Us Open's Symbolic Protest Against Belarus

The Belarus flag was banned from the US Open due to the country's involvement in Russia's invasion of Ukraine. Belarus has been used as a key staging area for the invasion, and as a launching point for attacks. As a result, the international governing bodies of tennis united to condemn Russia's actions and prevent athletes from competing under the name or flag of Russia or Belarus. This decision was reflected in the US Open's announcement that it would allow Russian and Belarusian players to compete under a neutral flag.

Belarus' role in the invasion of Ukraine

The decision to ban the Belarusian flag from the US Open came in the wake of Russia's invasion of Ukraine, with Belarus acting as a key staging area for the invasion. Belarus, a close ally of Russia, has supported its neighbour in the conflict.

Prior to the invasion, Belarus allowed the Russian Armed Forces to conduct military drills on its territory. However, Russian troops did not leave as scheduled and instead used Belarus as a base to launch part of the invasion, providing the shortest possible land route to Kyiv, Ukraine's capital. Belarus also allowed Russian missile launchers to be stationed on its territory to target Ukraine.

There have been several reports of Belarusian troops fighting alongside Russians in Ukraine, although the Belarusian leader, Aleksander Lukashenko, has denied direct involvement, stating that the Belarusian Armed Forces would not participate in the conflict unless his country was attacked first. Despite Lukashenko's claims, there have been numerous indications of Belarusian involvement, including satellite imagery and videos showing the movement of Russian armoured vehicles and helicopters in southern Belarus.

In addition to providing military support, Belarus has also been complicit in war crimes. The Belarusian state has actively participated in the forced transfers of Ukrainian children to Belarus, holding them in recreational camps. This has been confirmed by Belarusian state television and opposed by international organisations.

The involvement of Belarus in the invasion has been met with widespread condemnation, resulting in sanctions from the European Union, the United States, the United Kingdom, Canada, and Japan.

Belarus's Role in the Invasion of Ukraine

Belarus played a significant role in Russia's invasion of Ukraine by allowing its territory to be used as a staging ground for Russian forces. In the lead-up to the conflict, Belarus permitted Russian troops to conduct military drills on its soil, but these troops remained even after the drills were supposed to end. Belarus's proximity to Ukraine, especially Kyiv, provided Russia with a strategic advantage. Belarusian territory was utilised by Russian forces to launch attacks, and Russian missile launchers stationed in Belarus targeted Ukrainian locations.

There have been persistent reports and evidence, including satellite imagery, of Belarusian troops fighting alongside Russians in Ukraine. However, the Belarusian leadership has denied direct involvement in the conflict, stating that their troops would only engage if their country was attacked. Despite this denial, there is substantial evidence suggesting otherwise, and the international community has widely condemned Belarus's role in the invasion.

The Belarusian state has also been complicit in war crimes, including the forced transfer and detention of Ukrainian children in recreational camps within Belarus. This has been acknowledged by Belarusian state media and sparked outrage internationally.

The support provided by Belarus to Russia during the invasion has had significant implications for regional security and has further strained Belarus's relations with Western nations. The international community has responded with sanctions and other measures to hold Belarus accountable for its role in the conflict.

The banning of the Belarusian flag

The Belarusian flag was banned from the US Open following Russia's invasion of Ukraine in February 2022. Belarus aided Russia in the war, and the country has been used as a key staging area and launching point for attacks. As a result, the international governing bodies of tennis, including the International Tennis Federation (ITF), banned athletes from Russia and Belarus from competing under their country names or flags. This ban was also enforced at other tennis tournaments, including the French Open, and extended to all ITF international team competitions.

The decision to ban the Belarusian flag was made by the international governing bodies of tennis, including the ITF, the ATP Tour, the Women's Tennis Association (WTA), and the four Grand Slam events: the Australian Open, French Open, US Open, and Wimbledon. The ITF issued a neutral athlete policy, which meant that athletes from Russia and Belarus could continue to compete in international events but not under their country names or flags. This policy was designed to prevent either country from using the success of its athletes as propaganda and to show condemnation for Russia's invasion of Ukraine.

The USTA, which owns and operates the US Open, supported the banning of the Russian and Belarusian Tennis Federations from the ITF and followed the directive for players from those countries to compete under a neutral flag. The USTA expressed concern about holding individual athletes accountable for the actions of their governments and stated that their decision was based on principles rather than commercial or ethical questions.

The discrepancy between the approaches of different broadcasters, such as ESPN and Sky Sports, in their coverage of the US Open regarding the display of the Belarusian flag further highlights the complexities and challenges of balancing editorial standards with the official policies of sports governing bodies.

Belarusian players competing as neutral athletes

The International Tennis Federation (ITF) issued a policy in March 2022 that forced athletes from Belarus and Russia to compete as neutral athletes. This was done to prevent the athletes from being used as propaganda by their countries and to avoid the perception of supporting "atrocious acts by a government". This policy was implemented shortly after Russia's invasion of Ukraine, in which Belarus has been a key staging area.

As a result of this policy, Belarusian players competing in the US Open are not allowed to compete under the name or flag of Belarus. Instead, they compete under a neutral flag. This decision was made by the USTA, which owns and operates the US Open, in alignment with other tennis entities such as the ATP Tour, the Women's Tennis Association (WTA), and the ITF.

The USTA has expressed concern about holding individual athletes accountable for the actions of their governments. They have stated that their decision was based on principles rather than commercial or ethical questions. However, the ITF's policy has created a balancing act for media partners like ESPN, which has chosen to reflect the policy in its live broadcasts but not on its website or app.

While Belarusian players are allowed to compete in the US Open, they must do so as neutral athletes, without displaying any national insignia or symbols, flags, anthems, or any signs of patriotism associated with Belarus. This rule also applies to Russian athletes, who were banned from competing at Wimbledon but allowed to play at the US Open and the French Open.

The decision to allow Belarusian players to compete as neutral athletes in the US Open has sparked varying reactions. Some have criticised the ban on flags and country names, while others have expressed tension and strained friendships between players, particularly between Ukrainian and Russian players.

The discrepancy between ESPN's website and live broadcasts

On its live broadcasts, ESPN chose to align with the International Tennis Federation's (ITF) policy of treating athletes from Russia and Belarus as "neutral athletes". This decision was made in the wake of Russia's invasion of Ukraine, with Belarus being a key staging ground for the invasion. As such, ESPN's live broadcasts did not feature the Belarusian flag alongside the names of Belarusian athletes, such as Aryna Sabalenka, during the US Open.

However, on its website and app, ESPN chose to adhere to its editorial standards, which include identifying tennis players by their country. This created a discrepancy where the Belarusian flag was visible on ESPN's digital platforms but not during live broadcasts. This inconsistency extended to other media partners of the US Open, such as Sky Sports and Eurosport, who had differing approaches to displaying the flags of Russia and Belarus.

ESPN's decision to respect the ITF's protocol on live broadcasts was not an obligation but rather a choice to match the preferences of the governing body. At the same time, by reverting to its editorial standards on its website and other platforms, ESPN maintained its practice of identifying athletes by their country, reflecting its dual role as a broadcast partner and a news agency covering the event.

The ITF's neutral athlete policy was implemented to prevent Russia and Belarus from using the success of their athletes as propaganda and to show solidarity with Ukraine. This policy has been a source of tension within the tennis community, with differing opinions on whether individual athletes should be held accountable for the actions of their governments.

The USTA's rationale for allowing Belarusian players to compete

Secondly, the USTA has stated that they "condemn the unprovoked and unjust invasion of Ukraine by Russia," and Belarus' complicity in this invasion. By allowing Belarusian athletes to compete under a neutral flag, the USTA is attempting to balance their condemnation of the invasion with their commitment to fairness and sportsmanship.

Additionally, the USTA's decision is in line with the approach taken by other tennis governing bodies, such as the ATP and WTA tours, which have also allowed Belarusian athletes to compete in their tournaments under neutral flags. The USTA is also considering the financial implications of their decision, as broadcasting contracts bring in a significant portion of their operating revenue.

Furthermore, the USTA has committed to providing humanitarian support for Ukraine through their "Tennis Plays for Peace" initiative, and they plan to announce additional initiatives to provide financial assistance and other programmes to support humanitarian relief efforts.

Frequently asked questions