Belize's Corruption: A Deep-Rooted Issue

Belize has been described as a country with institutionalized corruption, with the prime minister and their ministers considered to be above the law. Political parties are considered the most corrupt institution in Belize, with approximately 64% of respondents in a survey believing that most or all members of Belizean political parties are involved in corrupt practices.

The country's complex tax system has been criticised for making it difficult for businesses to operate honestly, with some companies exempt from paying business tax. This has resulted in many businesses being forced to operate illegally and has created opportunities for graft and corruption.

In addition, there are concerns about the independence of the police force and the judiciary, with allegations that the prime minister can interfere in criminal cases. As a result, there is a perception that government officials engage in authoritarian behaviour, and that there is a lack of accountability for high-ranking officials who break the law.

However, it is important to note that these issues are not unique to Belize, and that the region as a whole struggles with democratic weaknesses and corruption.

Political affiliations protect civil servants from corruption charges

Belize is a democracy that has experienced regular rotations of power through competitive elections. However, government corruption is a significant concern. The country has struggled with corruption, and there is little political will to address the problem effectively. Anticorruption laws are poorly enforced, and corruption charges are rarely brought against civil servants due to their political affiliations.

In the 1970s, when Belize was a British colony, the country had a robust system for addressing government corruption. The Director of Public Prosecution Office, the Audit Department, and the Police Department worked together to investigate and prosecute crimes such as stealing, bribery, corruption, extortion, forgery, fraud, uttering, conversion, and embezzlement by government officials and civil servants. Most of the civil servants arrested, charged, and prosecuted for these crimes were employees of the post office, customs, and police departments.

Since Belize gained independence in 1981, however, civil servants have continued to commit these crimes boldly, and their political affiliations have shielded them from consequences. The prime minister and ministers in Belize are effectively above the law due to their power to appoint and control law enforcement officials, including the attorney general, commissioner of police, director of public prosecutions, magistrates, and judges. These individuals are loyal to the prime minister and serve their interests rather than those of the citizens and the country. As a result, even when civil servants are arrested for crimes, the prime minister or one of their ministers can intervene and have them released from prison.

This culture of impunity has led to widespread corruption in Belize, with the prime minister and ministers themselves engaging in corrupt practices with no repercussions. The country has seen numerous reports of government corruption, including misuse of public funds, corruption, and fraud by public officials, ministers, deputy ministers, and chief executive officers. In one notable case, the consul general in New York, Herman Longsworth, was fired after an audit revealed financial infractions, including the illegal use of official influence for personal gain.

The problem of corruption in Belize is further exacerbated by the lack of effective safeguards and enforcement of anticorruption laws. The Prevention of Corruption in Public Life Act, for example, has been in place for over 20 years, yet no one has ever been prosecuted under it. Additionally, there is little transparency in governance, with persistent issues regarding officials' financial disclosure statements and procurement processes. The business community has also alleged favoritism in the awarding of licenses and public contracts.

The persistence of corruption in Belize has had a detrimental impact on the country's development and the well-being of its citizens. It has contributed to a high rate of violent crime, police brutality, and human trafficking within the country's borders. It has also led to a lack of trust in the government and a sense of powerlessness among the people, who feel that their voices are not being heard or represented.

To address the issue of corruption in Belize, it is crucial to implement meaningful reforms that strengthen the country's anticorruption laws and increase transparency in governance. This includes legislating code and ethics laws for the prime minister, ministers, and civil servants, with strict penalties for infractions. Additionally, the process of appointing key law enforcement officials should be reevaluated to ensure their independence and impartiality.

Prime minister and ministers are above the law

Belize has been described as a country with "institutionalized corruption". The country's tax laws are often criticised as being too high and punitive, forcing businesses to operate illegally from the day they open.

In Belize, the prime minister and their ministers are above the law. If they are suspected of a crime, the people who have the power to arrest, charge, and prosecute are the same people that they appoint into their positions. These include the attorney general, commissioner of police, the director of public prosecutions, magistrates, and judges. All of these individuals are loyal to the prime minister and serve them, not the citizens and country. If a person is arrested for a crime in Belize, the prime minister or one of their ministers can call the inspector of police and ask them to release that person from prison.

The prime minister is established by section 37 of the Constitution of Belize, which provides that the governor-general of Belize "shall appoint a member of the House of Representatives who is the leader of the political party that commands the support of the majority of the members of that House". The prime minister's principal office is the Sir Edney Cain Building, Belmopan.

The current prime minister of Belize is Johnny Briceño, who assumed office in 2020. He succeeded Dean Oliver Barrow, who served as the country's first black prime minister from 2008 to 2020.

Police performance and accountability

Belize's national police force is the Belize Police Department, which is headquartered in Belmopan and headed by a Commissioner. The department has a long history, dating back to 1886 when it was established as the British Honduras Constabulary (BHC) by the Burgess family.

In the 1980s, the Belize Police Department faced significant challenges due to a surge in drug trafficking. This led to some personnel being corrupted by traffickers, resulting in public distrust of the police. There were also accusations of unnecessary force being used by the police to deal with escalating violent crime.

To address these issues, the police leadership in the late 1980s began expressing a commitment to investigating all allegations of malpractice and removing unworthy personnel. Penalties for violating criminal statutes were also increased. The department is divided into two main branches: Operational and Administrative, each headed by an Assistant Commissioner and the Deputy Commissioner, respectively.

While the Operational branch deals with day-to-day policing, the Administrative branch oversees the management and support functions of the department. The Operational branch is further divided into three territorial divisions: Eastern, Central, and Western, each covering different areas of the country. It also includes specialized units such as the Anti-Drug Unit, Gang Suppression Unit, and the Mobile Interdiction Team, which work to combat specific types of crimes.

The Administrative branch, on the other hand, oversees functions such as the National Criminal Investigation Branch, Special Branch, Management Services, and Police Information and Technology unit (PITU). The National Criminal Investigation Branch handles criminal investigations, while the Special Branch deals with national security matters. Management Services encompass various units responsible for legal, planning, welfare, and technological aspects of police operations.

Despite these structural measures, corruption within the Belize Police Department remains a significant concern. There have been reports of abuse of power, brutality, theft, extortion, and even murder by rogue police officers. This has led to a decline in public trust and confidence in the police force.

To restore trust and improve police performance and accountability, a complete overhaul of the department has been suggested, prioritizing transparency and accountability in protecting communities. However, the success of these efforts remains to be seen, and the issue of corruption within the Belize Police Department continues to be a challenge.

Public perception of corruption

Belize has been described as a country with "institutionalized corruption", with a complex web of tax laws that make it difficult for businesses to operate honestly. The country's tax system, which includes business taxes, general sales tax, import duties, and other fees, can result in the government claiming over 50% of profits for businesses with lower net profits. This situation pushes businesses to operate illegally and creates opportunities for graft and corruption.

A 2022 report by the World Justice Project provides insights into the Belizean public's perceptions of corruption. The report found that 48% of respondents believed that most or all police officers engage in corrupt practices, a slight increase from 45% in 2021. Political parties were considered the most corrupt institution, with approximately 64% believing that most or all members are involved in corrupt practices. In contrast, teachers in public schools were seen as the least corrupt, with only 22% suspecting them of corruption.

Belizeans' trust in various institutions improved between 2021 and 2022, with the biggest increase in trust observed in community members (58% in 2022, up from 48% in 2021). However, national government officers, police officers, and prosecutors remained the least trusted, with only 39% of respondents expressing trust.

The report also revealed that Belizeans had mixed views on the protection of fundamental freedoms. While 79% agreed that people could attend community meetings, only 49% believed that local government officials were elected through a clean process. There was a notable decline in perceptions of media freedom, with a decrease of 11 percentage points in the belief that the media could expose cases of corruption without fear of retaliation.

Belizeans also had negative perceptions of government accountability, with only 22% believing that high-ranking officials would be held accountable for breaking the law. This was the lowest perception of accountability among the Central American countries included in the report.

The complex interplay of factors, including tax laws, political affiliations, and public perceptions, contributes to the understanding of corruption in Belize. While some institutions are viewed with more trust than others, the overall perception of corruption in the country remains a concern.

The impact of corruption on voting behaviour

Belize is a constitutional parliamentary democracy where citizens can vote for their government in free and fair periodic elections. However, the country faces issues of corruption, which may impact voting behaviour.

Belize has been described as a country of "institutionalized corruption", with a complex tax system that makes it difficult for businesses to operate honestly. The country's tax laws are seen as punitive, with high business taxes and a range of other fees and duties that make it hard for businesses to survive without evading or avoiding the law. This has led to a culture of corruption, where businesses collude with tax officials to avoid paying the full amount owed.

In addition to issues with the tax system, there are also concerns about corruption within the government and law enforcement. There have been allegations of corruption and impunity by government officials, with few successful prosecutions. The prime minister and ministers are seen as being above the law, as they appoint the attorney general, commissioner of police, and other key law enforcement officials who are loyal to them. This makes it difficult to hold them accountable for any wrongdoing.

The police force has also been accused of using excessive force and inhumane treatment, with a significant number of complaints received by the Office of the Ombudsman against the Belize Police Department. There have also been reports of abuse of power, harassment, and arbitrary search and entry by the police.

The impact of this corruption on voting behaviour is likely to be significant. Citizens may lose trust in the government and the electoral process if they perceive that their leaders are corrupt and not accountable to the people. This could lead to a decrease in voter turnout as citizens become disillusioned with the political process. It could also increase support for alternative parties or candidates who run on an anti-corruption platform.

Additionally, corruption may impact the fairness and transparency of elections. If the government or ruling party is seen as corrupt, there may be concerns about electoral fraud or the misuse of state resources for political gain. This could further erode trust in the democratic process and lead to calls for electoral reforms to ensure free and fair elections.

Moreover, corruption can affect the quality of governance and the delivery of public services. If resources are diverted due to corruption, it can impact the government's ability to provide basic services, such as education, healthcare, and infrastructure. This can particularly impact marginalized communities, who may already face barriers in accessing these services. As a result, voters may become dissatisfied with the government and seek change through the electoral process.

Finally, corruption can also influence the policy agenda and priorities of the government. If officials are engaged in corrupt practices, they may be less responsive to the needs and concerns of citizens. This can create a disconnect between the government and the people, leading to voter dissatisfaction and a potential shift in voting behaviour.

In conclusion, corruption in Belize has the potential to significantly impact voting behaviour. It can lead to a loss of trust in the government and the electoral process, increase support for alternative parties or candidates, affect the fairness and transparency of elections, influence the policy agenda, and impact the delivery of public services. Citizens may demand change and seek to hold their leaders accountable through the power of their vote.

Frequently asked questions