The Plight Of Afghan Women: Enduring Abuse And Oppression

Afghanistan has been ranked as the worst place in the world to be a woman. Around 87% of Afghan women are believed to have experienced domestic abuse at least once in their lifetime. A 2012 survey found that 92% of Afghan women feel that a husband is justified in hitting or beating his wife for at least one reason, such as going out without telling her husband or refusing sex. Domestic abuse is horrifyingly pervasive in the country, and women often face additional barriers to seeking help and justice. The Afghan government's failure to provide accountability for violence against women has undermined progress in protecting women's rights, and with the Taliban's growing influence, there are heightened fears that legislation protecting women's rights will be in danger.

Domestic violence is pervasive, with 87% of Afghan women experiencing it

Afghanistan has been described as the worst place in the world to be a woman. Domestic violence is pervasive, with 87% of Afghan women experiencing it.

The acceptance of violence against women in Afghanistan is pervasive, even among women. A UNICEF-supported survey found that 92% of women in Afghanistan feel that a husband is justified in hitting or beating his wife for at least one of the following reasons: going out without telling her husband, neglecting the children, arguing with her husband, refusing sex, and burning the food. The survey also found that 63% of Afghan women feel a husband is justified in hitting or beating his wife if she wears inappropriate clothing.

The 2009 law on the Elimination of Violence Against Women was celebrated as a hard-won victory by activists, but it has since been largely ignored, with few victims able to seek justice. The Afghan government's failure to provide accountability for violence against women and girls has undermined progress in protecting women's rights.

The prevalence of domestic violence in Afghanistan is linked to poverty and economic stress. Men who are unable to fulfill their culturally defined role as providers may resort to violence as a means of regaining a sense of power and control. The drug trade, which has fuelled the conflict in Afghanistan, has also contributed to domestic violence. Many of the women interviewed for a study on domestic violence in Afghanistan reported that their husbands or fathers were addicted to drugs and that this contributed to violence in the home.

The conflict in Afghanistan has also led to a significant loss of life, particularly among men. In a patriarchal society like Afghanistan, the loss of a male guardian can leave women exposed to decisions made on their behalf, such as forced marriages.

The distinction between public and private spheres is often used to justify non-intervention by the state in cases of domestic violence, as it is considered a "household" affair. However, this ideological separation obscures how patriarchal ideologies create new vulnerabilities for women during conflict.

Domestic violence has serious consequences for women's physical and mental health, and it contributes to a cycle of violence that can persist for generations.

Women's acceptance of domestic abuse is high, with 92% believing a husband is justified in beating his wife for at least one reason

Afghanistan has been described as the worst place in the world to be a woman. Women's acceptance of domestic abuse is high, with 92% believing a husband is justified in beating his wife for at least one reason. The reasons given include going out without telling her husband, neglecting the children, arguing with her husband, refusing sex, and burning the food.

The acceptance of domestic abuse in Afghanistan is pervasive, even among women. This is due in part to the normalisation of violence in the home and as a coping strategy for dealing with external pressures. Women's acceptance of domestic abuse is also influenced by cultural and social norms, as well as economic constraints and a lack of education. For example, women with no education are more likely to accept domestic abuse than those with a secondary education or higher. In Afghanistan, 82% of women have no education.

The consequences of speaking out against domestic abuse in Afghanistan can be severe. Women who do so face social isolation, as perpetrators work to weaken their connections with family and friends. Shame and embarrassment may also play a role, as abusers are often well-respected or liked in their communities. Additionally, women may fear for their safety, as there is a huge rise in the likelihood of violence after separation. This fear is not unfounded, as police and judicial authorities often fail to protect women, and "honour" killings remain widespread.

The cycle of domestic abuse in Afghanistan is perpetuated by a lack of access to justice and effective support systems. Women who experience abuse often do not know where to turn, as the formal court system is seen as corrupt and inaccessible. Traditional dispute resolution methods, such as local councils or shuras, are more accessible but often fail to provide meaningful protection, instead pressuring women to reconcile with their abusers.

The issue of domestic abuse in Afghanistan is deeply ingrained and has serious impacts on the health and well-being of women. It is a violation of basic human rights and requires a multi-sectoral response, including legal and civil action, to address the cultural norms that promote its acceptance.

Women face barriers to seeking help, including economic and social dependence on abusers

Women in Afghanistan face several barriers to seeking help for domestic violence. These barriers are often economic and social, with many women being financially dependent on their abusers.

Economic Dependence

• Women in Afghanistan are often financially dependent on their abusers, which can prevent them from leaving abusive relationships.
• Many women are unable to access education, which limits their employment opportunities and increases their financial dependence on their abusers.
• Women who do work often have low-paying jobs, which can make them reliant on their abusers for additional financial support.
• Women may also be responsible for supporting their children and extended family, which can make them reluctant to leave their abusers.

Social and Cultural Norms

• Social and cultural norms in Afghanistan can make it difficult for women to leave abusive relationships or seek help.
• Women may face pressure from their family and community to stay in abusive relationships, as divorce is often seen as shameful.
• The acceptance of domestic violence is pervasive in Afghanistan, with 92% of women believing that a husband is justified in beating his wife for at least one reason.
• Women may also fear retribution from their abusers if they seek help, or that their children will be taken away.

Afghanistan's formal justice system is failing to protect women, with victims often turning to traditional dispute resolution instead

Despite this legislation, the Afghan government and police often deter women from filing complaints and pressure them to seek mediation within their families. This is due in part to a lack of knowledge about the law among police and prosecutors, as well as deep-rooted social and cultural norms that view violence against women as a private family matter. The UN has reported that the "wide use of mediation when a woman or girl has been beaten, mutilated or murdered... normalises such violence and makes it much more likely to recur".

In addition, women face significant barriers to accessing justice, including family pressure, financial dependence, stigma associated with filing a complaint, and fear of reprisals, such as losing their children. The UN has also noted that the use of mediation in cases of violent crime against women is a human rights violation by the state, which has an obligation to ensure the effective prevention of such crimes and the protection of women.

The ineffectiveness of the formal justice system has led to a reliance on traditional dispute resolution mechanisms, often facilitated by tribal elders, shuras, or other traditional community forums. While these mechanisms can offer a means of peaceful dispute resolution, they also have their weaknesses. Decisions may not be based on Afghan law, reinforce community inequities or power imbalances, and, in some cases, have resulted in severe rights violations, particularly against vulnerable or marginalised groups, including women.

The Taliban's growing influence further threatens the rights of Afghan women, with their courts generally pressuring parties to resolve disputes at home, leaving women with no recourse but to "forgive" their abusers and continue living in the same household. The international community's declining interest and support for Afghanistan also poses a risk to the protection and advancement of women's rights in the country.

The Taliban's growing influence threatens to undo fragile gains in women's rights and legal protections

Afghanistan has long been considered one of the worst places in the world to be a woman. The country has been racked by decades of war, and women disproportionately suffer in such conflict-torn societies. The Taliban ruled Afghanistan from 1996 to 2001, a period in which women were essentially invisible in public life, barred from going to school or working.

In 2001, then-First Lady Laura Bush urged Americans to "join our family in working to ensure that dignity and opportunity will be secured for all the women and children of Afghanistan." In the years since, despite efforts by the Afghan government and international donors to educate girls and improve women's rights, the situation remains dire. An estimated two-thirds of Afghan girls do not attend school, and 87% of women are illiterate.

The Taliban's return to power in 2021 has further threatened fragile gains in women's rights and legal protections. The group has imposed limitations on girls' education, banned women from most workplaces, and prohibited women from appearing in public without a male relative. Women have been forced to leave their jobs, and those who protest these violations face terrible consequences, including enforced disappearance, arbitrary detention, and torture.

The Taliban's actions have had far-reaching consequences, not only curtailing women's freedoms but also pushing them and their families to the brink of poverty. With women owning only about 3% of land in Afghanistan and rarely having livestock, they are now at the forefront of a massive food and economic crisis. The lack of access to education and employment opportunities will only worsen their financial insecurity.

The international community's response to the Taliban's abuses has been tepid and uncoordinated. There has been little concrete action to hold the Taliban accountable and protect the rights of Afghan women and girls. As the world turns its attention away from Afghanistan, the future looks increasingly bleak for those left behind.

Frequently asked questions