Austria's Eu Membership: To Leave Or Not?

Austria has been a member of the European Union since 1995, and a referendum on leaving the EU has been called for by some of its citizens. In a petition, 261,000 Austrian citizens (4.12% of the electorate) have requested a referendum on exiting the EU, stating that the economy, social conditions, and the environment would be better if Austria were not in the EU. This follows a period of political instability in Austria, with a potential far-right government on the horizon, and a failure to stick to EU spending rules.

The impact on Austria's economy

Austria's economy is highly industrialised, and the country has a well-developed social market economy. It ranks fifth in the European Union in terms of GDP per capita, with €46,200, well above the EU average of €37,600. Austria's economy is heavily dependent on foreign trade, with at least 67% of its imports coming from other European Union member states.

Austria's membership of the EU has drawn an influx of foreign investors attracted by its access to the single European market and proximity to aspiring economies. Membership of the EU has also given Austria better infrastructure and modernised and digitised public services.

However, some Austrians believe that their economy, social conditions, and environment would be in a better state if they were not in the EU. In 2015, 261,000 citizens (4.12% of the electorate) signed a petition calling for a referendum on leaving the EU.

Austria's economy is currently facing challenges due to its failure to stick to European spending rules. With a far-right government potentially on the horizon, there are fears that the country could end up in the same basket as highly indebted Italy and France. The country is expected to present a raft of measures to cut its public spending deficit to below 3% of GDP.

Austria's past as a European power and its cultural environment have also contributed to its strong economy. The country has a tradition of Royal Cuisine, which has influenced its food and beverage industry. Tourism in Austria accounts for almost 9% of its GDP, and it ranked 9th worldwide in international tourism receipts in 2007.

The impact on social conditions

Austria has been a member of the European Union since 1995 and has benefited from its membership in several ways. The country has high standards of living and is the fifth-highest-ranking EU country in terms of GDP per capita. It has a semi-presidential representative democracy with a popularly elected president as head of state and a chancellor as head of government and chief executive.

The impact of leaving the EU on Austria's social conditions is difficult to predict, but supporters of leaving believe that the economy, social conditions, and environment would be better outside of the EU. Austria's far-right Freedom Party (FPÖ) has expressed anti-EU sentiments, with MP Harald Stefan stating that "the EU has become something insane – we should really leave, but it’s not an option – the surveillance, the repression of freedom of speech...".

Austria's current economic situation is precarious, with the country at risk of being punished by the European Commission for excessive public spending from 2024 to 2026. A failure to reduce public spending could result in Austria being placed under the EU's special regime for overspenders. This would likely have significant social consequences for the country.

Additionally, Austria's relationship with the EU provides access to the single European market and proximity to aspiring economies, attracting foreign investors. Austria has also gained financially through EU-funded projects and recovery funds, which have improved infrastructure, public services, and medical treatment. Leaving the EU could impact these benefits and potentially lead to a decline in social conditions.

In conclusion, while there are arguments that Austria's social conditions would improve outside of the EU, the country currently enjoys high living standards, economic gains, and other advantages due to its membership. Leaving the EU could result in social consequences related to economic instability and a loss of benefits associated with EU membership.

The impact on the environment

Austria's environment is heavily influenced by its geographical location in the Alps, with over a quarter of the country's land area considered mountainous. The country's commitment to sustainability and climate change mitigation is evident through its renewable energy initiatives and protection of natural resources.

Austria's performance in addressing environmental concerns has been mixed. On the one hand, the country has made significant progress in certain areas, such as improving air quality and reducing emissions. According to the State of the Environment Report (SoER), emissions of most air pollutants have decreased, and Austria has achieved its climate change mitigation target under the Kyoto Protocol. Additionally, the share of renewable energy in gross final energy consumption has been steadily increasing, reaching 32.2% in 2012.

However, there are still challenges to be addressed. Austria's total waste generation has slightly decreased, but further efforts are needed to reduce waste from households and prevent food waste. Additionally, there is a growing loss of soil and unsealed areas due to development, with approximately 22.4 hectares of land being used for construction and infrastructure expansion daily. This development often involves sealing the ground with impermeable materials, impacting natural water absorption and contributing to flooding risks.

Public opinion in Austria reflects a strong commitment to environmental protection and sustainability. According to the European Investment Bank (EIB) Climate Survey, 72% of Austrians under 30 consider the climate impact of prospective employers when job hunting, and 59% favour stricter government measures to address climate change. Additionally, 65% of Austrians are willing to pay more for locally and sustainably produced food, and 48% support limiting meat and dairy consumption to combat climate change.

Austria's environmental policies and initiatives are closely tied to its membership in the European Union (EU). As an EU member, Austria has access to funding, resources, and collaborative opportunities that can enhance its ability to address environmental challenges. However, there are also critics who argue that leaving the EU would improve Austria's environmental conditions. It is worth noting that Austria's environmental performance and policies are influenced by a combination of national efforts and EU directives.

The far-right's anti-EU stance

Austria's far-right Freedom Party (FPÖ) has become the dominant political force in the country, with 28.9% of the vote in the latest national elections. This has sparked concerns about the future direction of Austrian policy and the potential for the country to descend into an authoritarian, aggressive right-wing regime. The party's anti-EU stance is a significant aspect of its platform, and there are worries that a far-right-led government could pose a threat to the stability and cohesion of the European Union.

Anti-Immigration and Nativist Rhetoric

The FPÖ has built its support by exploiting toxic discourse on issues such as migration, crime, and security. The party has stoked fears by equating immigration with violence and portraying Islam as a threat to Austrian culture. This has contributed to a paranoid mindset becoming entrenched in Austrian political culture. The party's election slogan, "On election Sunday, we will bring down the system," tapped into a sense of "cultural panic" and dissatisfaction with the status quo.

Criticism of the EU

The FPÖ has been fiercely critical of the EU, denouncing its regulations as "repression of freedom of speech" and calling for an end to "red tape" and "political excesses." The party's European election programme, "Stop the EU madness," demanded radical reforms and an immediate halt to immigration, which would be in breach of EU law. The FPÖ has also called for an end to sanctions against Russia and aid to Ukraine, reflecting its Moscow-friendly stance.

Undermining Democratic Norms

The FPÖ has been accused of undermining democratic norms and societal values. Its leaders have referred to Afghan refugees as "knife-wielding sex offenders" and expressed praise for the Taliban government in Afghanistan. The party has also advocated for the "remigration" of second- and third-generation immigrants, reflecting a nativist agenda. In previous coalitions, the centre-right Austrian People's Party (ÖVP) has been criticised for accommodating the FPÖ's attacks on democracy and failing to safeguard liberal democratic principles.

Impact on the EU

The potential for a far-right-led government in Austria has raised concerns among EU leaders. Some worry that a Chancellor from the FPÖ could be even more disruptive than Hungary's Viktor Orbán, who has consistently obstructed EU policies. There are fears that EU policies, particularly those requiring unanimity, could be targeted, including support for Ukraine and the Green Deal. However, analysts predict that budgetary concerns and the need to form a coalition with the ÖVP may temper the FPÖ's more extreme instincts.

Austria's relationship with Russia

Austria and Russia have historically enjoyed good bilateral relations, rooted in the pragmatic understanding that challenges must be overcome through dialogue and diplomacy. However, Russia's invasion of Ukraine in February 2022 has severely strained this relationship, with Austria joining its EU partners in condemning the unprovoked aggression and endorsing sanctions against Russia.

Even before the war, Austria-Russia relations had been tested by Russia's annexation of Crimea in 2014 and the subsequent hostilities in Ukraine. Despite this, Austria has continued to support diplomatic efforts aimed at ending the conflict and finding a peaceful resolution.

The history of Austria-Russia relations dates back to the 16th century, when contacts were established between the Holy Roman Emperor and the Tsardom of Russia. Over time, the relationship between the two monarchies became vital to European security, with Russia and Austria often allying against the Ottomans and France. This alliance was further strengthened by ideological solidarity during the French Revolution, with both absolutist monarchies fighting against France during the Revolutionary and Napoleonic Wars.

In the 19th century, Austria and Russia worked together to preserve the status quo and suppress revolutionary movements. Notably, Russia invaded Hungary in 1848 to restore Habsburg sovereignty and crush the Hungarian independence movement. However, the Crimean War marked a turning point, as Austria maintained a hostile neutrality towards Russia, straining their relationship.

In the lead-up to World War I, Austria-Hungary's annexation of Bosnia in 1908 and the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand in 1914 further damaged relations. The war itself, which ended with the overthrow of the monarchies in both countries, marked a significant shift in their relationship.

During the Cold War, Austria maintained its neutrality, refusing to join a military alliance or allow foreign troops on its territory. This stance allowed Austria to become an important hub for international diplomacy, hosting organisations like OPEC and the United Nations.

Following the collapse of the Soviet Union, Austria continued to foster close ties with Russia, particularly in the areas of commerce, banking, and espionage. Austrian companies have actively invested in Russia, and the country has long been a favourite destination for Russian commerce and intelligence activities.

Despite Austria's support for Ukraine and endorsement of sanctions, commercial ties between the two countries remain strong, especially in the energy and finance sectors. Austria's neutrality and its role as a bridge between East and West have shaped its approach to Russia, presenting a challenge to European unity and efforts to isolate Russia following its invasion of Ukraine.

Frequently asked questions