Muslims Drinking In Bahrain: Understanding The Exception

Alcohol is widely considered haram, or forbidden, in Islam, with the Quran labelling intoxicants as the work of Satan. However, in some Islamic nations, alcohol is available, albeit with varying regulations and restrictions. One such example is Bahrain, where Muslims are prohibited from drinking alcohol in public places, but non-Muslims are allowed to consume alcohol in places specified by the government. This has been a subject of heated debate, with some arguing that it goes against Islamic law, while others claim that it is necessary for the country's economy and investment appeal.

Drinking in private vs. public places

Drinking alcohol is considered haram, or forbidden, in Islam. Islamic scholars and Muslim religious authorities point to a verse in the Quran that calls intoxicants "the work of Satan". However, not all Muslims abstain from drinking, and some countries with a Muslim majority allow alcohol to varying degrees.

Bahrain is one such example. While alcohol is legal in Bahrain, there are strict rules surrounding its consumption. Muslims are prohibited from drinking in public places but are allowed to drink in private places. Non-Muslims are permitted to consume alcohol in places specified by the government. These places are designated for the consumption of alcohol.

The laws in Bahrain are designed to ensure that everyone is respectful of each other's faith and nationality. Visitors and residents are expected to respect Bahraini culture and values. Drinking alcohol in public or driving under the influence is against the law and can result in a fine, imprisonment, deportation, or the withdrawal of a driving license.

Bahrain's alcohol laws are the result of a compromise between conservative and liberal members of the country's legislature. The conservatives wanted a complete ban on alcohol, while the liberals argued that a ban would negatively impact the country's economy and investment climate. The compromise restricts the ban to Muslims and allows non-Muslims to drink in designated places.

The laws in Bahrain regarding alcohol consumption reflect a balance between Islamic religious values and the country's status as a civil state with a constitution that houses all religions.

The economic impact of alcohol restrictions

Bahrain's lawmakers approved a law that will impose a ban on drinking alcohol for Muslims only, allowing non-Muslims to drink in places specified by the government. This has been a subject of heated debate, with some arguing for a complete ban and others for no ban at all. Despite reaching a compromise by restricting the ban to Muslims, liberal members warned of the negative impact on investment in Bahrain. MP Khaled al-Moayed expressed concern about the interference of religious scholars in politics and economics. Groups such as liberals, chambers of commerce, and industry members supported this opinion, arguing that Bahrain, as an investment-friendly country with a free-market economy, would suffer if a ban is imposed.

Bahrain's decision to restrict the alcohol ban to Muslims only is an attempt to balance religious and civil considerations. The country is a civil state governed by a constitution that houses all religions, with Islam being the official religion and the primary source of legislation. The compromise allows non-Muslims to drink in specific places, which could include clubs, pubs, and restaurants.

The availability of alcohol is a factor that expatriates and tourists consider when choosing a destination like Bahrain. Relaxing alcohol laws can be seen as part of wider social reforms to enhance the country's appeal as a holiday or work destination. The income generated from alcohol sales and the spending of those consuming it can contribute significantly to the local economy.

However, it is essential to consider the potential negative economic impacts of alcohol restrictions. For example, a complete ban on alcohol in Bahrain could drive away foreign investment and tourists, especially when compared to neighbouring countries with more relaxed alcohol laws, such as the United Arab Emirates.

The impact of alcohol restrictions on the economy is complex and multifaceted. While the sale of alcohol can generate revenue for the government and businesses, it is also essential to consider the potential costs associated with alcohol consumption, such as healthcare expenses and the impact on productivity. Ultimately, the economic impact of alcohol restrictions in Bahrain will depend on various factors, including the country's ability to attract investment and tourists, the revenue generated from alcohol sales, and the costs associated with alcohol-related issues.

The role of religion in lawmaking

The relationship between religion and lawmaking is complex and multifaceted, with countries around the world adopting different approaches. In the context of Bahrain, the role of Islam in shaping alcohol laws provides an interesting case study. While Islam forbids the consumption of alcohol, Bahrain has adopted a nuanced approach that reflects the country's diverse population and economic priorities.

Bahrain's alcohol laws are deeply rooted in Islamic traditions and values, which form the cornerstone of daily life for many Bahraini families. Drinking alcohol is considered haram, or forbidden, in Islam, and Islamic scholars and religious authorities point to specific verses in the Quran that condemn intoxicants as "the work of Satan." As a result, the consumption of alcohol by Muslims in Bahrain is prohibited and punishable by law.

However, Bahrain also recognises the presence of other religions within its borders and the need to balance religious principles with economic considerations. As a result, the country has adopted a partial ban on alcohol consumption, allowing non-Muslims to drink in places specified by the government. This compromise aims to respect Islamic teachings while accommodating the beliefs and practices of other religious groups.

The implementation of this partial ban has sparked debates between conservative and liberal groups in Bahrain. Conservatives argue for a complete ban on alcohol consumption, in line with their interpretation of Islamic law. On the other hand, liberal members warn of the negative economic impact that a comprehensive ban could have on investment and the country's reputation as an investment-friendly, free-market economy.

In conclusion, the case of alcohol laws in Bahrain illustrates the complex interplay between religion and lawmaking. While Islam plays a significant role in shaping alcohol regulations, the country's lawmakers have also considered the diverse religious beliefs of their citizens and the potential economic implications. This example highlights the delicate balance between upholding religious principles and accommodating practical considerations in the process of lawmaking.

Alcohol availability in nearby Gulf States

Dubai, a top travel destination in the United Arab Emirates, is known for its glitz and love of superlatives. It boasts a variety of bars, nightclubs, and lounges that attract many visitors and well-to-do expatriate residents. In recent years, the city has also been loosening laws governing alcohol sales and possession of liquor.

Other Gulf Arab countries like Qatar and Oman also permit alcohol sales, but only in top hotels.

In contrast, Saudi Arabia and Kuwait have strict laws against drinking. Many expatriates and locals rely on a large black market for alcohol and occasionally travel to Dubai or Bahrain to drink.

In February 2024, Saudi Arabia took a step towards relaxing its alcohol laws by opening an off-licence in the diplomatic quarter of its capital, Riyadh. The shop sells exclusively to non-Muslim diplomats under strict controls and quotas. This move is part of the kingdom's Vision 2030 development plan, which includes creating a tourism offering with major hotels, resorts, entertainment venues, and (currently alcohol-free) restaurants and bars.

While Qatar, like Saudi Arabia, follows an ultraconservative version of Islam, it has permitted the sale of alcohol in hotel bars and fan zones during the 2022 FIFA World Cup. However, just two days before the World Cup opener, Qatar banned the sale of beer at stadiums, citing the need to respect their culture and traditions.

Bahrain's alcohol laws are unique in the region, as they impose a ban on drinking alcohol for Muslims only. Non-Muslims are allowed to drink in places specified by the government. This compromise was reached after heated debate, with some calling for a total ban and others arguing that a ban would negatively impact the country's economy and investment climate.

The enforcement of alcohol laws

Alcohol is legal in Bahrain, with a number of bars, licensed restaurants, and off-licenses. However, there are strict laws surrounding the consumption of alcohol, especially for Muslims.

In 2010, Bahrain approved a law that prohibits Muslims from drinking alcohol in public places but allows non-Muslims to consume alcohol in places designated for that purpose. This law was the result of a heated debate in the Bahraini council, with some members advocating for a complete ban on alcohol for all residents, while others supported the rights of non-Muslims to drink alcohol. The law was eventually passed as a compromise, with the specified places for non-Muslims to drink alcohol determined by the government.

The enforcement of this law means that Muslims caught drinking alcohol in public places can face jail time and/or a fine of up to 200 dinars. The owner of the place where Muslims are caught drinking will also be penalized if prior knowledge of the offense is proven. Penalties are doubled in case of repetition.

While alcohol is legal in Bahrain, drunken behavior in public or driving under the influence of alcohol is against the law. Offenders are liable to face fines, imprisonment, deportation, and the withdrawal of their driving licenses. Physical assault and damaging public property while under the influence of alcohol are also offenses that may lead to prison sentences.

The laws in Bahrain are designed to ensure that everyone is respectful of each other's faith and nationality. Visitors and residents are expected to respect Bahraini culture and values, and avoid conduct that might be perceived as breaching these norms, as it may lead to prosecution.

Frequently asked questions