Bolivia's Migration Stance: Open Doors, Open Arms?

Bolivia's position on migration is complex. While it has historically been a country of emigration, the government has at times promoted international immigration to achieve a process of colonisation in sparsely populated areas. However, these attempts have largely been unsuccessful, with the total number of immigrants never exceeding 100,000 people, or 1% of the population. Neighbouring countries, particularly Argentina, have been the main source of migration to Bolivia, and internal migration within the country is also significant, with thousands leaving rural areas for better job opportunities in the cities.

Bolivia has experienced far less immigration than its South American neighbours, but small groups of Germans, Spaniards, Italians, Yugoslavians, and others do reside in the country. The country has also received a small number of Jews, mainly Ashkenazi, and a small Japanese migration beginning in 1899 that continued until the 1970s.

In recent years, Bolivia has seen an increase in Peruvian migrants and, despite the financial crisis and tightening of immigration policies in destination countries, there has not been a significant number of returns to Bolivia. The country has not yet clearly defined an international migration policy, which has resulted in poor inter-institutional coordination and a lack of clarity about roles and responsibilities.

Bolivia's history of emigration and immigration

Bolivia has historically been a country of emigration, with a large proportion of its population living abroad. It is estimated that over 700,000 Bolivians reside outside the country, representing around 7% of the total population. The primary destination for Bolivian emigrants has been Argentina, followed by Spain and the United States.

Internal migration within Bolivia is also significant, with large historical flows of people moving from rural to urban areas. This phenomenon of internal migration coexists with that of emigration, as some segments of the population, mainly urban dwellers with certain socioeconomic characteristics, choose to leave the country.

Bolivia has experienced far less immigration than its South American neighbours. However, it has received small groups of immigrants from various countries throughout its history. During the 20th century, small numbers of Jews, Arabs, Mennonites, and Japanese arrived in the country, along with Germans, Spaniards, Italians, and a small Yugoslavian community. Neighbouring countries, such as Argentina, Brazil, and Peru, have been the main contributors to migration into Bolivia, with these groups settling mainly in the departments of Santa Cruz, La Paz, and Cochabamba, which offer better economic opportunities.

The Bolivian government has, at times, promoted international immigration to achieve a process of colonisation of sparsely populated lands, particularly in eastern Bolivia. However, these attempts have not been very successful in attracting a significant flow of immigrants. The total number of immigrants has remained relatively low, standing at around 1% of the population between the 1976 and 2001 population censuses, never exceeding 100,000 people.

The impact of climate change and environmental disasters on migration

Bolivia is a country of emigration, with around 700,000 Bolivians living abroad, representing about 7% of the total population. However, the Bolivian State has also promoted international immigration to achieve a process of colonisation of sparsely populated lands, mainly in eastern Bolivia.

Environmental migration is a reality in Bolivia, as climate change and disasters affect internal and international migration patterns every year. Climate change and environmental disasters have adverse impacts on health, biodiversity, ecosystems, and water availability, which in turn affect agriculture, food security, and rural infrastructure.

Bolivia is one of the poorest countries in Latin America, with nearly 35% of its population living below the poverty line. Poverty and the lack of employment opportunities in rural areas, as well as the search for income diversification and better access to education and healthcare, are the main drivers of rural-urban migration in the country. Climate change and environmental degradation also influence these population movements.

Impact on Agriculture and Food Security

Climate change can exacerbate desertification processes through the alteration of spatial and temporal patterns in temperature, rainfall, and winds. Desertification affects more than 40% of Bolivian territory and acts as a migration driver, mainly in the highlands, inter-Andean valleys, and the Chaco. Additionally, nearly 50% of Bolivia's glaciers have melted in the last 50 years, threatening a critical source of drinking water and irrigation for millions of people and inducing population movements in the highlands and inter-Andean valleys.

Impact on Water Availability and Infrastructure

Due to rising temperatures and stronger precipitation, many regions of Bolivia are exposed to prolonged dry periods and an increase in the frequency and magnitude of floods, hailstorms, landslides, and frost. These environmental disasters further impact rural infrastructure and force people to migrate from rural to urban areas or abroad.

Impact on Vulnerable Groups

Internal and international migrants are one of the most vulnerable population groups in Bolivia, often experiencing significant barriers to accessing essential healthcare and social protection services. The COVID-19 pandemic has further exposed the vulnerable situation of many migrant communities, who are often part of marginalized groups experiencing economic hardship and limited access to basic services.

Impact on Indigenous Communities

Indigenous communities in Bolivia, particularly those living near the departments of Santa Cruz and Beni, are at risk of displacement due to wildfires and other environmental disasters. However, there is a lack of precise information on the impact of the pandemic and climate change on indigenous peoples due to limited data collection.

Impact on Gender Dynamics

The migration of working-age men and young people from rural to urban areas is significant, resulting in women and the elderly remaining in rural areas and assuming larger workloads in agricultural activities, which has negatively impacted smallholder farming productivity.

The role of the government in managing migration

The Bolivian government, through organisations like the International Organization for Migration (IOM), plays a crucial role in facilitating regulated labour migration processes and providing direct assistance to migrants. The IOM aims to facilitate the development of mutually beneficial policies and programs for governments, migrants, and society. Additionally, the IOM promotes the integration of migrants by supporting policies and strategies that encourage social, economic, and cultural inclusion in their new environments. This includes educating host communities about the potential contributions of newcomers and disseminating information on the rights and obligations of migrants.

The Bolivian government has also sought assistance from the IOM in its policy of transforming land tenure and access. The IOM provides technical assistance in the organised transfer of internally displaced communities, ensuring their economically sustainable and socially dignified resettlement. This is particularly relevant in Bolivia's efforts to address issues of marginalisation and provide access to land and forests for previously marginalised sectors.

In recent years, the Bolivian government has faced challenges in managing migration due to economic and political factors. The country's economic growth and social development have been impacted by the COVID-19 pandemic, highlighting the vulnerabilities of migrant communities, especially those who are marginalised and lack access to basic services. Additionally, the financial crisis and tightening immigration policies in destination countries have influenced migration patterns, with migrants redirected to neighbouring countries rather than returning to Bolivia.

The Bolivian government has also faced criticism for its lack of a clearly defined international migration policy, resulting in poor inter-institutional coordination and unclear roles and responsibilities. This has led to challenges in providing an integrated system of reliable, official indicators to manage migration effectively.

Overall, the Bolivian government's role in managing migration involves encouraging immigration to sparsely populated areas, addressing internal migration flows, providing assistance to migrants, promoting integration and social inclusion, and implementing land redistribution policies. However, the government has faced challenges due to economic, political, and health crises, as well as the lack of a comprehensive international migration policy.

The economic and social impact of migration on Bolivia

Migration has had a significant economic and social impact on Bolivia, a country with a long history of emigration. While the country has experienced relatively low immigration rates compared to its South American neighbours, internal migration has been a prominent feature of its demographic landscape.

Economic Impact

Historically, Bolivia has been characterised by significant emigration patterns, with a substantial proportion of its population residing abroad. This outward migration has resulted in a brain drain, particularly of urban residents with certain socioeconomic characteristics. The primary destinations for Bolivian emigrants have been Argentina, Spain, and the United States, with smaller flows to neighbouring countries like Brazil. This exodus of skilled individuals has likely impacted the country's economic productivity and innovation capacity.

However, remittances sent by Bolivian migrants abroad constitute a notable portion of the country's GNP, contributing approximately 5% in recent years. This inflow of foreign currency has the potential to stimulate economic growth, alleviate poverty, and enhance financial stability in Bolivia.

Social Impact

Internal migration in Bolivia has led to substantial urbanisation, with people moving from rural areas to cities in search of better job opportunities. This rural-urban migration has resulted in the depopulation of certain regions, particularly the highlands and valleys, as working-age individuals migrate, leaving behind women, children, and the elderly. This demographic shift can have social implications for these rural communities, altering gender dynamics and increasing the workload for those who remain.

Additionally, internal migration in Bolivia is closely linked to environmental factors. Climate change, environmental degradation, and natural disasters influence population movements, particularly from rural to urban areas. The adverse impacts of these factors on health, agriculture, food security, and rural infrastructure motivate people to seek better living conditions in urban centres.

Policy Implications

The complex dynamics of migration in Bolivia call for comprehensive policies that address both the push and pull factors involved. Policies should focus on creating economic opportunities, improving living conditions, and providing social protections for vulnerable populations in rural areas to reduce the need for migration. Additionally, measures to enhance the integration and social inclusion of migrants in urban areas, as well as programmes to support the return and reintegration of emigrants, can help mitigate the social impacts of migration.

The impact of COVID-19 on migration patterns

The COVID-19 pandemic has had a profound impact on migration patterns in Bolivia, a country that has historically been characterised by emigration. The pandemic has exposed the vulnerable situation of migrant communities, who often face economic hardship and limited access to basic services. The health crisis has also highlighted the precariousness of the country's health systems, presenting enormous challenges and potentially reshaping migration patterns in the country.

One of the most significant impacts of the pandemic on migration has been the large-scale travel restrictions put in place by countries worldwide. Over the course of the first year of the pandemic, more than 108,000 COVID-related international travel restrictions were implemented, in addition to internal movement restrictions within countries. This has had a major impact on both international and domestic air travel, with the number of air passengers carried dropping by 60% from 2019 to 2020. The tourism industry, which is crucial to Bolivia's economy, has faced significant losses as a result.

The pandemic has also exacerbated existing social and economic inequalities in Bolivia, with large segments of the population at risk of slipping into poverty and food insecurity. This includes internal and international migrants, who are among the most vulnerable population groups and often experience barriers to accessing essential health care and social protection services. The economic downturn has also impacted the ability of migrants to send remittances to their families in Bolivia, which constitute an important source of income for many households.

The spread of COVID-19 has also had specific consequences for urban and rural communities in Bolivia. Urban areas, which have seen a rapid increase in population due to rural-urban migration, are now facing challenges related to overcrowding and limited access to basic services. On the other hand, rural communities, particularly those in environmentally degraded areas, are struggling with a lack of employment opportunities and the impact of environmental degradation and climate change.

The pandemic has also led to an increase in return migration, with some Bolivian temporary workers in neighbouring countries, such as Chile, being expelled or returning home after losing their jobs. However, the closure of the Bolivian border and quarantine requirements have left some migrants stranded for extended periods.

Overall, the impact of COVID-19 on migration patterns in Bolivia has been complex and multifaceted. The pandemic has highlighted the vulnerabilities of migrant communities and the need for effective policies and interventions to support and protect these populations. As Bolivia continues to grapple with the health, social and economic consequences of the pandemic, migration patterns may continue to evolve and change in the coming years.

Frequently asked questions