks, and uphold the right to asylum. They have also emphasised the need for humane treatment of migrants and refugees, and for all countries to work together to de-escalate the situation.

Poland refuses to let migrants cross the border, citing national security

Poland has refused to let migrants cross its border with Belarus, citing national security. The situation has led to a diplomatic and humanitarian crisis, with thousands of migrants stranded in harsh conditions.

The crisis appears to be stoked by the leader of Belarus, Alexander Lukashenko, over the country's tensions with the European Union (EU). Lukashenko has been accused of facilitating the influx of migrants in retaliation against sanctions imposed by the EU. In response, Poland has deployed troops to the border, erected a razor-wire fence, and passed a law allowing border guards to expel migrants who cross the border illegally and refuse asylum applications.

The EU has accused Lukashenko of turning migrants into pawns in a standoff with the union. Meanwhile, Belarus claims that Europe is blocking migrants from seeking refuge and turning its back on a growing humanitarian crisis. This has resulted in a stalemate, with both sides refusing to take responsibility for providing protection to the migrants.

The situation on the ground is dire, with limited access to food, water, shelter, and medical care. Temperatures have dipped below freezing, and at least 13 people have died, including a one-year-old Syrian boy. Humanitarian agencies are being prevented from accessing the area, and there are concerns that more fatalities are likely as winter approaches.

Poland's response to the crisis has been criticised by human rights groups and the EU. The country's actions violate international law, which states that anyone seeking international protection must be given access to the asylum process, even if they have crossed a border illegally. Despite this, Poland has continued to push back migrants, with border guards using water cannons and tear gas to turn away stone-throwing migrants.

The crisis at the Belarus-Poland border has become the biggest challenge to the EU's borders in years and has led to a diplomatic standoff between the two countries. It remains to be seen how the situation will be resolved, but with lives at stake, there are increasing calls for a swift de-escalation and humane treatment of migrants and refugees.

Belarus is accused of manufacturing the crisis to retaliate against EU sanctions

The migrant crisis on the Belarus-Poland border has been described as a "hybrid war" by the EU's top diplomat, Josep Borrell. Belarus has been accused of manufacturing the crisis to retaliate against EU sanctions, with the country's authoritarian leader, Alexander Lukashenko, allegedly orchestrating a scheme to entice migrants with the false promise of easy entry to the EU.

In August 2021, the Belarusian government began coordinating an influx of migrants, mostly from the Middle East and North Africa, to the borders of Poland, Lithuania, and Latvia. While Belarus denied involvement, the EU and independent observers viewed it as a form of hybrid warfare in response to the deterioration of Belarus-EU relations. This deterioration followed the disputed 2020 Belarusian presidential election, which resulted in Lukashenko's reelection to a sixth term, and the violent crackdown on subsequent protests.

The EU imposed sanctions on Belarusian officials in response to the alleged electoral fraud and the repression of protests. The situation escalated further when, in May 2021, Belarus intercepted a Polish commercial airplane and arrested opposition activist and journalist Roman Protasevich and his girlfriend, Sofia Sapega. This incident prompted additional sanctions from the US, EU, UK, and Canada, targeting members of the Belarusian government and state-owned companies.

In July 2021, Lukashenko threatened to "flood" the EU with "drugs and migrants." Belarusian authorities, state-controlled travel agencies, and airlines operating in the Middle East began promoting tours to Belarus and falsely advertising easy entry into the EU. Migrants who arrived in Belarus were provided with instructions on how to cross the EU border and what to tell border guards. Belarus has been accused of providing tools such as wire cutters and axes to cut through border barriers and even preventing failed crossers from returning to their home countries.

The EU has accused Lukashenko of using migrants as pawns in a game of blackmail, attempting to retaliate against EU sanctions and divert attention from human rights abuses within Belarus. Lukashenko has denied these accusations, calling them "absurd." However, the timing and nature of the migrant crisis suggest a deliberate strategy by the Belarusian government to exert pressure on the EU and undermine its security.

The crisis has resulted in a dire humanitarian situation, with thousands of migrants stranded in freezing temperatures, lacking adequate food, water, shelter, and medical care. Both Belarus and Poland have been criticized for their handling of the situation, with Poland denying access to humanitarian agencies and illegally denying migrants the right to seek asylum.

Poland's government is criticised for its nationalist rhetoric

Poland's government, the nationalist conservative Law and Justice (PiS) party, has been criticised for its nationalist rhetoric. The party's leader, Jaroslaw Kaczynski, has been accused of using anti-German sentiment as an electoral tactic in the upcoming 2024 elections. Critics argue that this rhetoric could damage Poland's relations with its Western allies and risk creating divisions at a time when unity is crucial due to Russia's war in Ukraine.

In the past, the PiS government has been criticised for its far-right ideology, including xenophobic and nationalist sentiments. The party has been accused of appeasing far-right groups and disbanding bodies that addressed racial discrimination and xenophobia. There have been reports of hate crimes targeting Poland's Muslim minority, fuelled by right-wing populist parties and organisations. Additionally, politicians from the PiS party have made racist and anti-Muslim comments during the European migrant crisis. For example, in 2015, Jarosław Kaczyński claimed that Poland "can't" accept any refugees because "they could spread infectious diseases."

The PiS government has also been criticised for its tough stance on abortion laws and politicising the courts, which have been described as a threat to democratic norms. The European Union has blocked billions of euros in funding to Poland due to what it views as democratic backsliding under the conservative party.

Humanitarian groups accuse Poland of violating the international right to asylum

The situation at the Belarus-Poland border has led to a diplomatic and humanitarian crisis. Thousands of refugees and migrants from countries including Iraq, Syria, and Afghanistan are stranded at the border between Belarus and Poland, amid growing political tensions. They are unable to seek asylum in neighboring countries or return to their home countries.

Humanitarian groups have accused Poland of violating the international right to asylum. In October 2024, the Polish parliament adopted a controversial amendment that allows authorities to dismiss asylum applications. The move has been criticized by the EU Commission, humanitarian agencies, and members of the European Parliament. Poland's leader, Prime Minister Donald Tusk, defended the plan to suspend the right to asylum, stating that it is their "right and duty to protect the Polish and European border."

However, humanitarian groups argue that fundamental rights must be respected. Amnesty International called Poland's plans to suspend the right to seek asylum "flagrantly unlawful." They stated that "EU member states like Poland are playing politics with the rights of refugees and migrants." They also emphasized that Poland is obligated to uphold human rights, including the right to asylum, as protected by the EU Charter on Fundamental Rights.

The International Rescue Committee (IRC) also criticized Poland's response, stating that meeting people at the border with violence and illegally denying them the right to seek asylum violates European and international law. They urged all countries involved to immediately cease using human beings as political leverage and to guarantee the humane treatment of migrants and refugees.

The situation at the Belarus-Poland border has resulted in a dire humanitarian crisis, with people stranded without adequate food, shelter, and medical care. As temperatures continue to drop, the conditions are likely to deteriorate further, putting more lives at risk.

Frequently asked questions