New Brunswick: Canada's Poorest Province?

New Brunswick is one of Canada's poorest provinces. This is due to a combination of factors, including low productivity, a small tax base, high public debt, a declining private sector, limited opportunities, and poor wages. As a result, New Brunswick has the lowest household income among all Canadian provinces. In 2018, child poverty in the province affected more than 1 in 5 children (21.8%), indicating that over 30,000 children live below the poverty line. The poverty rate in New Brunswick is also reflected in the high percentage of seniors living in poverty, with 10.9% of seniors and 13.8% of residents overall living below the poverty line in 2019.

The root causes of poverty in New Brunswick are multifaceted. Firstly, the province has a small population of around 800,000, which limits its tax base and makes it challenging for the government to generate sufficient revenue. This has led to operating on deficit budgets and accumulating debts. Additionally, New Brunswick faces challenges with low productivity due to its shrinking labour force and population. The province experienced a population decline between 2011 and 2016, and young people are migrating out in search of better opportunities. The ageing population further contributes to low productivity, with an increasing ratio of seniors to working-age residents.

Employment conditions also play a role in the province's poverty. New Brunswick has the lowest minimum wage rate among Canadian provinces and territories, with workers earning only around $20,480 annually, which may still be below the poverty line. The private sector's contribution to the provincial economy has decreased, limiting job opportunities for residents. The decline in key industries such as mining, forestry, fishing, manufacturing, and agriculture has had a significant impact on the economy and reduced opportunities for employment.

New Brunswick's status as one of Canada's poorest provinces is concerning, and it highlights the need for effective strategies to address the underlying socio-economic factors contributing to its high poverty rate.

New Brunswick has the lowest household income in Canada

New Brunswick's low household income can be attributed to various factors, including a small tax base, high public debts, a decline in the private sector, limited opportunities, and poor wages. The province has a population of around 800,000, which limits its tax base and makes it challenging to generate sufficient revenue. As a result, New Brunswick has operated on deficit budgets for several years, leading to increased debts.

The private sector's contribution to the provincial economy has also decreased significantly. The major industries in New Brunswick, such as mining, forestry, fishing, manufacturing, and agriculture, have seen a substantial decline in recent years. For example, the mining industry's value dropped from about $900 million in 2010 to around $350 million by 2014. This has reduced job opportunities for residents, as most people work in the public sector.

Additionally, New Brunswick has the lowest minimum wage rate among Canadian provinces and territories, at $11.75 per hour. According to Statistics Canada, an individual needs to earn around $21,000 per year to live above the poverty line. However, with the current minimum wage, workers in New Brunswick earn only around $20,480 annually. This means that even those earning minimum wage may still be below the poverty line.

The aging population of New Brunswick has also contributed to low productivity. As the number of seniors increases, the labour force is expected to shrink. In 2009, the ratio of seniors aged 65 or older to those of working age was 1:4.5. By 2018, this ratio changed to 1:3.1, and it is projected to be 1:2.3 by 2027. As a result, the labour force is anticipated to contract by 0.9% by 2027.

Furthermore, the cost of living in New Brunswick, although cheap compared to other provinces, does not offset the low incomes. About 16.8% of households in the province spend over 30% of their income on housing, indicating that housing is unaffordable for a significant portion of the population.

New Brunswick's low household income has had a significant impact on its residents. In 2018, child poverty in the province affected more than one in five children (21.8%), with over 30,000 children living below the poverty line. Additionally, a significant number of seniors are also living in poverty. In 2009, 10.9% of seniors in New Brunswick were below the poverty line, and this percentage has likely increased since then.

While New Brunswick faces economic challenges, it is important to note that it is not the only province with a struggling economy. All the Maritime provinces, including New Brunswick, have weaker economies compared to other regions of Canada.

The province has a small tax base and high public debts

New Brunswick has been dubbed the poorest province in Canada, receiving the highest per-capita amount of equalization payments from the federal government. This funding is designed to help poorer provinces provide comparable levels of service to citizens at similar levels of taxation to richer provinces. The province's poor economic situation has been attributed to various factors, including its small tax base and high public debts.

New Brunswick's tax base is limited due to its relatively small population, with only 775,610 inhabitants as of the 2021 census. Atypically for Canada, only about half of the population lives in urban areas, with the other half residing in rural communities. This distribution of the population across a smaller number of urban centres can make it challenging to generate a substantial tax base.

Additionally, New Brunswick has struggled with high public debts, which have contributed to its financial challenges. The province has historically run at a large deficit, and its efforts to stimulate economic growth through subsidies have not always been successful. As a result, New Brunswick has accumulated bad debt and struggled to reduce its reliance on federal support.

The province's economic challenges are further exacerbated by the high cost of providing government services to its dispersed and partially rural population. With about half of the population living in rural areas, the government incurs significant expenses in delivering education and health services to all citizens. This situation is not unique to New Brunswick, as other provinces with significant rural populations face similar challenges.

To address its financial challenges, New Brunswick has implemented measures such as the New Brunswick Low-Income Tax Reduction, which was introduced in 2001 to reduce the tax burden on eligible low-income families. Additionally, the province has received equalization payments from the federal government to help fund basic government services like healthcare and education. While these steps have provided some relief, New Brunswick continues to face economic challenges due to its small tax base and high public debts.

New Brunswick has the lowest minimum wage rate in Canada

New Brunswick has long been one of the poorest regions of Canada. In 2019, it was officially declared the poorest province in the country and began receiving the most funding per capita from the federal government's equalization support program.

In 2021, New Brunswick's minimum wage was $11.75 per hour, the lowest rate in Atlantic Canada. In December of that year, the provincial government announced a $2 increase to be implemented in two phases: the first $1 increase would take effect in April 2022, and the second $1 increase in October 2022, bringing the rate to $13.75 per hour. This represented a 17% increase over the previous rate and made New Brunswick's minimum wage the highest in Atlantic Canada.

The minimum wage increase in New Brunswick was met with mixed reactions. Some, such as the Human Development Council and the Common Front for Social Justice, felt that the increase was necessary but still not enough. The livable wage in major cities in New Brunswick, such as Fredericton and Saint John, was calculated to be higher than the new minimum wage. These groups advocated for a $15 minimum wage, arguing that it would better reflect the true cost of living in the province.

On the other hand, business groups, such as Restaurants Canada and the Retail Council of Canada, criticized the lack of consultation before the announcement and the magnitude of the increase, especially during a time when the industry was struggling. They argued that the sudden and significant increase in labour costs would be challenging for businesses to absorb and could negatively impact their operations.

While the minimum wage increase in New Brunswick aimed to address the province's economic challenges, it is just one aspect of a complex issue. The province has historically faced difficulties in industries such as agriculture, mining, and shipbuilding, and providing government services to a significant rural population has been costly. Additionally, New Brunswick has a powerful corporate concentration, with a large portion of the economy controlled by the Irving Group of Companies, which has been accused of exerting a form of economic feudalism in the province.

The province has the highest per-capita amount of equalization payments

New Brunswick has been dubbed Canada's poorest province and will receive the most funding per capita from the federal government's equalization support program. The province's share is jumping 9.2% to $2.21 billion, the largest increase among receiving provinces. This amount is calculated to be worth $2,826 per person in New Brunswick, which is the most ever paid to a province.

New Brunswick's Finance Minister, Ernie Steeves, expressed his disappointment in the province's economy, stating that "When your transfer payments go up, it's a sign your economy is weak. I'm not crazy about that. We want New Brunswick to be a have province, not a have-not province."

The equalization payments are part of a $20.6 billion federal program designed to help poorer provinces provide comparable levels of service to citizens at similar levels of taxation to richer provinces. The payments are determined by a complex mathematical formula that measures each province's revenue-generating ability against a national standard.

New Brunswick's economy has been struggling for some time, with the province relying on transfer payments since the mid-1900s. In 2019, the province's GDP growth was estimated at 3.7%, the weakest among equalization-receiving provinces and well below the national average.

Despite the influx of equalization funding, New Brunswick's goal remains to become a "have" province and reduce its dependence on federal support.

The private sector's contribution to the provincial economy has reduced

New Brunswick, Canada's only bilingual province, has been dubbed the country's poorest province. In 2019, it received the most funding per capita from the federal government's equalization support program, and its GDP growth from 2016 to 2019 was the weakest among equalization-receiving provinces.

The reduction in the private sector's contribution can be attributed to several factors, including:

• External economic factors: In the late 1800s, the forestry and shipbuilding industries, which were once major contributors to the provincial economy, began to decline due to external economic factors.
• Government policies: The provincial government has frequently attempted to create employment through subsidies, which have often failed to generate long-term economic prosperity and have resulted in bad debt.
• Concentration of economic power: The Irving Group's extensive holdings and influence in the province have contributed to a lack of economic diversification and competition.
• Global market changes: The province's traditional trade relations have been undermined by new barriers, such as high tariffs and the disruption of trading relationships with New England.

Despite these challenges, New Brunswick offers a skilled and motivated workforce, a low cost of doing business, and a competitive corporate tax structure, making it an attractive location for expansion and investment.

Frequently asked questions