Mauka Honey: New Zealand Vs. Austria, Which Is Superior?

which mauka honey is better new zealand or austria

Manuka honey has become a highly sought-after product worldwide, renowned for its medicinal and health benefits. The ongoing debate about the differences between New Zealand and Austrian Manuka honey has sparked interest and controversy. While both countries produce Manuka honey, there are distinct variations in the specific plant species, geographical origin, floral sources, grading systems, and production processes. The term Manuka is deeply rooted in Maori culture, and New Zealand has actively sought to protect its authenticity and reputation in the global market.

Characteristics Values
Scientific name Leptospermum scoparium
Origin The Manuka tree is found in certain areas of Australia, but it is considered native to New Zealand
Number of species Australia: 83-87; New Zealand: 1
Testing and quality control Australia: inconsistent testing standards; New Zealand: rigorous quality assurance through the internationally recognized UMF certification
Trademark New Zealand: The UMF Honey Association (UMFHA) has initiated a legal application with the New Zealand Intellectual Property Office for a certification trademark
Medicinal properties Australia: 12 species with medicinal properties; New Zealand: N/A
Potency Australia: unmatched in potency; New Zealand: N/A
Purity Australia: unmatched in purity; New Zealand: pristine environment
Quality Australia: unmatched in quality; New Zealand: N/A

shunculture

New Zealand's Manuka honey is derived from the Leptospermum scoparium plant

The Manuka tree is an evergreen shrub with flowers that are used to produce Manuka honey. The honey has a strong flavour, described as "earthy, oily, herbaceous", "florid, rich and complex", with a "damp earth, heather, aromatic" aroma and a "mineral, slightly bitter" flavour. The honey gets its unique properties from the natural signature chemicals found in the Manuka tree, including MGO (methylglyoxal), UMF (Unique Manuka Factor), leptosperin, DHA, and prebiotics.

New Zealand has conducted extensive research on Manuka honey, with hundreds of studies aimed at understanding and utilising its benefits. The country has also implemented strict standards and regulations to ensure the quality and purity of Manuka honey. The Ministry for Primary Industries has developed the Mānuka Honey Science Definition test, which comprises five attributes, four of which are chemical, and one of which is DNA testing to ensure the honey is pure Leptospermum scoparium.

The UMF Honey Association (UMFHA), an independent quality and rating organisation, certifies four quality factors for honey harvested, packed, and sealed in New Zealand. This organisation was established to secure the name "Manuka Honey" for New Zealand producers and the wider industry, protecting it similarly to other products like French Champagne and Scottish Whisky.

While Australian Manuka honey is derived from the same plant species, there are some chemical differences between the two countries' honey. Australian Manuka honey has higher levels of cinteole and monoterpines, and the plant-to-plant variation within each country is significant.

shunculture

The term Manuka is an embodiment of the Maori culture

The term "Manuka" is deeply rooted in the Maori culture of New Zealand. For the indigenous Maori people, the Manuka plant has been more than just a plant; it has been used in various forms in traditional remedies, carrying stories and practices that have been passed down through generations.

The Maori have long recognised the therapeutic and medicinal value of the Manuka plant. In traditional Maori medicine, known as "Rongoa Maori", ailments are treated holistically, incorporating plant use, massage, and incantations. The Manuka plant's bark, sap, leaves, and oil are all utilised in Rongoa Maori for their healing properties.

The unique geography and climate of New Zealand play a crucial role in fostering the growth of the Manuka bushes, which thrive in regions like Northland, East Cape, Wairarapa, and Taranaki. Each of these regions boasts distinct soil conditions and subclimate variations, contributing to the honey's distinct taste and properties.

The term "Manuka" is not just a name but a legacy. Its association with Maori culture is so strong that both the UK Trade Mark Registry and the Intellectual Property Office of New Zealand have ruled that the term "Manuka" is a Maori word, akin to how champagne can only be recognised as originating from a specific area of France. This ruling has significant implications for the ongoing debate between New Zealand and Australia over the ownership of the term "Manuka honey".

While the Manuka tree (Leptospermum scoparium) is found in certain areas of Australia, it is considered native to New Zealand. The lack of strict regulations for honey purity in Australia further complicates the matter, making it challenging to differentiate between the various Australian Leptospermum honey varieties and the native New Zealand Manuka honey.

shunculture

Australian Manuka honey comes from various Leptospermum species

Australian Manuka honey, historically known as Jelly Bush honey, is derived from various Leptospermum species. There are 83-87 species of Leptospermum found in Australia, 12 of which have bioactive medicinal properties, making them ideal for high-MGO Manuka honey production.

In contrast, New Zealand Manuka honey is derived exclusively from the Leptospermum scoparium plant, also known as the Mānuka tree. While the Mānuka tree is considered native to New Zealand, it is found in certain areas of Australia, and there are claims that it originated there.

The difference in plant species is not the only distinction between the two types of Manuka honey. New Zealand Manuka honey benefits from the country's pristine environment, Māori cultural stewardship, and rigorous quality assurance through the internationally recognized UMF certification. The UMF Honey Association (UMFHA) has initiated a legal application to secure the name "Manuka Honey" for New Zealand, further solidifying its status as the gold standard in the global market.

On the other hand, Australian Manuka honey lacks the same level of quality control as its New Zealand counterpart. Efforts have been made to improve its reputation, but inconsistent testing standards and environmental challenges have hindered its ability to match New Zealand's product in potency and reliability.

Despite this, some claim that Australian Manuka honey is superior due to the diversity of its Manuka tree species and the high MGO content of certain species. Australian Manuka honey producers also independently lab-test and rate their honey according to its MGO level.

shunculture

New Zealand has conducted hundreds of studies to understand and use Manuka honey

New Zealand has a long history with Manuka honey, with the first honey produced in the country believed to be of the Manuka variety. The indigenous Māori people of New Zealand have long valued the Manuka plant, and the honey it yields is considered an important part of their culture.

In the early 1980s, a local scientist confirmed that Manuka honey possesses unique antimicrobial properties, and since then, New Zealand has conducted hundreds of studies to understand and utilise this natural product. The country has also created specific tests and established laws to ensure the quality of the honey.

The UMF Honey Association (UMFHA) has applied for a certification trademark to secure the name "Manuka Honey" for New Zealand internationally. This move aims to protect the product's reputation and ensure its association with New Zealand producers, similar to how "Champagne" is protected for French producers.

The high demand for Manuka honey has led to a significant increase in its value. The industry, which exported around $40 million worth of honey a decade ago, saw this number soar to $270 million by 2017.

The unique properties of Manuka honey are attributed to the nectar bees collect from the native Manuka bush (leptospermum scoparium) and the bees' conversion of this nectar into honey. The honey's therapeutic and medicinal qualities have been recognised for many years, with people using it to treat wounds, improve digestion, boost immunity, and soothe coughs and sore throats.

The level of methylglyoxal (MGO), a chemical found in Manuka honey, determines its UMF® grade and antibacterial characteristics. The higher the MGO content, the higher the UMF® rating.

shunculture

Australian Manuka honey has 12 species with bioactive, medicinal properties

The debate over whether New Zealand or Australian Manuka honey is better has been a long-standing one. While New Zealand has conducted hundreds of studies to better understand and use Manuka honey, Australia has also stepped into the global honey market, claiming that its Manuka honey varieties are just as active and have essentially the same chemical profile as those produced in New Zealand.

Australian Manuka honey offers a range of bioactive and medicinal properties that set it apart. It is produced by bees that pollinate the native Leptospermum scoparium bush, commonly known as the tea tree. This honey contains methylglyoxal, which gives it its powerful antibacterial, antiviral, antioxidant, and anti-inflammatory properties. These qualities make it ideal for treating wounds, burns, and sores, as well as improving digestive issues, soothing sore throats, and preventing tooth decay.

Australian Manuka honey is also believed to provide relief from upper respiratory tract infections, including coughs, sore throats, and runny noses. Additionally, it may help prevent gingivitis and periodontal disease by reducing plaque buildup. One of the advantages of using honey for these issues is that, unlike antibiotics, it does not contribute to the development of resistant bacteria or "superbugs".

Furthermore, Australian Manuka honey is known for its ability to fight infections and boost healing. It has been used for centuries in various cultures for wound healing, and modern studies have shown that it can be effective in treating leg ulcers and speeding up recovery from burns and surgical wounds.

Australian Manuka honey is produced entirely in Australia and is subject to strict standards set by the Australian Mānuka Honey Association (AMHA). These standards ensure its purity and authenticity, requiring independent laboratory testing to meet minimum levels of naturally occurring methylglyoxal (MGO), dihydroxyacetone (DHA), and leptosperin.

With 12 species of the Leptospermum scoparium bush, Australian Manuka honey offers a diverse range of bioactive and medicinal properties that contribute to its unique profile and effectiveness in various therapeutic applications.

Frequently asked questions

It depends on what you're looking for in your honey. New Zealand Manuka honey is derived exclusively from the Leptospermum scoparium plant and benefits from the country's pristine environment, Maori cultural stewardship, and rigorous quality assurance. On the other hand, Australian Manuka honey comes from various Leptospermum species and lacks consistent testing standards and environmental protection. However, Australia is home to more species of Manuka, 12 of which have medicinal properties, making their honey unmatched in potency, purity, and quality.

The difference lies in the specific plant species that each type of Manuka honey comes from. New Zealand Manuka honey is sourced from the Leptospermum scoparium plant, while Australian Manuka honey comes from various Leptospermum species.

New Zealand Manuka honey has become popular due to its unique and powerful properties, renowned for its medicinal and health benefits. The Maori, the indigenous people of New Zealand, have a deep cultural connection to the Manuka plant, further adding to its significance.

Australian Manuka honey is considered superior by some due to the higher number of bioactive Leptospermum species in the country. Out of the 83 species of Manuka in Australia, 12 have medicinal properties, resulting in a more diverse range of honey varieties with high potency.

The UMF Honey Association (UMFHA) and the Manuka Honey Appellation Society Incorporated (MHAS) are working to secure the term "Manuka Honey" for New Zealand producers. These organizations aim to obtain certification trademarks and ensure that New Zealand Manuka honey maintains its authenticity and reputation in the global market.

Share this post
Print
Did this article help you?

Leave a comment