Maritime Merger: Should Ns And Nb Merge?

The idea of merging New Brunswick and Nova Scotia is not new. In fact, it is part of a larger proposed political union called the Maritime Union, which includes New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, and Prince Edward Island. The Maritime Union would form a single new province with a population of approximately 1.8 million people, becoming the fifth-largest province in Canada by population. While there are potential benefits to merging these provinces, there are also significant challenges and historical factors that need to be considered.

The potential economic benefits of a merger

Additionally, a merger could lead to a wider range of services for citizens, as larger municipalities have greater capacity to provide a broader array of services. A combined province would also have greater political power, with a larger population and, therefore, more seats in the House of Commons of Canada and the Senate. This increased representation could result in more favourable federal policies and funding for the region.

Furthermore, a merger could promote economic development and trade within the region, reducing economic ties to the US. The combined province would have a larger market, potentially attracting more investment and businesses. Finally, a merger could help standardise policies, regulations, and taxes across the region, creating a more stable and predictable business environment, which could encourage investment and economic growth.

Historical precedent for a political union

The idea of a Maritime Union, or a political union of the Canadian Maritime provinces of New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, and Prince Edward Island, has been proposed at various times throughout Canadian history. The region, historically referred to as Acadia, was once administered as a single colony named Nova Scotia after the British acquired it from France following the Seven Years' War. During the 1760s, the British split St. John's Island (now Prince Edward Island) and New Brunswick from Nova Scotia, granting them separate colonial administrations and capitals.

In the 1820s, Cape Breton Island, which had been part of Nova Scotia, was re-merged into the colony to free up its lucrative coal royalties. In the 1860s, the idea of a Maritime Union was considered by Arthur Hamilton Gordon, the Lieutenant Governor of New Brunswick, and formally discussed at the Charlottetown Conference in 1864. However, this meeting resulted in the Confederation of New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, and the Province of Canada, rather than a union of just the Maritime colonies.

The concept of a Maritime Union gained credibility in the 1960s when the Maritime governments, in partnership with the federal government, addressed economic underperformance through various regional development programs. This led to the formation of several institutions in the early 1970s to facilitate intra-regional cooperation, including the Council of Maritime Premiers and the Maritime Provinces Higher Education Commission.

In recent years, the idea of a political union has been reintroduced, with the most recent proposal in 2012 by three Conservative Senators from the region. A union of the three Maritime provinces would have a population of approximately 1.8 million, making it the fifth-largest Canadian province by population.

The impact on official languages in the region

While Canada is officially bilingual, with English and French being the official languages, the potential merger of New Brunswick and Nova Scotia would create a unique situation regarding official languages in the region.

New Brunswick is officially bilingual, with English and French having equal status and rights in all institutions of the legislature and government. This includes the right to distinct educational institutions and cultural institutions necessary for the preservation and promotion of both linguistic communities. New Brunswick's legal system also recognises the right of any person to use either English or French in court proceedings and to receive services from any office of the legislature or government in the language of their choice.

On the other hand, while English is the main language spoken in Nova Scotia, services are often offered in French as well, particularly in parts of Cape Breton. Nova Scotia is home to the largest Scottish Gaelic-speaking community outside of Scotland, with a small number of native speakers in Pictou County, Antigonish County, and Cape Breton Island. The language is also taught in several secondary schools throughout the province.

In the event of a merger, the issue of official languages would be a significant consideration. While English would likely remain the primary language, the French-speaking community in New Brunswick, as well as the Scottish Gaelic-speaking community in Nova Scotia, would need to be taken into account. This could result in a situation where multiple official languages are recognised in the merged region, with provisions made for the preservation and promotion of each linguistic community.

Additionally, the potential merger raises questions about the impact on the Acadian community in New Brunswick, who comprise over 30% of the province's population. While there are Acadian communities in Nova Scotia as well, they are much smaller in proportion. Ensuring that the cultural protections guaranteed to Acadians in officially bilingual New Brunswick are maintained or replicated in a merged region would be essential to respect the linguistic and cultural rights of this community.

Overall, the impact on official languages in the region of a potential merger between New Brunswick and Nova Scotia would be complex and would require careful consideration to ensure the rights and needs of all linguistic communities are respected and protected.

The representation of the provinces in a merged legislature

The representation of provinces in a merged legislature has been a topic of discussion in the proposed political union of New Brunswick and Nova Scotia, along with Prince Edward Island, to form a single new province. This idea has been proposed multiple times throughout Canadian history, including in 1863 and 1864 by Arthur Hamilton Gordon, the Lieutenant Governor of New Brunswick, and more recently in 2012 by three Conservative Senators from the region.

One of the key challenges in the discussion of a merged legislature is determining the capital city. Charlottetown, Fredericton, and Halifax all have existing legislative buildings and traditions, while the largest cities in the region are Halifax, Saint John, and Moncton. Moncton, Sackville, and Amherst have been suggested as potential capitals due to their central locations, and the possibility of a rotating capital has also been proposed.

Another issue is the official language of the merged province. The Acadian and Brayon linguistic communities in New Brunswick and, to a lesser extent, in Nova Scotia and Prince Edward Island, would advocate for official bilingualism, as currently in place in New Brunswick. Additionally, the Maliseet and Mi'kmaq Nations, as well as the Gaels, may seek support for their languages.

The federal representation of the merged province is also a consideration. Each of the three Maritime provinces has been guaranteed a minimum number of seats in the House of Commons of Canada and the Senate due to their historical context. However, in the case of a union, there is a possibility that this representation guarantee might not be retained. Moreover, the merged province would likely be represented by a single voice at the nation's First Ministers' meetings, instead of the current three or four.

The history and identity of each province also play a role in the discussion of a merged legislature. Nova Scotia's legislature is the oldest seat of responsible government in the Commonwealth of Nations, while Prince Edward Island's legislative seat is the second oldest in Canada. New Brunswick's legislature is the only officially bilingual assembly among the Maritimes. These historical and cultural factors are significant in the debate.

The choice of a capital city

Geographical Considerations:

• Central Location: A common approach is to select a city that is geographically central to the merged region. This choice emphasises equity and unity by ensuring that the capital is accessible to all residents and is not biased towards a specific region. For instance, Abuja, Nigeria's capital, is located in the centre of the country, symbolising unity in a geographically divided nation.
• Population Centres: Capitals are often the most populous cities in their respective countries or regions. For instance, Seoul, South Korea, is home to nearly 20% of the country's residents. Therefore, cities like Moncton or Saint John, which are the largest urban centres in New Brunswick, could be considered as potential capital cities due to their population size.

Political Compromise:

• Rival Cities: In some cases, the capital city is chosen as a compromise between two or more rival cities or regions, with the new capital located roughly equidistant between the competing population centres. For example, Canberra, Australia, was selected as a compromise between Melbourne and Sydney.
• Historical Reasons: Historical considerations may also play a role in the decision. For instance, Fredericton, the capital of New Brunswick, could be chosen to honour its history as a seat of government. Alternatively, a completely new planned city could be built to house the seat of government, as seen with Brasília, Brazil's capital.

Practical Factors:

• Administrative Efficiency: The selection of a capital city may be influenced by practical considerations such as the potential for improving administrative efficiency and reducing costs by consolidating government offices and services in one location.
• Economic Considerations: The economic significance of a city could be a factor, with some capitals historically being the major economic centres of their regions. For example, Saint John, New Brunswick, is a leading economic centre due to its port and industries.

Potential Options:

• Moncton: Moncton is one of the largest cities in the region and could be a viable option due to its central location and economic significance.
• Saint John: As the largest city in New Brunswick and a significant economic hub, Saint John could be a contender for the capital.
• Fredericton: Fredericton's history as a seat of government and its central location in the province could make it a potential choice.
• Halifax: Halifax, as the largest city in Nova Scotia and a significant economic centre, could also be in the running for the capital city of the merged province.
• Charlottetown: Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island's capital, could be an option if the merger includes all three Maritime provinces.

Frequently asked questions