The Dark Legacy Of War: Afghanistan's Heroin Epidemic

Afghanistan has been the world's leading producer of opium, which is used to make heroin, since the US invasion in 2001. Opium production in the country has increased from 185 tons to 9,000 tons, and the country now supplies more than 75% of the world's heroin. The drug trade has played a central role in shaping Afghanistan's destiny, with the country becoming the world's first true narco-state. The US has spent billions of dollars and deployed over 100,000 troops in its war in Afghanistan, but has been unable to control the country's heroin trade, which has fuelled the Taliban insurgency. The Taliban has profited massively from the drug trade, which makes up at least 60% of their income, and has used the profits to finance their growing insurgency. Efforts to curb opium production in Afghanistan have been largely ineffective, and the drug trade continues to be a major challenge for the country and the international community.

The Taliban's role in the heroin trade

The Taliban first emerged in Kandahar in 1994 and initially did not exploit the drug economy for financial gain. Their financial resources at this time came from external sponsors and the exploitation of the illicit traffic of legal goods under the Afghan Transit Trade Agreement. However, as they expanded their influence and sought to consolidate their power, they turned to the drug economy as a source of income and a way to provide livelihoods for the local population, which helped strengthen their political power.

The Taliban's approach to the drug trade has evolved over time. In the late 1990s, they issued bans on poppy cultivation, which had mixed results. While these bans may have contributed to a reduction in opium production in the short term, they also faced a popular backlash and were difficult to sustain. The Taliban rescinded the ban on poppy cultivation in 2001, and since then, they have generally adopted a more laissez-faire approach, taxing and providing security for the drug trade while also deriving income from it.

The United States and its allies have spent billions of dollars trying to disrupt the Taliban's profits from the drug trade through various measures, including poppy eradication, airstrikes, and raids on drug labs. However, these efforts have largely been unsuccessful and have even had counterproductive effects, such as increasing sympathy for the Taliban among farmers and laborers who depend on opium production for their livelihood.

As the Taliban regained control of Afghanistan in 2021, there were concerns that the drug trade would continue to flourish and provide a significant source of income for the group. Experts predicted that the Taliban was unlikely to prohibit poppy cultivation and risk alienating their rural supporters. The economic and humanitarian crisis in the country, along with the dependence of many Afghans on the drug trade for survival, further complicated counter-narcotics efforts.

The US's failure to address the heroin trade

Background

Afghanistan has a long history of opium production, dating back to the 1970s. During the Cold War, the US first intervened in Afghanistan, backing Muslim militants fighting to expel the Soviet Red Army. The CIA provided these guerrillas with an estimated $3 billion in arms, and during this time, Afghanistan's opium production grew from about 100 tonnes annually to 2,000 tonnes by 1991.

US Intervention and the Rise of the Taliban

In 2001, the Taliban banned poppy cultivation, reducing opium production by 97%. However, after the US invasion, opium production surged, reaching 9,000 tonnes in 2017. Afghanistan now supplies more than 75% of the world's heroin, and the profits from the drug trade are a significant source of income for the Taliban, estimated at up to 60%.

Failed Counter-Narcotics Efforts

The US has spent billions of dollars on counter-narcotics efforts in Afghanistan, but these attempts have largely failed. Initial strategies included eradication and bans on opium poppy cultivation, which were often borne by the poorest communities and generated political capital for the Taliban. Later, the focus shifted to interdiction, targeting top-level narco-terrorists. However, these efforts did not significantly weaken the Taliban's finances or reduce opium production.

Political and Strategic Challenges

The failure to address the heroin trade in Afghanistan is due to a combination of political, strategic, and economic factors. Politically, there has been a lack of coordination and disagreement between different US government agencies, with no clear strategy or leadership. Strategically, the US military's primary focus has been on fighting terrorists, and there has been reluctance to take actions that could alienate poppy farmers or US-friendly warlords who profit from opium trafficking. Economically, alternative livelihood efforts have often been poorly designed and ineffective, and the illicit drug economy remains deeply entrenched, providing vital income for many Afghans.

Way Forward

Experts agree that counternarcotics policies in Afghanistan should be well-planned and sequenced, taking into account the complex political, economic, and security dynamics. Eradication of drug crops should be suspended until peace is achieved and stable governance is in place. Selective interdiction efforts targeting the most dangerous actors, such as international terrorist groups, may be considered, but the prospects for significantly weakening the Taliban or reducing the drug trade are poor. Improving access to treatment and prevention for Afghans suffering from opioid use disorder should be a priority.

The CIA's involvement in the heroin trade

The CIA has been accused of involvement in the trafficking of illicit drugs, including in Afghanistan. While investigations by the United States government have generally not led to clear conclusions that the CIA itself has directly conducted drug trafficking operations, there may have been instances of indirect complicity in the activities of others.

In the 1980s, the CIA's secret war against the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan helped transform the Afghani-Pakistani borderlands into a launchpad for the global heroin trade. The CIA looked the other way while Afghanistan’s opium production grew from about 100 tonnes annually in the 1970s to 2,000 tonnes by 1991. In 1979 and 1980, a network of heroin laboratories opened along the Afghan-Pakistan frontier, soon becoming the world’s largest heroin producer.

During the 1980s, the CIA’s secret war against the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan helped transform the region into a launchpad for the global heroin trade. The CIA relied on Pakistan’s powerful Inter-Services Intelligence agency (ISI) and its Afghan clients, who soon became key players in the burgeoning cross-border opium traffic.

The CIA has been accused of forming alliances of convenience with drug traffickers around the world in the name of anti-communism. In Afghanistan, the CIA worked through Pakistan's ISI, backing Afghan warlords who used the Agency's arms, logistics, and protection to become major drug lords.

In 2006, the US Ambassador in Kabul, the CIA station chief, and MI6/SIS's station chief met with Afghan President Hamid Karzai to address allegations regarding his brother, Ahmed's involvement in the drug trade. Karzai demanded clear evidence of his brother's involvement be presented—evidence which the US and the UK were either unwilling or unable to provide.

In 2009, it was reported that Ahmed Wali Karzai had received regular payments from the CIA for eight years and was involved in the trafficking of opium in Afghanistan. A CIA spokesman said: "No intelligence organization worth the name would ever entertain these kinds of allegations."

The impact of the heroin trade on the Taliban's resurgence

The Taliban's resurgence in Afghanistan has been greatly influenced by the heroin trade. The Taliban has been profiting from the drug trade, with the country now producing about 85% of the world's opium. The Taliban's income from the heroin trade is estimated to be in the billions, with the trade providing a reliable source of livelihood for a large segment of the population. The Taliban has been able to exploit the drug trade to gain political capital, as they provide protection to farmers and drug traffickers. The trade has also allowed the Taliban to gain control of border towns, which has given them greater control over international trade and taxation. The heroin trade has also contributed to the Taliban's ability to recruit new fighters, as they are able to offer monthly payments that far exceed agricultural wages.

The heroin trade has also had a destabilising effect on Afghanistan, with the country becoming a narco-state. The trade has led to increased insecurity, corruption, and macroeconomic distortions. The drug trade has also contributed to a growing drug problem within Afghanistan, with an estimated 1.6 million drug users in the country. The heroin trade has also had a negative impact on the environment, with poppy cultivation leading to deforestation and water depletion.

The international community's attempts to address the heroin trade

• Eradication and bans on opium poppy cultivation: These measures were often enforced on the poorest and most marginalized communities, generating political capital for the Taliban and undermining counterinsurgency efforts. While temporary decreases in poppy cultivation were achieved, they were not sustained due to the lack of economic alternatives for farmers.
• Selective interdiction: Efforts led by the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) and the U.S. military targeted Taliban-linked traffickers but failed to significantly weaken the Taliban's finances or reduce the size of the Afghan drug economy.
• Alternative livelihood efforts: These initiatives aimed to provide sustainable income alternatives to poppy-dependent populations, but they were often poorly designed and ineffective. The intensification of civil war and the Taliban's strength have further hampered these efforts.
• Aerial interdiction and airstrikes: The U.S. conducted airstrikes on suspected heroin labs and other targets, but these efforts did not substantially reduce the drug trade and may have contributed to civilian casualties.
• Drug treatment and prevention: Demand reduction measures, such as treatment and prevention programs, have been grossly neglected and underfunded. The limited efforts in this area have had little impact on the overall drug problem in Afghanistan.

Despite these efforts, Afghanistan remains the world's largest illicit opiate supplier, and the drug trade continues to fuel instability and insurgency in the country. The Taliban benefits financially from the drug trade and is deeply involved in all aspects of the narcotics business. The failure to effectively address the heroin trade has contributed to the ongoing war and instability in Afghanistan.

Frequently asked questions