Bolivian Government: A Study In Corruption And Its Impact

Bolivia has a serious problem with corruption, which is considered an accepted part of life and can be found at all levels of society. Citizens perceive the judiciary, police, and public administration to be the most corrupt sectors in the country. Corruption is also widespread among officials who are supposed to control the illegal drug trade and those working in or with the extractive industries. Bolivia's customs service is highly corrupt and inefficient, with a third of respondents in a survey saying they had paid a bribe to customs officers in the previous year. Companies also consider corruption a major obstacle for business in the country, especially in the courts, public services, land administration, tax administration, customs administration, public procurement, and natural resources sectors.

Corruption in the judiciary

Corruption is a major problem in Bolivia, and it can be found at all levels of society. Citizens perceive the judiciary as the country's most corrupt sector. The judiciary in Bolivia faces several issues, including a lack of resources and independence. In 2010, President Evo Morales appointed five judges to the Supreme Court, Constitutional Court, and Judicial Council, which was seen as a challenge to its independence. Prosecutors also lack independence and have often targeted opposition-party politicians and their supporters. The 2009 Constitution placed indigenous courts on a par with the mainstream judicial system, creating conflicts, confusion, and delays.

In 2014, the Bolivian Senate called on the attorney general to suspend 300 of the country's 508 public prosecutors for corruption and other offenses. Between January and August of that year, 45 prosecutors were disbarred, twice the number from the previous year.

The judiciary's inefficiency and lack of independence have led to serious problems concerning judicial independence and fair public trials. There have been reports of authorities pressuring judges to change verdicts and judges practicing self-censorship to avoid harassment by the government. The judiciary is also overburdened and underfunded, with justice officials vulnerable to bribery and corruption.

Overall, the issues within the Bolivian judiciary contribute to a perception of widespread corruption in the country and negatively impact the administration of justice.

Corruption in the police force

Corruption is a significant problem in Bolivia, and it is considered an accepted part of life in the country. It is found at all levels of society, and the police force is no exception.

The police force in Bolivia is a centralized force of around 40,000 members, known as the Cuerpo de Policía Nacional (National Police Corps). They are responsible for internal security and maintaining law and order, and report to the national government.

Police corruption is a major issue, and it is partly due to low wages and poor training. The police are generally viewed as the nation's third most corrupt institution, after the judiciary and public administration. Corruption is seen as the main impediment to legitimate crime-fighting, and it has resulted in the firing of three police chiefs in six years for corruption or abuse of power. Many police officers have ties to organized crime, particularly drug traffickers, and those with political connections are often appointed to senior positions.

In recent years, there have been several high-profile cases of police corruption. In 2011, the former anti-drug czar, Police General Rene Sanabria, was arrested in Panama and later convicted of drug smuggling in a Miami court. In 2015, it was suspected that police officers guarding the house of a Peruvian politician, Martín Belaunde Lossio, accepted bribes to allow his escape from house arrest in La Paz. This incident prompted Bolivian President Evo Morales to fire the police chief, interior minister, and dozens of others suspected of involvement.

Bribery is also common within the police force. Low-ranking officials may pay bribes of USD 30 to USD 50 to get promoted, while mid- and high-ranking officers may pay up to USD 2,000. Bribes are also often demanded by police officers to grant inmates the right to attend their own hearings.

To combat corruption, the Bolivian government has taken some steps, such as passing laws to increase transparency and accountability. In 2015, President Morales promised to rewrite laws to tackle corruption in the police force. However, critics argue that stricter laws and harsher punishments are needed to effectively address the issue.

Despite these efforts, police impunity remains a significant problem due to corruption and the politicization of the judicial system. Mechanisms to investigate abuse are rarely utilized or enforced, and complex legal procedures, large numbers of detainees, judicial inefficiency, executive interference, and corruption contribute to police impunity.

Corruption in the public services sector

Corruption in Bolivia is a significant issue that is deeply ingrained in the country's history and culture. It is perceived to exist at all levels of society, with the judiciary, police, and public administration being considered the most corrupt sectors. The problem is exacerbated by a lack of education among Bolivians about their rights and the laws prohibiting corruption.

The country's instability since gaining independence from Spain in 1825, with over 200 changes of government and constant constitutional rewrites, has created an environment conducive to corruption. Widespread poverty and poor governance have further contributed to the issue.

In recent years, there have been numerous instances of corruption in the public services sector, which is characterized by extensive patronage networks and clientelism. Companies often have to pay bribes to obtain licenses and permits, and the sector lacks transparency in land administration, with property rights often infringed and compensation amounts determined through negotiations rather than consistent processes.

The tax bureau and customs sectors are also affected by corruption, with businesses facing challenges due to the complexity of tax laws and the inefficiency of customs services. The product procurement sector is particularly corrupt, with government contracts and public funds often awarded to favored companies and individuals through bribery.

The current government, led by President Luis Alberto Arce Catacora, has been accused of corruption, including allegations of receiving bribes from foreign companies and influencing judicial appointments. However, the government has taken some steps to address corruption, such as establishing the Ministry of Anticorruption and Transparency in 2009 and passing laws to increase transparency and reduce corruption in the police force.

Overall, while there have been some efforts to combat corruption in Bolivia, it remains a significant issue in the public services sector, hindering economic development and contributing to the country's instability.

Corruption in the natural resources sector

Bolivia is rich in natural resources, and the country is heavely dependent on the extractive industries that exploit them. This sector is highly prone to corruption worldwide, and Bolivia is no exception. The government controls both the operation and regulation of the hydrocarbon resources sector, which is widely seen as increasing opportunities for corruption.

The state-owned oil and gas company YPFB has been plagued by scandals involving nepotism, kickbacks, and other forms of corruption for years. This has led to the imprisonment of several individuals, including YPFB's former president, Santos Ramirez, who was sentenced to 12 years in prison for accepting a large kickback.

Local communities officially control their natural resources, but they are susceptible to corruption by government agencies or corporations. Citizens' constitutional right to access financial information about extractive industries is not always respected.

Bolivia's natural resources have been exploited to improve macroeconomic performance. However, the country remains the poorest in South America, with a low GDP and most of the population living below the poverty line.

The current president, Luis Alberto Arce Catacora, has been accused of receiving a $2.6 million bribe from the China Harbor Engineering Company to approve a highway project.

Lack of government transparency

Bolivia has long struggled with corruption, which has been called an accepted part of life in the country. It is found at all levels of society, with the judiciary, police, and public administration being perceived as the most corrupt sectors. The country's history of instability, poverty, and weak rule of law has contributed to the pervasive corruption. While there have been some efforts to address corruption, a lack of government transparency remains a significant challenge.

One of the key issues contributing to the lack of transparency in the Bolivian government is the inefficient and bloated bureaucracy. Hiring and promotions within the government are often politically driven and lack transparency. There is also a lack of financial transparency, as government officials tend to treat public financial data as their property and are reluctant to provide information to the public. For example, in 2010, Bolivia scored 13 out of 100 on the Open Budget Index, indicating a lack of transparency in the country's budget process.

The Bolivian government has also been criticized for its lack of transparency in the management of natural resources. The country is rich in natural resources, particularly hydrocarbons, but the government has been accused of nepotism, kickbacks, and other forms of corruption in this sector. Local communities, who are supposed to control their own natural resources, have also reported a lack of transparency and federal intervention in their affairs.

Another area where the Bolivian government has faced criticism is in its handling of the illegal drug trade. Officials tasked with controlling the drug trade have been implicated in corruption scandals, and the country has become a regional hub for drug trafficking. The complex Bolivian tax law has also provided opportunities for corruption, with businesses facing burdensome procedures and illegal facilitation payments.

The elections and campaign financing in Bolivia have also been criticized for a lack of transparency. While the elections themselves are generally considered free and fair, there are inadequate safeguards for campaign financing. There are no limits on political donations, and there is no law requiring the disclosure of donations. This lack of transparency has led to widespread abuse of public funds by incumbents and the financing of campaigns through civil servants' salaries.

The Bolivian government has also interfered with the freedom of expression and media, retaliating against outlets that express dissenting opinions. Journalists have faced threats, harassment, and censorship, and the government controls the allocation of licenses for media outlets. This interference has led to self-censorship and a lack of transparency in the media sector.

Overall, the lack of government transparency in Bolivia is a significant issue that contributes to the country's struggle with corruption. Efforts to improve transparency and address corruption have been made, but consistent enforcement of anti-corruption laws and greater transparency in various sectors are needed to effectively tackle the problem.

Frequently asked questions