Which Wich Shop: New Brunswick's Favorite

The Ale ‘N ‘Wich Pub in New Brunswick, New Jersey, has been serving the Rutgers community for 49 years. It's located at 246 Hamilton Street and is open Sunday from 7 pm to 2 am, Monday from 7 pm to 2 am, Tuesday and Wednesday from 7 pm to 2 am, and Thursday through Saturday from 5 pm to 2 am. The pub offers a range of alcoholic beverages, including beer, wine, and liquor, and has a covered outdoor smoking patio where patrons can drink and smoke simultaneously. The building has a long history, having been constructed in 1920 and housing a variety of businesses over the years, including a tailor shop, a grocery store, a grill, a sports bar, and finally, the Ale ‘N ‘Wich Pub.

Which Wich's vegan and vegetarian options

Which Wich has plenty of vegan and vegetarian options. You can choose from a variety of signature sandwiches or build your own with their vegan-friendly ingredients.

Signature Sandwiches

The Black Bean Avocado and Garden Party sandwiches can be ordered vegan by removing the cheese and mayo/dressing. The Black Bean Avocado comes with a vegan black bean patty, avocado, lettuce, tomatoes, and red onion, while the Garden Party comes with avocado, cucumbers, lettuce, tomatoes, and red onion.

Build Your Own

Start by choosing white bread (vegan) or a Bowlwich (a salad in a bowl) as your base. Then, pick your ingredients from the following vegan-friendly options:

• Peanut Butter Grape Jelly Chips
• Lettuce
• Tomatoes
• Banana Peppers
• Bell Peppers
• Black Olives
• Pickles
• Cucumbers
• Jalapeños
• Avocado (extra charge)
• Which Wich House Chips

Other Options

The Superfood Wich bag is also a vegan option, although it is only available for a limited time.

Additionally, the cheese at Which Wich may contain animal rennet, but it can be removed by request.

The Ale 'N 'Wich Pub's history

The Ale N Wich Pub has been serving the Rutgers community for 49 years. The building was originally constructed in 1920 as a tailor's shop, with the tailor living behind the shop. Over time, it has undergone several transformations, including serving as a grocery store and the Hamilton Grill in 1934. In 1971, it became Angie's Sports Bar, a local watering hole for hunters and fishermen, with a Hunting and Fishing Club using the bar for meetings and social events.

On August 5, 1974, Angie's was reopened as The Ale 'N 'Wich Pub. The name 'Wich' comes from the game room, which was originally a kitchen and still has white tiles on the wall from when it was a grill. The outdoor patio was added around 1991, and the pub has been frequented by several famous people over the years, including musicians and actors. The pub has undergone recent renovations, including restoring the original tin ceiling and adding new lighting fixtures. The Ale 'N 'Wich Pub is handicap accessible via a side gate on Louis St and allows customers to bring their own food, a unique feature for a pub in New Brunswick.

Other sandwich shops in New Brunswick, NJ

New Brunswick, NJ, has a variety of sandwich shops to choose from, including:

Harold's New York Deli Restaurant

This deli has received positive reviews for its sandwiches, with one review noting that a $35 sandwich was enough to feed four people.

European Homemade Provisions

A specialty food market offering Polish cuisine, this shop has been praised for its homemade salads, kielbasa, and other Eastern European delights.

Jersey Mike's Subs

With two locations in New Brunswick, Jersey Mike's offers subs and sandwiches made with fresh ingredients. They are known for their "Sub Above," which is carefully crafted and measured in more than just inches or seconds until served.

Old Man Rafferty's

A full-service restaurant established in 1981, Old Man Rafferty's offers a variety of American dishes, including grilled salmon, steaks, and sandwiches. They have outdoor seating and are wheelchair accessible.

Mamoun's Falafel

Mamoun's Falafel is a family-owned and operated Middle Eastern restaurant that has been serving high-quality falafel sandwiches since 1971. They offer take-out and delivery services.

Hansel 'n Griddle

Hansel 'n Griddle offers a variety of sandwiches, including a grilled chicken sandwich with roasted red peppers and mozzarella. They also serve breakfast and brunch items.

Khyber Coffee & Tea House

While still in its soft opening period, this locally owned and operated coffee shop has already gained recognition for its customer service. They offer sandwiches and other food items, along with coffee and tea.

Yelp reviews for New Brunswick, NJ sandwich shops

Yelp users have plenty of options for sandwich shops in New Brunswick, NJ, and they have a lot to say about them. Here's a round-up of some of the reviews:

Harold's New York Deli Restaurant

One Yelp reviewer says that a "$35 sandwich is enough to feed four people, so it's really a bargain".

European Homemade Provisions

A reviewer on Yelp says this shop offers "an authentic eastern European shop with delicious homemade salads, kielbasa..."

Jersey Mike's Subs

Jersey Mike's Subs has multiple locations in New Brunswick, and one Yelp reviewer says: "I love that they sliced the cheese and meats fresh for every single sandwich they make!"

Hansel 'n Griddle

One Yelp reviewer ordered the "grilled chicken, roasted red peppers and mozzarella sandwich" and shared their positive experience.

Khyber Coffee & Tea House

A Yelp reviewer mentions that the staff at Khyber Coffee & Tea House are "acknowledging repeat customers and that should serve them well".

Destination Dogs

Destination Dogs gets a mention from a Yelp reviewer who says they had a "tough time deciding which hot dog I wanted so I went with the conquistadog which was to represent Spain".

Old Man Rafferty's

A "full-service restaurant" that serves "American-style dishes", Old Man Rafferty's is described by a Yelp reviewer as "crowded and hectic but that's the price you pay for being popular! Food always good".

Mamoun's Falafel

With multiple locations in New Brunswick, Mamoun's Falafel is described by a Yelp reviewer as having "a great amount of food for your money".

Panera Bread

Multiple locations of Panera Bread in New Brunswick are highlighted by a Yelp reviewer who says: "From focusing on quality, clean ingredients to serving our food to you in a warm and welcoming environment, Panera Bread is committed to being an ally".

Monster Sandwich

Although there aren't any reviews for Monster Sandwich on Yelp, it's worth noting as an option for sandwich lovers in New Brunswick.

Which Wich's rewards and app

Which Wich has a rewards program called the Vibe Club Rewards. By joining the Vibe Club Rewards, customers can get free rewards for their purchases. For every 75 reward points accumulated, customers can get a free 7" Wich. They also get a free drink just for joining, a free Wich on their birthday, and the potential for other special promotions or giveaways. To start earning points, customers can download the Which Wich mobile app on iOS or scan the app at the register every time they visit.

Frequently asked questions