Austria's Germanic Roots: A Cultural And Historical Perspective

Austrians have historically been regarded as Germanic, and they have also viewed themselves as such. Austria was a part of the Holy Roman Empire of the German Nation and was a member of the German Confederation until the Austro-Prussian War in 1866, which resulted in Prussia expelling the Austrian Empire from the Confederation. However, when Germany was founded as a nation-state in 1871, Austria was not a part of it. After World War I, Austria began to establish itself as a sovereign nation. The official language of Austria is Austrian German, which is mutually intelligible with Standard German, though there are some differences in vocabulary and accent.

Austrians speak German

Historically, Austrians were regarded as ethnic Germans and viewed themselves as such. Austria was a part of the Holy Roman Empire of the German Nation and was a member of the German Confederation until the Austro-Prussian War of 1866, which resulted in Prussia expelling Austria from the Confederation. Thus, when Germany was founded as a nation-state in 1871, Austria was not a part of it.

The development of an Austrian identity can be traced to the dynastic policy of the House of Habsburg, which brought together a complex conglomerate of territories under one ruling house. In the 18th century, the Austrian lands experienced an independent cultural development strongly influenced by the unification programs pursued under Maria Theresa and Joseph II, whose intention was to turn their heterogeneous dominions into a unified Austrian state.

The Austrian identity was put to a severe test in 1871 when a unified German nation-state was founded without the Austrian Germans. The 'Austriandom' that subsequently developed was marked by a mixture of pride in Austria's leading position in the German-speaking world and a feeling of exclusion, resulting in an inferiority complex towards the dynamic development of the young German nation-state.

The quest for Austrian identity became even more problematic due to the successful emancipation and self-confident political representation of the other nationalities within the multi-ethnic Monarchy, which the German-Austrians perceived as a threat. This led to a strengthening of German nationalism and a weakening of Habsburg-Austrian patriotism. The change from an Austrian to a German identity often occurred rapidly and was experienced as a personal conversion.

Today, the vast majority of Austrians do not identify as German. They have developed a distinct national identity separate from their German neighbours. However, the influence of their shared history and language continues to shape the relationship between the two countries.

Austria was historically part of the Holy Roman Empire

In the late Iron Age, Austria was occupied by the Hallstatt Celtic culture, which was organised as a kingdom referred to by the Romans as Noricum. In the 6th century, the Bavarii, a Germanic people, occupied these lands until they fell to the Frankish Empire in the 9th century.

In 996, the Ostarrîchi (Austria) was first used to refer to a margravate of the Duchy of Bavaria. In 1156, it became an independent duchy of the Holy Roman Empire. The name "Austria" has been in use since 996.

In 1273, the House of Habsburg began to rule over Austria, which lasted until 1918. In 1806, when Emperor Francis II of Austria dissolved the Holy Roman Empire, Austria became the Austrian Empire and was also part of the German Confederation until the Austro-Prussian War of 1866.

In 1867, Austria formed a dual monarchy with Hungary: the Austro-Hungarian Empire. When this empire collapsed after the end of World War I in 1918, Austria was reduced to the main, mostly German-speaking areas of the empire.

Austrians were historically considered ethnically German

In the 19th century, the term "Austrians" referred to the citizens of the Empire of Austria (1804-1867), and from 1867 until 1918 to the citizens of Cisleithania. The term Austria originally referred to the historical March of Austria, corresponding roughly to the Vienna Basin in what is today Lower Austria.

After the collapse of the Austro-Hungarian Empire in 1918 at the end of World War I, Austria was reduced to a rump state and briefly used the name the Republic of German-Austria in an attempt to unite with Germany. However, this was forbidden due to the Treaty of Saint-Germain-en-Laye (1919). The First Austrian Republic was founded in 1919.

After World War II, the political ideology of pan-Germanism and the union with Germany became associated with Nazism, resulting in Austrians developing their own separate and distinct national identity. Today, the vast majority of Austrians do not identify as German.

While there are many similarities between Austrians and Germans, especially in southern Germany, there are also differences. Northern Germans, for example, tend to look physically different from Austrians. Additionally, there has been more Slavic influence in Austria, particularly in the southern regions, due to its geographical proximity to Slavic countries such as Slovenia, Hungary, and Croatia.

Some people argue that Austrians are ethnically the same as Germans, but others disagree, pointing to differences in haplogroups and the influence of other ethnic groups throughout history, such as the Bavarians, Celtic tribes, and Slavic tribes.

The question of whether Austrians are ethnically German is complex and has been influenced by historical, cultural, and linguistic factors. Today, most Austrians consider themselves to be their own distinct ethnic group, separate from Germans.

Austria was expelled from the German Confederation by Prussia

The Austro-Prussian War of 1866, also known as the Seven Weeks' War, the German Civil War, the Brothers War, or the Fraternal War, was fought between the Austrian Empire and the Kingdom of Prussia. Prussia was aided by various allies within the German Confederation, as well as the Kingdom of Italy, while Austria was supported by several smaller German states, including Bavaria, Württemberg, Baden, and Hesse-Kassel. The war was part of a wider rivalry between Austria and Prussia, and resulted in Prussia expelling Austria from the German Confederation and establishing dominance over the German states.

The conflict between Prussia and Austria was sparked by a dispute over the administration of Schleswig-Holstein, which both powers had conquered from Denmark and agreed to jointly occupy at the end of the Second Schleswig War in 1864. In March 1866, Austria reinforced its troops along its frontier with Prussia, leading Prussia to respond with a partial mobilization of its forces. The Prussian Minister President, Otto von Bismarck, played a key role in the conflict by forming an alliance with Italy and manipulating events to portray Prussia as acting in self-defense.

The war began on June 15, 1866, with Prussia invading Hanover, Saxony, and the Electorate of Hesse. Italy joined the war on Prussia's side on June 20 and declared war on Austria. The Prussian army, under the leadership of Chief of General Staff Helmuth von Moltke, was better trained, disciplined, and equipped than the Austrian army. Additionally, Prussia's more extensive railway system allowed for faster mobilization and concentration of troops.

The main campaign of the war took place in Bohemia, where the Prussian armies converged and defeated the Austrian army at the Battle of Königgrätz on July 3. This victory was decisive, and an armistice between Prussia and Austria came into effect on July 22. The Peace of Prague, signed on August 23, 1866, resulted in the dissolution of the German Confederation and the exclusion of Austria from German affairs. Prussia annexed several of Austria's former allies and formed the North German Confederation, which excluded Austria and the other southern German states.

The expulsion of Austria from the German Confederation marked a shift in power among the German states, with Prussia now holding hegemony. This set the stage for the unification of Germany under Prussian leadership, which was achieved in 1871 with the formation of the German Empire. The rivalry between Austria and Prussia, known as German dualism, ended with Prussia's dominance and the formation of the German nation-state.

Austrians have a distinct national identity

Historically, Austrians were considered ethnic Germans and identified themselves as such, given their shared language and long-standing political unions. Austria was part of the Holy Roman Empire and the German Confederation until the mid-19th century when it was expelled by Prussia after the Austro-Prussian War. This expulsion marked a turning point, as Austria was not included when Germany was founded as a nation-state in 1871. The establishment of the Austro-Hungarian Empire in 1867 further distinguished Austria from Germany, as it now encompassed a diverse range of ethnic groups beyond just Germans.

The collapse of the Austro-Hungarian Empire after World War I marked a significant shift in Austrian national identity. The idea of uniting with Germany was proposed, and briefly, the country was called the Republic of German-Austria. However, this union was forbidden by the Treaty of Saint-Germain-en-Laye in 1919, and Austria was reduced to a much smaller state. The rise of Nazism and the association of pan-Germanism with Nazism further contributed to Austrians developing their own distinct national identity. Today, the vast majority of Austrians do not identify as German.

Austrian identity is influenced by its multicultural history and geographical location. The country has been shaped by various ethnic groups, including Bavarians, Slavs, Hungarians, and Celts. The Austrian lands experienced independent cultural development, particularly under the rule of Maria Theresa and Joseph II, who aimed to unify their heterogeneous dominions into a single Austrian state. This unification process had a significant impact on Austrian culture and identity.

Language also plays a role in shaping Austrian identity. While Austrians and Germans speak German, there are notable differences in accent, vocabulary, and grammar. Austrian German is considered softer and more melodic, with distinct regional dialects, such as the Viennese dialect. Additionally, the Austrian standard differs grammatically from Standard German in some cases, such as the use of "sein" instead of "haben" in the perfect tense.

In conclusion, Austrians have developed a distinct national identity that sets them apart from their Germanic roots. This identity is shaped by historical events, cultural influences, language variations, and the country's multicultural and multi-ethnic heritage. While Austrians and Germans share a language, their national identities have diverged significantly over time, resulting in a clear sense of Austrian nationality that is separate from German identity.

Frequently asked questions