Austrian Economics: Fringe Or Force In Economic Thought?

Austrian economics is a heterodox school of economic thought that originated in Vienna in 1871 with the work of Carl Menger, Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk, Friedrich von Wieser, and others. It is considered heterodox because it is set apart from other schools of economic thought, including neoclassical, new Keynesians, and monetarists, in its focus on individualism and a priori thinking rather than data and mathematical models. Austrian economics is also unique in its belief that economic truths can be discovered through thought experiments that do not rely on data.

While Austrian economics has contributed significantly to the field of economics, it is not widely taken seriously by modern economists. Critics argue that Austrian economics lacks the mathematical and empirical foundations of mainstream economics and relies on hand-waving arguments rather than empirical analysis. Austrian economics is also often associated with conservative political beliefs and libertarian political theory, which further contributes to its reputation as unscientific or ideological.

Despite these criticisms, Austrian economics has attracted renewed interest in recent years, and some economists continue to defend its relevance and legitimacy.

Austrian economics is considered heterodox and not mainstream

Austrian economics is also considered heterodox because it rejects many widely accepted economic theories, such as the idea that free markets can be inefficient. It also diverges from other schools of thought on several key economic issues, including the laws of supply and demand, the cause of inflation, the theory of money creation, and the operation of foreign exchange rates.

Another reason Austrian economics is seen as heterodox is its association with libertarian and right-wing political ideologies. Austrian economics strongly opposes government intervention and promotes unregulated free markets. This has made it a useful ideological tool for far-right actors, who use it to disguise hateful ideologies as economic theories.

Despite being considered heterodox, Austrian economics has made significant contributions to the field. Early Austrian economists were key figures in the marginalist revolution of the 1870s, introducing concepts like marginal utility and opportunity cost that are still widely acknowledged and taught today. Additionally, Austrian economists have offered unique insights into some of the most complex economic issues, earning the school a permanent place in economic theory.

Austrian economics is based on a priori thinking and thought experiments

Austrian economics is a heterodox school of economic thought that is based on a priori thinking and thought experiments. It originated in 1871 in Vienna with the work of Carl Menger, Eugen von Böhm-Bawerk, Friedrich von Wieser, and others. The Austrian school holds that economic theory should be derived from basic principles of human action, rather than data and mathematical models used by mainstream schools of economics.

Austrian economists believe that economic truths can be discovered through "thought experiments" that don't rely on data. They use logic and reasoning to postulate their theories, downplaying or rejecting the role of econometrics and data in economics. This sets them apart from mainstream, orthodox economics, where empirical evidence and quantitative skills are considered critical.

The Austrian school uses the logic of a priori thinking, or something a person can think on their own without relying on the outside world, to discover economic laws of universal application. They argue that these laws are determined by subjective factors, such as an individual's preference to buy or not buy a particular good. In contrast, other schools of economics, like the neoclassical school, rely on objective data and mathematical models.

Austrian economics is often associated with free-market economics and a rejection of government intervention. They believe that economic institutions form unintentionally as a result of individual choices and actions. Therefore, they tend to view government activity as harmful and believe that economic systems are not purposefully designed.

While Austrian economics has contributed significantly to economic theory, it is no longer considered mainstream. Many professional economists today consider Austrian economics to be misguided or heterodox due to its lack of empirical rigor and rejection of widely accepted economic theories. However, Austrian economics continues to have a dedicated following and has earned a permanent place in the complex world of economic theory.

Austrian economics is criticised for lacking empirical foundations

Austrian economics is considered heterodox, or not mainstream. It is criticised for lacking the mathematical and empirical foundations of mainstream economics, instead focusing on conceptual thought and hand-waving arguments.

Austrian economics is a purely deductive framework, using logic and reasoning to postulate theories. It is based on a priori thinking, which means it is derived from self-evident truths, rather than relying on the outside world. This is in contrast to other schools of economics, which use data and mathematical models to prove their point objectively. Austrian economics is also criticised for its lack of empirical rigour, with some Austrian economists even rejecting econometric methods.

Austrian economics is also criticised for its lack of predictive power. One user on Reddit commented that "the Austrian school actually has the lowest predictive power of most of the established economics schools of thought". Another user commented that Austrian economics "lacks the ability to show" that its ideas are sound.

However, defenders of Austrian economics argue that it is not an inductive approach, and therefore it would be easier for ideological biases to slip into analyses. They argue that because it is a deductive theory, critics should be able to easily show that it is ideological, either by arguing that the action axiom is ideological, or by pointing out where the reasoning is flawed and abandoned for ideological reasons.

Austrian economics is also defended on the basis that it is not intended to "formulise human behaviour" but to provide relief from the "technical mumbo jumbo" of mainstream economics.

Austrian economics is associated with libertarian political theory

Austrian economics is a heterodox school of economic thought that advocates strict adherence to methodological individualism, the concept that social phenomena result primarily from the motivations and actions of individuals along with their self-interest. Austrian-school theorists hold that economic theory should be exclusively derived from basic principles of human action. This is in contrast to other mainstream schools of economics, like the neoclassical school, the new Keynesians, and others, which make use of data and mathematical models to prove their point objectively. Austrian economics is considered “heterodox”, or not mainstream. Some modern economists do not even consider it legitimate economics.

However, this association with libertarian political theory is not without its critics. Some argue that Austrian economics is not libertarian but conservative. Critics argue that Austrian economics is not a reliable framework for analysis but a consistently slanted worldview. They argue that Austrian economics is ideological because it proceeds from premises that its proponents like: that unfettered selfishness and greed are good. Critics also argue that Austrian economics is not scientific but religious, and that it is a form of religious fanaticism where the "free market" is God. They argue that Austrian economics is not neutral to the facts but by definition anything but neutral.

Austrian economics has influenced modern economic concepts

Austrian economics has had a significant influence on modern economic concepts. The Austrian School of Economics, founded by Carl Menger in 1871, is a heterodox school of economic thought that emphasises methodological individualism. This means that Austrian economists believe that social phenomena, such as economic activity, are primarily driven by the motivations, actions, and self-interest of individuals.

One of the key contributions of the Austrian School is the development of the theory of marginal utility, which holds that the value of goods and services is subjective and varies from person to person. This theory, introduced in Menger's "Principles of Economics", marked the beginning of the marginalist revolution in economics. Another important concept introduced by Austrian economists is opportunity cost, which refers to the value of the next best alternative option that is foregone when making a choice. This idea was first formulated by Austrian economist Friedrich von Wieser in the late 19th century and is now a key concept in mainstream economics.

Additionally, Austrian economists have contributed to our understanding of capital and interest. Eugen Böhm von Bawerk, an Austrian economist, argued that interest rates and profits are determined by the supply and demand for final goods and time preference. Furthermore, Austrian economists have offered insights into the causes of inflation and the operation of foreign exchange rates. They argue that any increase in the money supply that is not supported by a corresponding increase in the production of goods and services leads to rising prices, with some goods experiencing faster price increases than others.

The Austrian School has also shaped our understanding of business cycles and economic fluctuations. According to Austrian economists, banks' issuance of credit at artificially low-interest rates leads businesses to invest in production processes that are unsustainable in the long run, resulting in a misallocation of resources and eventually a recession. This theory, known as the Austrian Business Cycle Theory (ABCT), highlights the role of central banks and the financial system in causing economic instability.

While Austrian economics has made significant contributions to economic thought, it is important to note that it is considered heterodox and is not widely accepted by mainstream economists today. This is partly due to its rejection of empirical evidence and mathematical modelling, which are fundamental tools in modern economics. However, Austrian economics continues to offer unique insights and has had a lasting impact on the field of economics.

Frequently asked questions