Polio And The Afghanistan Veteran: Understanding The Potential Health Risks To America

Afghanistan and Pakistan are the only two remaining polio-endemic countries in the world. The US withdrawal from Afghanistan has put the three-decade-long global quest to eradicate polio in jeopardy. The Taliban has blocked house-to-house polio vaccination in areas under its control, putting up to 3 million children out of reach of the vaccination campaign. The US withdrawal from Afghanistan has also resulted in a decrease in immunization rates, with only 68% of children in Syria being vaccinated in 2012, for example. This has led to the re-emergence of polio in countries that were previously polio-free. The conflict in Afghanistan has resulted in mass migrations, with migrants bringing diseases that are common in their home countries to new areas. It is possible that US veterans could bring polio to America, but this is purely speculative.

The Taliban's ban on house-to-house polio vaccination campaigns

The ban was enacted in May 2018 by the Taliban's military leadership, who alleged that health workers were spies gathering intelligence for airstrikes and special forces raids. This suspicion arose partly due to a fake hepatitis vaccination program run by the CIA in neighbouring Pakistan, which aimed to collect DNA from residents of the compound where Osama bin Laden was hiding. While the DNA collection effort was ultimately unsuccessful, it fostered distrust of vaccinators and exposed them to deadly attacks.

The ban has negatively impacted polio eradication efforts, with around 3.4 million children being missed in each vaccination drive. The lack of access to these children has become the biggest obstacle to the global campaign to eliminate polio. The door-to-door approach is crucial for reaching newborns, sick children, and children who are visiting homes other than their own.

In April 2019, the Taliban imposed a nationwide ban on all vaccinations for five months, putting nearly 10 million children at risk of contracting polio. Additionally, the COVID-19 pandemic disrupted polio campaigns for four months, further hindering progress.

However, there is some hope for a resolution. In 2023, the Taliban launched an annual polio vaccination drive, aiming to reach more than nine million children. Female vaccinators played a crucial role in this campaign, as they are often needed to access children who are at home with their female caregivers. To address security concerns in areas with longer travel distances, female staff were accompanied by male chaperones, including male family members who had been recruited and trained for this purpose.

While the Taliban's participation in the 2023 vaccination drive is a positive development, the situation remains fragile. Some health experts believe that the Taliban's support for polio eradication could encourage acceptance of vaccination in conservative areas. However, the Taliban has also banned female NGO workers and stopped women from attending universities and most high schools, creating challenges for female vaccinators.

The global quest to eradicate polio continues, and the involvement of the Taliban in these efforts is critical to reaching vulnerable children and preventing the spread of the disease.

The risk of polio to US veterans

Poliomyelitis, or polio, is a highly infectious disease caused by the poliovirus, which invades the nervous system and may cause total paralysis. The development of effective vaccines in the 1950s and 1960s brought polio under control in countries with relatively high living standards. However, it was not until the 1970s that routine immunizations were introduced in developing countries.

Afghanistan is one of only two countries in the world, along with Pakistan, where the wild poliovirus remains endemic. In 2014, Pakistan, Nigeria, and Afghanistan were the only three countries where polio was endemic. The poliovirus is mostly carried by children without symptoms, and each infected child can spread the virus to up to a thousand others.

The U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan has imperiled the 30-year global quest to eradicate polio. The Taliban has blocked house-to-house polio vaccination campaigns in areas under its control, putting up to 3 million children out of reach of the vaccination campaign. The COVID-19 pandemic has also disrupted polio vaccination campaigns and other essential health services, creating additional immunity gaps that have resulted in an increase in polio cases in Afghanistan.

Civil unrest and war contribute to the spread of infectious diseases, as troops, equipment, and displaced persons move from place to place, carrying disease organisms and vectors with them. Wars also spur mass migrations, and migrants may have low immunity to diseases in their new areas. These conditions, especially in crowded refugee camps, can lead to disease epidemics.

The U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan has resulted in increased political instability and conflict, which are associated with higher rates of polio. Displaced populations and those living in hard-to-reach areas may lack access to proper vaccinations and health care.

While there is no evidence that U.S. veterans returning from Afghanistan pose a specific risk of spreading polio to the U.S., the instability and conflict in Afghanistan increase the risk of polio transmission within the country and across its borders. The poliovirus could potentially spread to neighboring countries through travel or the movement of displaced populations. Therefore, there is a general risk of polio transmission from Afghanistan to other parts of the world, including the U.S., especially in areas with low vaccination rates or large numbers of unvaccinated individuals.

The impact of the US withdrawal from Afghanistan on polio eradication efforts

The US withdrawal from Afghanistan has had a significant impact on the global quest to eradicate polio, a highly infectious disease that can cause paralysis and even death. Afghanistan and neighbouring Pakistan are the only two countries in the world where the wild poliovirus is still endemic.

The US withdrawal and the subsequent Taliban takeover have negatively impacted polio eradication efforts in several ways. Firstly, the Taliban has blocked house-to-house polio vaccination campaigns in areas under its control, resulting in millions of children being missed in each round of the National Immunization Day (NID). This ban has been in place since May 2018 and has led to a significant increase in the number of polio cases in Afghanistan. The Taliban's opposition to house-to-house campaigns is due to suspicions that polio vaccinators are passing information to the US to target airstrikes against Taliban leadership. However, there is hope that if the Taliban consolidates its power, its suspicions may ease, and it may allow vaccination campaigns to resume.

Secondly, the political instability and prolonged conflict in Afghanistan have contributed to a humanitarian crisis, high population movement, poor livelihoods, and weakened health systems. These factors have further constrained vaccination efforts and left children vulnerable to polio. The fear instilled during the Taliban rule, where pro-polio leaders were killed, remains a key concern, and many people are still afraid to endorse polio vaccination.

Thirdly, the US withdrawal has disrupted coordination and collaboration between Afghanistan and Pakistan in their cross-border polio eradication activities. The two countries share a long and porous border, and the virus often jumps back and forth between the two countries. Therefore, close coordination between them is crucial to interrupting poliovirus transmission.

Finally, the US withdrawal has limited the access of humanitarian organizations and health workers to areas under Taliban control, making it difficult to reach children in need of vaccination. This is further exacerbated by the ongoing conflict between the Taliban and the Afghan government, which has resulted in active fighting in many areas.

Despite these challenges, there is some optimism that a clear resolution to the conflict in Afghanistan, regardless of who prevails, may aid eradication efforts. Additionally, there have been recent breakthroughs in negotiations with the Taliban, who have allowed polio vaccination campaigns in mosques in certain provinces. However, the ultimate success of polio eradication efforts in Afghanistan depends on improving security, addressing vaccine hesitancy, and strengthening collaboration with neighbouring countries, especially Pakistan.

The role of the Global Polio Eradication Initiative in Afghanistan

The Global Polio Eradication Initiative (GPEI) has been working to eradicate polio in Afghanistan for over three decades. Despite significant progress, Afghanistan and Pakistan are currently the only two remaining polio-endemic countries in the world.

In Afghanistan, GPEI is focusing on reaching every child with vaccines, strengthening surveillance, and maintaining political commitment, financial resources, and technical support at all levels. The initiative is implemented by the World Health Organization (WHO) in close collaboration with the Ministry of Public Health of Afghanistan, UNICEF, and other key partners.

GPEI's efforts in Afghanistan include:

• Conducting National Immunization Days (NIDs) campaigns, targeting around 9.4 million children under 5 years of age.
• Carrying out Sub-National Immunization Days (SNIDs) campaigns through a house-to-house vaccination approach, targeting 3.6 million children.
• Implementing case-response polio vaccination campaigns in areas with confirmed polio cases.
• Supporting the vaccination of children at cross-border points with Pakistan through permanent transit teams.
• Establishing Emergency Operations Centres (EOCs) at the national and regional levels to oversee the implementation of the National Polio Emergency Action Plan (NEAP) for Polio Eradication.
• Focusing on high-risk areas with district-specific plans for 47 high-risk districts.
• Strengthening surveillance for acute flaccid paralysis (AFP) and environmental surveillance for the poliovirus, particularly in the Southern, Eastern, and Central regions.
• Training polio vaccinators, micro-planning, vaccination campaign monitoring, and post-campaign assessments.
• Collaborating with local influencers, religious scholars, medical professionals, and the Islamic Advisory Group (IAG) to address refusals in the Southern and Eastern regions.
• Working with Pakistan to coordinate cross-border activities, as the two countries share one epidemiological block.

GPEI has made significant progress in Afghanistan, with wild poliovirus transmission currently at its lowest level in history. However, challenges remain, including inaccessible areas, vaccination refusals, security concerns, and coordination issues. Sustaining the gains and ensuring high-quality vaccination campaigns that reach all children are critical to ending polio transmission in Afghanistan.

The challenges of polio vaccination in war and conflict-affected areas

The poliovirus is highly infectious and can be difficult to manage and eradicate in politically unstable areas. Conflict and insecurity have exerted a substantial impact in altering the scope and quality of both National Immunization Days (NIDs) and Sub-National Immunization Days (SNIDs) in polio-endemic countries. Wars and conflict have also resulted in the re-emergence of polio in otherwise polio-free countries.

Political instability and conflict

Political instability and prolonged conflict have contributed to humanitarian crises, high population movement, underdevelopment, poor livelihoods, and weakened health systems. All these factors have further constrained vaccination efforts, leaving children vulnerable to the disease. The fear instilled during Taliban rule, where pro-polio leaders were killed, remains a key concern today, and most successors are still afraid and not motivated to endorse polio vaccination.

Inaccessibility

Conflict and insecurity have severely impacted polio vaccination coverage in several provinces in Afghanistan and Pakistan, resulting in parts of these provinces being partially or entirely inaccessible for polio vaccination campaigns. In Nigeria, vaccination activities in the northeast have been disrupted by the activities of extremists and insurgent groups.

Vaccine hesitancy

In some countries, like Pakistan, militants and radical religious groups spread claims that the polio vaccine is a Western ploy to sterilize Muslim children or turn them away from religion. Vaccine hesitancy has also been observed in Nigeria, where religious leaders have disapproved of the vaccine, perceiving it as being associated with birth control and as part of a foreign conspiracy.

Attacks on polio workers

In Pakistan, more than 40 vaccination staff have been killed since July 2012. In Nigeria, at least nine young women working on a polio vaccination campaign were targeted and killed in 2013.

Poor infrastructure

Poor infrastructure, such as treacherous roads and sporadic electricity, can pose challenges to maintaining the cold chain necessary for preserving vaccines.

Frequently asked questions