New Brunswick: A Boring Province?

New Brunswick is one of Canada's thirteen provinces and territories. It is one of the Maritime provinces and one of the four Atlantic provinces. It is bordered by Quebec, Nova Scotia, the Gulf of Saint Lawrence, the Bay of Fundy, and the U.S. state of Maine. The province has a rich history and culture, with approximately 83% of its land being forested and a variety of landscapes and natural landmarks to explore, including the Hopewell Rocks, Fundy National Park, and Parlee Beach. However, some people find the province boring due to its quiet cities and lack of exciting attractions compared to other provinces.

Lack of attractions and natural beauty

New Brunswick is a boring province due to its lack of attractions and natural beauty. There are no breathtaking landscapes or awe-inspiring nature that will leave you in wonderment. The university campuses are dull, and there are no charming parts to this province. The cities also have nothing worth seeing or doing. There are no magical spots that will make you feel like you've stepped into a storybook. The province is mostly rural, with vast stretches of uninhabited land and sparsely populated towns, which can make it feel quite isolated.

While there are some natural wonders, such as the Bay of Fundy and its famous Hopewell Rocks, these may not be enough to excite those seeking breathtaking natural beauty. The province's climate is continental, with snowy winters and temperate summers, which may not appeal to those seeking more extreme or varied weather conditions.

New Brunswick is about 83% forested, and its northern half is occupied by the Appalachians. While this provides ample opportunities for outdoor activities like hiking, camping, and kayaking, it also means that the province may lack the diverse landscapes and natural wonders found in other parts of Canada.

The province's top attractions include the Bay of Fundy and Fundy National Park, Roosevelt Campobello International Park, Kingsbrae Garden, and Magnetic Hill. While these may be interesting to some, they may not compare to the attractions found in larger provinces or cities.

In conclusion, New Brunswick's lack of diverse and exciting attractions, combined with its predominantly forested landscape, can make it feel like a boring province to those seeking breathtaking natural beauty and a variety of entertainment options.

Poor economic state

New Brunswick has long been regarded as one of the poorest regions in Canada, with a poor economic state that has led to it receiving the most funding per capita from the federal government's equalization support program. The province has the lowest median household income in the country and was the only province to record a population decline between 2011 and 2016. Its tax base is shrinking, and it has suffered consecutive deficit budgets and staggering debt. The public sector is steadily increasing, while the private sector sheds labour, and the province's GDP growth has been weak, with a decline in industries such as shipbuilding and lumbering.

New Brunswick's poor economy has been described as an "elephant in the room," with economists warning of a fiscal cliff ahead if action isn't taken soon. The province's financial recovery has been feeble, hampered in part by demographics and a shrinking workforce. In 2017, nearly 5,000 people left the province's labour force, and while the labour force is expected to grow by 2,000 people in the following year, it won't be enough to make up for the losses.

The province's economic woes can be partly attributed to its history. In the late 1700s, New Brunswick was a peripheral corner of the British Empire, and its economy was poor for agriculture, mining, and fishing. While the lumber trade stimulated the economy in the early 1800s, protectionism disrupted trade with New England after Confederation. The province also experienced economic decline in industries such as shipbuilding and lumbering. The Great Depression of the 1930s further exacerbated the situation, and by the end of it, New Brunswick had the highest infant mortality and illiteracy rates in Canada.

More recently, the province has struggled with consecutive deficit budgets and a staggering debt. In 2019, New Brunswick's GDP growth was estimated at 3.7%, the weakest among equalization-receiving provinces and below the national average. The province's high public debt has also been a cause for concern, and economists have warned that a sharp rise in interest rates or a downgrade in bond ratings could push New Brunswick over the edge.

Despite its challenges, New Brunswick has seen a recent increase in migration, with people moving to the area from Ontario and other parts of Canada. Additionally, the province has a thriving tourism industry, with popular destinations such as the Hopewell Rocks, Fundy National Park, and Magnetic Hill. Efforts have also been made to improve the economy, with political leaders promising measures to boost economic growth and protect social services. However, New Brunswick continues to face significant economic challenges and will require long-term solutions to improve its financial situation.

Language war

Some people may find New Brunswick boring. One source states that there is nothing worth looking at and nowhere worth visiting. However, others may find the province's landscapes, countryside, nature, civil engineering achievements, university campuses, cities, bridges, wide-open skies, and riverside boardwalks interesting. New Brunswick also has historical significance in Canada's history.

New Brunswick is the only officially bilingual province in Canada, with French and English being recognised as official languages. The province has the highest level of linguistic duality in the country, with about two-thirds of the population being English-speaking and one-third French-speaking. The recognition of both languages dates back to the Official Languages Act of 1969, which grants citizens the right to receive government services in the language of their choice.

Despite this official recognition, language policy remains a contentious issue in New Brunswick's society and politics. There are recurring debates regarding the interpretation of the provincial bilingualism policy, duality (the system of parallel French and English-speaking public services), and the specifics of implementation.

The French-speaking community in New Brunswick continues to advocate for full funding of French-language public services and fair representation in public sector employment. On the other hand, some Anglophones (and even some Francophones) argue that the system of duality is financially inefficient and that the provincial government's targets for bilingualism in public employment reduce their chances of obtaining government jobs, as Anglophones are less likely to be proficient in both languages.

The province's bilingual status is enshrined in both provincial and federal law, including the Canadian Constitution and the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which contain New Brunswick-specific articles that emphasise the equal rights and privileges of the French and English-speaking communities.

Despite these legal protections, tensions between the two linguistic communities persist, and the extent of the provincial policy on bilingualism continues to be a source of debate and disagreement in New Brunswick.

Political culture steeped in linguistic tribalism

New Brunswick, one of Canada's first four provinces, has long been a microcosm of the country's linguistic balancing act. The province's political culture is steeped in linguistic tribalism, with the Liberal Party dominant in the mostly French-speaking northern part and the Progressive Conservative Party relying on support in the largely English-speaking southern region. This divide has resulted in a political landscape where governing often means pitting north against south, French against English, and urban against rural.

The province's language tensions have been further exacerbated by the requirement for provincial government services to be provided in the official language of the recipient's choice, with French and English recognised as official languages. While this has had economic benefits, attracting call centres and fostering business with Quebec, it has also led to sign laws, legal battles, and rhetoric from linguistic camps.

The Progressive Conservative government, led by Premier Blaine Higgs, has faced the challenge of governing in a minority situation, with two minor parties holding the balance of power. Soon after taking office, the government loosened bilingual hiring requirements in areas where one language was dominant, a decision that almost cost Higgs his deputy premier and lone Francophone cabinet minister, Robert Gauvin.

The ongoing language tensions in New Brunswick have been further inflamed by a push for language requirements to take a back seat when filling paramedic jobs, with staffing shortages at Ambulance NB. The issue has become a key campaign topic for the People's Alliance and their supporters.

In addition to the language divide, New Brunswick has witnessed an economic downturn, with an ageing population, out-migration, and diminishing economic opportunities. The province's economy has traditionally been reliant on natural resource sectors such as forestry, agriculture, and fishing, which now face challenges. The province also has a high proportion of rural residents, making the provision of health and education services more expensive for the government.

The combination of linguistic tribalism and economic hardships has created a challenging political landscape for New Brunswick, requiring careful navigation by its leaders.

Poor infrastructure

New Brunswick's Department of Transportation and Infrastructure is responsible for maintaining the province's highway network and government facilities. The department also operates several ferry services, most of which are free of tolls.

In 2016, the Government of Canada and New Brunswick signed an agreement to invest over $87 million in federal funding for the rehabilitation, repair, and modernisation of existing infrastructure. The goal was to provide communities with more reliable water and wastewater systems and improve public transit systems across the province. This was followed by a second agreement in 2018, which provided more than $666 million in federal funding for long-term infrastructure projects through four streams: Public Transit Infrastructure, Green Infrastructure, Community, Culture & Recreational Infrastructure, and Rural & Northern Infrastructure.

The Government of Canada's investments in modern infrastructure aim to build efficient transportation systems, provide clean drinking water, increase access to high-speed internet, and build inclusive communities. The projects funded by the government not only improve the everyday lives of Canadians but also attract talent and investments to create new jobs and business opportunities.

However, despite these investments and efforts, some critics might argue that more could be done to improve the province's infrastructure, particularly in rural and remote areas. Ensuring adequate infrastructure maintenance and development is crucial for the well-being of residents and the province's economic growth.

Frequently asked questions