Philippine Vs Belize: Public Education Face-Off

Belize and the Philippines have vastly different approaches to public education, with Belize spending 7.9% of its GDP on education, while the Philippines spends 3.2%. This difference in spending has a significant impact on the quality of education in each country. Belize's education system is primarily based on the British model, influenced by its history as a British colony, while the Philippines blends Eastern and Western educational traditions, influenced by its colonial past under Spain and the US. The Philippines has over 2,000 universities and colleges, catering to a diverse range of international students, while Belize has a mix of public and private schools, with varying levels of quality and access to resources. While Belize has made strides towards improving its education system, it still faces challenges such as underpaid teachers and underfunded schools, especially in rural areas. On the other hand, the Philippines faces challenges such as underfunding but is committed to enhancing its educational quality and global competitiveness.

Curriculum and cultural orientation

Belize's education system is based on the British system but has been influenced by the US academic syllabus, particularly through the Jesuits. The curriculum is therefore a blend of British and US educational traditions. The system is divided into three levels: primary, secondary, and tertiary education.

Belizean children begin their eight years of primary education with two years of "infant" classes, followed by six "standards". Secondary education is divided into four "forms", with the sixth form being a two-year post-secondary course.

The curriculum in Belizean schools varies according to the type of school. Most private and denominational schools emphasize academic and commercial studies, while some also offer technical-vocational programs. On the other hand, the government directly manages nine schools, all of which offer a curriculum oriented towards technical-vocational subjects.

Education practices, rituals, and valuative criteria in Belizean schools have been influenced by Jesuit institutions in the US. Nearly 30 years of Peace Corps and other US volunteer teachers have also left an impact on the country's education culture.

The Philippines' education system blends Eastern and Western educational traditions, with a bilingual curriculum in Filipino and English. The system consists of kindergarten, elementary school (grades 1-6), junior high school (grades 7-10), and senior high school (grades 11-12).

The curriculum in the Philippines has recently shifted to the K-12 system, which includes one year of kindergarten, six years of elementary education, four years of junior high school, and two years of senior high school. This shift aims to align the country's education system with global standards.

The curriculum in the Philippines covers a range of subjects, including Filipino, English, mathematics, science, social science, history, and culture, physical education, and arts. One notable change is the introduction of minority languages ("mother tongues") as the language of instruction in the early years of elementary education in certain areas.

The senior high school curriculum is specialized, with four tracks: Academic, Technical-Vocational-Livelihood, Sports, and Arts and Design. The Academic track is further divided into strands: Accountancy and Business Management, Humanities and Social Sciences, Science and Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics, and General Academic.

The Technical-Vocational-Livelihood track also has several strands, including Home Economics, Agriculture/Fishery, Industrial Arts, and Information and Communications Technology. The Sports and Arts and Design tracks prepare students for careers in sports-related fields and creative industries, respectively.

The Philippines' education system also includes Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET), which offers a range of programs to train the country's labor force in various vocations.

Teacher training and pay

In addition to their salaries, teachers in the Philippines receive benefits and compensation packages. These include allowances for clothing/uniforms, productivity incentives, performance-based bonuses, vacation pay, and chalk allowances. They also receive loyalty cash incentives, special hardship allowances for those assigned to remote areas, and leave privileges. Social security benefits such as retirement and life insurance, hospitalization, and an employees' compensation program are also provided.

In Belize, teaching jobs typically offer modest, entry-level salaries, with the average wage for a primary school teacher being $10,685 for both foreigners and locals. The cost of living in Belize, especially in coastal and island areas, can be higher than in neighbouring countries, but wages reflect this. Teachers usually pay for their own accommodation, but the cost of rent and utilities is reasonable.

Belizean teachers are required to have a Bachelor's degree in an academic or education-based subject, as well as a teaching qualification to qualify for a work permit. Teaching jobs are available in public and private schools, with the majority of public schools being jointly run by the government and the Catholic Church. Private schools often hire teachers from overseas and offer generous salaries, but longer working hours are expected.

While the specific details of teacher training curricula and methods in the Philippines and Belize may differ, both countries have implemented measures to ensure that teachers receive fair compensation and have the necessary qualifications to educate their students effectively.

Education expenditure

Belize spends 7.9% of its GDP on education, while the Philippines spends 3.2% of its GDP on education. This means that Belize spends 2.63 times more on education than the Philippines.

Belize's education system is based on the British model, as the country was a British colony for over a century. However, there has also been a significant influence from the United States, particularly through the presence of Jesuit missionaries and teachers from the American Peace Corps. As a result, the content of the curriculum is more American than British.

The Belizean government has primary responsibility for overseeing schools in the country, and it certifies and pays the majority of teachers. However, a significant number of schools are run by churches, predominantly Catholic, but also including a range of Protestant denominations.

While primary education in Belize is compulsory and free in some schools, there are associated expenses such as uniforms, books, and fees, which can be a financial burden for low-income families. This contributes to a high number of school dropouts and children not receiving an education.

The Philippines, on the other hand, faces challenges of underfunding in its education system. The country has over 2,000 universities and colleges, offering a bilingual curriculum in Filipino and English. The Philippines has recently adopted the K-12 system, bringing it in line with international standards and extending basic education to 12 years.

School fees and costs

The cost of education in Belize can range from very cheap public primary schools to very expensive private schools. Public schools in Belize are often run by the Catholic Church under a Church-State partnership, with the government paying tuition fees for students from needy families. While tuition is free, parents must pay for uniforms and books. The typical cost of a public school education is around US$35 per semester, but rates can go up to US$3,000 per year in a private primary school. High school prices are about US$500 a year for tuition and fees, while universities charge about US$675 per semester (approximately 15 credit hours).

In the Philippines, public schools do not charge tuition fees, but parents must consider other costs such as books, uniforms, laboratory, and miscellaneous fees. Private schools, on the other hand, charge tuition fees to cover the maintenance and provision of facilities, such as air-conditioned classrooms and designated computers. The cost of private schooling in the Philippines varies depending on the grade level and the school's location and facilities. For instance, grade school (Nursery to Grade 6) can range from ₱30,000 to ₱100,000 annually, while high school and senior high school (Grade 7 to Grade 12) can cost between ₱50,000 to ₱150,000 per year. College or tertiary education is the most expensive, with annual costs ranging from ₱60,000 to ₱200,000 or more.

It is worth noting that the Philippines has implemented the Universal Access to Quality Tertiary Education Act, which provides free college education at over 112 universities for qualified students. Additionally, the government's Free Higher Education program has eliminated tuition and miscellaneous fees for over two million Filipino students.

Language of instruction

The Philippines and Belize have different approaches to the language of instruction in their education systems. The Philippines offers a bilingual curriculum in Filipino and English, while Belize primarily uses English as the medium of instruction.

Philippines

The Philippines education system blends Eastern and Western educational traditions, influenced by its colonial past. The curriculum is bilingual, using both English and Filipino (Tagalog) as the mediums of instruction. This approach aims to align with global standards and cater to a diverse student population, including international students. The bilingual policy ensures that Filipino and English are taught as subjects in schools to achieve bilingual competence among students.

Belize

Belize, as a former British colony, has English as its official language and the primary language of instruction in public education. However, Belize is a diverse society with a multitude of cultures and languages. While English is widely used, Belizean Creole is the most commonly spoken dialect, and Spanish is the second-most-spoken language. Over half of the population is multilingual due to their diverse linguistic backgrounds.

In conclusion, while both countries have unique approaches to the language of instruction, the Philippines stands out for its bilingual curriculum, whereas Belize primarily relies on English as the medium of instruction.

Frequently asked questions