Challenges Facing Bolivia: Economy, Politics, And Social Issues

Bolivia is a landlocked country in central South America with a diverse geography and a multiethnic population. It is one of the poorest countries in Latin America, with significant disparities between its regions. Bolivia has been governed by democratically elected governments since 1982, but it has faced a series of political and economic challenges in recent years.

One of the main challenges facing Bolivia is the need to address important structural issues to consolidate stability, promote private sector development, and protect its vulnerable population. The country has a history of economic instability, with high public debt, declining natural gas production, and limited international reserves. Bolivia's economy is heavily dependent on the export of natural resources, particularly hydrocarbons, and it has struggled to diversify its exports and production.

Another challenge for Bolivia is the need to improve its judicial system and address issues of corruption and political interference. The country has a weak and inefficient judiciary, and there have been allegations of judicial weaponization for political prosecution. Additionally, Bolivia has struggled with issues of violence and human rights violations, particularly during periods of political unrest.

Bolivia also faces challenges related to climate change, as it is vulnerable to natural disasters and has a high rate of deforestation. The country needs to balance its economic development with environmental protection and address the social and environmental impacts of its resource-based development model.

Furthermore, Bolivia has a high rate of poverty and inequality, and it needs to improve access to education, health care, and other social services for its population. The country has made some progress in reducing poverty and improving social indicators, but more needs to be done to address these issues.

Finally, Bolivia has struggled with political polarization and instability, with frequent changes in government and internal conflicts within political parties. The country needs to find a way to bridge its social and political divisions and promote consensus-building to achieve stability and effective governance.

Political instability and social unrest

Bolivia has faced political instability and social unrest since the 2019 elections, which were disputed and led to the resignation of President Evo Morales. Morales' Movement for Socialism (MAS) party returned to power in 2020 with the election of Luis Arce as president, but the country remains politically and socially divided. MAS is positioned on the left, while a diffuse right-wing faction has grown in influence, particularly in the southeastern lowlands (known as the Media Luna). The election of Luis Fernando Camacho as governor of Santa Cruz has further heightened the polarisation.

The political crisis in Bolivia has been characterised by violent clashes between pro- and anti-MAS groups, with both sides willing to use violence to achieve their goals. The interim government of Jeanine Áñez, which replaced Morales, was also met with protests and accusations of human rights abuses, including the use of excessive force by security forces.

The current Arce administration has been accused of persecuting political and social leaders, with a particular focus on opponents from the Santa Cruz region. The government has also faced criticism for its handling of the justice system, with concerns about a lack of independence and the weaponisation of the judiciary as a tool for political prosecution.

The deep-seated social and political divisions in Bolivia have been exacerbated by economic challenges, including high deficits, low reserves, and overdependence on primary commodity exports. The country's heavy reliance on natural gas exports has made it vulnerable to external shocks, such as the global economic slowdown and the conflict between Russia and Ukraine.

The combination of political instability, social unrest, and economic challenges has created a challenging environment for doing business in Bolivia. The country's weak judicial system, complicated regulatory environment, and political pressures have adversely affected the private sector. Additionally, the growing fiscal deficit and unsustainable fuel import subsidies have further contributed to economic instability.

Economic challenges and dependence on primary commodity exports

Bolivia's economy is heavily reliant on the export of primary commodities, particularly hydrocarbons, metals, and grains. This dependence leaves the country vulnerable to fluctuations in global demand and prices. The country's economic challenges are further exacerbated by high deficits, low reserves, and an overvalued exchange rate.

Bolivia's economic woes can be traced back to the decline in export income following the end of the commodities boom in 2014. The situation was compounded by a fall in the international reserves, which halved between 2014 and 2019. This depletion of reserves was financed by increasing external debt, which stood at $15.4 billion in 2021.

The Bolivian economy is also highly vulnerable to external shocks, such as the COVID-19 pandemic and the conflict between Russia and Ukraine, which have slowed the global economy. Additionally, the country's economic growth is constrained by a lack of diversification in exports and production. Efforts to industrialize and reduce dependence on commodity exports have yielded limited results.

The government has attempted to address these challenges by promoting public investment and state-led development. However, these efforts have been criticized for their impact on the fiscal deficit, which has remained close to 7.5% of GDP since 2015. The current account deficit has also been significant, averaging over 5% of GDP during the same period.

To improve the economic situation, experts suggest that Bolivia's next government will need to take decisive actions to narrow the fiscal deficit, redress external accounts, and adjust domestic prices of heavily subsidized fuels. There is also a need to strengthen institutions, improve the business climate, and promote diversification to achieve long-term economic growth and ensure equity.

Judicial reform and independence

Bolivia's judicial system has been marred by political interference for years. The country's justice system is in dire need of reform and independence from political influence, which has resulted in a lack of public trust.

The 2009 constitution, implemented during Evo Morales' presidency, empowered voters to elect high court judges from lists created by the Plurinational Assembly. However, this process was manipulated by Morales' party, the Movement Towards Socialism (MAS), which packed the lists with its supporters. This resulted in a lack of independence and the perception of judges as being aligned with the government.

The issue of judicial independence has persisted under subsequent administrations. During the interim government of Jeanine Áñez (November 2019 - November 2020), politically motivated charges were brought against opponents, and the independence of the judiciary was further eroded.

The current administration of Luis Arce (November 2020 - present) initially took steps towards reform by establishing a commission of experts to propose changes. However, these efforts were undermined by a controversial amnesty decree in February 2021, which was seen as favouring impunity for supporters of the government.

The Bolivian judiciary continues to face challenges, including a high proportion of "temporary" judges and prosecutors (around 80%), who may be more susceptible to political pressure to retain their positions. There is also a lack of institutional strengthening, with issues such as rule of law and central bank independence being neglected.

The country's economic situation, characterised by high deficits, low reserves, and overdependence on primary commodity exports, further complicates the need for judicial reform. A robust and independent judiciary is essential to attract investment and improve the business climate, which could help diversify the economy and promote equity.

Overall, the lack of judicial independence and reform in Bolivia has been a significant challenge, impacting public trust and the country's economic development.

Human rights violations and violence against women and girls

Bolivia has a long history of human rights violations, with a particular focus on violence against women and girls. Despite a 2013 law establishing comprehensive measures to prevent and prosecute gender-based violence, women and girls remain at high risk. This law created the crime of femicide, which is the killing of a woman under certain circumstances, including domestic violence.

The Attorney General's Office reported 117 femicides in 2019 and 86 between January and September 2020. In addition, there were over 20,000 cases of violence against women from January through August 2020.

The COVID-19 pandemic has disproportionately affected Bolivian women, who earn 30% less than men on average. They are overrepresented in the informal sector and bore the brunt of increased caregiving responsibilities during the pandemic. The interim government's COVID-19 aid programs did not adequately address the needs of women, especially in rural areas.

Indigenous women in Bolivia also face specific challenges. They have been disproportionately affected by unregulated mining and have experienced attacks and intimidation by government sympathizers.

The issue of violence against women in Bolivia is deeply rooted and pervasive, with a lack of institutional capacity and political will to address it effectively. However, there have been some positive developments, such as the creation of shelters for women and special prosecutors and courts for gender-based crimes.

Environmental concerns and climate change

Bolivia is especially vulnerable to the negative consequences of climate change. Twenty percent of the world's tropical glaciers are located within the country, and are more sensitive to change in temperature due to the tropical climate they are located in. Temperatures in the Andes increased by 0.1 °C per decade from 1939 to 1998, and more recently the rate of increase has tripled (to 0.33 °C per decade from 1980 to 2005), causing glaciers to recede at an accelerated pace and create unforeseen water shortages in Andean agricultural towns. Farmers have taken to temporary city jobs when there is poor yield for their crops, while others have started permanently leaving the agricultural sector and are migrating to nearby towns for other forms of work; some view these migrants as the first generation of climate refugees. Cities that are neighbouring agricultural land, like El Alto, face the challenge of providing services to the influx of new migrants; because there is no alternative water source, the city's water source is now being constricted.

Bolivia's government and other agencies have acknowledged the need to instill new policies battling the effects of climate change. The World Bank has provided funding through the Climate Investment Funds (CIF) and are using the Pilot Program for Climate Resilience (PPCR II) to construct new irrigation systems, protect riverbanks and basins, and work on building water resources with the help of indigenous communities.

Bolivia is also vulnerable to climate-related disasters such as the drought currently affecting several regions around the country and the ongoing El Niño event expected to last at least until April 2024.

Frequently asked questions