Belarus: A Racist Country?

Racism is a recurring issue in Europe, and Belarus is no exception. As a predominantly Christian society that was formerly part of the Russian Empire and later the Soviet Union, Belarus has a history of anti-Semitic and anti-Gypsy narratives and practices. However, it is important to note that racism in Belarus is not limited to these groups, and other minorities may also face discrimination. While some travellers report feeling unsafe in Belarus due to their skin colour, others claim to have had positive experiences, suggesting that racism may not be as prevalent or accepted as in other European countries. Nevertheless, it is essential to recognise that racism exists in Belarus and that the country is not immune to the global issue of racial inequality.

Is racism in Belarus influenced by its history?

Racism in Belarus is influenced by its history, particularly its time within the Russian Empire and later the Soviet Union. As a predominantly Christian society, Belarus has a history of anti-Semitic and anti-Gypsy narratives and practices, which can be traced to its time as part of the Russian Empire. After the collapse of the Soviet Union, Belarus struggled to develop a national identity, which has contributed to the racialization processes in the context of mass migration.

During the Soviet era, Belarusians experienced state-sanctioned racism and discrimination, particularly towards Jews. This history of antisemitism in the region has had a lasting impact on the country. Following the collapse of the Soviet Union, Belarus began to develop its own national system of education, aiming to balance the Soviet legacy with democratization. The education system plays a crucial role in translating dominant ideologies, and changes in the curriculum can reflect shifts in public policy and social attitudes.

In recent years, there have been reports of racist incidents in Belarus, particularly targeting people of colour. However, some travellers have reported feeling safe in the country, with no issues related to their nationality or skin colour. It is important to note that individual experiences may vary, and while Belarus may be safer than neighbouring countries like Russia, isolated racist incidents can still occur.

The impact of history on racism in Belarus is complex and multifaceted, shaped by the country's unique cultural, political, and social context. While the country has made strides towards inclusivity and equality, there is still work to be done to address the legacy of historical racism and discrimination.

Is Belarus safe for people of colour?

Belarus has a history of anti-Semitic and anti-Tsygan (anti-Gypsy) narratives and practices, which have been present since its time as part of the western edges of the former Russian Empire. However, it is suggested that Belarus is one of the safest countries in Europe when it comes to racist attacks.

A Safe Haven?

One source suggests that Belarus is the safest country in Europe in terms of racist attacks. This is supported by a first-hand account of a trip made by a group of Indian tourists to Belarus, who reported that everything went smoothly and that they had not heard of any violent accidents towards tourists in relation to their nationality.

Another source states that there are students from Africa and China in Minsk, and that they have not heard of any problems with people of darker skin colour. They suggest that Belarus is a very safe place, but to keep in mind that any situation can happen, as in any other country in the world.

A Different Perspective

However, one source suggests that Belarus is not safe at all, and that racism is widespread and commonly accepted. They refer to a recent BBC documentary, which showed Indians being beaten and thrown out of a football stadium.

A Comparison

Compared to other countries, one source suggests that Belarus is safer than Russia, but that Poland and Ukraine have more issues with racism than Belarus, though not to the same extent as Russia.

Is racism in Belarus comparable to racism in Russia?

Racism in Belarus and Russia is comparable in some ways, but there are also differences between the two countries. Both countries have a history of racist discourses and practices, with long-standing anti-Semitic and anti-Gypsy narratives and practices. However, Belarus has been described as one of the safest countries in Europe for people of colour, while Russia has seen a significant increase in racial ideas, practices, exclusions, and violence since the 1990s.

In Belarus, there have been reports of racist attacks, particularly against people of colour. For example, a Lebanese doctor was attacked on a commuter train, and there have been reports of Indian tourists being targeted by football fans. However, these incidents appear to be relatively rare, and some travellers of colour have reported feeling safe in the country.

On the other hand, Russia has a more prominent history of racism, with neo-Nazi groups and skinheads targeting both Russian citizens of diverse backgrounds and non-Russian citizens. Since the 1990s, Russia has seen a significant increase in racial ideas, practices, exclusions, and violence. Russian Orthodox Church has called for a campaign against extremism and for immigrants to be given jobs and opportunities to learn about Russian culture.

In terms of national policies, both Belarus and Russia have been influenced by their predominantly Christian societies and their historical connection to Moscow. However, it is worth noting that Belarus has been described as safer for people of colour than Russia, with Poland and Ukraine falling somewhere in between.

While both countries have their challenges when it comes to racism, the specific manifestations and the extent of the issue differ. It is important to recognize that racism is a complex and multifaceted issue, and direct comparisons between countries may overlook important nuances.

Is racism in Belarus comparable to racism in Ukraine?

Racism in Belarus and Ukraine has been influenced by their shared history as predominantly Christian societies within the former Russian Empire and later the Soviet Union. Both countries have experienced anti-Semitic and anti-Gypsy narratives and practices, with these attitudes persisting in the present day. However, it is important to note that the expression of racism and its impact on different communities may vary between the two countries.

In Belarus, the education system has been identified as a tool for propagating dominant ideologies, including those related to gender and sexuality. The country's nationalist movement emerged in the early 20th century, and debates surrounding ethnic, racial, and cultural belonging continue to shape its society. While some sources characterise racism as a fringe issue in Belarus, others argue that it is a significant problem, particularly towards Russian citizens and those of African, Central Asian, East Asian, and European descent.

Ukraine, on the other hand, has witnessed a more visible rise in racism and xenophobia in recent years, with ultra-nationalist parties gaining attention. Racially motivated attacks have been reported, particularly targeting people of African, Asian, and Middle Eastern origin, as well as religious minorities. The European Commission against Racism and Intolerance (ECRI) noted a decline in tolerance towards Jews, Russians, and Romani people in Ukraine since 2000, with prejudices reflected in daily life and access to goods and services. The country's Romani community, estimated at 400,000 people, faces both governmental and societal discrimination, including racial profiling, eviction, denial of public assistance, and inadequate access to education and employment.

During the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine, allegations surfaced of African and Indian students facing discrimination while attempting to flee the country, with reports of being denied entry onto trains and through borders. This has sparked solidarity movements among communities of colour in Canada, the United Kingdom, France, and the United States.

While both Belarus and Ukraine have struggled with racism, the expression and impact of racist attitudes may vary due to historical, political, and social factors unique to each country. The available information suggests that racism in Ukraine has gained more social influence and resulted in more violent incidents, with targeted groups experiencing discrimination in various aspects of their lives. However, it is important to recognise that both countries have ongoing challenges in addressing racism and protecting the rights of minority communities.

Is racism in Belarus comparable to racism in Poland?

Racism in Belarus and Poland has been a subject of extensive studies. Both countries have a history of racist discourses and practices, influenced by their past as part of the Russian Empire and the Soviet Union. However, it is challenging to make a direct comparison between the two countries regarding racism due to differences in historical contexts, societal dynamics, and the specific manifestations of racist attitudes and behaviours.

In Belarus, the dissolution of the Soviet Union led to the development of a national education system that reflected dominant ideologies, including gender and sexuality. The country's Christian majority and search for national identity have contributed to racist discourses and practices, particularly against Jewish and Roma communities. While there is limited recent data on racist incidents in Belarus, studies suggest that mass migration and deteriorating relations with Russia have influenced racialization processes.

Poland, on the other hand, has a history of ethnic diversity, with minorities constituting a significant proportion of the population before World War II. The country has experienced waves of antisemitism, targeting its large Jewish population throughout history. While the Jewish population has dwindled, antisemitism persists and is fueled by religious sentiments, denial of historical responsibility for anti-Jewish crimes, and scapegoating. Poland also faces issues with racism towards ethnic Poles, Ukrainians, and people of African descent. Notably, Poland has been ranked as one of the least racist countries in the European Union, with a low percentage of respondents experiencing discrimination based on race or ethnicity.

Both Belarus and Poland have witnessed the influence of far-right groups and political parties that promote racist ideologies and engage in violent acts. However, the specific manifestations of racism, the frequency of racist incidents, and the societal responses to them may differ between the two countries. While racism is a complex and pervasive issue in both societies, a direct comparison is challenging due to the unique historical and cultural contexts that shape racist attitudes and behaviours in each country.

To fully understand the extent and nature of racism in Belarus and Poland, further research and up-to-date data are necessary.

Frequently asked questions