The Complex Conflict In Afghanistan: Understanding The War's Evolving Dynamics

The war in Afghanistan was triggered by the September 11 attacks and lasted 20 years, becoming the longest war ever fought by the United States. The conflict consisted of three phases. The first phase was toppling the Taliban, an ultraconservative political and religious faction that ruled Afghanistan and provided sanctuary for al-Qaeda, the perpetrators of the September 11 attacks. The second phase, from 2002 until 2008, was marked by a U.S. strategy of defeating the Taliban militarily and rebuilding core institutions of the Afghan state. The third phase, from 2008, was a turn to classic counterinsurgency doctrine, with a focus on protecting the population from Taliban attacks and reintegrating insurgents into Afghan society. The war resulted in a terrible loss of life, with more than 160,000 Afghan deaths and nearly 8,000 Western deaths.

The Taliban's return to power

The Taliban's resurgence followed the withdrawal of US and UK troops, and the end of NATO's 20-year military campaign in Afghanistan. The Taliban's swift offensive prompted tens of thousands of people to flee their homes, many arriving in Kabul, and others heading to neighbouring countries.

The Taliban's harsh interpretation of Islamic law has also led to a range of human rights abuses, including the killing of opponents, and the beating and detention of journalists and protesters.

The future for Afghans living under Taliban rule remains highly uncertain. While the end of the war has brought relief to many, millions are now struggling to survive, amid a collapsing economy and a lack of access to food and other essentials.

The US-led coalition's evacuation efforts

The evacuation process began in April 2021 when the US and its allies decided to withdraw all troops from Afghanistan by May 2021. The evacuation efforts intensified in August 2021 following the collapse of the Afghan government and the Afghan National Defence and Security Forces. During this period, the US and its allies evacuated more than 120,000 people, including US citizens, US military personnel, and vulnerable Afghans such as interpreters and women leaders.

The evacuation efforts were not limited to US citizens and military personnel. The US and its allies also worked to evacuate Afghans who were at risk due to their collaboration with the US-led coalition or their advocacy for women's rights and other progressive values. These Afghans often faced reprisal attacks from the Taliban and other extremist groups. The US and its allies provided various forms of support to these Afghans, including evacuation to third countries, resettlement in the US or other countries, and assistance with immigration procedures.

The evacuation efforts were coordinated by the US Department of State and the US Department of Homeland Security, in collaboration with other US government agencies and international partners. The US military played a crucial role in securing evacuation routes and protecting evacuees. The evacuation efforts also involved non-governmental organizations and private individuals, who provided support in areas such as legal assistance, housing, and humanitarian aid.

The evacuation process was not without challenges. The US and its allies had to navigate a rapidly deteriorating security situation in Afghanistan, as well as opposition from the Taliban and other extremist groups. There were also logistical challenges, such as coordinating the evacuation of large numbers of people from a war zone and processing their immigration status in their host countries. Despite these challenges, the US and its allies were able to evacuate and resettle tens of thousands of people, demonstrating their commitment to protecting those who collaborated with them during the war and upholding their values.

The role of the Afghan government

Initially, the focus of the war was on overthrowing the Taliban regime, which had provided sanctuary to al-Qaeda, the perpetrators of the 9/11 attacks. This effort was led by the United States and Britain, who partnered with anti-Taliban forces within Afghanistan, including the Northern Alliance and Pashtun tribes led by Hamid Karzai. The Taliban's last stronghold was captured in December 2001, and an interim government was established, led by Karzai.

During this initial phase, the Afghan government, under Karzai, played a crucial role in coordinating with international forces and leading the fight against the Taliban. However, the government was also plagued by corruption and struggled to establish a strong central authority, partly due to Afghanistan's long-standing traditions of regional and local autonomy.

As the war progressed into its second phase, from 2002 to 2008, the focus shifted to defeating the Taliban militarily and rebuilding core institutions of the Afghan state. The United States and its allies provided training and equipment to the Afghan National Army and Police, but these efforts were hampered by ethnic differences and a lack of international support.

By 2005, the Taliban had reasserted its presence and adopted new tactics, such as suicide bombings and IEDs, which caused heavy casualties. The Afghan government, still led by Karzai, struggled to counter the Taliban's growing influence and was criticized for corruption and human rights abuses.

In 2009, with the election of President Barack Obama, the U.S. strategy shifted again to a classic counterinsurgency approach, aiming to protect the population from Taliban attacks and reintegrate insurgents into society. However, this approach also faced challenges, as insurgent attacks and civilian casualties remained high, and the Afghan security forces continued to struggle.

Throughout the war, the Afghan government played a crucial, yet challenging role in maintaining stability and countering the Taliban insurgency. The government was often hampered by corruption, ethnic divisions, and limited resources, which made it difficult to establish a strong central authority and effectively govern the country.

In 2021, with the withdrawal of U.S. and NATO troops, the Afghan government faced its toughest test as the Taliban rapidly advanced and eventually regained control of the country. This raised questions about the legacy of the war and the ability of the Afghan government to secure the country without international support.

The impact on the West

The war in Afghanistan has had a profound impact on the West, shaping an entire generation of policymakers and leaving a lasting mark on the collective conscience. Here are some key ways in which the conflict has affected the West:

Political and Social Impact

The war in Afghanistan has influenced political and social landscapes in Western countries, particularly those that were actively involved in the conflict. The experience of military service in Afghanistan has shaped the perspectives and identities of many individuals who later entered politics and policymaking roles. This first-hand exposure to the complexities of war and its human consequences has likely informed their approach to foreign policy and national security decision-making.

Emotional and Psychological Impact

The withdrawal of Western forces from Afghanistan evoked strong emotions, including anger, grief, and rage, among veterans and civilians alike. The sense of loss and failure associated with the withdrawal was deeply personal for many, reflecting a collective sense of responsibility for the fate of Afghanistan and its people. This emotional response extended beyond those directly involved in the war to the broader civil society in Western nations.

Diplomatic and Strategic Impact

The war in Afghanistan also had significant diplomatic and strategic implications for the West. The invocation of NATO's mutual defence clause (Article 5) following the 9/11 attacks united Western allies in a collective effort to combat international terrorism. However, the eventual withdrawal of US and NATO forces laid bare the limitations of multilateralism and raised questions about the effectiveness of organisations like the UN, G7, EU, and NATO in addressing complex global challenges.

Financial Impact

The financial cost of the war was substantial, with the US alone estimating its expenditure in the region of $2 trillion. This massive investment diverted resources from other domestic and foreign policy priorities, shaping budgetary decisions and influencing economic policies in Western nations.

Impact on Gender Equality and Civil Society

While the war caused immense suffering, it also brought about some positive changes in Afghanistan. Women's lives were immeasurably improved, and an educated and globally connected Afghan civil society emerged. These developments challenged traditional gender norms and empowered a new generation to advocate for democratic values and human rights. These shifts in Afghan society influenced Western perceptions and approaches to gender equality and civil society development in post-conflict settings.

The future of Afghanistan

Security

The security situation in Afghanistan remains precarious. The Taliban's control over the country is not yet fully established, and there are reports of ongoing clashes between the Taliban and resistance forces. The Islamic State group also poses a threat, having claimed responsibility for several deadly attacks in recent months.

Economic Development

Afghanistan's economy is in a dire state, with high unemployment and poverty rates. The country relies heavily on foreign aid, which has been suspended since the Taliban's takeover. The international community has pledged to provide humanitarian assistance, but it is unclear if this will be sufficient to address the country's needs.

Political Reconciliation

Political reconciliation is a key challenge for Afghanistan. The Taliban have formed an interim government that includes some non-Taliban figures, but it does not represent the country's ethnic and religious diversity. There are also concerns about the Taliban's commitment to human rights, particularly regarding women and girls' access to education and work.

The Role of the International Community

The international community has a crucial role to play in Afghanistan's future. Providing humanitarian and development assistance, supporting political reconciliation, and promoting good governance are essential. However, there are differing views on how to engage with the Taliban, with some countries calling for conditional engagement, while others advocate for a more pragmatic approach.

Frequently asked questions