Belize Barrier Reef: Paradise In Peril

The Belize Barrier Reef, the second-largest reef system in the world, has long been considered to be in danger. However, in 2018, it was removed from UNESCO's List of World Heritage in Danger sites. This decision was made due to the successful conservation efforts of the Belizean government and local communities, who have worked to address various threats to the reef, including oil exploration and drilling, destruction of mangroves, and unsustainable development. While this is a significant achievement, the reef still faces challenges from tourism, invasive species, and the impacts of climate change, such as coral bleaching events and rising sea temperatures.

Oil exploration and drilling

In 2010, a map was released by the Geology and Petroleum Department confirming that massive oil exploration concessions had been granted throughout Belize, including in marine reserves and national parks. This sparked concern from environmental groups such as Oceana, who believed that offshore drilling of this magnitude would be devastating to Belize's tourism and fishing industries, marine food security, and the viability of coastal communities.

In 2011, Oceana, in collaboration with other organisations, triggered a referendum for offshore oil exploration and drilling by delivering over 18,000 signatures to the Governor-General's office. In February 2012, approximately 30,000 Belizeans voted in the referendum, with 96% voting against offshore oil drilling in Belize's waters. In 2015, the Belize government withdrew its appeal against a legal ruling that oil concessions are null and void, demonstrating its commitment to protecting marine resources and Belizean livelihoods.

In 2017, the Belize government announced its commitment to an indefinite moratorium on offshore oil activity in its territorial sea, including its Exclusive Economic Zone. This was followed by the introduction of legislation to enshrine this moratorium, which was passed unanimously in December 2017. This legislation was a direct response to the voices of 22,090 Belizean voters who called for legislative amendments that would require a referendum if the government contemplated lifting the moratorium.

The passage of this legislation was welcomed by environmental groups such as Oceana and WWF as a landmark step forward to protect the Belize Barrier Reef and strengthen marine conservation worldwide. It also recognised the collective leadership and persistent involvement of tens of thousands of Belizeans over many years on the issue of offshore oil.

Climate change

The Belize Barrier Reef, the second-largest reef system in the world, is in danger due to climate change. Climate change poses a significant threat to the reef's integrity, and like all reefs globally, the Belize Barrier Reef faces major challenges due to this phenomenon.

The impacts of climate change on the reef include increased water temperatures, coral bleaching events, ocean pollution, and acidification. These factors have led to large-scale mortality of coral cover and irreversible changes to the ecosystem. Climate change has also caused more frequent and severe storms and rising sea levels, which further endanger the reef. The rising sea levels and the potential increase in significant hurricane events associated with climate change will severely impact the future of Belize and the seven component sites that comprise the World Heritage site.

In addition to climate change, the reef also faces threats from other human activities such as oil exploration and drilling, development along the coast, and a lack of strong regulations. However, through community-based conservation efforts and government action, there has been some success in mitigating these threats.

Community-based conservation efforts in Belize have empowered local tour guides, fishermen, and volunteers with the skills and resources needed to protect and restore the reef. These efforts have led to an increase in coral coverage in protected areas. Additionally, the Belizean government has implemented a moratorium on oil exploration and drilling in all offshore waters, providing critical protection to the reef.

While the removal of the Belize Barrier Reef from UNESCO's List of World Heritage in Danger is a positive step, the effects of climate change continue to pose a significant threat to the health and longevity of this precious ecosystem.

Mangrove destruction

Mangroves are a vital part of the Belize Barrier Reef ecosystem. They provide many important services, including protecting the shoreline from storm waves and winds, and serving as a nursery for many marine and fish species. They also play a crucial role in preventing coastal erosion by holding the soil together. This prevents sediment from falling into the sea, which can kill coral reefs as they require clean water to survive.

Belize is home to three types of mangrove: the red mangrove (Rhizophora mangle), the black mangrove (Avicennia germinans), and the white mangrove (Laguncalaria racemosa). Mangroves cover 3.4% of Belize's land and border much of the country's 386-kilometer coastline and cayes. They form a vital part of the natural ecosystem and provide habitat for a diverse range of species, including birds, lobsters, crabs, and fish.

Despite legislation protecting the mangroves of Belize, their overall cover is decreasing due to expanding developments, including hotels and resorts. Mass tourism continues to drive the clearance of wetland areas to accommodate the rising number of tourists. This destruction of mangroves poses a significant threat to the integrity and extent of mangrove cover and, consequently, to the Belize Barrier Reef Reserve System.

However, there is hope for the mangroves of Belize. Recent changes in government policies and regulations give optimism that their value will be recognized and preserved. The Belizean government has taken steps to slow the loss of mangroves by revising national mangrove regulations to better protect them and the services they provide. These new measures include robust screening of land clearance proposals within mangrove landscapes, higher application and permitting fees, surety bonds for permits granted in mangrove priority areas, and an increased focus on restoration and planting in degraded areas.

The World Heritage Centre has recommended the removal of the Belize Barrier Reef from the List of World Heritage in Danger, recognizing the country's efforts to safeguard this precious ecosystem.

Overfishing

The Belize Barrier Reef, the second-largest reef system in the world, has been under threat from overfishing, among other dangers. In 2011, local fishermen teamed up with environmental groups to transition to a different management system, where they get dedicated rights to fish in exchange for respecting no-take zones and other regulations. This has helped curb overfishing in Belize, with thousands of fishermen asking for a nationwide system of rights-based management, which the government implemented in 2016.

For decades, Belizean fisheries had been depleted by illegal fishing and overfishing. Driven by short-term needs, fishermen used gear such as gillnets, and their numbers grew unsustainably. As a result, it could take an entire season to catch what used to be a week's worth of spiny lobster. Overfishing also impacted the health of the reef, as fishermen targeted reef-grazing species such as parrotfish, which play a critical ecological role in keeping algae growth in check. This, in turn, affected the health of the coral, as algae can smother and stunt the growth of corals.

To address this issue, the Wildlife Conservation Society (WCS) conducted a 14-year study at Glover's Reef and found that while a fishing ban in the Conservation Zone was effective in helping predatory species recover, it did little to aid the recovery of herbivorous species like parrotfish. As a result, in 2009, the Belize government passed the Fisheries Regulations to protect overfished species, specifically prohibiting the taking of parrotfish and surgeonfish, which are major reef-grazers. This was followed by the 2020 Fisheries Resources Act, which added further regulations to protect the endangered Nassau Grouper.

The effectiveness of the fishing ban in restoring fish populations and coral assemblages has been evaluated in studies between 2009 and 2022, which found that herbivorous fish biomass had increased in about half of the studied sites, but coral and algae cover remained unchanged. However, the authors of the study attributed this lack of change to the recent implementation of the ban. Enforcement efforts also appear successful, with very few instances of illegal parrotfish catch since the ban.

While overfishing has been a significant threat to the Belize Barrier Reef, through community-based conservation efforts and government regulations, progress has been made in curbing this issue and restoring the health of the reef.

Invasive species

The Belize Barrier Reef is home to a diverse array of plant and animal species, including 70 hard coral species, 36 soft coral species, and hundreds of invertebrate species. However, this delicate ecosystem is under threat from various factors, including invasive species.

In the case of the Belize Barrier Reef, the introduction of invasive species can have detrimental effects on the native flora and fauna. These invasive species can alter the natural balance of the ecosystem, leading to a decline in native populations and even the extinction of certain species. Additionally, they can introduce new diseases or parasites, further endangering the health of the native organisms.

The presence of invasive species in the Belize Barrier Reef can also have economic implications. For example, if invasive species damage the coral reefs or disrupt the natural food chain, it could impact the country's fishing industry and tourism, which are vital sources of income for Belize.

To mitigate the impact of invasive species, it is crucial to implement strict biosecurity measures to prevent their introduction into the reef ecosystem. This includes regulating the import and trade of potentially invasive species, conducting risk assessments, and establishing early detection and rapid response protocols. Additionally, increasing public awareness about the dangers of invasive species and promoting responsible practices among tourists and locals can also help protect the Belize Barrier Reef from this threat.

Frequently asked questions