The Enduring Debate: Afghanistan And The Burqa

The burqa, a traditional Afghan garment, has long been a symbol of the country's women's identity and a source of controversy. In May 2022, the Taliban mandated that women in Afghanistan cover themselves from head to toe in public, with the burqa or a hijab as the preferred options. This decree evoked memories of the Taliban's previous rule from 1996 to 2001, when they strictly enforced the wearing of the burqa and punished those who failed to comply. The recent order has sparked international condemnation and raised concerns about the Taliban's commitment to respecting women's rights. While some women in Afghanistan have chosen to wear the burqa for religious and traditional reasons, others see it as a loss of identity and a symbol of subjugation. The Taliban's latest ruling has significant implications for women's autonomy and participation in public life, and it remains to be seen how the international community will respond to ensure the protection of women's rights in Afghanistan.

The Taliban's decree that women must wear the burqa

The Content of the Decree

The Taliban's decree states that women must cover themselves from head to toe when appearing in public, with only their eyes visible. It recommends the burqa, a traditional Afghan garment that covers the wearer's entire body and face, with a small grille for vision, as the preferred form of covering. The decree also allows for a full hijab that covers the entire body and face, leaving only the eyes uncovered. According to the Taliban, this decree is in accordance with Islamic law and tradition, and is necessary to protect women's dignity and safety.

The Impact of the Decree

The impact of the Taliban's decree has been significant, with women in Afghanistan now facing severe restrictions on their freedom of movement and autonomy. Women who do not comply with the decree face punishment, although it is their male guardians who are held responsible and liable for fines or imprisonment. This dynamic further reinforces the patriarchal system in Afghanistan, where men hold power over women and make decisions on their behalf. The decree has also had a detrimental effect on women's participation in public life, as it discourages women from leaving their homes and engaging in social, political, and economic activities.

International Reaction

The Taliban's decree has been met with widespread condemnation from the international community, including human rights organizations such as Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International, and world leaders such as the United Nations Secretary-General António Guterres. The decree has been seen as a betrayal of the Taliban's pledges to respect gender equality and women's rights, and a step backwards for women's rights in Afghanistan. There have been calls for the international community to take urgent action and increase pressure on the Taliban to reverse their decision. However, the Taliban have shown immunity to pressure in the past, and it remains to be seen what concrete steps will be taken to address this issue.

The enforcement of the decree by male relatives

The Taliban's strategy of compelling men to police their female relatives is particularly disturbing as it strips away the autonomy of women and girls, giving them no say in the matter. They are left with no choice but to comply with the Taliban's restrictions or put their male relatives at risk of punishment. This dynamic also enables the Taliban to avoid direct responsibility for enforcing their oppressive rules, shifting the blame onto men who are now tasked with enforcing these rules within their families.

The decree has been widely criticised by women's rights activists and organisations, who argue that it gives men even more power over the female members of their families, potentially exacerbating the already grave problem of domestic abuse in Afghanistan. Shaharzad Akbar, a former head of the Afghanistan Independent Human Rights Commission, stated that the decree "gives men, and even younger men and boys, even more power over the female members of their families". She also noted that it sends a message to women that they have no protection or support and will be constantly policed inside and outside the home.

Heather Barr, the associate women's rights director at Human Rights Watch, highlighted the disturbing nature of the Taliban's strategy, emphasising that it takes away women's agency and puts them in a vulnerable position. She also pointed out that it makes it difficult for the international community to hold the Taliban accountable, as the direct enforcers of these oppressive rules are now the male relatives, not the Taliban themselves.

The dynamic of male relatives enforcing the decree also contributes to the overall goal of the Taliban regime, which is to erase women from public life and make them invisible. By confining women to their homes and restricting their access to education, employment, and mobility, the Taliban aim to exert control over all aspects of women's lives and reinforce their power.

The Taliban's return to power in Afghanistan

The Taliban's actions have drawn widespread condemnation from the international community, with many countries refusing to recognise their government formally. The United Nations and human rights organisations have expressed deep concern over the situation, and there are fears that the country's economic crisis and humanitarian situation will worsen.

The Taliban's return to power has had a devastating impact on the lives of Afghan women, with many fearing a loss of freedom and autonomy. Women who lived through the Taliban's previous rule from 1996 to 2001 recall the harsh restrictions and punishments enforced by the group's "moral police". The current situation is characterised by a climate of fear and uncertainty, with women reporting feelings of despair and defiance.

The Taliban's justifications for their actions centre on their interpretation of Islamic law and tradition, which has been contested by many Islamic scholars and activists. The group has also pointed to the reduction in corruption and improvements in security since their return to power. However, their actions have been met with resistance, with women organising protests and marches to demand their rights.

The future for Afghans, especially women, under the Taliban's rule remains uncertain. The group's hardline stance on various issues has hindered their pursuit of international recognition and the release of frozen assets. The Taliban's policies and actions continue to shape the daily lives and broader societal landscape of Afghanistan, with far-reaching consequences for its people.

The impact on women's rights and freedom

The impact of the Taliban's decree that women in Afghanistan must wear the burqa on women's rights and freedom is significant and far-reaching. The decree, which calls for women to cover themselves from head to toe, with only their eyes visible, has been met with international condemnation and outrage. The requirement to wear the burqa is seen as a violation of women's rights and a rollback of the freedoms that Afghan women had gained since the fall of the Taliban in 2001.

The burqa mandate has severe implications for women's mobility, education, employment, and overall well-being. Women are effectively being told to stay at home, with their ability to move freely in public spaces restricted. The decree also sets back gains made in girls' education, as the Taliban have prevented most girls from attending school beyond the sixth grade. Additionally, women have been forced out of most work, except for a few specific jobs that men cannot do. The restrictions on women's movement and employment contribute to the already dire economic situation in Afghanistan, with job losses expected to be as high as 900,000 by the middle of 2022.

The decree also has a detrimental impact on women's safety and increases their vulnerability to domestic abuse and harassment. Compliance with the decree is the responsibility of women's male relatives or guardians, who face punishment if their female relatives do not adhere to the rules. This dynamic further entrenches the power of men over women and makes women more dependent on them, limiting their autonomy and self-determination.

The burqa mandate also affects women's mental health and well-being. The requirement to cover oneself from head to toe can be oppressive and cause feelings of despair and defiance among women. The loss of the ability to present oneself in public as one wishes and the restriction of movement can lead to a sense of powerlessness and grief.

The impact of the burqa decree on women's rights and freedom in Afghanistan is profound and widespread. It restricts their mobility, limits their access to education and employment, increases their vulnerability to abuse, and affects their mental health and overall well-being. The international community has expressed concern and called for action to address this serious women's rights crisis.

The international community's response

The Taliban's decision to reinstate the burqa mandate is seen as a setback to their bid for international recognition and support, especially as the country faces economic and humanitarian crises. Foreign Office spokespeople have emphasized that the Taliban's commitment to protecting women's rights is a prerequisite for international acceptance and the lifting of sanctions.

Heather Barr, the associate women's rights director at Human Rights Watch, has called for concerted and coordinated action from the international community, specifically urging countries with self-proclaimed feminist foreign policies to take the lead in tackling what she deems the most serious women's rights crisis globally.

The Taliban's decree has been criticized for contradicting Islamic tradition and Afghan culture, with some arguing that it grants men more power over women, potentially exacerbating domestic abuse issues. The international community, including Islamic nations and Muslim scholars, have implored the Taliban to uphold their pledges to respect human rights, particularly those of women.

The World Bank, which holds over $1 billion in trust for Afghanistan, has indicated that progress on equal access to education is necessary for the release of funds. In response to the Taliban's reversal on reopening girls' secondary schools, the World Bank suspended $600 million earmarked for projects in health, education, and agriculture.

Frequently asked questions