Bavaria's Independence: Can It Leave Germany?

Bavaria, a state in southern Germany, has a long history of independence movements. Bavarians have sought to secede from Germany since the Kingdom of Bavaria was incorporated into the German Empire in 1871. Bavarian nationalism, a political ideology that asserts Bavarians as a distinct nation, has been a strong phenomenon since the unification of Germany. The wealthy state, which comprises roughly one-fifth of Germany's landmass, has a unique culture and is known for its traditions such as Oktoberfest, lederhosen, and sauerkraut. While some Bavarians take pride in their cultural identity and desire independence, others recognize the benefits of remaining within Germany, including economic advantages and representation in the Bundesliga football league. The question of Bavaria's potential independence has sparked debates among its citizens, with a mix of support and opposition.

Bavaria's history as an independent kingdom

Bavaria was an independent kingdom from 1806 until 1871. The Kingdom of Bavaria was created when Elector Maximilian IV Joseph of the House of Wittelsbach was crowned King of Bavaria. The kingdom was formed from the Electorate of Bavaria, which had succeeded the Duchy of Bavaria in the 6th century.

The Kingdom of Bavaria was the second-largest and second-most powerful state in the German Empire, behind the Kingdom of Prussia. The kingdom was ruled by the House of Wittelsbach until its end in 1918. The kingdom's existence was marked by several territorial changes. In 1808, the kingdom was divided into 15 administrative government districts, which were later reduced to eight. In 1810, Bavaria ceded southern Tyrol to Italy and some small districts to Württemberg, receiving parts of Salzburg, the Innviertel and Hausruck, and the principalities of Bayreuth and Regensburg in return. In 1814, after the defeat of Napoleon's France, Bavaria lost the territories it had gained from Austria but was compensated with new territories, including the Grand Duchy of Würzburg and parts of the Grand Duchy of Hesse.

In 1818, a constitution was proclaimed, creating a bicameral Parliament. The upper house was comprised of the aristocracy and noblemen, while the lower house included representatives of landowners, the universities, the clergy, the towns, and the peasants.

In 1848, King Ludwig I abdicated in favour of his eldest son, Maximilian II, due to the revolutions of that year. In 1866, Bavaria sided with Austria in the Austro-Prussian War, which resulted in a Prussian victory. This marked a shift in Bavarian relations towards Prussia, and in 1871, Bavaria joined the Prussian-led German Empire while retaining its title of kingdom.

Bavaria's incorporation into Germany in 1871

In the early 1800s, Bavaria was an independent kingdom with a constitution and a parliament. However, the kingdom's existence was fraught with challenges, including financial troubles and territorial disputes with neighbouring powers such as Austria and Prussia.

In 1866, the Austro-Prussian War significantly altered the political landscape. Bavaria, which had sided with Austria, was defeated and lost influence over some of its territories. Prussia, on the other hand, emerged as a dominant force in the region.

In 1870, when France declared war on Prussia, Bavaria joined forces with the North German Confederation, which was led by Prussia. The combined German forces defeated France, and this victory paved the way for German unification.

On January 18, 1871, the Prussian King Wilhelm I was proclaimed German Emperor at the German-occupied Palace of Versailles in France. The territories of the new German Empire included the states of the North German Confederation and all the south German states, except Austria. Bavaria became a part of this unified German Empire while retaining its title of kingdom and some special rights within the federation.

Bavaria's entry into the German Empire was met with mixed reactions. While some Bavarians celebrated the defeat of their long-time rival, France, others resented being ruled by the mostly Protestant northerners in Prussia, as Bavaria had a heavily Catholic majority population. This led to the formation of political parties advocating for Bavarian independence.

Despite these tensions, Bavaria remained a part of the German Empire, and its political and administrative structures evolved over time. In 1918, with the end of World War I, the Bavarian monarchy was abolished, and Bavaria became a republic within the Weimar Republic.

Bavarian nationalism and its supporters

Bavarian nationalism is a political ideology that asserts Bavarians are a nation and promotes the cultural unity of Bavarians. Bavarian nationalists claim that the terms under which Bavaria entered into Germany in 1871 were controversial and that the German government has long intruded on the desired autonomy of Bavaria. Bavarian nationalism has been a strong phenomenon since the incorporation of the Kingdom of Bavaria into the German Empire in 1871.

Bavaria was politically and culturally closer to Catholic Austria than Protestant Prussia, and the Bavarians shared a common contempt for the Prussians, leading Bavaria to ally with Austria in the Austro-Prussian War. However, Austria and Bavaria were defeated by Prussia and its allies. As a result, Bavaria paid a large indemnity to Prussia and joined the Prussian-founded German Empire in 1871. After unification with Germany, Bavarian nationalists were opposed to Prussian domination of the German state and refused further integration into the German Empire.

Bavarian nationalism grew in strength after Germany's defeat in World War I, becoming popular among both revolutionary and reactionary political movements. The Bavarian monarchy was toppled, and Bavaria was proclaimed an independent communist state, known as the Bavarian Soviet Republic. Bavarian nationalism, associated with anti-Prussian and anti-Semitic tendencies, became popular among radical and reactionary movements. There were also proposals for Austria to join Bavaria, with the Bavarian government expressing interest in incorporating the regions of North Tyrol and Upper Austria into Bavaria.

The pro-independence Bavaria Party is a significant player in Bavarian state politics, polling from 5% to over 20% in state and federal elections during the 1950s. In 2013, the Bavaria Party won 2.1% of the total vote in state elections. In a 2017 poll, 32% of Bavarians supported the idea of independence.

Bavaria's Christian Social Union (CSU) is a regional conservative party that complements and sometimes rivals the nationwide conservative party, the Christian Democratic Union (CDU). The CSU is bound by a deal with the CDU, agreeing not to compete in each other's territories in exchange for forming a nationwide force at the federal level. The CSU is considered more socially conservative than the CDU, especially on religion and law enforcement, reflecting Bavaria's Catholic traditions.

Bavaria's pro-independence party

The Bavaria Party's ideology is rooted in Bavarian nationalism, which has been a strong force since the Kingdom of Bavaria joined the German Empire in 1871. Bavarian nationalists have long claimed that the terms of Bavaria's entry into Germany were controversial and that the region's desired autonomy has been intruded upon by the German government. Bavarian nationalism gained traction after World War I, with proposals for Austria to join Bavaria, and it became popular among both revolutionary and reactionary political movements.

The Bavaria Party's platform likely resonates with Bavarians who feel a stronger connection to Catholic Austria than to the Protestant Prussians who ruled the German Empire. Additionally, some Bavarians feel that they are economically supporting weaker EU states and poorer parts of Germany. The European refugee crisis also fuelled anger in Bavaria, with politicians criticising Chancellor Angela Merkel for her handling of the situation.

However, the Bavaria Party's influence has been limited in recent years. In the 2018 elections, the party secured only 1.7% of the voters' share, a slight decrease from their 2013 performance, where they garnered 2.1% of the vote. The party has faced challenges in consolidating its upward trend and has not been able to secure seats in the Bavarian Parliament since 1962.

While the Bavaria Party's influence has fluctuated over the years, it continues to advocate for Bavarian independence and represents a segment of the Bavarian population that desires greater autonomy and a potential separation from the rest of Germany.

German court rulings on Bavaria's independence

Bavaria, officially the Free State of Bavaria, is a state in the southeast of Germany. It is the largest German state by land area, comprising roughly a fifth of the country's total land area. Bavaria has a distinct culture, largely due to its Catholic heritage and conservative traditions, which includes a language, cuisine, architecture, festivals, and elements of Alpine symbolism.

Historically, Bavaria was an independent kingdom after 1806. It joined the Prussian-led German Empire in 1871 while retaining its title of kingdom. Finally, in 1949, it became a state of the Federal Republic of Germany.

Despite being a part of Germany, Bavarians have often emphasised a separate national identity and considered themselves "Bavarians" first and "Germans" second. This sentiment is reflected in the designation of Bavaria as a "Free State," a term that implies a degree of autonomy and is shared by only two other German states.

While there have been efforts to leave Germany and regain independence, these have not been successful. The most recent attempt was in 2017 when a Bavarian man filed a case with the Constitutional Court, seeking to hold a 'Bayxit' vote to decide if Bavaria should remain in Germany. However, the court ruled that the Grundgesetz (German constitutional law) does not allow for individual states to break away.

The court's decision stated:

> "In the Federal Republic of Germany, which is a nation-state based on the constituent power of the German people, states are not 'masters of the constitution'. Therefore, there is no room under the constitution for individual states to attempt to secede. This violates the constitutional order."

This ruling effectively shut down hopes for a breakaway Bavaria, and the pro-independence Bavaria Party expressed defiance, stating that the struggle for independence would be decided by the will of the Bavarian people rather than a court.

While the independence movement in Bavaria may not be widely known, it has a long history in the region, and the idea of secession is not taken seriously by most.

Frequently asked questions