Austria-Hungary's Russian Ambitions: A Historical Perspective

The relationship between Austria-Hungary and Russia has been complex and fraught with conflict, dating back to the Napoleonic Wars. Once allies, the two empires experienced a souring of relations in the lead-up to World War I, with Austria-Hungary's annexation of Bosnia and Herzegovina in 1908-09 being a significant turning point. This event, along with the Eastern Question regarding the weakening Ottoman Empire, created tensions that ultimately led to their involvement in the First World War. During the war, Austria-Hungary and Russia fought on the Eastern Front, with Russia rapidly mobilising its forces and contributing to significant losses for Austria-Hungary. The conflict between these two powers had cataclysmic results and played a crucial role in shaping the post-war world order.

Austria and Russia have had bilateral relations since 1955

Historically, the two countries were in an alliance for much of the 18th century, with their predecessor states having had contact since the 16th century. Their alliance was often directed against the Ottomans and France. They fought together during the War of the Polish Succession (1733-1738), the War of the Austrian Succession (1740-1748), and the Seven Years' War (1756-1763). They were also allies during the First Partition of Poland in 1772 and the Third Partition of Poland in 1795.

During the Revolutionary and Napoleonic Wars, Russia and Austria continued their alliance, fighting together during the War of the Second Coalition (1798-1801) and the War of the Third Coalition (1805-1807). However, after French victories, Austria was forced to join Napoleon's invasion of Russia in 1812.

Following the Congress of Vienna in 1815, the two countries generally cooperated to support the conservative order and prevent revolution. This continued into the 19th century, with Russia sending troops to help Austria defeat Hungary's bid for independence in 1849. However, during the Crimean War (1853-1856), Austria maintained a hostile neutrality towards Russia, supporting the Anglo-French coalition. This strained relations between the two countries.

In the late 19th and early 20th centuries, Austria and Russia's interests clashed in the Balkans, with both seeking to expand their influence in the region. This tension contributed to the assassination of Austrian Archduke Franz Ferdinand in 1914, which sparked World War I. During the war, both the Russian and Austro-Hungarian empires collapsed.

After World War I, the Republic of Austria and the Soviet Union did not have significant relations. Austria was absorbed into Hitler's Germany in 1938 and participated in the German invasion of the Soviet Union. After World War II, Austria was divided into four zones of occupation and Vienna was located in the Soviet zone.

In 1955, Austria regained its independence and neutrality, and diplomatic relations between the two countries resumed. Since then, Austria has maintained its neutrality while also seeking to develop close economic cooperation with Russia. Despite recent tensions due to Russia's invasion of Ukraine, Austria has continued to support efforts aimed at ending hostilities and achieving a political peace process.

There is a Russian community in Vienna, with 5,500 people of Russian origin living in Austria

Vienna, the historical capital city of Austria, is home to a Russian community that dates back to the 17th century. Over the centuries, Russians have travelled to Austria for various reasons, including business and education. Today, there are approximately 5,500 people of Russian origin living in Austria, with the majority residing in Vienna and Salzburg. The Russian Embassy School in Vienna caters to Russian families living in the city, and there is also a Russian cultural centre and an Austrian-Russian Chamber of Commerce.

The InterNations expat community in Vienna includes a vibrant circle of Russian expatriates, who organise regular social events and activities to connect with one another and integrate into their host country. These events include dinners in hip restaurants, outings to the Neusiedler See in the rural Burgenland district, and networking events.

Austria and Russia have had bilateral relations for centuries, and both countries are members of the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe and the World Trade Organization. Since World War II, Austria has maintained a neutral stance in global conflicts, including the Cold War and, more recently, the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine. Despite this neutrality, Austria has expelled several Russian diplomats in recent years, citing behaviour incompatible with their diplomatic status.

Hungary is highly dependent on energy sources imported from Russia

Hungary's dependence on energy sources imported from Russia is a complex issue with significant implications for the country's economy, politics, and relationships with its European allies. While Hungary has profited from its role as a trading hub for Russian gas, this reliance on Russian energy carries risks and contributes to tensions with Western allies.

Hungary has become a significant hub for Russian gas, even as many other European countries have reduced their dependence on Russian energy sources following Russia's invasion of Ukraine in 2022. Hungarian energy companies and the government have profited handsomely from this arrangement. In October 2024, Hungary's Foreign Minister, Peter Szijjarto, announced that the country would increase its annual gas imports from Russia by more than 2 billion cubic meters. This move surprised many, as it went against the EU's policies aimed at reducing Russian gas purchases.

The majority of the gas imported by Hungary comes from the south via the TurkStream pipeline, which runs under the Black Sea to Turkey and then through Bulgaria and Serbia. This pipeline became operational in 2020 as part of Russia's efforts to bypass Ukraine, which was previously the main transit route for Russian gas to Europe. Hungary's long-term gas contract with Gazprom, the Russian state-owned energy company, includes prices pegged to the Dutch TTF index, making it relatively expensive. However, the additional gas imports come with a significant discount of 13-15%.

Hungary's state-owned energy company and main gas importer, MVM Group, has benefited financially from the increased gas trade with Russia. While lower prices caused a decrease in revenue from gas sales, this was partially offset by the higher volume of gas sold. According to an anonymous source, the company is earning at least 500-600 million euros from the Russian gas trade.

Hungary's role as a gas hub in the region has given its government special leverage and importance over neighbouring countries. However, this dependence on Russian energy sources has also raised concerns among experts and insiders. They warn that the Hungarian government's focus on short-term economic gains could result in higher political costs in the long term, as defying Western allies may lead to tensions and isolation within Europe. Additionally, there are security risks associated with over-reliance on Russian energy, and the EU has expressed its desire to wean itself off Russian fossil fuels completely by 2027.

Hungary's refusal to quickly diversify its energy sources has caused friction with its European allies. In December 2024, Hungary was the only major EU country that did not expel Russian diplomats in response to the poisoning case in Salisbury. Furthermore, Hungary has threatened to block European sanctions against Russia if its energy interests are affected. This stance has created challenges for European unity in responding to Russian actions.

In summary, Hungary's high dependence on energy sources imported from Russia has resulted in economic gains for the country and provided it with leverage in the region. However, this reliance carries political and security risks, and it has contributed to tensions with Western allies. As Europe moves towards reducing its dependence on Russian energy, Hungary's position becomes more isolated, and the potential costs of its energy policies become more apparent.

The Hungarian People's Republic was the official state name of Hungary from 1949 to 1989 during its Communist period under Soviet control

The Hungarian People's Republic was the official state name of Hungary from 20 August 1949 until 23 October 1989, during its Communist period under Soviet control. It was a one-party socialist state, governed by the Hungarian Socialist Workers' Party, which was under the influence of the Soviet Union.

The creation of the Hungarian People's Republic was an agreed outcome of the 1944 Moscow Conference, where Winston Churchill and Joseph Stalin agreed that after the war, Hungary would be included in the Soviet sphere of influence. In the years following the conference, the Communists consolidated their power, weakening the other parties. This culminated in October 1947, when the Communists told their non-Communist coalition partners that they had to cooperate with a reconfigured coalition government if they wanted to stay in the country.

In the 1949 elections, voters were presented with a single Communist-dominated list of candidates from all parties. A newly elected legislature then adopted a Soviet-style constitution, and Hungary was officially renamed the "Hungarian People's Republic". The same political dynamics continued in the following years, with the Soviet Union influencing Hungarian politics through the Hungarian Communist Party and intervening through military coercion and covert operations when necessary.

Political repression and economic decline led to a nationwide popular uprising in October–November 1956, known as the Hungarian Revolution of 1956. After initially allowing the Revolution to run its course, the Soviet Union sent thousands of troops and tanks to crush the opposition and install a new Soviet-controlled government under János Kádár. This resulted in the deaths of thousands of Hungarians and the exile of hundreds of thousands more.

However, by the early 1960s, the Kádár government had considerably relaxed its policies, implementing a unique form of semi-liberal Communism known as "Goulash Communism". The state allowed the import of certain Western consumer and cultural products, gave Hungarians greater freedom to travel abroad, and significantly rolled back the secret police state. These measures earned Hungary the nickname "the merriest barrack in the socialist camp" during the 1960s and 1970s.

János Kádár, one of the longest-serving leaders of the 20th century, finally retired in 1988 after being forced from office by pro-reform forces amid an economic downturn. Hungary remained a one-party socialist state until the late 1980s, when turmoil broke out across the Eastern Bloc, culminating in the fall of the Berlin Wall and the dissolution of the Soviet Union. Despite the end of Communist control in Hungary, the 1949 constitution remained in effect with amendments to reflect the country's transition to liberal democracy. On 1 January 2012, the 1949 constitution was replaced with a new constitution.

The International Investment Bank in Budapest has been accused of being a front for Russian espionage

The International Investment Bank (IIB) in Budapest has been accused of being a front for Russian espionage. The bank, which was initially formed by the Soviet Union in 1970, has been described as "Putin's Trojan Horse" by critics, including the Hungarian opposition. The accusations are supported by the fact that the bank's former chief, Nikolai Kosov, has close ties with Russian intelligence agencies, and his parents were both allegedly spies for the KGB in the 20th century. Additionally, the Hungarian government has been criticized for providing privileges to the IIB, such as diplomatic immunity for its staff and exclusion from regulatory supervision in Hungary.

The accusations of espionage have been denied by the IIB, with chairman Nikolay Kosov stating that there are no spies among the bank's 110 employees. However, the suspicions have been further fueled by the Russian-friendly policies of the Hungarian government, led by Viktor Orbán, which has granted the IIB and its guests, business partners, and experts EU residence and full diplomatic immunity. This has led to concerns domestically and internationally, especially in the United States, where nine US senators described the bank as "widely seen as an arm of the Russian secret service" in 2019.

The IIB's relocation to Budapest, an EU member state, has been particularly controversial. The bank's presence in Hungary has been seen as a potential security risk for Europe, as Russian employees of the IIB enjoy diplomatic immunity and can move freely within the EU's Schengen Area. Additionally, there are concerns about the lack of transparency and regulatory oversight of the IIB. The bank is not subject to national banking regulations and enjoys immunities and privileges determined by the Agreement Establishing the IIB and corresponding agreements with its member states.

The accusations of espionage against the IIB have come at a time when Hungary's relations with its EU and NATO allies have been strained due to its perceived closeness to Russia. Hungary has been criticized for not taking a stronger stance against Russia in the wake of the Ukrainian invasion, and its decision to allow the IIB to establish its headquarters in Budapest has further harmed its reputation among Western allies.

In conclusion, the International Investment Bank in Budapest has been accused of being a front for Russian espionage due to its close ties to the Russian government and intelligence agencies, the diplomatic privileges granted to its staff, and the lack of transparency and regulatory oversight. These accusations have raised concerns about European security and strained Hungary's relations with its Western allies.

Frequently asked questions