Austria-Hungary's Balkan Legacy: Complex History, Complex Identity

The Austro-Hungarian Empire was a bureaucratic empire that incorporated many Balkan nations. The Balkans were a Balkan powder keg where the interests of major powers clashed with the national programmes of the emergent peoples of southeastern Europe. The annexation of Bosnia and Herzegovina by Austria-Hungary in 1908 upset the fragile balance of power in the Balkans, enraging Serbia and pan-Slavic nationalists throughout Europe. This ultimately led to the First World War.

Austria-Hungary annexes Bosnia and Herzegovina in 1908

Austria-Hungary's annexation of Bosnia and Herzegovina in 1908 was a unilateral action that sparked outrage across Europe and inflamed tensions in the Balkans. This annexation was the culmination of a decades-long struggle for control of the region, which had been formally under the sovereignty of the Ottoman Empire. Here is a detailed account of the events surrounding this significant episode in history:

Background to the Annexation:

Austria-Hungary had administered Bosnia and Herzegovina since the Congress of Berlin in 1878, when the Great Powers of Europe awarded them the right to occupy these provinces while legal ownership remained with the Ottoman Empire. This arrangement was intended to preserve the delicate balance of power in Europe, as both provinces were coveted by many, including Austria, Hungary, and nearby Serbia, which had pan-Slavic ambitions. The largely Slavic population of Bosnia and Herzegovina also had their own nationalist aspirations, further complicating the situation.

The Annexation Crisis:

On October 6, 1908, the Dual Monarchy of Austria-Hungary announced its formal annexation of Bosnia and Herzegovina, declaring them an integral part of its territory. This unilateral action was timed to coincide with Bulgaria's declaration of independence from the Ottoman Empire on October 5. The annexation sparked immediate protests from all the Great Powers and Austria-Hungary's Balkan neighbors, particularly Serbia and Montenegro. The Serbian and Montenegrin governments vehemently opposed this move, as did the pan-Slavic nationalists within their countries and across Europe.

Diplomatic Fallout:

The annexation upset the fragile balance of power in the Balkans and had far-reaching consequences. It permanently damaged relations between Austria-Hungary and its neighbors, especially Serbia, Italy, and Russia. Russia, already reeling from its defeat in the Russo-Japanese War and internal revolution in 1905, was forced to submit to the annexation but viewed Austria-Hungary's actions as aggressive and threatening. In response, Russia encouraged pro-Russian, anti-Austrian sentiment in Serbia and other Balkan provinces, stoking Austrian fears of Slavic expansionism.

International Reactions:

The annexation caused a volcanic eruption of hostility towards Austria-Hungary and its ally, Germany. There were mass demonstrations across Europe, and countries that had previously been friendly, such as Rome, now turned against Vienna. Even Britain, which had signed an international agreement with Austria regarding the Balkans, denounced the violation of this pact. France also opposed the scheme, and Turkey, while initially quiet due to cash payments, eventually protested more vigorously against Bulgarian independence than the annexation of Bosnia and Herzegovina.

Long-Term Impact:

The short-term diplomatic victory for Austria-Hungary came at a cost. The annexation permanently damaged relations with neighboring countries and contributed to the tensions that led to World War I. By 1914, Austro-Serbian relations had deteriorated to the point of declaring war on each other. Additionally, Italy broke its alliance with Austria-Hungary in 1915, partly due to unmet expectations of compensation in the Balkans. The battle lines of World War I began to form as Germany and Austria-Hungary found themselves with too many enemies.

The Balkan region's diverse races and creeds

The Balkan region is a diverse ethnolinguistic area, home to multiple Slavic and Romance languages, as well as Albanian, Greek, Turkish, Hungarian, and others. The region is inhabited by a large variety of ethnicities, including Greeks, Albanians, Turks, Bulgarians, Serbs, and Romanians, among others. The most numerous group is the South Slavs, who form the majority of the population in Bulgaria, Serbia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia, Slovenia, North Macedonia, and Montenegro. The Bulgarians, North Macedonians, and Slovenes speak their own Slavic languages, while the Slavs of Serbia, Croatia, Bosnia and Herzegovina, and Montenegro all speak dialects of Serbo-Croatian.

The Ottoman Empire began its expansion into the region in the second half of the 14th century, reaching central Europe by the early 16th century. The conquest was facilitated by existing divisions among the Orthodox peoples and the rift between Eastern and Western Christians. The Albanians under Skanderbeg resisted the Ottomans for a time using guerilla warfare, but by the end of the 16th century, the Ottoman Empire had become the controlling force in the region. The Jewish communities of the Balkans, dating back to ancient times, suffered immensely during World War II, and the vast majority were killed during the Holocaust.

The Balkan region has been characterised by ethnic heterogeneity, with difficult terrain encouraging the preservation of diversity. The compartmentalisation brought about by the mountainous relief and the size of the region have contributed to the fragmentation of ethnic groups. The influence of large empires, such as the Austro-Hungarian, Russian, and Ottoman Empires, has also played a role in shaping the religious and ethnic diversity of the Balkans. The policies of these empires, such as the Ottoman Empire's policy of bringing in Muslim minorities, have left a lasting impact on the region's demographics.

Austria-Hungary's complex bureaucracy

The Austro-Hungarian Empire was a complex bureaucracy, with a civil service that was one of the most important linchpins of the monarchy. The administration of the empire was regulated by an intricate and precise allocation of responsibility and authority, with a strict hierarchy and a system of service ranks. The civil service was seen as a sphere of activity in keeping with the social standing of the old aristocracy, and there even existed a special civil service nobility made up of families with long histories of working in the administration.

The bureaucracy was divided into three parts: the common foreign, military, and a joint financial policy under the monarch; the "Austrian" or Cisleithanian government; and the "Hungarian" or Transleithanian government. The common government came into existence in 1867 as a result of the Austro-Hungarian Compromise, which turned the Habsburg domains into a real union between the Austrian Empire and the Kingdom of Hungary. The two halves shared a common monarch, who ruled as Emperor of Austria and King of Hungary, respectively. While foreign relations and defence were managed jointly, and the two countries formed a customs union, all other state functions were handled separately by each of the two states.

The government of the Austrian half of the empire, officially named The Kingdoms and Lands Represented in the Parliament of the Realm, included the following ministries:

• Imperial-Royal Prime Minister
• Imperial-Royal Ministry of Agriculture
• Imperial-Royal Ministry of Worship and Education
• Imperial-Royal Ministry of the Railways
• Imperial-Royal Ministry of Finance
• Imperial-Royal Ministry of Commerce
• Imperial-Royal Ministry of Interior Affairs
• Imperial-Royal Ministry of Justice
• Imperial-Royal Ministry of Territorial Defence
• Imperial-Royal Ministry of Public Works [Expenditure]
• Imperial-Royal Ministry of Social Care
• Imperial-Royal Ministry of People's Healthcare

The Hungarian half of the empire, officially named The Lands of the Holy Hungarian Crown, included the following ministries:

• Prime Minister
• Minister of Finance
• Minister of the Interior
• Minister of Agriculture, Industry, and Trade
• Minister of Public Works and Transport
• Minister of Justice
• Minister of National Defence
• Minister of Religion and Public Education
• Minister besides the King
• Minister without Portfolio of Croatian, Slavonian and Dalmatian Affairs

The complex bureaucracy of the Austro-Hungarian Empire extended beyond the central government, with each half of the empire divided into territories and local communal administrations. The administrative system in the Austrian Empire, for example, consisted of three levels: the central state administration, the territories, and the local communal administration. Each of the seventeen territories of Cisleithania had an official from the central government, called a territorial chief, who played a dual role as a viceroy on behalf of the Emperor and a governor on behalf of the Austrian central government.

The bureaucracy was also influenced by the general tendency towards nationalism, with Germans and Magyars being over-represented in the lower echelons, Czechs represented in approximate accordance with their population, and all other nationalities grossly under-represented. This led to in-fighting over the distribution of jobs and contributed to the eventual disintegration of the empire.

The Balkan League and the war against Turkey

The Balkan League was a quadruple alliance formed by a series of bilateral treaties concluded in 1912 between the Eastern Orthodox kingdoms of Greece, Bulgaria, Serbia, and Montenegro. The alliance was ostensibly created to limit increasing Austrian power in the Balkans, but it was actually formed at the instigation of Russia to expel the Turks from the region.

The Balkans had been in turmoil since the early 1900s, with years of guerrilla warfare in Macedonia, the Young Turk Revolution, the protracted Bosnian Crisis, and several Albanian uprisings. The Italo-Turkish War in 1911 further weakened the Ottomans and emboldened the Balkan states.

Under Russian influence, Serbia and Bulgaria settled their differences and signed an alliance on 13 March 1912, which was originally directed against Austria-Hungary. However, by adding a secret chapter to the treaty, they redirected the alliance against the Ottoman Empire. Serbia then signed a mutual alliance with Montenegro, and Bulgaria did the same with Greece.

The First Balkan War broke out in October 1912, with the Balkan League successfully seizing control of almost all European Ottoman territories. The combined Balkan armies overcame the initially inferior Ottoman forces, achieving rapid success. The war was a comprehensive disaster for the Ottomans, who lost 83% of their European territories and 69% of their European population.

However, the Balkan League's triumph was short-lived. Unresolved prior differences between the allies re-emerged over the division of spoils, particularly in Macedonia. This led to the effective break-up of the League, and on 16 June 1913, Bulgaria attacked its erstwhile allies, beginning the Second Balkan War.

The Second Balkan War ended in defeat for Bulgaria, which lost territory and gained powerful enemies. This led to its participation in the First World War on the side of the Central Powers.

The Austro-Hungarian Empire's expansionist policy

The Austro-Hungarian Empire, a multi-national constitutional monarchy in Central Europe, was formed in 1867 after the Austro-Prussian War. It was a military and diplomatic alliance consisting of two independent states, Austria and Hungary, with a shared monarch, foreign affairs ministry, military, currency, and trade policy. While the Empire did not have overseas colonies, it did have expansionist policies, particularly focused on the Balkans region. Here is an overview of the Empire's expansionist policy:

• Preserving the Status Quo: Count Gyula Andrássy, the Austro-Hungarian Foreign Minister from 1871 to 1879, sought to maintain peace and prevent conflicts with Russia over the Balkans. He believed that the Empire was already a "saturated state" and opposed partitioning the region with Russia. Instead, he focused on strengthening the Empire's position through alliances, such as the Dreikaiserbund (Three Emperors' League) with Germany and Russia in 1873.
• German-Austrian Alliance: The formation of the German-Austrian alliance in 1879 furthered the Empire's expansionist goals in the Balkans. This alliance, driven by the policy of Drang nach Osten, aimed to exert influence over the Ottoman Empire by driving a corridor through the Balkans and controlling Constantinople. This put the Empire in direct competition with Russia, which had its own ambitions in the region, known as Panslavism.
• Annexation of Bosnia and Herzegovina: A pivotal moment in the Empire's expansion was the annexation of Bosnia and Herzegovina in 1908. These territories had been under Austro-Hungarian administration since 1878 but remained nominally under Ottoman rule. By formally annexing these lands, the Empire provoked protests from its Balkan neighbours, particularly Serbia and Montenegro, as well as the Great Powers. This unilateral action damaged relations with Serbia, laying the groundwork for future conflicts, including World War I.
• Balkan League and Conflict with Serbia: In 1912, the Balkan League was formed, comprising Serbia, Greece, Bulgaria, and Montenegro. This alliance challenged the Empire's influence in the region, particularly with Serbia's aspirations for access to the Adriatic Sea. In response, the Empire supported Albanian independence, causing strife among the Balkan Allies and leading to the Second Balkan War.
• Assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand: The assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand, the heir to the Austro-Hungarian throne, in Sarajevo in 1914, was a pivotal event. This assassination was carried out by a pro-Serbian activist from Bosnia, Gavrilo Princip, and it set off a chain of events leading to World War I. The Empire issued an ultimatum to Serbia, which was rejected, resulting in a declaration of war.
• World War I and Balkan Front: The Empire's expansionist policies in the Balkans played a significant role in the outbreak of World War I. The conflict with Serbia escalated as the Empire's allies, Germany and Bulgaria, joined the war, while Serbia was supported by Russia, France, and later, Great Britain. The Balkan Front became a critical theatre of the war, with the Empire fighting on multiple fronts and ultimately suffering significant military defeats.
• Consequences: The Empire's expansion into the Balkans had far-reaching consequences. It heightened tensions with neighbouring powers, particularly Serbia, and contributed to the complex web of alliances that led to World War I. The war brought about the end of the Habsburg Monarchy and the dissolution of the Empire into independent nations, reshaping the geopolitical landscape of Europe.

Frequently asked questions