Switzerland And Austria: A History Of Conflict And War

Switzerland has a long history of neutrality, with the earliest moves towards this policy dating back to 1515 when the Swiss Confederacy suffered a significant loss to the French at the Battle of Marignano. However, it was the Napoleonic Wars that truly sealed Switzerland's neutral stance. During World War I, Switzerland maintained its neutrality despite sharing land borders with both the Central Powers (including Austria-Hungary) and the Allied Powers. Similarly, during World War II, Switzerland found itself encircled by the Axis powers but managed to maintain its independence and neutrality. While there were skirmishes and airspace violations, Switzerland was never fully invaded by Austria or any other country and has not participated in a foreign war since its neutrality was established in 1815.

Switzerland's neutrality in World War I

Switzerland has maintained a policy of armed neutrality since the Treaty of Paris in 1815, and has not participated in a foreign war since then. However, the country did have a civil war in 1847. During World War I, Switzerland continued to uphold its neutrality, despite sharing land borders with two Central Powers (Germany and Austria-Hungary) and two Allied Powers (France and Italy).

Switzerland's neutrality was tested during World War I. The country mobilised its army of about 250,000 men, with an additional 200,000 in supporting roles, in case of a potential attack on Swiss territory. Swiss troops were deployed along the French, Italian, and eastern borders. Switzerland also served as a refuge for around 300,000 refugees during the war.

The internal population was divided along linguistic lines, with the German-speaking majority generally favouring the Central Powers, while the French and Italian-speaking populations sided with the Entente Powers. Despite this, Switzerland managed to maintain its neutrality, although it was blockaded by the Allies and suffered some difficulties as a result. The country's central location, neutrality, and lack of damage meant that the Swiss banking industry grew during the war. Switzerland also became a haven for foreign refugees, revolutionaries, politicians, artists, pacifists, and thinkers.

In 1917, Switzerland's neutrality was called into question by the Grimm-Hoffmann Affair. Robert Grimm, a Swiss socialist politician, travelled to Russia to negotiate a separate peace agreement between Russia and Germany to end the war on the Eastern Front in the interests of socialism and pacifism. He was supported by Arthur Hoffman, a Swiss Federal Councillor, but the Allied Powers were outraged when they found out. The scandal resulted in the resignation of Hoffmann.

Switzerland's neutrality in World War II

Switzerland's neutrality during World War II has been the subject of much historical debate and scrutiny. While the country maintained official neutrality, its financial dealings with Nazi Germany and treatment of Jewish refugees have been widely criticised.

Switzerland's neutrality was largely due to its geographical location and topography, with its mountainous landscape making invasion difficult. However, its central location also made it a hub for espionage, diplomacy, commerce, and as a safe haven for refugees. Switzerland served as a "protecting power" for both sides of the conflict, facilitating communications and protecting diplomatic interests. It also accepted wounded prisoners of war from all sides for recovery in mountain resorts.

Switzerland's banking sector played a significant role during the war. Swiss banks served as a repository for Jewish capital smuggled out of Nazi Germany and occupied territories, as well as for valuables plundered from Jews and others across Europe. Swiss banks also did extensive business with the German Reichsbank and individual Nazi officials, even laundering hundreds of millions of dollars in stolen assets. After the war, Switzerland resisted Allied calls for restitution and retained much of the looted gold and assets.

Switzerland's refugee policies have also been a source of controversy. While it took in 300,000 refugees during the war, its strict asylum laws made it difficult for Jews fleeing persecution to find sanctuary. Swiss authorities actively blocked the entry of Jewish refugees, even requesting that Germany mark Jewish passports with a "J" to deny them admission. As a result, the majority of those denied sanctuary perished in Nazi death camps.

In summary, while Switzerland maintained official neutrality during World War II, its financial and refugee policies have been heavily criticised. The country's banks facilitated the laundering of looted assets, and its refugee policies contributed to the persecution of Jews. Switzerland's role during the war highlights the complexities of neutrality and the ethical dilemmas faced by neutral nations.

Switzerland's involvement in the War in Afghanistan

Switzerland has maintained neutrality since its independence from the Holy Roman Empire in 1499. However, it has been involved in military operations, including the War in Afghanistan (2001-2021).

Switzerland's engagement in Afghanistan has primarily focused on international cooperation, humanitarian aid, and development. The country has committed around CHF 30 million per year to protecting the human rights of the Afghan population and helping to meet their basic needs. Key focus areas include food security, basic education, and climate-resilient agriculture. Switzerland also supports local initiatives and works with national NGOs and civil society to strengthen the resilience of the Afghan population.

Switzerland's diplomatic relations with Afghanistan date back to 1928, five years after recognising the country's independence in 1922. These relations continued after the Soviet invasion in 1979 and the Taliban's rise to power in 1996, although official contacts with the new government were not maintained. Switzerland joined UN-imposed sanctions against the Taliban regime in 2000 and temporarily closed its cooperation office in Kabul after the fall of the republican government in 2021.

Switzerland's bilateral trade volume with Afghanistan is marginal, with Swiss exports to Afghanistan amounting to CHF 6.7 million in 2022, mainly consisting of pharmaceutical products, vehicles, and machinery. Swiss imports from Afghanistan, including textiles and agricultural products, amounted to CHF 1.7 million in the same year.

Switzerland's stance on the Russian invasion of Ukraine

Switzerland has historically maintained a stance of armed neutrality, notably during the First and Second World Wars. However, the Russian invasion of Ukraine has caused Switzerland to question its long-held neutrality.

Switzerland's response to the invasion sparked debates about its traditional non-partisan stance. Initially, Switzerland hesitated to act, but it eventually joined European Union sanctions against Moscow. This was seen by some as a decisive break with the past, as Switzerland had never before imposed sanctions on another country. Switzerland has since imposed sanctions 11 more times, with measures targeting the Russian diamond and liquefied gas sectors. The sanctions affect various Swiss industries, including banking and commodities trading.

Switzerland has also frozen Russian-owned financial assets in the country. By December 2023, CHF7.7 billion ($8.8 billion) in assets had been frozen—a sizeable figure by European comparison. However, this amount is only a fraction of the estimated CHF150 billion stashed away by wealthy Russians in Switzerland. The country has also found a way to sell tanks to Germany.

Switzerland's mediation role has also come under pressure. In August 2022, Russia rejected Switzerland's offer to represent its interests in Ukraine, claiming that Switzerland was no longer neutral. Switzerland's diplomatic efforts have since been limited to hosting conferences and gatherings, such as the Ukraine Recovery Conference in Lugano in July 2022. Switzerland intends to host a high-level peace summit on the conflict, but one of the warring parties, Russia, is unlikely to attend as it believes the conference is too closely aligned with Ukrainian interests.

Switzerland has received around 86,000 applications for a special "S" status, which it introduced for the first time in March 2022. This status enables refugees to work and benefit from integration measures such as language classes. About two-thirds of the refugees are women, many of whom have children. As of 2024, 22% have found work. Switzerland has also sent humanitarian aid to Ukraine, including fire engines and trams.

The Swiss population remains largely supportive of neutrality, with over 90% backing it in a 2023 poll. However, the Swiss government is grappling with the question of whether to follow a path of openness or isolationism. There is growing public appetite for NATO membership, with over half of the public approving of closer cooperation with the alliance. The Swiss government has announced plans for closer cooperation with NATO, but politicians are keen to set limits on how far this will go.

Switzerland's neutrality and its involvement in the Napoleonic Wars

Switzerland's neutrality can be traced back to the defeat of the Old Swiss Confederacy at the Battle of Marignano in 1515. Following this defeat, the Confederacy abandoned its expansionist policies and looked to avoid future conflict. However, it was the Napoleonic Wars that truly sealed Switzerland's neutral stance.

In 1798, Switzerland was invaded by the French First Republic and later became a satellite state of Napoleon Bonaparte's empire, compromising its neutrality. However, after Napoleon's defeat at Waterloo, the major European powers concluded that a neutral Switzerland would serve as a valuable buffer zone between France and Austria. During the 1815 Congress of Vienna, these powers signed a declaration affirming Switzerland's "perpetual neutrality" within the international community.

During the Napoleonic Wars, Switzerland became a battlefield of the Revolutionary Wars, with the country being enveloped in battles against Austria. In 1799, Switzerland became a battle zone between the French, Austrian, and Imperial Russian armies, with the locals primarily supporting the latter two and rejecting calls to fight with the French in the name of the Helvetic Republic. The Battles of Winterthur and Zürich were significant conflicts during this period.

Switzerland maintained its neutrality through World War I, mobilizing its army and accepting refugees but refusing to take sides militarily. In 1920, the newly formed League of Nations officially recognized Swiss neutrality and established its headquarters in Geneva. During World War II, Switzerland was encircled by the Axis powers and faced a difficult situation, maintaining its independence by promising retaliation in the event of an invasion. While Switzerland did not join the United Nations until 2002, it has since taken a more active role in international affairs through humanitarian initiatives while remaining fiercely neutral regarding military affairs.

Frequently asked questions