New Brunswick: Canada's Worst Province?

New Brunswick is often regarded as the worst Canadian province. It has been described as boring, with nothing worth looking at, and no awe-inspiring nature. The province's economy is in a downward spiral, with more deaths than births, and it is now Canada's poorest province. It has an uninteresting cityscape, constant bragging about high tides, and a lack of attractions. The political culture is steeped in linguistic tribalism, with an ugly language war, pitting north against south, French against English, and urban against rural. New Brunswick has a high average age, an out-migration of young residents, and a struggling economy reliant on federal support.

Poorest province in Canada

New Brunswick has been dubbed the "poorest province in Canada", with the highest per-capita amount of equalization payments from the federal government's support program. The province's economy is in a downward spiral, with more deaths than births, and an ugly language war. New Brunswick's GDP growth of 3.7% is the weakest among equalization-receiving provinces, and less than the national average. The province's debt is projected to hit $13.5 billion by the end of the fiscal year.

New Brunswick has a significant demographic challenge, with an aging population and a high rate of out-migration, particularly among younger residents. The average age in the region of Campbellton-Miramichi is 49.4, the second-highest in Atlantic Canada. The province's rural areas have outsized political clout, with 33 mostly rural ridings tending to guard their services and institutions despite their shrinking populations.

The province also faces a burgeoning language war, with French and English populations pitted against each other, mirroring the linguistic tribalism seen in Quebec. This has resulted in sign laws, legal battles, and rhetoric from linguistic camps. The bilingualism in New Brunswick has had economic benefits, fostering business with Quebec and attracting call centres and office-support operations. However, it has also led to tensions over issues such as busing children according to the language they speak.

New Brunswick has been described as boring and lacking in natural beauty or awe-inspiring landscapes. However, it does have some notable features, such as Fundy National Park and Parlee Beach National Park. The province also has a rich history, with sites such as the Carleton Martello Tower.

Uninteresting cities

New Brunswick is one of the Maritime provinces in Eastern Canada. It has eight cities, 26 towns, and 61 villages. The cities in New Brunswick are considered uninteresting, which is one of the reasons why it is considered the worst province.

The largest city in New Brunswick is Moncton, with a population of 79,470 residents. Moncton is located in the valley of the Petitcodiac River and is considered a major transportation hub for the Maritime provinces. However, despite its functional importance, it is seemingly uninteresting to visitors. The second most populous city in New Brunswick is Saint John, with a population of 67,575. Saint John is a port city located on the Bay of Fundy and is known for its shipbuilding and fishing industries. While it may have some cultural significance, it is not a popular tourist destination. Fredericton, the provincial capital, is the third-largest city, with a population of 58,270. It is a hub of culture and education, hosting events such as the Harvest Jazz & Blues Festival. However, it does not seem to offer much excitement for those seeking entertainment outside of educational or cultural pursuits.

Other cities in New Brunswick include Dieppe, which is the fourth-largest city and is officially francophone, with more than 70% of residents speaking French natively. Riverview is the fifth-largest municipality, located in Albert County along the Petitcodiac River. Campbellton, the smallest city in New Brunswick, has a population of 6,883 people and is located on the banks of the Restigouche River.

The general consensus seems to be that the cities of New Brunswick are uninteresting, with a lack of exciting attractions or activities for visitors. This perception contributes to the province's reputation as the "worst" in Canada.

Economic free fall

New Brunswick's economy is in a state of free fall, with the province facing a host of challenges that have led to this economic decline. The province has been grappling with a declining population, as young residents continue to migrate out of New Brunswick due to limited economic opportunities. This brain drain has resulted in a shrinking tax base, hindering the province's ability to generate sufficient revenue.

Compounding this issue, New Brunswick has an aging population, with a high number of residents requiring care and housing for the elderly. This has led to a growth industry in the region, but it is not enough to offset the economic decline. The province's GDP growth has been weak compared to other provinces, and New Brunswick has had to rely on equalization payments from the federal government to fund basic government services such as healthcare and education.

The economic woes of New Brunswick can also be attributed to the decline of its traditional industries. The closure of mines and lumber, pulp, and paper mills, as well as the air force base in 1996, have dealt a significant blow to the provincial economy. Additionally, the province's debt is projected to reach $13.5 billion, further exacerbating the financial strain.

New Brunswick's high reliance on federal cash transfers, which make up about 36% of its budget, is another concerning factor. This makes the province highly dependent on external support, limiting its financial autonomy. The province's rural areas also hold significant political clout, which has led to a continuation of unsustainable policies and bailouts for failing industries.

The current economic situation in New Brunswick is a stark contrast to two decades ago when the province was in a strong financial position. Former premier Frank McKenna's government had achieved successive surplus budgets and made significant progress in reducing the provincial debt. However, the province has since posted five straight budget deficits, and the economic outlook remains bleak.

Ugly language war

New Brunswick, Canada's poorest province, is facing an ugly language war. The province is officially bilingual, with the right to receive provincial government services in English or French. However, this has led to tension and conflict between the French and English-speaking populations, mirroring the language wars in Quebec.

The province's linguistic divide is reflected in its electoral map, with the Liberal Party predominantly representing the French-speaking north and the Progressive Conservatives holding seats in the English-speaking south. This divide has resulted in a political culture steeped in linguistic tribalism, with governing often requiring pitting north against south, French against English, and urban against rural.

The language war in New Brunswick has resulted in absurd legal battles, such as the controversy over busing school children. The suggestion that French and English students could share buses sparked anger from the Education Minister, who promised to end this practice, claiming it was an "administrative anomaly". This incident highlights the deep-rooted nature of the language war, where even minor issues can become highly contentious.

The language war has also led to accusations of favouritism towards French-speaking New Brunswickers. English-speaking advocates argue that the requirement for bilingualism in government positions disproportionately affects the English population, as a higher percentage of French speakers are bilingual. Additionally, they claim that French signage requirements and the renaming of streets to honour Acadian poets are further examples of favouritism.

The language war has resulted in threats and violence, with members of the Anglophone Rights Association of New Brunswick being spat on while distributing flyers. This conflict has also had economic implications, with some companies leaving the province due to subsidies ending and the high cost of bilingualism.

The language war in New Brunswick is a complex issue with deep historical roots. The province's bilingual status, while providing economic benefits, has also created divisions and conflict between its French and English-speaking populations, leading to a tense political and social climate.

Poor political leadership

New Brunswick has been dubbed Canada's poorest province, with the nation's lowest median household income and the only province that recorded a population decline between 2011 and 2016. The province has suffered through consecutive deficit budgets and staggering debt, and its tax base continues to shrink.

The province's poor economic situation has been attributed to a lack of leadership and poor decision-making by its political leaders. Economist Richard Saillant, author of "Over the Cliff?: Acting Now to Avoid New Brunswick’s Bankruptcy," argues that the government is failing to address the province's demographic reality and spending beyond its means. He warns that a sharp rise in interest rates or a downgrade in bond ratings could push New Brunswick over the edge if no action is taken soon.

In 2018, New Brunswick's Finance Minister, Ernie Steeves, acknowledged the province's poor economic situation and expressed his desire for New Brunswick to be a "have" province rather than a "have-not" province. However, the province's economic growth has remained stagnant, and it continues to rely on equalization payments from the federal government to provide basic government services such as healthcare and education.

The province's political leaders have also been criticized for their handling of other issues, such as their response to the COVID-19 pandemic. Premier Blaine Higgs, the leader of the Progressive Conservative Party, initially gained popularity for his government's management of the pandemic but later faced a backlash after a premature loosening of public health restrictions, which led to a spike in cases.

Additionally, Higgs has faced internal dissent and a caucus revolt within his own party. Six MLAs rebelled against his leadership, and two ministers resigned, citing concerns about the centralization of power in the premier's office. Higgs has also been criticized for his decision-making process, with some accusing him of causing division within the province and his own party.

In conclusion, New Brunswick's poor political leadership has contributed to its economic woes and other challenges, such as the COVID-19 response and internal political turmoil. The province's leaders have been accused of failing to address pressing issues, spending beyond their means, and causing division instead of unity. As a result, New Brunswick continues to struggle economically and faces an uncertain future if no significant changes are made.

Frequently asked questions