Nationalism's Impact: Germany Vs. Austria-Hungary

Nationalism had a profound impact on the course of history in both Germany and Austria-Hungary, but the effects were markedly different in these two regions. In Germany, nationalism was a driving force behind the country's political and military agenda, influencing its foreign policy and relationships with neighbouring countries. In contrast, Austria-Hungary, a diverse empire comprising multiple ethnic groups, struggled to foster a unified national identity. The rise of nationalism within the empire led to increasing tensions between different ethnic groups, ultimately contributing to its breakup and the outbreak of World War One.

The rise of nationalism in the years preceding World War One

Nationalism in the years preceding World War One had a significant impact on the Austro-Hungarian Empire, which encompassed a diverse range of ethnic groups and modern-day states, including Austria, Hungary, the Czech Republic, Slovakia, and Slovenia, among others. The rise of nationalism within the empire led to increasing tensions and a struggle for power between these different groups, who were keen to form their own nations.

In Hungary, nationalists attempted to restrict minority languages and Magyarise the population, while in Austria, speakers of non-German languages faced challenges in gaining influence. German nationalists in Austria took advantage of the suspension of civil rights and the military control of the civilian administration, known as military absolutism, to settle scores with their Czech and Slovene counterparts.

The Ruthenians, for example, were developing a national consciousness that could have led them to join the Russian Empire, while the Czechs and Slovaks were demanding more power. These nationalist sentiments threatened the survival of the empire, and when Archduke Franz Ferdinand was assassinated in Sarajevo, Austria-Hungary saw an opportunity to go to war with Serbia, which was backed by Germany.

The rise of nationalism also affected the sense of identity within the empire. While previously, it was possible for individuals to identify with both the empire and their specific ethnic group, nationalist voices began to insist that this dual loyalty was unacceptable as World War One approached. This contributed to the breakup of the empire and the eventual outbreak of World War One.

Overall, the rise of nationalism in the years preceding World War One had a significant impact on the Austro-Hungarian Empire, leading to increasing tensions, power struggles, and ultimately, the empire's dissolution and the outbreak of war.

The suspension of civil rights in Austria

Nationalism affected Germany and Austria-Hungary differently in the years leading up to World War One. The Austrian part of the monarchy was characterised by the suspension of many civil rights and the military control of the civilian administration – so-called 'military absolutism'. This empowered German nationalists who felt that nationalist politics needed to be removed from governance. They used their new power to settle accounts with their Czech or Slovene counterparts, prosecuting their national and political opponents.

In Hungary, the situation was slightly different. The Hungarian government prevented a military takeover of the administration. However, Hungarian nationalists increasingly tried to restrict minority languages and Magyarise the population.

The Austro-Hungarian Empire was spread across a huge swathe of central and eastern Europe, encompassing the modern-day states of Austria and Hungary, as well as the Czech Republic, Slovakia, Slovenia, Bosnia, Croatia and parts of present-day Poland, Romania, Italy, Ukraine, Moldova, Serbia and Montenegro. The notion of a shared national identity was always going to be a problem given the disparate nature of the union and the number of ethnic groups involved – most of whom were keen to form their own nation. Until the rise of nationalism in the years preceding World War One, the Empire had managed to incorporate a degree of self-governance, with certain levels of devolution operating alongside the central government.

Various diets and parliaments allowed the Empire’s subjects to feel some sense of dual-identity. It was possible to be both a good servant of the Kaiser and proud of Austria-Hungary and identify as a Czech or a Pole. But, increasingly, as World War One approached, nationalist voices began to insist that you couldn’t be both. The Ruthenians were beginning to develop a national consciousness that might lead to them wanting to join with the Russian Empire, and the Czechs and the Slovaks were already demanding more and more power. Serbia had to be stopped if the Empire was to survive. When Archduke Franz Ferdinand was assassinated in Sarajevo, Austria-Hungary had the perfect excuse to go to war with Serbia. Backed by Germany, the Austro-Hungarian leaders presented a list of demands – known as the July Ultimatum – to Serbia that they believed would never be accepted.

The prevention of a military takeover in Hungary

The Hungarian government prevented a military takeover of the administration, which was different to the situation in Austria, where military absolutism empowered German nationalists to settle accounts with their Czech or Slovene counterparts.

Hungary's situation was unique within the Austro-Hungarian Empire, which was spread across a huge swathe of central and eastern Europe, encompassing the modern-day states of Austria and Hungary, as well as the Czech Republic, Slovakia, Slovenia, Bosnia, Croatia and parts of present Poland, Romania, Italy, Ukraine, Moldova, Serbia and Montenegro. The notion of a shared national identity was always going to be a problem given the disparate nature of the union and the number of ethnic groups involved – most of whom were keen to form their own nation.

Hungarian nationalists increasingly tried to restrict minority languages and Magyarise the population. The Ruthenians, for example, were beginning to develop a national consciousness that might lead to them wanting to join with the Russian Empire. The Czechs and the Slovaks were already demanding more and more power.

The Ruthenians' national consciousness

The Ruthenians were developing a national consciousness, which could lead to them wanting to join the Russian Empire. This was a problem for the Austro-Hungarian Empire, as it was already struggling to contain the nationalist voices of its various ethnic groups. The Empire, which encompassed modern-day states of Austria and Hungary, as well as the Czech Republic, Slovakia, Slovenia, Bosnia, Croatia and parts of present Poland, Romania, Italy, Ukraine, Moldova, Serbia and Montenegro, was a disparate union of many different ethnic groups, most of whom were keen to form their own nations.

The struggle of non-German speakers in Austria

Nationalism had a very different impact on Germany and Austria-Hungary, with the latter being a multi-ethnic empire that struggled to maintain a shared national identity. In Hungary, nationalists tried to restrict minority languages and Magyarise the population, while in Austria, speakers of non-German languages faced struggles and discrimination.

The Austrian part of the monarchy was home to various ethnic groups, including Czechs, Slovaks, Ruthenians, and Poles, who had their own distinct languages and cultures. As World War One approached, nationalist voices became more assertive, claiming that it was impossible to be loyal to both the Austrian Empire and these other identities. This created a tense atmosphere, with non-German speakers facing increasing pressure to assimilate and adopt German culture and language.

The suspension of civil rights and the implementation of military absolutism in Austria further empowered German nationalists, who used their military positions to target their Czech and Slovene counterparts. This dynamic was noted in a 1917 ministerial commission report, which observed that German nationalists in positions of military power felt empowered to prosecute their national and political opponents, using their personal views on what constituted anti-state thinking as the standard.

The assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand in Sarajevo provided the perfect excuse for Austria-Hungary, backed by Germany, to go to war with Serbia, which had become a threat to the survival of the empire. This chain of events ultimately led to World War One, demonstrating how the struggle of non-German speakers in Austria was not just an internal matter but had far-reaching consequences for Europe as a whole.

Frequently asked questions