The Strained Ties Between Russia And Austria-Hungary

why did russia and austria-hungary not get along

Russia and Austria-Hungary's relationship was strained due to several factors, including competing imperialist agendas, the Crimean War, the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand, and their differing stances on Serbia. Both nations were imperialist, multi-ethnic states with competing interests in the Balkans, which led to diplomatic tensions. Russia saw itself as the protector of Slavic peoples, while Austria-Hungary's anti-Slavic policies and occupation of Bosnia Vilayet caused dismay in Russia. The Crimean War marked a significant shift in their relationship, with Austria-Hungary's neutrality angering Russia and leading to a series of complex alliances and treaties. These alliances, influenced by Germany and other powers, further complicated relations. Ultimately, the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand by Serb nationalists and Austria-Hungary's declaration of war on Serbia pushed the two nations into direct conflict during World War I, with Russia and Austria-Hungary fighting on the Eastern Front.

shunculture

The Crimean War

The Origins of the Crimean War

Diplomatic Complexities

The diplomatic landscape leading up to the Crimean War was intricate. Initially, Russia and Austria-Hungary had been allies, with Russia even intervening to support Austria during the Hungarian Revolution of 1848-1849. However, during the Crimean War, Austria-Hungary adopted a position of hostile neutrality towards Russia, siding with the Anglo-French coalition instead. This stance angered Tsar Nicholas I of Russia and strained relations between the two empires.

The War's Impact on Russo-Austrian Relations

The Road to World War I

In the decades following the Crimean War, the rivalry between Russia and Austria-Hungary intensified, particularly in the Balkans. Both empires sought to exert influence over the region, often backing opposing sides. This rivalry played out in events such as the annexation of Bosnia-Herzegovina by Austria-Hungary in 1908, which dismayed Russia and other European powers. The assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand of Austria-Hungary by Serb nationalists in 1914 further escalated tensions, ultimately leading to the outbreak of World War I.

World War I and its Aftermath

During World War I, Russia and Austria-Hungary fought each other on the Eastern Front, with German formations supporting the Austro-Hungarian army. The war resulted in the overthrow of the monarchies in both countries and the dissolution of their empires. Following the Bolshevik Revolution in Russia in November 1917, efforts were made to terminate the war with the Central Powers, including Austria-Hungary, leading to the Treaty of Brest-Litovsk in 1918. Diplomatic relations between Austria and the Soviet Union were eventually established in 1924.

shunculture

Austria-Hungary's annexation of Bosnia

The relationship between Russia and Austria-Hungary was complex and characterised by periods of both alliance and rivalry. One major source of tension between the two empires was their competing imperialist ambitions in the Balkans. This rivalry came to a head with the Austro-Hungarian annexation of Bosnia-Herzegovina in 1908, which upset the fragile balance of power in the region and contributed to the outbreak of World War I.

The annexation of Bosnia-Herzegovina by Austria-Hungary in 1908, known as the Bosnian Crisis, was a significant event that strained the empire's relations with Russia and other neighbouring countries. The provinces of Bosnia and Herzegovina were strategically valuable and had been under Austrian administration since the Congress of Berlin in 1878, although they remained nominal possessions of the Ottoman Empire. The Treaty of Berlin allowed for sole Austrian occupation of Bosnia-Herzegovina but did not specify the final disposition of the provinces, leaving their status uncertain.

In the lead-up to the annexation, Austria-Hungary's position in the region was threatened by the rise of pan-Slavic nationalism and the growing influence of its rival, Serbia, in the Balkans. Serbia's success in the Pig War and the radical calls for a "Great Serbia" that included Bosnia-Herzegovina heightened tensions. Additionally, the largely Slavic population of Bosnia and Herzegovina had their own nationalist ambitions, which were supported by their fellow Slavs in nearby Serbia.

In 1908, the Young Turks revolution in Constantinople (now Istanbul) prompted the Austrian foreign minister, Alois/Lexa von Aehrenthal, to resolve to annex Bosnia and Herzegovina before the new Turkish regime could regain control. Aehrenthal met with the Russian foreign minister, Alexander Izvolsky, and offered to support Russia's access to the Turkish Straits for its naval vessels in exchange for Russia's agreement not to object to the annexation. Izvolsky agreed, but the immediate action by Austria-Hungary caught him unprepared, and he struggled to control the strong popular opposition to the annexation in Russia.

The annexation of Bosnia-Herzegovina upset the fragile balance of power in the Balkans and enraged Serbia and pan-Slavic nationalists. Serbia, which had close geographical and ethnic ties to Bosnia and Herzegovina, demanded that Austria cede a portion of the annexed territory. Russia, although weakened and humiliated by its recent defeat in the Russo-Japanese War, was forced to submit but still viewed Austria-Hungary's actions as a threat. In response, Russia encouraged pro-Russian, anti-Austrian sentiment in Serbia and other Balkan provinces, fuelling Austrian fears of Slavic expansionism.

The Bosnian Crisis ultimately contributed to the outbreak of World War I. While Germany supported Austria-Hungary, Russia's ability to support its ally Serbia was limited due to its prior military humiliation. However, the embittered relations between Austria-Hungary and Serbia, coupled with Russia's resentment, laid the groundwork for the wider international conflict to come.

shunculture

Russia's pan-Slavic policy

Russia saw itself as the natural leader and protector of the Slavic peoples in the region, including those within Austria-Hungary. This put them at odds with Austria-Hungary, which also included some Slavic peoples. The Russian Tsars viewed themselves as the heads of the most powerful Slavic state in the world and felt honour-bound to support other Slavic peoples. They believed that Slavic peoples in neighbouring states would be treated better if those lands were part of the Russian Empire. If Slavic peoples were part of someone else's state and wished to leave, Russia felt it should help them do so.

Austria-Hungary's perception of Serbia as a magnet for the South Slavs within its empire and a threat to its existence led it down the path to World War I. Serbia was a traditional Russian ally, and Russia came to Serbia's defence when Austria-Hungary attacked. Russia's expansionist policies also extended beyond Slavic peoples, as seen in their expansion into Siberia, Finland, Poland, and Ukraine.

The Crimean War marked a turning point in Russo-Austrian relations. Austria-Hungary maintained a policy of hostile neutrality towards Russia during the war, supporting the Anglo-French coalition. This angered Tsar Nicholas I and strained relations between the two countries. While Russia was punished by the Treaty of Paris, Austria-Hungary ultimately lost the most from the war despite barely participating.

The two empires were briefly allies with the German Empire in the League of Three Emperors from 1873 to 1887. However, their competing interests in the Balkans, particularly regarding the weakening Ottoman Empire, continued to fuel tensions. Russia's victory in the Russo-Turkish War (1877-1878) and the subsequent Treaty of Berlin allowed Austria-Hungary to occupy the Bosnia Vilayet, further straining relations.

shunculture

The Dreikaiserbund

Despite the Dreikaiserbund, tensions between Russia and Austria-Hungary continued to grow in the lead-up to World War I. This was due in part to their conflicting foreign policies in the Balkans, where both empires were imperialist, multi-ethnic states with rival ambitions. Russia saw itself as the natural leader and protector of the Slavic peoples in the region, which included some of the populations within Austria-Hungary. Additionally, Russia sought to expand its influence in the Balkans and the Ottoman Empire, which was seen as a threat by Austria-Hungary.

The assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand of Austria-Hungary in 1914 by a Serbian nationalist brought these tensions to a head, as Russia supported Serbia, its traditional ally, while Austria-Hungary sought to punish Serbia, seeing it as a threat to its empire. This conflict ultimately led to the outbreak of World War I, as Germany backed Austria-Hungary, while France and Britain entered the war in support of Russia.

shunculture

The Eastern Question

In diplomatic history, the "Eastern Question" refers to the strategic competition and political considerations of the European Great Powers in response to the political and economic instability of the Ottoman Empire from the late 18th to the early 20th centuries. The weakening of the Ottoman Empire's military strength threatened to disrupt the balance of power in Europe, leading to concerns among the major powers. The Eastern Question encompassed various interrelated elements, including Ottoman military defeats, institutional insolvency, ongoing modernisation efforts, the rise of ethno-religious nationalism, and Great Power rivalries.

The rivalry between Russia and Austria-Hungary was influenced by their conflicting foreign policies in the Balkans, their imperialist and multi-ethnic state nature, and their competition for influence over Slavic peoples in the region. Russia considered itself the natural leader and protector of the Slavs, including those within Austria-Hungary, which fuelled tensions between the two empires. Additionally, the Serbian Revolution and Serbia's emancipation from the Ottoman Empire further contributed to the complexities of the Eastern Question.

Frequently asked questions

Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment