The Evolution Of Brunei's Separation Of Powers

Brunei is an absolute monarchy with the Sultan as the head of state and government. The Sultan also serves as the Prime Minister and Minister of Defence, Finance, and Foreign Affairs. The country has a unicameral legislature, the Legislative Council, which is simply consultative and whose members are all appointed by the Sultan.

The 1959 Constitution established the Council of Succession, Privy Council, Executive Council, Legislative Council, and Religious Council, with the Sultan as the head of the latter. The Council of Ministers or Cabinet performs the day-to-day administrative functions of the government, with the Sultan as its head.

The separation of powers in Brunei is limited due to the Sultan's extensive powers and the lack of national elections, which restricts legitimate political involvement and prevents opposition forces from gaining prominence. The Legislative Council has no political authority and is simply consultative, with the Sultan retaining the power to pass legislation and make laws.

While the Constitution provides for the establishment of these councils, the Sultan's authority remains largely unchecked due to the absence of national elections and the concentration of power in the hands of the Sultan. The lack of separation of powers in Brunei raises concerns about the balance of powers and the accountability of the Sultan and the government.

The role of the Privy Council in Brunei

The Privy Council in Brunei is a formal body of advisers to the country's monarch. It was established in 1959 in accordance with the country's constitution and is tasked with advising the Sultan and Yang Di-Pertuan of Brunei on the three branches of government: the executive, judicial, and legislative. The Privy Council's members include members of the royal family and senior government officials.

The Privy Council's primary role is to advise the Sultan on matters concerning the exercise of authority, such as the amendment or revocation of constitutional provisions, and the appointment of individuals to Malay customary ranks, titles, and honours. The council also performs functions such as proclaiming the succession of regency.

The Privy Council's proceedings are recorded in minutes, and a Clerk to the council is appointed by the Sultan. The advice of the Privy Council is not binding, and the Sultan may make decisions independently. The council can be summoned by the Sultan, the senior male Regent (in the Sultan's absence), or the Perdana Wazir (if no Regent is appointed).

In 2008, the Privy Council was granted the additional duty of advising the Sultan in connection with the exercise of his powers under Clause (1) of Article 9 of the Constitution of Brunei Darussalam. This further solidified the Privy Council's role as a key advisory body to the monarch.

The role of the Council of Succession in Brunei

The Council of Succession in Brunei is one of the five councils established by Sultan Omar Ali Saifuddien III in accordance with the 1959 Brunei Constitution. The Council of Succession is tasked with deciding who will succeed to the throne in the event that it becomes necessary. The council is led by the Duli Pengiran Bendahara and is made up of the cheterias, four menteris, six members of the Religious Council, and every Malay member of the Executive Council.

The Council of Succession is one of the councils that assist the Sultan of Brunei in performing his duties. The Sultan of Brunei is the head of state, supreme executive authority, and absolute monarch of Brunei. He is also the head of the government as Prime Minister and holds several other positions, including Defense Minister, Finance Minister, and Superintendent of Police. The Sultan's Birthday on July 15th is one of the most important events in the national calendar, marked by activities and festivities across the country.

The politics of Brunei take place within the framework of an absolute monarchy, with the Sultan of Brunei serving as both head of state and head of government. Brunei is the only ruling monarchy in Southeast Asia and is considered one of the most stable dictatorships in the world. The Sultan holds absolute power in the state for administrative purposes and has maintained a state of emergency since 1962, which is renewed every two years, allowing him to retain absolute authority.

The role of the Council of Ministers in Brunei

The Council of Cabinet Ministers, or cabinet, is the body of high-ranking Brunei officials, consisting of the top leaders of the executive branch of the Brunei government. The council is led by the Sultan himself, who has also been the Prime Minister of Brunei since 1984. The council consists of the Prime Minister, the Senior Minister (the Crown Prince), ministers, second ministers, and deputy ministers of their respective ministries. All ministers and deputy ministers are appointed by the Prime Minister-Sultan. The ministers are responsible directly to the Sultan and hold their seats at His Majesty's pleasure. The cabinet was established in 1959 and was last reshuffled in 2022.

The primary duty of the Council of Cabinet Ministers is to advise the Sultan on matters of national administration, including policy approval. The council also performs the day-to-day administrative functions of the government. In addition, the council develops and distributes working documents to its members.

The role of the Legislative Council in Brunei

The Legislative Council of Brunei is a national unicameral legislature with 36 appointed members, including the Sultan, the Crown Prince, and cabinet ministers. The council has a consultative role, reviewing policies implemented by the government, passing bills and motions, and approving budgets and revenue estimates. The council has no independent authority and its members are appointed by the Sultan, who can revoke appointments at any time without cause. The council meets annually in March for roughly two weeks and has no political authority.

The Legislative Council was established in 1959 by Article 23 of Brunei's 1959 Constitution, which included five advisory bodies and granted the Sultan full executive authority. The council initially included elected members, but after the left-wing Brunei People's Party (BPP) won all 10 of the council's elected seats in 1962, Sultan Omar Ali Saifuddien III invalidated the results. Since then, the council's members have been appointed by the Sultan.

The Legislative Council's role is largely ceremonial, with the Sultan holding absolute power in Brunei. The council's activities generally lack transparency, and the Sultan's personal authority is largely untouched by the Internal Security Act (ISA). The council's primary duty is to advise the Sultan on matters of national administration, including policy approval. The council also has the power to create laws, but these must be approved by the Sultan to take effect.

The role of the Religious Council in Brunei

The Religious Council, also known as the Islamic Religious Council, is a body that advises the Sultan of Brunei on all matters relating to Islam. The State Religious Affairs Officer serves as its chairman or president, and its members include government ministers, a pengiran cheteria, pehin manteris, the state mufti, the attorney general, the syarie chief justice, and additional members appointed by the Sultan.

The Religious Council is responsible for advising the Sultan on all subjects pertaining to Islam, as he is the Head of the Islamic Faith in Brunei. The Council's role is to counsel the Sultan on all matters concerning Islam and its function as the state religion. This includes providing advice on any laws relating to the Islamic religion, which the Sultan may then choose to enact.

The Religious Council also has a role in the appointment of religious officials. For example, the State Religious Affairs Officer, who serves as the chairman of the Council, is appointed by the Sultan under the Religious Council and Kadis Courts Act. Additionally, the Council plays a part in the appointment of the Mufti Kerajaan, who is responsible for advising the Sultan on matters of Islamic law.

The Religious Council is one of five councils established by the Sultan in accordance with the 1959 Brunei Constitution. The other four councils are the Privy Council, the Executive Council, the Legislative Council, and the Council of Succession.

Frequently asked questions