Austria-Hungary: Could A Reunion Be Possible?

Austria-Hungary, also known as the Austro-Hungarian Empire, was a multi-national constitutional monarchy in Central Europe that existed from 1867 to 1918. It was a union between two sovereign states, Austria and Hungary, with a single monarch who held the titles of Emperor of Austria and King of Hungary. The empire was geographically the second-largest country in Europe and the third most populous, constituting one of Europe's major powers at the time. However, the empire collapsed at the end of World War I due to a combination of factors, including crop failure, starvation, economic crisis, and growing nationalist sentiments among its diverse ethnic groups. Today, Austria and Hungary are separate countries with their own distinct identities and sovereignty. While they share a common history and have neighbourly relations as members of the European Union, there are no indications or discussions about a potential reunification. Therefore, the question of whether Austria and Hungary could join again remains purely hypothetical.

The Austro-Hungarian Empire's collapse

The collapse of the Austro-Hungarian Empire was a significant political event that occurred due to various factors, including internal social contradictions, diverging interests of Hungary and Austria, and the impact of World War I. Here is an overview of the factors that led to the empire's collapse:

Internal Social Contradictions and Diverging Interests:

The Austro-Hungarian Empire was weakened by growing internal social contradictions and a widening gap between Hungarian and Austrian interests. The Hungarian and Austrian halves of the Dual Monarchy had distinct interests and goals, contributing to their eventual separation.

Impact of World War I:

World War I had a devastating impact on the Austro-Hungarian Empire. The empire suffered from food shortages, starvation, an economic crisis, and a weakened multi-ethnic army. The pressures of the war exacerbated existing tensions and contributed to the rise of socialist and nationalist movements within the empire. The Allied Powers' encouragement of breakaway demands from minorities further destabilized the empire.

Failure to Address Nationalists' Demands:

As World War I progressed, nationalist movements within the empire gained momentum. These movements, particularly in the Czech, Slovak, and South Slav territories, demanded full independence rather than just autonomy. The empire's failure to adequately address these demands contributed to its disintegration.

Economic Collapse and Social Unrest:

By 1918, the Austro-Hungarian Empire was facing a severe economic crisis, with widespread starvation and social unrest. The government's failure to manage the home front effectively further eroded its legitimacy and support among its citizens.

Rise of Leftist and Liberal Movements:

Leftist, liberal, and pacifist political movements gained traction during World War I, particularly in Vienna and Budapest. These movements opposed the monarchy and advocated for internationalism rather than patriotism. They contributed to the political upheaval and the decline of support for the imperial regime.

Loss of Heirs and Political Stability:

The Austro-Hungarian Empire faced a series of tragedies, including the deaths of possible heirs to the throne, such as Crown Prince Rudolf's suicide and the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand. These losses weakened the monarchical power and contributed to political instability.

Annexation of Bosnia-Herzegovina:

The Annexation of Bosnia-Herzegovina in 1908 angered Serbian and Pan-Slav nationalists and increased tensions in the region. This annexation is considered the catalyst for the conflicts that led to World War I, further destabilizing the empire.

Assassination of Empress Elisabeth:

In 1898, Empress Elisabeth of Austria was assassinated by an anarchist, Luigi Lucheni. While the assassin's intended target was the Duke of Orleans, the Empress's death shocked the people of Austria and Hungary and left the empire in a period of mourning.

Ultimately, the combination of these factors led to the rapid collapse of the Austro-Hungarian Empire in the autumn of 1918. The empire disintegrated into smaller independent states, and the formal dissolution was legalized by the Treaty of Saint-Germain-en-Laye with Austria in 1919 and the Treaty of Trianon with Hungary in 1920.

The 1918 crop failure

By 1918, the Austro-Hungarian economy was in a dire state. The harvest failure meant that food supplies were dwindling, and the government was struggling to feed its people. The situation was particularly bad in Austrian-controlled Galicia, which accounted for about a third of the country's grain harvest, and the Bukovina. These regions had been occupied by Russia and suffered widespread devastation, and never fully recovered their agricultural output during the war.

The labour shortage caused by conscription also hit the agricultural sector hard. Attempts to address this by assigning prisoners of war to work on farms were largely unsuccessful. The mobilisation of resources for the war effort also led to a lack of draught animals and a scarcity of mineral fertilisers, further hitting crop yields.

The state's attempts to control food prices also had a negative impact on agricultural production. By limiting the price of cereals, the state discouraged farmers from maximising output, especially as the relative prices of animal products were rising. Large farmers and estate owners responded by moving away from growing bread grain and into animal feed production, even using crops needed for human consumption as livestock feed.

The impact of the crop failure was felt across the empire. In the Austrian half, which was particularly hard hit, the gap between domestic supply and demand for bread grain widened. In Hungary, production lagged behind normal consumption levels, and there was little surplus to export. The average calorific value of rations was higher in Hungary than in Austria, which fuelled anti-Magyar sentiment among German and Slavic ethnic groups.

The struggle for food also caused social fragmentation, with the emergence of a "shadow economy" that further widened the gap between rich and poor, and between town and country. The unequal distribution of food led to food riots, particularly in Vienna, where the population felt that their wartime sacrifices had not been adequately rewarded.

The Austro-Hungarian Compromise of 1867

The Compromise of 1867 established a military and diplomatic alliance between two sovereign states, Austria and Hungary, with a single monarch, Emperor Franz Joseph, at its head. As Emperor of Austria-Hungary, Franz Joseph reigned as Emperor of Austria in the Austrian half of the empire and as King of Hungary in the Kingdom of Hungary. While the two countries shared a monarch, they were governed by separate parliaments and prime ministers, each with its own government.

The Compromise of 1867 restored the territorial integrity of the Kingdom of Hungary and granted it significant internal autonomy. Hungary's independent legal and judicial systems were restored, along with its historic constitution and the reform laws of the 1848 Hungarian Revolution. However, in matters of foreign affairs and defence, Hungary remained part of the monarchy, and its interests had to be coordinated with those of the other components.

To maintain unity within the Dual Monarchy, common ministries for foreign affairs, defence, and finance were established. The ministry of foreign affairs was responsible for diplomacy and foreign policy, while the ministry of defence oversaw the large Common Army. Additionally, a common finance ministry was founded to manage expenditures for the Common Army, navy, and diplomatic service.

The Compromise of 1867 was unpopular among ethnic Hungarian voters, who felt that it betrayed the vital interests of Hungary and the achievements of the 1848 Revolution. Despite this opposition, the Compromise remained in place until the dissolution of the Dual Monarchy after World War I. The tensions between the two kingdoms and the rise of nationalist movements ultimately contributed to the collapse of the Austro-Hungarian Empire.

The Habsburg Monarchy

Over time, the Habsburgs expanded their influence through arranged marriages and by gaining political privileges. They frequently intermarried with other branches of the family, even as the dynasty split several times into parallel branches. The Habsburg Monarchy was a union of crowns, with only partial shared laws and institutions beyond the Habsburg court itself. The provinces were divided into three groups: the Archduchy proper, Inner Austria (including Styria and Carniola), and Further Austria (including Tyrol and the Swabian lands). The territories of the monarchy were thus united only by a common monarch.

The Habsburg realms were officially unified in 1804 with the formation of the Austrian Empire, and the monarchy was later split into two with the Austro-Hungarian Compromise of 1867. The monarchy began to fracture in the final years of World War I and ultimately disbanded with the proclamation of the Republic of German-Austria and the First Hungarian Republic in late 1918. The collapse of the Austro-Hungarian Empire was catalysed by a combination of factors, including World War I, crop failure, starvation, economic crisis, and the rise of nationalism and socialism.

The Habsburgs produced numerous emperors, kings, queens, and rulers across Europe and its colonies. They occupied the throne of the Holy Roman Empire from 1440 until their extinction in the male line in 1740, and as the Habsburg-Lorraines from 1765 until the Empire's dissolution in 1806. They also produced kings of Bohemia, Hungary, Croatia, Slavonia, Dalmatia, Spain, Portugal, Sicily, Lombardy-Venetia, and Galicia-Lodomeria, among others. The Habsburgs were one of the most prominent and important dynasties in European history, and their rule extended across vast territories and colonies.

The Treaty of Trianon

The treaty is famous for the territorial changes imposed on Hungary and the recognition of its new international borders. Hungary's territory was reduced to less than a third of its pre-war size, and it lost almost 60% of its population. The Kingdom of Romania, the Czechoslovak Republic, the Kingdom of Serbs, Croats and Slovenes (later Yugoslavia), and the First Austrian Republic were the principal beneficiaries of the treaty.

The treaty also led to the international recognition of Hungary and its sovereignty. It cancelled the Belgrade armistice, which had given the Allied Powers the right to occupy Hungary. It also granted Hungarian citizens abroad the right to protect their property from nationalisation. One of the main elements of the treaty was the doctrine of "self-determination of peoples", which aimed to give non-Hungarians their own national states.

The treaty was dictated by the Allies and presented to Hungary as an ultimatum. The Hungarian delegation signed under protest, and agitation for its revision began immediately. The current boundaries of Hungary are, for the most part, the same as those defined by the Treaty of Trianon. The treaty has been a source of resentment in Hungary ever since.

Frequently asked questions