Battalion Presence In Afghanistan: Examining The Numbers

The number of battalions in Afghanistan has varied over time, depending on the military and political situation in the country. In May 2009, President Obama ordered a surge of 21,000 troops to Afghanistan, including the 2nd Battalion, 8th Regiment, known as America's Battalion. The UK also had battalions stationed in Afghanistan as part of the NATO-led Resolute Support mission, which aimed to train, advise, and assist Afghan security forces. In August 2021, the US and its allies evacuated their personnel from Afghanistan as the security situation deteriorated, marking the end of a nearly 20-year military presence in the country.

The US and NATO's withdrawal from Afghanistan in 2021

In February 2020, the Trump administration and the Taliban signed the United States-Taliban deal in Doha, Qatar, which stipulated fighting restrictions for both the US and the Taliban and provided for the withdrawal of all NATO forces from Afghanistan by May 2021. In April 2021, NATO Foreign and Defence ministers decided to withdraw all Allied troops from Afghanistan within a few months. The US also decided to withdraw its remaining troops by September 2021.

The withdrawal of US and NATO troops from Afghanistan was carried out amid escalating violence in the country. The Taliban had launched a major offensive against the Afghan National Defence and Security Forces, capturing several strategic locations. The US military had been supporting the Afghan forces with airstrikes against Taliban targets. However, the speed at which the Taliban took over territories and the rapidly deteriorating security situation in Afghanistan prompted the US and other NATO countries to evacuate their embassy staff and citizens.

The US and NATO allies had invested billions of dollars in Afghanistan over the last two decades. The US spent more than $2 trillion, with about half of this sum going towards the US Army. The withdrawal of international forces from Afghanistan raised concerns about the future of the country and the potential resurgence of terrorism. The Taliban's return to power was celebrated by white nationalists and extremists, and experts warned about the recruitment of more terrorists and the planning of attacks on Europe.

The US and NATO's withdrawal from Afghanistan was criticised for the lack of proper planning and coordination. Many NATO allies were unhappy with the decision to withdraw, as they believed it would jeopardise the gains made in the country over the last two decades and empower the Taliban. The evacuation operations at the Kabul airport were chaotic, with each ally running its own operation. The US and NATO's withdrawal also strained transatlantic relations and raised questions about the US commitment to its international security role.

Following the withdrawal, the US and its allies continued to provide diplomatic, humanitarian, and development assistance to Afghanistan. They also provided "over-the-horizon" support to the Afghan National Security Forces from outside the country. However, the future of Afghanistan remains uncertain, with the Taliban imposing strict Sharia law and committing human rights violations.

The Taliban's takeover of Afghanistan

In the two decades since their initial removal from power, the Taliban regrouped and waged an insurgency against the Afghan government and its international allies. Despite billions of dollars spent by the US and its NATO allies to train and equip Afghan security forces, corruption and low morale meant that they were no match for the Taliban. The Taliban's offensive began in earnest in 2021, as the US withdrawal neared completion, and saw them rapidly capture territory and major cities. By August 2021, they had entered the capital, Kabul, and the Afghan government had collapsed, with President Ashraf Ghani fleeing the country.

The Taliban's return to power has had devastating consequences for the people of Afghanistan. The group has imposed a harsh interpretation of Islamic law, restricting the rights of women and girls and cracking down on freedom of expression and religion. The economy has also suffered, with malnutrition soaring and hundreds of thousands of job losses. The humanitarian crisis in the country has been exacerbated by the withdrawal of international aid, with the UN estimating that the number of people in need of assistance increased from 18.4 million in 2022 to nearly 29 million by August 2023.

The Taliban's takeover has also raised concerns among the international community about the country once again becoming a safe haven for terrorist groups, particularly al-Qaeda. The Taliban has historically had close ties with al-Qaeda and provided them with a base of operations in the lead-up to the 9/11 attacks. While the Taliban has pledged not to allow Afghan soil to be used for attacks against other countries, experts remain skeptical, and the US has continued to target al-Qaeda leaders in the country.

The Afghan National Army's collapse

The collapse of the Afghan National Army (ANA) in 2021 was the result of several factors, including low morale, internal distrust, and the loss of US airstrikes and military support. Here is a detailed analysis of the reasons behind the ANA's collapse:

• Loss of US Airstrikes and Military Support: The ANA was heavily reliant on US airstrikes and military support for intelligence, logistics, planning, and other critical areas. When the US decided to withdraw its troops from Afghanistan, the ANA lost this vital assistance, which severely impacted their ability to conduct offensive operations and maintain control over the country.
• Low Morale and Demoralization: The ANA soldiers' morale was low due to various factors, including a lack of support for the families of slain soldiers, inadequate leadership, and widespread corruption. Many soldiers felt that the government did not care about their well-being, which affected their willingness to fight and die for the cause.
• Corruption and Embezzlement: Widespread corruption within the Afghan government and military led to a lack of trust among the troops. Commanders embezzled money by creating "ghost soldiers" and submitting fund requests for salaries of non-existent soldiers. This resulted in unpaid soldiers, while commanders enjoyed lavish lifestyles, further demoralizing the troops.
• Lack of Ideological Cohesion and National Duty: There was a significant mistrust towards the country's political leadership, and Afghan soldiers were not willing to fight and die for President Ashraf Ghani or the government. Conspiracy theories about secret deals between the Afghan government and the Taliban circulated among the troops, creating an environment of doubt and suspicion.
• Taliban's Smart Military Strategy: The Taliban employed a strategic approach by taking control of major border crossings, main highways, and besieging big cities. This crippled the Afghan government's ability to send reinforcements and supplies, forcing many army units to flee or dissolve.
• Incompetent Leadership and Lack of Training: The ANA struggled to find qualified commanders, and those appointed were often incompetent or corrupt. The lack of effective leadership and proper training in basic tasks, such as equipment maintenance and map reading, further contributed to the ANA's collapse.
• Political Interference: Continuous political interference and reshuffling of office holders, including interior and defense ministers, governors, and police chiefs, affected the ANA's performance. The frequent changes in military leadership disrupted the continuity of command and proper functioning of the army.
• Overreliance on US and NATO Troops: Despite receiving years of training and billions of dollars worth of equipment, the ANA never developed the capacity to stand on its own. They were entirely dependent on US and NATO troops to protect urban areas. Once these forces began to withdraw, the ANA was left vulnerable, and their weaknesses were exposed.

The collapse of the ANA had far-reaching consequences, leading to the fall of the Afghan government and the Taliban's capture of Kabul in August 2021. The ANA's disintegration also resulted in the surrender or desertion of many soldiers, with some joining the anti-Taliban resistance forces in the Panjshir Valley.

The Taliban's offensive in 2021

The Taliban's offensive included a continuation of negotiated or paid surrenders from the village level upwards. The Taliban also strategically chose to attack northern provinces, and enjoyed freedom of movement on the main Afghan highways.

The offensive was aided by the Taliban's effective use of online social media, and the support of various other armed militant groups, especially al-Qaeda. The Taliban also enjoyed substantial support from Pakistani militant groups, including Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan, which had about 5,0000 fighters in Afghanistan.

In May, the Taliban captured 15 districts from the Afghan government, including Nirkh and Jalrez districts in Maidan Wardak Province. In June, the Taliban captured 69 districts from the Afghan government, and entered the cities of Kunduz and Puli Khumri.

In July, the Taliban captured 64 districts from the Afghan government and entered the second and third largest cities of Afghanistan, Kandahar and Herat respectively.

On August 6, the Taliban launched an assault on the provincial capitals, with most of the towns surrendering without a fight. On August 13, the Taliban won weeks-long battles in the major cities of Herat, Kandahar and Lashkargah.

On August 15, President Ashraf Ghani fled the country, and the Taliban captured the Afghan capital Kabul with only sporadic resistance. Thus, the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan's government fell, resulting in the de facto takeover of the country and the reinstatement of the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan.

The speed of the Taliban's takeover came as a surprise to many, including the governments of the United States, Russia, and the Taliban themselves.

The US-led invasion of Afghanistan in 2001

The invasion of Afghanistan was dubbed "Operation Enduring Freedom" in US military parlance. The invasion began with an intense bombing campaign by American and British forces, with logistical support from other nations, including France, Germany, Australia, and Canada. The ground invasion was carried out by Northern Alliance forces, with air and ground support from the US and other nations.

The invasion of Afghanistan was the opening salvo in the US "war on terror" and marked the beginning of the longest war in US history. The conflict in Afghanistan spanned two decades and resulted in heavy casualties on all sides. The war ended with the Taliban victory in 2021, which led to the collapse of the Afghan government and the US-led evacuation of Kabul.

Frequently asked questions