Democrats' Afghanistan Dilemma: Withdrawal Support Or Long-Term Commitment?

The topic of withdrawing US troops from Afghanistan has been a highly debated issue among Democrats. While some Democrats have supported the idea of withdrawing troops, others have criticised the manner in which the withdrawal was executed. In 2019, prominent Democratic presidential candidates, including Joe Biden, Elizabeth Warren, and Pete Buttigieg, expressed their eagerness to end the long-running conflict in Afghanistan. They argued that the presence of US troops was not helping the safety and security of the United States, the world, or Afghanistan. However, some Democrats, such as House Democrats and key pro-war GOP lawmakers, worked together to restrict Trump's planned withdrawal of troops from Afghanistan. They voted in favour of an amendment that prohibited the reduction of US troops in Afghanistan below 8,000 without certain conditions being met. This amendment was passed by a vote of 45-11. Overall, the Democratic Party's stance on withdrawing troops from Afghanistan has been influenced by their assessment of US goals and interests in the region, as well as considerations of national security and humanitarian concerns.

Democrats want to withdraw troops from Afghanistan, but have been criticized for not speaking out as the situation deteriorates

Democrats have been largely supportive of withdrawing troops from Afghanistan, but have faced criticism for not speaking out as the situation in the country deteriorates.

In 2021, as the Taliban took control of Afghanistan, President Joe Biden faced bipartisan criticism over the U.S. withdrawal. While most Democrats supported the idea of withdrawing troops, few spoke out as the situation on the ground worsened. Some Democrats, such as Senator Bob Menendez and Representative Jim Langevin, publicly criticised Biden's handling of the withdrawal. However, many others stayed silent or defended Biden's decision to end the 20-year conflict.

The silence from some Democrats may be due to a desire to avoid giving ammunition to Republicans, who have strongly criticised Biden's handling of the withdrawal. Additionally, some Democrats may agree with the underlying decision to withdraw troops, even if they disagree with how it was carried out.

The criticism of Biden's handling of the withdrawal comes as the Taliban's rapid advance and the collapse of the Afghan military underscore the challenges of the situation. The U.S. public also broadly criticised the Biden administration's handling of the situation, with only about a quarter saying the administration did an excellent or good job.

The debate over the withdrawal of troops from Afghanistan has highlighted divisions within the Democratic Party, with some hawks criticising the decision to withdraw, while others defend Biden's decision to end a costly and lengthy conflict.

Some Democrats have called for the protection of endangered Afghan women, and an immediate expansion of the refugee program

In 2021, as the Taliban took control of Afghanistan, the Biden administration faced bipartisan criticism for its handling of the U.S. withdrawal. While Democrats largely supported the idea of withdrawing troops, they criticized the haphazard manner of the pullout. Notably, a group of 47 senators, led by Democratic Sens. Bob Menendez, Edward Markey, and Jeanne Shaheen, called on the Biden administration to take swift action to protect endangered Afghan women.

In a letter to Secretary of State Antony Blinken and Secretary of Homeland Security Alejandro Mayorkas, the senators urged the creation of a humanitarian parole category to facilitate the relocation of Afghan women leaders, activists, human rights defenders, judges, parliamentarians, journalists, and members of the Female Tactical Platoon of the Afghan Special Security Forces to the United States. They emphasized the need to streamline the paperwork process to allow for fast, humane, and efficient relocation.

Senator Shaheen, a member of the Senate Armed Services and Foreign Relations committees, highlighted the dire conditions on the ground and warned that without swift and decisive action, Afghan civilians, especially women, would suffer or die at the hands of the Taliban. She called for an immediate expansion of the refugee program for Afghan women seeking asylum, stating that failure to act would seal the fate of a generation of girls who had grown up with freedoms, education, and dreams of building their country's future.

The call for the protection of Afghan women and the expansion of the refugee program reflects a broader concern for the rights and well-being of women and girls in Afghanistan. Since the Taliban takeover, there have been fears that the progress made over the last two decades in advancing women's rights could be erased. Afghan women who worked with the U.S. or international groups are at risk of retaliation from the Taliban and face challenges in accessing refugee programs.

The situation has led to a broader discussion about the role of the U.S. in Afghanistan and the impact of its withdrawal. While some argue that the U.S. should have stayed engaged to prevent the rollback of women's rights, others believe that the U.S. presence could not address the underlying issues and that a different approach is needed to effectively support Afghan women and promote their rights.

Democrats have criticized the haphazard manner of the US withdrawal from Afghanistan

While Democrats supported the idea of withdrawing troops from Afghanistan, they criticized the haphazard manner of the US withdrawal.

In August 2021, the Taliban took control of Afghanistan, and the US military evacuation of the country commenced, bringing America's longest war to an end. The public was critical of the Biden administration's handling of the situation, with only about a quarter saying the administration had done an excellent or good job.

Democrats, while acknowledging that President Biden was carrying out the policies of his predecessor, criticized the haphazard manner of the US withdrawal. They argued that the withdrawal of US troops "should have been carefully planned to prevent violence and instability" and that the Biden administration owed it to US military service members and their families to have a plan in place.

Some Democrats also expressed concern about the fate of the Afghan people, particularly women and girls, and called for the immediate expansion of the refugee program for Afghan women seeking asylum. They also criticized the slow process of bringing Afghan translators and other allies to the US, many of whom were at risk of persecution by the Taliban.

In his defense, Biden argued that there was never a good time to withdraw US forces and that the US had already spent too long trying to shape circumstances in Afghanistan.

Democrats have supported the idea of withdrawing troops from Afghanistan, but not Syria

In 2019, more than 50 Democratic House members issued an open letter to then-President Trump condemning his decision to withdraw troops from northeastern Syria. The letter stated that Trump's decision would put U.S. allies in danger, jeopardize counterterrorism efforts, and cause current and future allies to question the reliability of the U.S. as a partner. This stance was reiterated by several Democratic presidential candidates, including Joe Biden, who called the withdrawal "the most shameful thing any president has done in modern history in terms of foreign policy."

However, Democrats have simultaneously supported the withdrawal of U.S. troops from Afghanistan. In 2020, the Democratic presidential candidates raced to reassure voters about how quickly they would bring the remaining troops home from Afghanistan. Senators Elizabeth Warren and Bernie Sanders, and former Vice President Joseph Biden, were so eager for the U.S. to depart that they said they would pull out combat troops even without an agreement with the Taliban. This position was maintained by the Biden administration, which defended its decision to withdraw from Afghanistan in 2021.

The difference in approach can be attributed to several factors. Firstly, the presence of U.S. troops in Afghanistan was seen as a direct response to the 9/11 attacks, with Democrats viewing the war in Afghanistan as a "good war." Secondly, the human and financial costs of the war in Afghanistan were significantly higher, with approximately 14,000 American troops and an annual cost of roughly $45 billion. In contrast, the U.S. had only 1,000 troops in Syria, and the financial and human costs were lower. Additionally, the U.S. mission in Syria was seen as sustainable in a way that the Afghanistan mission was not, as the Afghan army was expected to crumble without U.S. support.

Despite their support for withdrawing troops, Democrats criticized the haphazard manner of the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan, which led to a bipartisan backlash. In contrast, their criticism of Trump's withdrawal from Syria focused on the abandonment of allies and the potential humanitarian consequences, rather than the manner of the withdrawal itself.

Democrats have been criticized for their Afghan strategy, which is a lot like Trump's

The 2020 Democratic candidates shared a major goal for Afghanistan: to get out. They were keen to differentiate themselves from a president they saw as having a feckless, isolationist view of American power.

During the 2019 debates, there was almost no discussion of American goals for the country, such as building a democracy or protecting the rights of women. This was a striking change from previous elections, where Democrats saw Afghanistan as the "good war", prompted by a direct attack on the United States.

However, Democrats have been criticized for their Afghan strategy, which is a lot like Trump's.

In 2020, the House Armed Services Committee voted in favor of an amendment prohibiting the reduction of U.S. troops in Afghanistan below 8,000 without certain conditions being met. This amendment was jointly sponsored by a Democrat, Jason Crow, and a Republican, Liz Cheney. The amendment passed with a significant majority of Democratic votes.

In 2021, there was bipartisan backlash to President Biden's handling of the withdrawal from Afghanistan. While Republicans were scathing about the White House's actions, Democrats, while acknowledging that Biden was carrying out the policies of his predecessor, criticized the haphazard manner of the U.S. withdrawal.

In 2017, Democrats criticized Trump's Afghanistan strategy for lacking details and argued that he was proposing an open-ended commitment with no exit strategy or ceiling on U.S. troops.

Frequently asked questions