Austria-Hungary: Could The Empire Reunite?

The Austro-Hungarian Empire, a confederation of the Kingdom of Hungary and the Habsburg Empire, was one of the most powerful European forces at the outbreak of World War I in 1914. However, the Allied Powers slowly captured its territories, and the empire finally surrendered in 1918, bringing an end to Austria-Hungary. Since then, several analyses and explanations have emerged about how different the world would be if the territories were reunited. A reunited Austria-Hungary would be the fourth or sixth most populous country in Europe, and its territory would affect 13 or 14 modern-day countries.

What would a reunited Austria-Hungary look like?

A reunited Austria-Hungary would be a diverse and complicated state, with a mix of Austrian and Hungarian politics, cultures, and traditions. It would likely adopt a federal system of government, uniting the two countries while acknowledging their differences. This would also help address the economic disparities between the mountainous and prosperous Austrian provinces and the plains and poorer Hungarian provinces.

A reunited Austria-Hungary would have a diverse population, with Hungarians as the largest ethnic group, followed by Germans, Ukrainians, Czechs, Romanians, Poles, and Croats. The official language would be challenging to predict, but it could be a hybrid of Germanic and Uralic languages, allowing the country to retain the benefits of both linguistic traditions. The capital would likely be Budapest and Vienna as joint capital cities, reflecting their historical significance and large populations.

In terms of economy, a reunited Austria-Hungary would have a combined nominal GDP of around $1.211 trillion, placing it 15th globally. However, the nominal GDP per capita would be moderate at $17,008. The country would have a large military force of around 188,250 active-duty troops, ranking 30th in the world.

A reunited Austria-Hungary would face challenges, including cultural conflicts between Austrian and Hungarian identities and environmental issues, as Hungary is one of the most polluted countries globally, contrasting with Austria's focus on environmentalism. Additionally, the process of reunification would be lengthy and complex, requiring the voluntary union of sovereign nations and potentially involving bitterness and recrimination.

What would be the economic impact?

If Austria and Hungary were to reunite, the economic impact would be significant. Firstly, the reunited country would have a large population of around 70-90 million people, which would make it one of the most populous countries in the world. This large population would also result in a significant increase in the labour force, which could boost economic growth and productivity.

In terms of GDP, a reunited Austria-Hungary would have a large economy, estimated to be around $1.2 trillion to $1.9 trillion. This would make it one of the largest economies in the world, providing economic benefits such as increased global influence and the ability to compete with other major economies. However, it is important to note that the impact on unemployment and average income could vary between the two countries. For example, Austria's unemployment rate is predicted to decrease, while Hungary's is expected to rise.

The adoption of a new common currency to replace the Austrian Euro and the Hungarian Forint would be a significant institutional change. This would create a single monetary system, helping to unite the two provinces economically and facilitating trade and investment. Additionally, the diverse economic models and industries in the mountainous regions and plains could complement each other, creating a more resilient and diverse economy.

The reunion could also lead to the modernization of the Austrian and Hungarian economies, which are currently struggling to keep up with the rest of Europe. Sharing best practices and knowledge in manufacturing, research and development, and other fields could help both countries improve their economic performance and competitiveness.

However, there would also be challenges and adjustments. The cultural conflict between the two sides, with their distinct identities and languages, could create tensions and make it difficult to forge a new national identity. Additionally, environmental issues, such as Hungary's high pollution levels, could pose challenges in aligning with Austria's stronger environmental norms.

What language would they speak?

If Austria and Hungary were to reunite, the question of what language the new country would speak is a complex one. Both countries have their own official languages, and a reunion would likely result in a multilingual state.

Austria's official language is German, with Austrian German being the most widely spoken language variety. It is an important prerequisite for participating in the country's working, economic, and social life. Additionally, Croatian, Slovenian, and Hungarian are recognised as official languages of autonomous population groups in some regions. English is also widely spoken in Austria, taught as the first foreign language in most schools, and used extensively in urban areas.

In Hungary, Hungarian is the sole official language and is the first language of about 98.9% of the population. However, Hungary also recognises several minority languages, including German, Slovak, Serbian, Slovene, Croatian, Romanian, and Romani. These languages are spoken in various regions of the country and are protected under the European Charter for Regional or Minority Languages.

In a reunited Austria-Hungary, it is likely that both German and Hungarian would be widely spoken, reflecting the historical and cultural significance of these languages in their respective territories. The specific language dynamics would depend on the political and cultural context of the reunion, as well as the degree of integration and cooperation between the two regions.

It is worth noting that a reunited Austria-Hungary would encompass a diverse range of linguistic groups. In addition to German and Hungarian, languages such as Czech, Ukrainian, Romanian, Polish, and Croatian would be spoken by significant portions of the population. As a result, the new country would likely need to accommodate and promote the use of multiple languages to ensure effective communication and representation for all its citizens.

Therefore, a reunited Austria-Hungary would likely be a multilingual entity, with German and Hungarian serving as the most prominent languages, while also recognising and accommodating the various minority languages spoken within its borders.

What would be the global impact?

The reunification of Austria and Hungary would have a significant global impact, given the countries' central location in Europe and their membership in the European Union. Firstly, it would result in the formation of a new regional superpower, with a GDP of approximately $1.9 trillion, making it the 16th most powerful country in the world economically. This economic strength would provide the reunited country with greater political influence on the global stage, potentially rivaling that of Germany and France within the European Union.

Secondly, the reunification would lead to a significant shift in European demographics and politics. The new country would have a population of around 70-90 million people, depending on which territories join the union, making it the 5th or 20th most populous country worldwide. This large and diverse population would encompass multiple ethnic, linguistic, and religious groups, creating a complex societal landscape. The federal system of government, likely to be adopted, would grant autonomous provinces a degree of self-governance while acknowledging cultural and economic differences between the regions.

The impact of reunification would also extend beyond the economic and political spheres. The environmental implications, for instance, would be notable due to the contrasting natural settings and climates of Austria and Hungary. Austria's mountainous terrain and Hungary's plains would necessitate distinct economic and environmental models within the reunited country. Additionally, Hungary's status as one of the most polluted countries in the world would present challenges in aligning with Austria's environmentally conscious norms.

Furthermore, the cultural implications of reunification would be profound, as Austrians and Hungarians have developed distinct identities over the past century. Reconciling these differences and forging a new national identity would be a complex and potentially divisive process, with some groups struggling to find their place in the new entity. The adoption of a common language, likely a hybrid of Germanic and Uralic languages, would be a significant aspect of this cultural transition.

On a global scale, the reunification of Austria and Hungary could have both positive and negative consequences. It could contribute to stabilizing Central and Eastern Europe by counterbalancing the influence of Russia and Germany. Additionally, the reunification would bring together two populations with democratic traditions, enhancing their role in shaping Europe's future. However, it is worth noting that the re-establishment of a powerful Austria-Hungary could also spark tensions with former neighbors, given its historical role in the lead-up to World War I.

Overall, the global impact of an Austria-Hungary reunification would be far-reaching, reshaping the geopolitical landscape of Europe and potentially leading to both collaboration and conflict on the world stage.

What are the challenges?

There are several challenges to consider when discussing the potential reunification of Austria and Hungary. Firstly, it is important to acknowledge the presence of several sovereign nations within the territories that historically comprised the Austro-Hungarian Empire. This presents a significant obstacle, as it would require these nations to give up their sovereignty or, at the very least, a significant portion of it. While there may be conditions that could make this more palatable, such as a confederative or federalized system, it is still a complex and contentious issue.

Another challenge lies in the cultural and linguistic differences that have emerged since the Empire's dissolution. Today, Austria is a German-speaking country, while Hungary has its own distinct language. Forging a new shared identity and deciding on a common language for a reunited Austria-Hungary would be a difficult task, and could lead to bitterness and recrimination on all sides. Additionally, the environmental differences between the two countries, with Austria being mountainous and Hungary consisting mostly of plains, would create distinct economic and environmental models that would need to be reconciled.

The potential dominance of the Austrian population within a reunited Austria-Hungary is also a concern. With a larger population, Austrians could gradually erode the powers of the Hungarian government and replace them with their own institutions and culture. This could result in Hungarians being marginalised within the newly-formed state.

Furthermore, the process of reunification itself would likely be lengthy and contentious. Almost no countries have successfully reunified after being broken apart, and the breakup of the Austro-Hungarian Empire was particularly messy and painful. A reunification of Austria and Hungary would require extensive debate and negotiation between the constituent nations and could take many years, if not decades.

Lastly, it is worth considering the potential international implications of a reunited Austria-Hungary. While it could help stabilise Central and Eastern Europe by counterbalancing Russia and Germany, it could also spark tensions with former neighbours. Given the Empire's role in the lead-up to World War I, this is a sensitive issue that cannot be overlooked.

Frequently asked questions