Bolivia's Rape Crisis: Understanding The Surge

Bolivia has the highest rate of sexual violence in Latin America, with one in three women experiencing some form of sexual abuse before the age of 18. The country also has the lowest reporting rates for these crimes in the region, with those who do come forward facing barriers to accessing justice. The causes of the persistence of such violence include a pervasive culture of machismo, inadequate legislation, a lack of law enforcement, the judicial system, and societal attitudes. The World Health Organization estimates that 30% of women globally experience some form of sexual violence, with 70% of Bolivian women reporting physical or sexual abuse during their lifetime.

Rape culture and victim-blaming

• Cultural Attitudes and Victim-Blaming: Bolivian culture often portrays adolescent girls as treacherous, seductive, and manipulative, blaming them for the actions of adult men. This victim-blaming mentality is deeply ingrained and contributes to a culture of silence and shame that discourages reporting.
• Lack of Legislation and Poor Enforcement: Bolivia's legal system fails to adequately address sexual violence. Consent is not defined in the penal code, and survivors must prove intimidation, physical or psychological violence, which is challenging and re-traumatizing.
• Judicial Discretion and Loopholes: Judges have discretion in applying laws, creating loopholes that favor perpetrators. For example, the ""estupro" law imposes lesser penalties for rapes of adolescents aged 14-18, and judges often use their discretion to reduce charges, allowing rapists to evade justice.
• Inadequate Investigation and Victim Support: The justice system fails to adequately support victims. Victims are often asked to repeat their traumatic experiences to unqualified professionals, facing intimidation and blame instead of compassion.
• Impunity and Corruption: Impunity for rapists is common in Bolivia due to a corrupt and politicized judicial system. Inadequate investigation, police impunity, and a lack of accountability perpetuate the cycle of violence.
• Societal Attitudes and Gender Inequality: The pervasive culture of machismo and patriarchy in Bolivia contributes to gender inequality and devalues women. This societal attitude influences legislators, law enforcement, and the general public, hindering progress in addressing sexual violence.

To address these issues, Bolivia needs comprehensive legal reforms, improved law enforcement, and a shift in societal attitudes to prioritize consent, accountability, and support for survivors.

Poor legislation and law enforcement

One of the main issues is the lack of a clear definition of consent in Bolivian law. Currently, survivors of sexual violence must prove "intimidation, physical violence, or psychological violence" to establish that their consent was absent. This requirement poses a significant barrier, often deterring survivors from pursuing legal action or leading to their cases being dismissed during the initial investigatory stages. The absence of a clear consent definition in the law enables perpetrators to evade justice and perpetuates a culture of impunity for sexual crimes.

Additionally, Bolivia's "estupro" law further exacerbates the problem. "Estupro" is defined as "having carnal access" to a person through seduction or deceit and carries a lesser penalty than rape. Judges have been known to use their discretion to reduce charges from rape to "estupro," particularly in cases involving adolescent girls. This legal loophole not only undermines the severity of the crime but also reinforces societal stereotypes that portray adolescent girls as treacherous and seductive.

The Bolivian justice system also faces criticism for its inadequate enforcement of existing laws. There is a pervasive culture of impunity, with authorities often failing to investigate and prosecute sexual violence cases effectively. This failure to hold perpetrators accountable sends a message of indifference and encourages further crimes. Moreover, survivors who report their cases face numerous obstacles, including intimidation, blame, and a lack of support from authorities and their communities.

The combination of poor legislation and ineffective law enforcement has created a cycle of violence and silence in Bolivia. It is essential that the government addresses these issues by implementing comprehensive legal reforms, establishing specialized training for officials, and fostering a culture that supports and protects survivors of sexual violence. Only then can Bolivia begin to tackle the scourge of sexual violence and improve access to justice for all its citizens, particularly the most vulnerable members of society.

Patriarchal society and gender inequality

Bolivia has the highest rate of sexual violence in Latin America, with one in three women experiencing some form of sexual abuse before the age of 18. The country also has some of the lowest reporting rates for these crimes. This can be attributed to a patriarchal society and gender inequality, which normalises and perpetuates violence against women.

Bolivian culture highly values "machismo", or the concept of "manliness". This, combined with inadequate legislation and poor enforcement of existing laws, creates a culture of shame and silence that enables perpetrators to evade justice. In Bolivian culture, adolescent girls are often portrayed as treacherous, seductive, and manipulative, preying on helpless adult men. This perception of girls and women as temptresses not only discourages survivors from reporting their abuse but also grants their abusers unfair advantage in the eyes of the law.

Consent is not defined in the Bolivian penal code, and survivors must prove intimidation, physical violence, or psychological violence for their cases to proceed. Even when cases do make it to court, survivors face further obstacles such as unqualified judges, prosecutors, and forensic doctors who perpetuate misinformation and question the veracity of their complaints. This was the experience of Brisa de Angulo, a rape survivor and founder of A Breeze of Hope, a charity supporting sexually abused children in Bolivia. During her trial, a judge implied that de Angulo could not have been raped because she had a "strong personality" and did not scream.

The prevalence of sexual violence in Bolivia is a direct consequence of the country's patriarchal society and gender inequality. The normalisation of "machismo" and the objectification of women and girls create a culture that enables and excuses abuse. The lack of legislation and ineffective law enforcement further perpetuate a cycle of violence and impunity, with perpetrators rarely being held accountable for their crimes.

Lack of education and awareness

The increase in rape and sexual violence in Bolivia can be attributed to a lack of education and awareness on the topic. This is evident in the country's inadequate legislation and poor enforcement of existing laws, with consent not defined in the Bolivian penal code and survivors facing obstacles to obtaining justice.

The issue is deeply rooted in the country's culture, with one in three girls experiencing sexual violence before the age of 18 and a pervasive culture of machismo, or "manliness," that values male dominance. This is further exacerbated by the portrayal of adolescent girls as treacherous, seductive, and manipulative in Bolivian culture, which influences legislators, law enforcement personnel, medical staff, and the general public.

The lack of education and awareness is also evident in the justice system, where designated official bodies are not adequately trained to handle the sensitivities of sexual violence trials. Victims are often retraumatized by having to repeat their stories and face questions that doubt the veracity of their complaints. This leads to a culture of silence and shame, making it difficult for survivors to come forward and report their experiences.

Furthermore, the absence of comprehensive sex education contributes to the problem. For example, young girls who become pregnant as a result of rape face practical challenges in accessing abortion services due to a lack of knowledge about the laws and cultural beliefs that discourage such procedures.

The Mennonite community in Bolivia, which experienced a series of mass serial rapes, also highlights the impact of a lack of education and awareness. The community chooses to be socially and culturally isolated, with minimal general education and a lack of sexual education, making it difficult for victims to effectively document and report their experiences.

To address the issue, there is a need for broader legal reforms, improved training for officials, and the implementation of sex education to increase awareness and understanding of sexual violence in Bolivia.

Inadequate government response

The government's response to the issue of rape in Bolivia has been inadequate for several reasons. Firstly, there is a lack of legislation and poor enforcement of existing laws, which has allowed a culture of sexual violence to persist. Consent is not defined in the Bolivian penal code, and survivors must prove "intimidation, physical violence, or psychological violence", which discourages many victims from pursuing legal action. In addition, judges have discretion over the application of the law, often in favour of the perpetrators. For example, in the case of "estupro", or "having carnal access to a person by means of seduction or deceit", judges have been known to reduce charges from rape to the lesser charge of estupro, even when evidence points to rape. This results in shorter sentences for perpetrators and further discourages reporting.

Secondly, the government has failed to address the underlying cultural attitudes that contribute to sexual violence. Bolivian culture highly values "machismo", or "manliness", and adolescent girls are often portrayed as treacherous, seductive, and manipulative, which can lead to blame being placed on the victim. The government has also failed to provide comprehensive sex education, which could help to challenge these stereotypes and promote a culture of consent.

Thirdly, there is a lack of support and protection for victims who choose to report sexual violence. The process of reporting and seeking justice can be traumatising and re-victimising, with victims often facing intimidation and blame from their communities, extended families, and even authorities. There is also a lack of training among officials dealing with sexual violence cases, with victims reporting that they were asked to repeat their stories multiple times and that the veracity of their complaints was questioned.

Finally, the government has failed to adequately address corruption within the justice system, which has led to impunity for perpetrators. For example, in the case of whistleblower Marco Antonio Aramayo, who accused government officials of stealing from the Indigenous Fund, the authorities failed to protect him from attacks and torture while he was in prison awaiting trial. This indicates a lack of accountability for gender-based violence and a failure to protect whistleblowers and victims who speak out.

Frequently asked questions