The Shadow Of Afghanistan: America's Dilemma

The US withdrawal from Afghanistan in August 2021 marked the end of the country's longest war, spanning two decades. The decision to leave was justified by the need to refocus on great-power competition with China, free up resources, and address domestic priorities. However, the chaotic exit drew criticism from various quarters, including national security experts, politicians, and the media. The Taliban's takeover of Afghanistan has raised concerns about human rights violations, media censorship, and the potential for the country to become a terrorist safe haven once again. Despite the challenges, the Biden administration remains committed to its decision, arguing that the war's objectives had been achieved and that the US can still address counter-terrorism priorities through over-the-horizon capabilities.

The US withdrawal from Afghanistan

The US exit from Afghanistan resulted in the Taliban regaining control of the country, causing a refugee crisis as many Afghans fled. The Taliban's takeover also raised fears that Afghanistan would become a safe haven for terrorists, with al-Qaeda leader Ayman al-Zawahiri discovered in the country's capital, Kabul, and killed in a US drone strike.

The withdrawal was chaotic and faced strong criticism, particularly regarding the evacuation process. There were reports of Afghans who had assisted US and allied forces being left behind, and up to 200 Americans were still in the country when the last troops departed. The Biden administration was accused of failing to adequately prepare for the evacuation and not taking responsibility for its mishandling.

The US decision to withdraw from Afghanistan was influenced by a shift in national security priorities, with a greater focus on great power competition, particularly with China. Additionally, there was a recognition that the war on terror could not be "won" in the traditional sense, and the resources committed to Afghanistan were needed elsewhere. However, the manner of the US withdrawal and the subsequent collapse of the Afghan government have been criticised, with some arguing that the US should have done more to prevent a Taliban takeover.

The legacy of the US withdrawal from Afghanistan continues to be debated, with the Biden administration facing ongoing scrutiny and criticism for its handling of the situation.

The Taliban's takeover of Afghanistan

The Taliban's swift offensive came as the US withdrew its remaining troops from Afghanistan, in line with a 2020 peace agreement between the Trump administration and the Taliban. The agreement stipulated that the US would withdraw all troops in exchange for the Taliban cutting ties with terrorist groups and entering negotiations with the Afghan government. However, the Taliban reneged on this deal, and no official ceasefire was put in place.

The Taliban's takeover was facilitated by the corruption within the US-backed Afghan government and security forces. Billions of dollars spent by the US and its NATO allies to train and equip Afghan forces were undermined by commanders who exaggerated the number of soldiers to siphon off resources. This led to a lack of ammunition, supplies, and even food for troops in the field, causing their morale to erode. As a result, entire units surrendered after brief battles, and Kabul fell without a fight.

The consequences of the Taliban's takeover were immediate and severe. Afghans, particularly women, saw their rights and freedoms drastically curtailed. Girls were banned from attending school past the sixth grade, and women were prohibited from working, appearing in public without a male chaperone, or travelling significant distances alone. Independent media outlets were shut down, and journalists, activists, and protestors were arrested, forcibly disappeared, or worse. The economy floundered, malnutrition soared, and hundreds of thousands of jobs were lost.

The Taliban's return to power also raised concerns among the international community about the potential for Afghanistan to once again become a safe haven for terrorist groups, particularly al-Qaeda. While the Taliban pledged to prevent its territory from being used by terrorists, analysts and US military officials worried that the group's ties to al-Qaeda could result in Afghanistan becoming a base for international terrorist attacks once more.

The speed and ease of the Taliban's takeover, coupled with the subsequent regression in rights and freedoms, led to widespread criticism of the Biden administration's handling of the withdrawal. The chaotic exit was seen as a "blind spot" for President Biden, who was accused of shutting out critical warnings and approaching the withdrawal with "stubbornness". The perception of mishandling and calamity damaged the credibility of the US on the world stage, raising questions about its reliability as an ally.

The future of Afghanistan

There are concerns that Afghanistan could once again become a safe haven for terrorist organizations. The U.S. has stated that it will retain counterterrorism capabilities and will hold the Taliban accountable for its commitment to not allow terrorist groups to threaten the U.S. or its allies from Afghan soil. However, the effectiveness of these measures remains to be seen.

The economic crisis in Afghanistan has been exacerbated by the freezing of billions of dollars in Afghan central bank assets and the reduction in international aid. There are calls for the international community to negotiate the release of these frozen assets to help alleviate the humanitarian crisis. The Taliban's restrictions on women and minorities are also hurting the local economy and alienating the international community.

Regional powers, such as Pakistan, China, Russia, and Iran, will also play a significant role in Afghanistan's future. They have varying interests and objectives in the country and are likely to engage with the Taliban in different ways. The U.S. withdrawal has created a power vacuum that these regional powers will seek to fill, potentially leading to increased competition and conflict in the region.

Overall, the future of Afghanistan remains highly uncertain, with the country facing political, economic, and humanitarian challenges. The Taliban's actions, the international community's response, and the resilience of the Afghan people will shape the country's trajectory in the coming months and years.

The impact on the Biden administration

The Biden administration's decision to withdraw troops from Afghanistan has had a significant impact on both domestic and foreign policy. On the domestic front, the withdrawal was initially supported by a majority of Americans, with 54% agreeing with the decision to leave Afghanistan. However, the Biden administration faced intense criticism for the chaotic nature of the exit, with 70% of Americans expressing negative views of the administration's handling of the situation. This criticism was particularly strong among Republicans, with 82% disapproving of the administration's handling of the withdrawal. The chaotic exit from Afghanistan also accelerated the decline in Biden's job approval ratings, which had already been on a downward trajectory.

In terms of foreign policy, the Biden administration's decision to withdraw from Afghanistan was driven by a desire to refocus resources on great power competition, particularly with China. The withdrawal was intended to free up resources, including money and troops, which could be redirected towards deterring Chinese aggression in the Pacific theater. However, the manner of the withdrawal has raised questions about the credibility and reliability of the United States as an ally. The perception of calamity in Afghanistan has amplified the need for the United States to demonstrate its commitment to its allies, particularly those in the Indo-Pacific region.

The withdrawal from Afghanistan has also had a significant impact on the geopolitical situation in the region. With the United States no longer having a military presence in Afghanistan, regional powers such as Russia, China, and Iran are now working to fill the vacuum and expand their influence. Russia has been holding military drills in Tajikistan, which borders Afghanistan, and China has been increasing its pressure on Pakistan, bringing the country closer to its orbit. The Taliban's takeover of Afghanistan has also led to a rollback of human rights, particularly for women and girls, and there are concerns that the country could once again become a safe haven for terrorist groups.

The Biden administration has defended its decision to withdraw from Afghanistan, arguing that it was necessary to end a war that was no longer in the national interest of the United States. The administration has also emphasized its commitment to counterterrorism efforts and the evacuation of American citizens and vulnerable Afghans. However, the chaotic nature of the withdrawal and the subsequent Taliban takeover have had a significant impact on the Biden administration's reputation, both domestically and internationally.

The US's next steps

The US's withdrawal from Afghanistan has been a highly controversial topic, with many Americans and politicians criticising President Biden's handling of the situation. Biden himself has stood firmly by his decision, calling it a "moral imperative".

The US has emphasised its ability to operate "beyond the horizon", indicating that it will rely on non-military means, such as intelligence and special operations, to address security concerns in Afghanistan. This includes over-the-horizon capabilities, which allow the US to strike terrorist targets without a large military presence on the ground.

The US will also continue to support the evacuation and resettlement of American citizens and Afghan allies who remain in the country. Secretary of State Antony Blinken has indicated that the administration has facilitated the departure of roughly 900 US citizens since the withdrawal.

On the international stage, the US will aim to strengthen its alliances and deter adversaries, particularly China, from inciting conflicts. The US's support for Ukraine has been seen as a step towards restoring its standing in the eyes of the world.

However, the US's ability to influence events in Afghanistan is now limited, and the country faces challenges in maintaining its credibility and global standing. The Taliban's control of Afghanistan has raised concerns about human rights violations, media censorship, and the potential for Afghanistan to become a safe haven for terrorist groups once again.

The US will need to carefully navigate its approach to Afghanistan, balancing its counter-terrorism goals with the need to prevent further instability and protect the interests of its citizens and allies.

Frequently asked questions