Austria-Hungary: Eastern Or Western Europe?

The classification of countries as Eastern or Western European is a complex issue that has changed over time and is still debated by experts. The term Eastern Europe is often associated with the communist states of the Eastern Bloc during the Cold War, which included countries such as Bulgaria, Czechoslovakia, Hungary, Poland, and Romania. However, the boundaries of Eastern Europe are not fixed and can vary depending on historical, cultural, religious, and geopolitical factors.

Austria-Hungary, as a historical dual monarchy, had a unique position in Europe. During the Cold War, Hungary was considered part of the Eastern Bloc under the influence of the Soviet Union. On the other hand, Austria, which was not under Soviet control, is generally considered a Central European or Western European country.

Today, Hungary is often classified as a Central European country by its citizens and neighbouring countries. However, some still consider it Eastern European due to its historical and cultural ties to the region. The classification of Austria-Hungary as Eastern or Western European is a complex issue that depends on the context and the specific definition being used.

Hungary's geopolitical history

During the Cold War, Hungary was firmly within the Eastern Bloc, being a part of the Warsaw Pact and under the influence of the Soviet Union. This association strongly contributed to the perception of Hungary as an Eastern European country. However, even before the Cold War, Hungary's geopolitical orientation was complex. While it had ties to both the East and the West, it did not always fit the stereotypical view of an Eastern European country. For example, Hungary adopted Catholicism instead of Orthodox Christianity, aligning it with Western Europe in religious terms.

In the nineteenth century, German nationalists defined Eastern Europe as "Slavic Europe," in contrast to Germanic (Western) Europe. This characterisation was reinforced during the lead-up to World War II and was often used in racist terminology to depict Eastern/Slavic culture as inferior. However, Hungarians are not Slavs, and they have historically been opposed to being associated with Russia or Slavic cultures. This sentiment persists today, with many Hungarians taking offence at being referred to as Slavic or Russian.

Hungary's unique position between East and West is reflected in its architecture, culture, and self-perception. Budapest, the capital city, is known for its architectural style, which resembles Paris. At the same time, other major cities in Hungary have their distinct styles and characters. Hungarians often view their country as a bridge between East and West, with people from the east seeing it as Western and those from the west seeing it as Eastern. This perception is captured in a quote by an anonymous poet:

> "When you visit Budapest, if you're from Paris you'll feel like you're in Moscow. But if you're from Moscow, you'll feel like you're in Paris."

In recent years, Hungary's geopolitical orientation has shifted significantly. Since joining the European Union, Hungary has distanced itself from its Eastern Bloc past and embraced a more pro-Western stance. However, under the leadership of Prime Minister Viktor Orbán, Hungary has also pursued a controversial foreign policy, moving away from its traditionally pro-European stance and towards a closer relationship with Russia, particularly in the energy sector. This realignment has caused tension with other European Union members and raised concerns about Hungary's commitment to democratic principles.

In conclusion, Hungary's geopolitical history is complex and multifaceted, shaped by its geographical position, cultural influences, and shifting political alliances. While it has historically been considered a part of Eastern Europe, the country's unique characteristics and evolving relationships with its neighbours continue to influence how it is perceived in the geopolitical landscape.

The Cold War's impact

The Cold War was a conflict between the two superpowers of the world: the Soviet Union and its satellite states, and the United States and its allies. It was an ideological conflict between communist and capitalist countries, which had a significant impact on Europe.

Following World War II, Europe was divided into two spheres of influence: the Soviets in Eastern Europe and the Americans, British and French in Western Europe. This division created a fault line that split the continent in half, with Poland, Czechoslovakia, and East Germany in the Soviet sphere, and Western Europe in the American sphere. This division was solidified by 1947-48 when U.S. aid brought several Western countries under American influence, and the Soviets installed openly communist regimes in Eastern Europe.

The Cold War impacted the region in several ways. Economically, the U.S. provided aid to Western European countries under the Marshall Plan, while Eastern European countries were heavily influenced by the Soviet Union and its economic structures, such as Comecon. Politically, the Cold War led to the establishment of organisations such as NATO and the Warsaw Pact, which solidified the division between East and West. The Soviet Union also installed left-wing governments in Eastern European countries, which caused concern in the West about the permanent Soviet domination of the region.

The Cold War also impacted social and cultural relations between Eastern and Western Europe. The concept of the "Iron Curtain" separating the two regions led to a cultural division between Western Christianity and Eastern Orthodox Christianity and Islam. This division was further emphasised by the construction of the Berlin Wall, which became a physical symbol of the divide. The wall prevented East Germans from defecting to the West and was a source of tension between the two sides.

The end of the Cold War brought about significant changes in Eastern Europe. The fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989 marked the end of the Cold War and the divisions between East and West. The Communist bloc collapsed, and the bipolar world built around the U.S.-Soviet rivalry came to an end. This led to the reunification of Germany and the improvement of relations between the two parts of the continent. Political and economic reforms were carried out, leading to the creation of market economies and democratic governments in Eastern Europe.

In summary, the Cold War had a significant impact on Eastern and Western Europe, creating a division between the two regions that lasted for decades. The conflict led to economic, political, and social differences, as well as the establishment of rival organisations and alliances. The end of the Cold War brought about a period of transformation and improved relations between Eastern and Western Europe.

Religion and culture

Austria-Hungary was a multilingual empire, with a diverse range of ethnic and religious groups. The census of 1910 recorded the everyday language of the population, with German, Hungarian, Romanian, Slovak, Serbo-Croatian, Polish, Ruthenian, Slovenian, and Italian being spoken. The census also recorded the mother tongues of the inhabitants, with Hungarian being the most common, followed by Romanian, Slovak, German, Ruthenian, Serbian, Croatian, and Slovenian.

In terms of religion, Austria-Hungary had a predominantly Christian population, with a significant presence of Roman Catholicism. According to the 2021 national survey, 68.2% of Austria's population identified as Christians, with 80.9% of those being Catholics, 7.2% Orthodox Christians, 5.6% Protestants, and the remaining 6.2% belonging to other Christian denominations. The census also showed an increase in the number of Muslims and Serbian Orthodox Christians due to immigration from Turkey and the former Yugoslavia.

Austria has a long history of religious conflict and reformation. In the 16th century, many Austrians converted to Protestantism, particularly Lutheranism, during the Protestant Reformation. However, the Habsburgs enacted measures of Counter-Reformation, harshly repressing Austrian Protestantism. Despite this, a minority of Austrians remained Protestant.

During the reign of the House of Anjou in Hungary, Christian culture flourished, with the founding of universities and the construction of the cathedral at Kaschau. The Hungarian ruler, Géza, and his wife Sarolta, were favourably inclined towards Christianity due to the influence of the court of Byzantium and St. Wolfgang, a monk. The real Apostle of the Magyars was Géza's great son, St. Stephen, who received a Christian education and was baptised by St. Adalbert.

The religious composition of Austria-Hungary also included a significant Jewish population, particularly in Vienna. However, during the Second World War, the Jewish community was reduced from over 200,000 to around 4,500 due to the Holocaust and emigration.

Historical boundaries

The boundaries of Eastern Europe are subject to considerable overlap and fluctuation depending on the context in which they are used. The term is often used to refer to all European countries that were previously ruled by communist regimes (the Eastern Bloc) during the Cold War. The idea of the "Iron Curtain" separating Eastern and Western Europe was extremely common during this period.

The term "Eastern Europe" is also used to refer to the nations bordered by the Baltic and Barents seas to the north, the Adriatic, Black, and Caspian seas and the Caucasus Mountains to the south, and the Ural Mountains to the east. Using this definition, countries such as Albania, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Croatia, Serbia, Estonia, Latvia, and Lithuania would be included.

Historically, the concept of Eastern Europe was defined by 19th-century German nationalists to be synonymous with "Slavic Europe," as opposed to Germanic (Western) Europe. This concept was reinforced during the years leading up to World War II and was often used in racist terminology to characterise Eastern/Slavic culture as inferior to Western/Germanic culture. The dividing line between these two spheres has changed over time due to the impact of the World Wars, expulsions, and genocides.

During the Cold War, the idea of Eastern Europe was greatly strengthened by the domination of the region by the Soviet Union and the communist governments that took control of the nations in the region. However, this strict dualism failed to account for the complexities of the region, as some countries, such as Yugoslavia and Albania, refused to be controlled by Moscow.

With the end of the Cold War, the ideological division between East and West disappeared, and the cultural division between Western Christianity and Eastern Orthodox Christianity and Islam reemerged. This division follows the "Huntington line" of "clashing civilisations," which corresponds roughly to the eastern boundary of Western Christianity in the year 1500.

In terms of historical boundaries, Hungary has been considered both a Central European country and part of Eastern Europe. During the Cold War, Hungary was politically part of the Eastern Bloc. However, Hungarians often claim that their country is culturally and geographically Central European. Similarly, Austria is generally considered Western European but was politically part of the Eastern Bloc during the Cold War.

Socio-economic factors

The socio-economic factors that determine whether Austria-Hungary is considered Eastern or Western European are complex and multifaceted. One key factor is the standard of living in the region. By 1870, Austria-Hungary was a large, heavily rural country with wealth and income levels comparable to France or the USA. However, the standard of living varied significantly across the empire, with the western areas becoming more developed than the eastern regions. This disparity persisted until the end of the 19th century, when economic growth in the eastern parts of the empire began to surpass that of the west.

Another important socio-economic factor is the level of industrialization. Austria-Hungary experienced slow economic change during its existence from 1867 to 1918. While the capitalist mode of production spread throughout the empire, replacing medieval institutions, industrialization lagged behind other parts of Europe. The GNP per capita grew by approximately 1.76% per year from 1870 to 1913, which compared favourably to other European nations. However, the Austro-Hungarian economy as a whole lagged behind due to a late start to sustained modernization.

The structure of the economy also played a role in shaping socio-economic conditions. Austria-Hungary had a predominantly rural economy, with 67% of the workforce employed in agriculture in 1870, decreasing only slightly to 60% by 1913. The industrial sector showed some growth, with 16% of the workforce employed in 1870 rising to 22% over time. The empire's heavy industry focused on machine building, particularly for the electric power, locomotive, and automotive industries. Light industry, such as the precision mechanics industry, also played a significant role.

Foreign investment and trade were other key socio-economic factors. Germany dominated foreign investment in the empire from 1870 to 1913, followed by France and, to a lesser extent, Great Britain. Vienna raised tariffs during this period to protect its growing industries, resulting in strong economic growth and a doubling of GNP from 1870 to 1913. However, Austria-Hungary's economic growth lagged behind that of the rest of Europe, which grew by 115% over the same period.

In summary, while Austria-Hungary had a high standard of living and a growing economy, it faced regional disparities, a late start to industrialization, and a predominantly rural economic structure. These socio-economic factors contributed to its complex position between Eastern and Western Europe.

Frequently asked questions