Bavaria's Secession: A Break From Germany?

Bavaria, officially the Free State of Bavaria, is a state in the southeast of Germany. It is the largest German state by land area and has a distinct culture, largely due to its Catholic heritage and conservative traditions. While some Bavarians have expressed a desire for secession, it is not a widespread or realistic movement. Bavaria has a strong regional identity, and its political expression is dominated by the Christian Social Union (CSU), a regional party that advocates for Bavarian autonomy within the federal system. The CSU has successfully navigated the conflict between regional autonomy and Bavaria's role in the German federation. Despite cultural differences and historical votes against the German constitution, Bavarians recognise the benefits of remaining within Germany, such as economic success and representation in the Bundesliga.

Bavaria's strong regional identity

Bavaria has a distinct culture, largely due to its Catholic heritage and conservative traditions. These traditions include a language, cuisine, architecture, festivals, and elements of Alpine symbolism.

Bavaria's history includes its earliest settlement by Iron Age Celtic tribes, followed by the conquests of the Roman Empire in the 1st century BC. In the 6th century AD, following the collapse of the Western Roman Empire, it became the Duchy of Bavaria. It was later incorporated into the Holy Roman Empire and became the independent Kingdom of Bavaria in 1806.

The Kingdom of Bavaria succeeded the former Electorate of Bavaria and continued to exist until 1918. In 1871, the kingdom became a federated state of the German Empire and was second in size, power, and wealth only to the Kingdom of Prussia.

Bavaria has a strong regional identity, with many inhabitants considering themselves "Bavarians" first and "Germans" second. This separate national identity is emphasised by unique traditions, such as traditional costumes known as Tracht, including Lederhosen for males and Dirndl for females. Bavarians also tend to place great value on food and drink, with renowned dishes such as Weißwurst ("white sausage") and a strong tradition of brewing beer.

Bavaria is also home to several football clubs, including FC Bayern Munich, and has a thriving arts and culture scene, with many theatres, orchestras, opera companies, museums, and art galleries.

While there is a strong sense of regional identity, the idea of Bavaria seceding from Germany is largely seen as a joke or a meme. There are some small groups that support the idea, but it is not a widespread or realistic possibility.

The Bavaria Party (BP)

The Bavaria Party saw some success at the polls in the late 1940s and 1950s, obtaining 20.9% of the votes in Bavaria in 1949 and 17 seats in the German Bundestag. In 1950, they won 17.9% of the votes and 39 seats in the Bavarian state parliament, where they formed a coalition with the Bavarian branches of the Social Democratic Party of Germany (SPD) and the Free Democratic Party (FDP). This coalition forced the CSU out of power for three years, from 1954 to 1957.

However, due to various factors, including the casino affair influenced by the CSU, the Bavaria Party rapidly lost voters. They were last elected to the Bavarian state parliament in 1962. In the 2008 local elections, the party made a small comeback, winning 50 seats, mostly in Upper Bavaria, including one seat in the City Council of Munich, after a 42-year absence. In the 2018 Bavarian Parliament elections, the BP reached 1.7% of the voters' share, and they are currently represented in three administrative regions of Bavaria: Upper Bavaria, Lower Bavaria, and Swabia.

The Bavaria Party continues to advocate for Bavarian independence and a return to the monarchy, with a King from the House of Wittelsbach, the old Bavarian nobility. While some Bavarians may romanticise the idea of secession, it is not a serious or feasible prospect, and most Bavarians accept Bavaria as part of Germany.

The Christian Social Union (CSU)

The CSU was founded in 1945-1946 by various Roman Catholic and Protestant groups and is committed to free enterprise, federalism, and a united Europe operating under Christian principles. It is considered the de facto successor of the Weimar-era Catholic Bavarian People's Party. The CSU has governed Bavaria continuously since 1946, except for a brief period between 1954 and 1957. In national elections, it has consistently performed well, often receiving more than half of the votes in Bavaria.

The CSU is more conservative than the CDU, especially on social issues influenced by Catholic social teaching, such as abortion, church-state matters, immigration, and the rights of foreign residents. The CSU also tends to take a more nationalist position in foreign policy. For example, in the 1970s, it opposed the Social Democratic Party-led government's efforts to normalize relations with Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union. Additionally, the CSU has been less supportive of European integration than the CDU, and its nationalism led to an embarrassing debacle in 2019 when a CSU plan to introduce a toll on foreign cars on the highway was deemed against European Union rules.

The CSU has contributed eleven of the twelve minister-presidents of Bavaria since 1945. The party leader, Markus Söder, currently serves as Minister-President of Bavaria, a position previously held by Franz Josef Strauß, a prominent figure in the party's history. Strauß led the CSU from 1961 until his death in 1988 and was the party's first candidate for the German chancellery in the 1980 federal election, where he lost to the incumbent Helmut Schmidt. In the 2021 federal election, the CSU had a weak showing, receiving 5.2% of votes nationally and 31.7% of the total in Bavaria.

The CSU has a unique relationship with the CDU, sometimes complementing and sometimes rivaling its larger counterpart. The two parties have a deal whereby they agree not to compete in each other's territories and instead form a nationwide force at the federal level. This arrangement gives the CSU national power, as it has representatives in the federal parliament as part of the joint CDU/CSU parliamentary group. The CSU is guaranteed seats in the Cabinet when the CDU/CSU wins a national election, and it traditionally runs the Transport and Agriculture ministries, reflecting Bavaria's strong automobile industry and agricultural traditions.

While the marriage between the CSU and CDU is mutually beneficial, it has also faced challenges. There have been clashes between members of the two parties, such as when CSU Interior Minister Horst Seehofer bitterly disagreed with Chancellor Angela Merkel over her migration policy in 2015-2016. Additionally, the CSU has faced competition from other right-wing rivals, such as the populist center-right Free Voters and the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD), which have peeled off sections of its electorate.

Bavarian exceptionalism

Bavaria, officially the Free State of Bavaria, is the largest German state by land area and has the second-largest economy among the German states by GDP figures, giving it the status of a wealthy German region. It has a distinct culture, largely due to its Catholic heritage and conservative traditions, including a unique language, cuisine, architecture, festivals, and Alpine symbolism.

Bavaria's economic strength has allowed it to exert influence disproportionate to its size in German politics. The conservative Christian Social Union (CSU) has ruled the state for decades, ignoring the vagaries of German national politics and retaining its regional identity. This has earned the state-based party a unique role as a powerful conservative force in national politics.

Bavaria's exceptionalism is deeply rooted in its history and culture. The state was settled by Iron Age Celtic tribes and later conquered by the Roman Empire in the 1st century BC. It became the Duchy of Bavaria in the 6th century AD and was incorporated into the Holy Roman Empire. After the collapse of the Western Roman Empire, Bavaria became the independent Kingdom of Bavaria in 1806, joined the Prussian-led German Empire in 1871, and finally became a state of the Federal Republic of Germany in 1949.

Bavaria's distinct culture and history have contributed to a sense of pride and tradition among its inhabitants. Traditional costumes, such as Lederhosen for males and Dirndl for females, are worn on special occasions. Centuries-old folk music is performed, and traditional Bavarian sports disciplines, such as Aperschnalzen (competitive whipcracking), are still practised. Bavarians are also known for their renowned dishes and beer culture, with nearly half of all German breweries located in the state.

Bavaria's political tribalism has had a significant impact on German politics and European unity. The CSU, in an unprecedented escalation over Germany's migration policy, has even undermined Chancellor Angela Merkel's government. The CSU's agenda is more xenophobic, fiscally conservative, and socially regressive than that of Merkel's Christian Democratic Union (CDU).

While Bavarian exceptionalism is a strong force, the idea of Bavarian secession from Germany is largely seen as a joke or a meme. However, there is a secessionist current within Bavaria, and according to polls, around 30-32% of Bavarians would support the state's independence.

The Scottish independence referendum

The referendum was the result of a commitment by the Scottish National Party (SNP) to hold an independence referendum when it published its manifesto for the 2011 Scottish Parliament election. The SNP won 69 of the 129 seats, securing a majority in a proportional representative voting system.

The referendum was made possible by the Edinburgh Agreement, which allowed for the temporary transfer of legal authority from the UK government to the Scottish Parliament. The Scottish Independence Referendum Act 2013 was passed by the Scottish Parliament on 14 November 2013 and received Royal Assent on 17 December 2013.

The campaign in favour of Scottish independence, Yes Scotland, was supported by the SNP, the Scottish Green Party, and the Scottish Socialist Party. The campaign in favour of Scotland remaining in the UK, Better Together, was supported by the Conservative Party, Labour Party, and Liberal Democrats.

The referendum was held against the backdrop of the UK's plans for an EU referendum, which some commentators suggested could undermine the case for Scottish independence. The Scottish government argued that an independent Scotland should become a full member state of the European Union (EU) with some exemptions, such as not having to adopt the euro. There was debate over whether Scotland would be required to reapply for membership and whether it could retain the UK's opt-outs.

The UK government published an analysis identifying a 'Union dividend' of £1,400 per year for each person in Scotland, mainly due to the higher level of public spending. The Scottish government disputed this analysis, saying that each Scot would be £1,000 better off per year under independence by 2030.

The referendum also raised questions about the future of the Northern and Western Isles, with some islanders calling for separate referendums to be held. The Scottish government committed to devolving further powers to Orkney, Shetland, and the Western Isles in the event of independence.

Following the referendum, the SNP took a clear lead over other parties in Scottish opinion polls. In the 2015 general election, the SNP won 56 out of the 59 Scottish seats contested in the election. However, the SNP's political fortunes have since declined, with the party winning just 9 seats in the 2024 UK general election.

Despite the setback, the SNP leader Nicola Sturgeon has vowed to renew the push for independence, aiming to hold a referendum in 2023. However, this faces a significant obstacle as the British Prime Minister Boris Johnson has stated he will not consent to a binding referendum.

Frequently asked questions