Austria And Switzerland: Comparing Military Service Requirements

Austria and Switzerland are neighbouring countries in Central Europe with a shared commitment to neutrality. Both countries have a long history of maintaining their neutrality and sovereignty, which has influenced their military strategies and policies. While there are some similarities between the two countries' approaches to neutrality, there are also significant differences.

Austria's armed forces, known as the Bundesheer, consist of 16,000 active-duty personnel and 125,600 reservists, with a military budget of 1.0% of national GDP or €3.317 billion (as of 2023). On the other hand, Switzerland has a larger active-duty personnel of 101,584 and a smaller reservist force of 49,715. Switzerland's defence budget is also higher at $9,300,000,000. Both countries have a mix of domestically produced and imported weapons systems, with the United States being a leading supplier of military armaments to Switzerland.

One key difference between the two countries is their relationship with NATO. Austria is not a member of NATO but has joined the organisation's Partnership for Peace framework. Switzerland, on the other hand, has periodically participated in EU, NATO, and the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe initiatives. Swiss law prohibits the country from participating in combat operations for peace enforcement, and Swiss units will only take part in operations under the mandate of the UN or OSCE.

In terms of military strategy, Austria and Switzerland have taken different approaches. Austria's main focus has been on protecting its neutrality and assisting with border control to manage the influx of undocumented migrants. Switzerland, on the other hand, has historically maintained a large and well-equipped army to defend its neutrality. During the Cold War, Switzerland even contemplated building nuclear weapons to uphold its neutrality in the nuclear age.

While both Austria and Switzerland have similar commitments to neutrality, their military strategies, budgets, and relationships with international organisations differ significantly.

Austria's and Switzerland's commitment to neutrality

Austria and Switzerland share a border in the Alps and a long-standing commitment to neutrality. At the Congress of Vienna in 1814–1815, the Austrian Empire was one of eight Great Powers that guaranteed Switzerland's "perpetual neutrality." Following the Second World War, Austria agreed to become a neutral state "like Switzerland" to end the post-war occupation.

Austria's neutrality is enshrined in its constitution, which states that the country will not join any military alliances or allow foreign military bases on its territory. However, Austria is a member of the European Union and participates in EU peacekeeping and crisis management operations. It has also joined NATO's Partnership for Peace framework.

Switzerland, on the other hand, has maintained a policy of military neutrality and does not participate in combat operations. It periodically engages with organisations like the EU, NATO, and the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe. Swiss law prohibits the country from participating in peace enforcement operations, and Swiss units only take part in operations under the mandate of the UN or OSCE.

Despite their shared commitment to neutrality, Austria and Switzerland have different interpretations and applications of the concept. Austria takes a more engaged approach, actively participating in international organisations and initiatives. On the other hand, Switzerland has traditionally maintained a more isolationist stance, focusing on safeguarding its independence and neutrality.

Both countries have faced challenges and debates regarding their neutrality, especially in light of recent global conflicts. Austria's participation in EU and NATO initiatives has sparked discussions about the compatibility of its neutrality with international integration. Meanwhile, Switzerland's decision to impose sanctions on Russia following the invasion of Ukraine has prompted debates about the definition and limits of neutrality.

Austria's and Switzerland's military strengths

Austria and Switzerland are two Central European countries with different approaches to military strength and strategy. While Switzerland has mandatory military service for all able-bodied male citizens, Austria offers its citizens a choice between military and alternative civil or community service. Both countries are constitutionally non-aligned and are not members of NATO, but they participate in the alliance's Partnership for Peace programme.

Austria's Military Strength

Austria's military, known as the Bundesheer or "Federal Army", consists of 16,000 active-duty personnel and 125,600 reservists. The military budget is approximately 1.0% of the country's GDP, totalling €3.317 billion in 2023 (excluding pensions). The Austrian military's arsenal includes a mix of domestically produced and imported weapons systems, with recent purchases including Leopard 2 main battle tanks, Ulan and Pandur infantry fighting vehicles, C-130 Hercules transport planes, S-70 Black Hawk utility helicopters, and Eurofighter Typhoon multi-purpose combat aircraft. The air force, considered a constituent part of the army, operates with a squadron of 15 Eurofighter Typhoons and 28 Saab 105 trainers, among other aircraft.

Austria's military strategy has historically focused on protecting the country's neutrality and delaying or harassing potential invaders through determined resistance. The country's armed forces are organised into operational areas and zones, with a mix of active units, mobile militia, and stationary militia. The Jagdkommando, or "Hunting Command", is Austria's special operations group, trained for counter-terrorism and counter-insurgency missions.

Switzerland's Military Strength

Switzerland's military, officially known as the Swiss Armed Forces, consists of land and air service branches. The country maintains a militia system, with regular soldiers constituting a small part of the military, while the rest are conscripts or volunteers aged 19 to 34 (up to 50 in some cases). Switzerland's long-standing neutrality policy has kept its armed forces out of foreign wars since the early 19th century, but they do participate in international peacekeeping missions. The Swiss Armed Forces include approximately 120,000 active-duty personnel, with 9,000 professionals and the rest being conscripts or volunteers. Women, for whom military service is voluntary, make up less than 1% of the total.

Switzerland's military inventory includes a mix of domestically produced and imported weapons systems, with the United States as the leading supplier of military armaments. The air force has downsized in recent years, now consisting of approximately 270 fixed- and rotary-wing aircraft. The Swiss Armed Forces also maintain a maritime branch with a flotilla of military patrol boats for lakes that span the country's borders.

Switzerland's defence strategy focuses on homeland defence, with extensive underground fortifications and blast shelters built to accommodate its population. The country's mountainous terrain and small size pose challenges for defending its airspace, and its neutrality policy means that its aircraft are unlikely to be deployed outside of training exercises.

Austria's and Switzerland's history of conscription

Switzerland and Austria have a long history of conscription as part of their military policies. Both nations have a history of neutrality, with Switzerland maintaining a policy of military neutrality and Austria declaring itself constitutionally non-aligned.

Switzerland's History of Conscription

Switzerland's conscription policy can be traced back to the federal treaty of 1815, where the Tagsatzung or the assembly of delegates from the cantons, prescribed that each canton contribute a contingent of 2% of its population to the federal army, amounting to around 33,000 men. This was further formalized in the constitution of 1848, which converted the cantonal armies into a federal army and made it illegal for individual cantons to declare war or sign peace agreements.

The constitution of 1848 also included Paragraph 18, which declared the "obligation" of every Swiss male citizen to serve in the federal army if conscripted, setting the army size at 3% of the population, plus a reserve of one and a half that number, or about 80,000 men. In 1874, a revised constitution extended the definition of the federal army to include all able-bodied male citizens, which would have significantly increased the army's size. However, this was replaced by later revisions.

Today, Switzerland maintains a militia system, with regular soldiers making up a small part of the military and the rest being conscripts or volunteers aged 19 to 34 (up to 50 in some cases). Compulsory military service applies to all male Swiss citizens, while women can serve voluntarily. About two-thirds of young Swiss men are found suitable for service, and alternative service exists for those deemed unfit. Annually, approximately 20,000 individuals undergo basic training for 18 weeks, followed by seven 3-week intermittent recalls for training over the next 10 years.

Austria's History of Conscription

Austria also has a long history of conscription. In the early 1990s, about 45,000 conscripts completed their initial military training each year, and 80,000 reservists participated in exercises annually. Until 1971, Austrian males were obligated to serve nine months in the armed forces, followed by four days of active service every two years for training and inspection. In 1971, this period was reduced to six months of initial service and a total of 60 days of refresher training in the reserves.

In 2006, conscription was further reduced to a total of six months, and mandatory reserve training was abolished. Currently, the army reserve battalions are facing a lack of new reservists and are overaging. Under the constitution, the President of Austria is the commander-in-chief of the armed forces, but the Chancellor holds the decision-making authority and can delegate this to the Minister for National Defence.

Austria's armed forces consist of 16,000 active-duty personnel and 125,600 reservists. The main constitutional tasks of the Austrian military today include protecting the country's democratic institutions and freedoms, maintaining order and security within the country, and providing assistance in natural disasters.

Austria's and Switzerland's air forces

The Austrian Air Force is a component of the Austrian Armed Forces. It was created in May 1955 by the victorious Allied powers, subject to restrictions on its use of guided missiles. The Austrian State Treaty of 1955 also committed Austria to permanent neutrality. The Austrian Air Force's inventory includes a mix of domestically-produced and imported weapons systems from European countries and the USA.

The Austrian Air Force is divided into two brigade-level formations: the Air Surveillance Command in Salzburg, tasked with defending Austrian airspace, and the Air Support Command in Hörsching Air Base, which utilises helicopters and transport planes. The Air Surveillance Command includes two fighter squadrons, a radar battalion, an air defence battalion, and maintenance facilities. The Air Support Command consists of various helicopter and light transport squadrons, an air reconnaissance squadron, and a liaison helicopter squadron.

Austria's air defence consists of modernised Eurofighter jets, which are to be equipped with night vision, self-defence capabilities, and medium-range missiles. Additionally, Austria is considering the purchase of light jets with light armament. The Austrian Air Force also operates several types of helicopters, including the Agusta-Bell AB-204, AB-206, and AB-212, as well as the Bell OH-58 Kiowa scout helicopter.

The Swiss Air Force, established in July 1914, is the air component of the Swiss Armed Forces. It is responsible for military operations in Switzerland's airspace, including airspace protection, aerial transport, and intelligence gathering. Dübendorf serves as the operational headquarters during peacetime. The Swiss Air Force operates from fixed bases, but its personnel are trained to carry out air operations from temporary highway airstrips in times of crisis or war.

Switzerland's air defence consists of 30 McDonnell Douglas F/A-18 Hornets and 53 Northrop F-5 Tiger IIs. The F/A-18 pilots are career military, while the F-5 pilots are reservists, mostly air or freight liner pilots. In 2021, it was announced that Switzerland would replace its fleet of F/A-18 Hornets with 36 Lockheed F-35A fighter jets, along with the purchase of five MIM-104 Patriot SAM systems.

Switzerland's air force includes several operational centres, with the primary military command centre at Dübendorf Air Base, shared with civilian air traffic control. The locations of the other operational centres are classified. The Swiss Air Force also supports third-party organisations, providing equipment and staff. It provides radar data to the civilian radar Skyguide for safe air traffic management and conducts surveillance flights for the Border Guard Corps.

Austria's and Switzerland's military budgets

Austria and Switzerland are two Central European countries with differing approaches to their military budgets and defence policies. Switzerland has historically maintained a policy of military neutrality, only participating in EU, NATO, and Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe operations periodically. In contrast, Austria is constitutionally non-aligned but actively engages in EU peacekeeping and crisis management operations as an EU member.

Switzerland's defence budget has been a topic of recent discussion, with plans to significantly increase defence spending over the next few years. Defence Minister Viola Amherd has stated that three decades of cost-cutting measures have weakened the army, and global instability, including the Ukraine war, has heightened the need to strengthen their defence capabilities. The Swiss government intends to raise the defence budget ceiling to 25.8 billion Swiss francs (€27 billion) between 2025 and 2028, a substantial increase from the previous four-year period's budget of 21.7 billion francs. This additional funding will be allocated to various areas, including the development and upgrade of radar systems, short-range missile defence, tank fleet enhancements, and improved cyberattack defence capabilities.

On the other hand, Austria has a different approach to its military budget. While it is not a member of NATO, it has joined the alliance's Partnership for Peace framework. Austria's defence industry is active in producing and supplying a range of military equipment, partnering with other countries. However, specific details of Austria's defence budget and spending plans were not readily available in the sources provided.

Both countries have compulsory military service for males, with Switzerland requiring 19-26-year-old men to serve at least 260 days in the armed forces, including mandatory training and intermittent recalls for training over ten years. Austria also offers the option of alternative civil or community service instead of military service.

Frequently asked questions