Bahrain's Government: Limited Or Unlimited Power?

Bahrain is a constitutional monarchy with a semi-democratic framework. The government is appointed by the King of Bahrain, who holds ultimate authority over most government decisions. The King also appoints the Prime Minister, who is not required to be a member of parliament. The parliament is bicameral, with the Council of Representatives elected by universal suffrage, and the Shura Council (or Consultative Council) appointed directly by the King. The King also appoints the upper house of parliament, which has the power to veto legislation.

Bahrain's political system has been criticised for its lack of transparency and accountability, with the King enjoying wide executive powers. The country has also faced criticism for its human rights record, with reports of arbitrary arrests, detention without trial, torture, and suppression of freedom of expression and assembly.

While Bahrain has a semi-democratic framework, the actual level of democracy and political freedom enjoyed by its citizens is limited by the concentration of power in the hands of the King and the royal family, who dominate political and military posts.

Bahrain's government is a semi-constitutional monarchy

Bahrain is a semi-constitutional monarchy, also known as a limited monarchy, where the monarch exercises their authority in accordance with a constitution and is not the sole decision-maker. In Bahrain, the government is appointed by the King, who also holds wide executive powers, including the ability to appoint the prime minister and ministers, command the army, and chair the Higher Judicial Council.

Bahrain's transition to a constitutional monarchy occurred in 2002, under the rule of Hamad bin Isa Al Khalifa, who became the Emir of Bahrain in 1999. This shift involved democratic reforms, including the introduction of elections for parliament, the right for women to vote, and the release of all political prisoners. The country's official name was also changed from the State of Bahrain to the Kingdom of Bahrain.

The Bahraini parliament is a bicameral legislature, consisting of the Council of Representatives, whose members are elected by universal suffrage, and the Consultative Council, whose members are appointed directly by the King.

While the Bahraini monarchy has moved towards a more democratic system, it still retains substantial powers. The King can dissolve parliament and has the authority to appoint the parliament's upper house. Additionally, the constitution grants the monarch substantial discretionary powers, allowing them to exercise authority within certain limits prescribed by an established legal framework.

The transition to a constitutional monarchy in Bahrain has had a significant impact on the country's political landscape. It has opened up politics, leading to gains for both Shia and Sunni Islamist parties, and enhanced the influence of religious leaders, who can deliver the votes of their congregations to candidates. At the same time, liberal groups have faced challenges due to the dominance of religious parties in elections and their ability to impose restrictive social agendas.

Overall, Bahrain's government as a semi-constitutional monarchy represents a balance between monarchical authority and democratic principles, with the King of Bahrain holding significant powers while also operating within the framework of a constitution and an elected parliament.

The King of Bahrain has wide-ranging executive powers

The Kingdom of Bahrain has been a constitutional monarchy since 2002, with a parliament consisting of a Council of Representatives elected by universal suffrage, and a Consultative Council (or Shura Council) appointed by the king. The current ruler, Hamad bin Isa Al Khalifa, has been in power since 1999, first as the Emir of Bahrain and then as king from 2002.

The Al Khalifa family has ruled Bahrain since the late 1700s, with Hamad bin Isa Al Khalifa being the current king. The king's powers are not unlimited, however, as Bahrain's constitution provides for a bicameral legislature with an elected lower house. The king's executive powers are balanced by the legislative powers of the parliament, particularly the elected lower house.

The king's role as the head of state and the framework of constitutional monarchy in Bahrain allow for a balance of powers between the executive and legislative branches of the government. The king's wide-ranging executive powers are an important aspect of Bahrain's political system, providing the monarch with the authority to make key appointments and decisions regarding the country's defence and judicial system.

The Bahraini parliament is bicameral

The National Assembly, the legislative body of Bahrain, is made up of these two houses. The joint session of the National Assembly is chaired by the Speaker of the Council of Representatives or, in their absence, by the Speaker of the Consultative Council.

The Bahraini parliament has been criticised for giving the Shura Council, as the unelected upper house, equal or more legislative power than the elected lower house, effectively allowing the King to control all legislation. This criticism is levelled particularly by the opposition, including Islamic parties, who boycotted the 2002 election in protest.

Supporters of the system, however, point to long-established democracies such as the United Kingdom and Canada, which also operate with bicameralism, featuring an appointed upper chamber and an elected lower chamber.

The Bahraini government is criticised for human rights violations

Bahrain's human rights record has been described as "dismal" by Human Rights Watch, with the organisation noting a sharp deterioration in the latter half of 2010. The Bahraini government has been criticised for its treatment of the native Shia Muslim population, who have faced marginalisation, torture, and forced disappearances. The crackdown on protesters during the 2011 Arab Spring brought further human rights complaints, including the destruction of Shia mosques.

The Bahraini government has been accused of practicing "sectarian apartheid" by preventing Shiites from holding key government posts or serving in the police or military. This discrimination also extends to the fields of employment and housing, with certain jobs and neighbourhoods being off-limits to Shiites.

The Bahraini government has also been criticised for its treatment of stateless people, known as Bedoon. These individuals, who are often descendants of Iranians with long-standing ties to Bahrain, face numerous restrictions on their rights, including the denial of legal residency, the right to travel abroad, and the ability to own land or property.

Additionally, Bahrain has been criticised for its use of torture and ill-treatment during interrogations. Despite repeated government claims of improvement, Human Rights Watch maintains that "torture is a regular part of the legal process in Bahrain."

The country's press freedom has also come under scrutiny, with the government accused of blocking websites, harassing journalists, and firing editors who are critical of the regime.

In terms of civil and political rights, while Bahrain has introduced parliamentary and municipal elections, the prime minister and government ministers are directly appointed by the king, and the upper chamber of parliament is also appointed by the monarch. This has led to concerns about the influence of religious parties in politics and the curtailment of freedoms.

On a more positive note, King Hamad bin Isa Al Khalifa has taken some steps to promote women's rights, such as granting them the right to vote and run for office. However, these reforms have been contentious, with conservatives and the royal family opposing them.

Overall, the Bahraini government faces widespread criticism from human rights organisations, journalists, and activists for its violations of human rights, including discrimination, torture, and the suppression of freedom of expression and association.

Bahrain's economy has diversified away from oil and gas production

Bahrain has been actively working to diversify its economy away from oil and gas production. While oil and gas still play a significant role in the country's economy, Bahrain has made notable strides in developing other sectors.

Bahrain's finance industry is particularly successful, with the country being named the world's fastest-growing financial centre by the City of London's Global Financial Centres Index in 2008. The country has benefited from its position as a regional financial and business centre, with a strong regulatory framework that has attracted international financial institutions. Additionally, Bahrain's free trade agreement with the US in 2006 has further enhanced its economic diversification efforts.

The country has also invested in the tourism sector, with its capital, Manama, offering a range of attractions. Bahrain's success in ventures such as the Bahrain Grand Prix has raised its international profile and encouraged major airlines to resume services to the country.

In addition to finance and tourism, Bahrain has expanded into other sectors, including banking, heavy industries, retail, and manufacturing. The country has a growing high-tech industry and is committed to investing in research and development to remain competitive in the global market.

While oil and gas still account for a significant portion of government revenues, Bahrain's efforts to diversify its economy have shown promising results. The non-oil sector in Bahrain has been displaying robust growth, indicating the country's successful economic diversification initiatives.

Frequently asked questions