Shadow Soldiers: Unveiling Afghanistan's Hidden Mercenary Forces

The use of mercenaries in Afghanistan has been a controversial aspect of the US military's involvement in the country. In 2021, the Pentagon reported that there were over 18,000 contractors in Afghanistan, with only 2,500 US troops remaining in the country. This ratio of contractors to troops is much higher than in previous years, and it has raised concerns about the US military's over-reliance on private contractors. These contractors are often referred to as private military contractors or security contractors, and they provide a range of services including logistics, maintenance, base support, and security. The use of these contractors has been criticised as ineffective and detrimental to US interests, with some arguing that it undermines the US military's traditions and puts troops at greater risk.

The US withdrawal from Afghanistan

The US State Department's report on the withdrawal detailed several shortcomings and detrimental consequences. It found that there was insufficient consideration of worst-case scenarios and that crisis preparation was hindered by concerns about sending signals of a lack of confidence in the Afghan government. The report also noted that senior administration officials had not made clear decisions regarding the evacuation of at-risk Afghans, adding to the challenges faced.

The withdrawal was characterized by a rapid reduction in the number of private military contractors operating in Afghanistan. This was a departure from previous administrations, which relied on contractors to stabilize the security vacuum left by departing US troops. The number of contractors dropped by more than half in the months leading up to the withdrawal, falling from almost 17,000 in April to 7,800 by July. This included a significant decrease in security contractors, with fewer than 1,400 remaining by July.

The withdrawal of US troops and contractors had a significant impact on the Afghan government and security forces. The Afghan government struggled to transition from an insurgency to governing, and the economy collapsed under the weight of sanctions and the loss of foreign aid. The Taliban's resurgence and the fall of Kabul took many by surprise, and the US government was criticized for failing to anticipate this outcome.

The evacuation process was chaotic, with thousands of Afghans who had worked with US forces left behind. The US military completed its withdrawal on August 30, 2021, but thousands of Afghans who assisted the US and its allies, as well as some American citizens, remained in the country. The Biden administration pledged to continue working to get them out.

The aftermath of the US withdrawal from Afghanistan has been marked by a humanitarian crisis, with half of the population facing food insecurity. There are also concerns about the Taliban providing safe havens for terrorist groups, such as al-Qaeda. The collapse of the Afghan economy and the humanitarian crisis have led to calls for more creative policies to help alleviate the suffering of the Afghan people without aiding the Taliban regime.

The use of private military contractors

In Afghanistan, PMCs have been used to provide a range of services, including training and supplementing official armed forces, providing security for companies and government affiliates, and performing logistical and maintenance tasks. The number of private military contractors in Afghanistan has fluctuated over the years, depending on the needs of the military and the political climate.

During the Trump administration, the employment of private security contractors in Afghanistan soared to nearly 6,000. However, under the Biden administration, there has been a push for a full withdrawal of military support, including private military contractors. As of July 2021, the total number of contractors in Afghanistan had dropped to 7,800, with fewer than 2,700 Americans among them. This reduction in contractors has left local Afghan forces without the on-the-ground military support they once relied on.

On the other hand, supporters of PMCs argue that they provide essential services and advantages on the battlefield, including more flexible personnel systems. They also fill gaps left by military personnel, who are often expensive and challenging to recruit. In Afghanistan, contractors have worked closely with the military, providing support and performing critical tasks.

As the U.S. continues to withdraw its presence in Afghanistan, the role and impact of private military contractors will continue to be a subject of debate and scrutiny.

The number of contractors in Afghanistan

2024

According to a report from March 2024, the U.S. had more than 18,000 contractors in Afghanistan, while the number of troops was approximately 2,500. This means that there were more than seven contractors for every service member, indicating a heavy reliance on contracted support. The majority of these contractors were not U.S. citizens, with about a third being Americans, and the rest coming from countries like Uganda and Nepal.

2021

In July 2021, news sources reported a significant drop in the number of contractors in Afghanistan. The total number of all kinds of contractors had decreased by more than half in the previous three months, going from almost 17,000 in April to 7,800 in July, with fewer than 2,700 Americans among them. This reduction was attributed to the Biden administration's withdrawal of military support and a shift away from the practice of deploying contractors to war zones, as done by previous administrations.

2020

In the fourth quarter of 2020, the U.S. Department of Defense reported having 27,388 private personnel working across Afghanistan, Iraq, and Syria. This included both contractors performing various non-combat roles and mercenaries engaging in actual combat operations.

2019

In April 2019, there was a notable increase in the number of security contractors in Afghanistan, with more than 5,800 privately employed security personnel operating under Pentagon contracts. This spike represented a more than 20% increase in just three months and raised concerns about the government concealing the situation on the ground.

2017-2018

During the Trump administration, the use of private security contractors in Afghanistan increased significantly. By 2017, the number of security contractors had reached around 6,000, and in 2018, the Pentagon was said to be considering a surge of "26,000 to 56,000" contractors to accompany the deployment of additional U.S. troops.

The role of contractors in the US withdrawal

The US withdrawal from Afghanistan has been described as a scramble to exit the country, with little to no clear plan in place for how the US will continue to support its local allies. This is especially concerning given the Taliban's growing onslaught in the country.

The withdrawal includes the removal of thousands of private contractors—who provide support to the Afghan Air Force, among other tasks. The Afghan military is heavily reliant on these contractors for repairs, maintenance, fueling, training, and other jobs necessary to keep their forces operating.

The Pentagon has spent $107.9 billion on contracted services in Afghanistan since 2002. At the height of the war, there were 3,300 US troops and 40,000 civilian contractors in the country. In 2021, the US Department of Defense employed more than 16,000 contractors in Afghanistan, of whom 6,147 were US citizens—more than double the number of remaining US troops.

The number of contractors has since decreased. In April 2021, there were almost 17,000 contractors in Afghanistan, which dropped to 7,800 in July of the same year. This reduction in contractors is indicative of the US's full withdrawal of military support and its departure from its previous approach of deploying contractors to war zones to help stabilize the security vacuum left by departing troops.

The departure of contractors poses myriad problems for the Afghan military, which relies heavily on them to function. The Afghan Air Force, in particular, is dependent on contractors for maintenance and repairs. The Afghan National Army and the Afghan National Police have also struggled to complete their own maintenance work orders, falling well below their target goals.

The removal of contractors also has financial implications for the Pentagon, which could face costly litigation or settlements from contractors due to the early termination of contracts. Some contracts had completion dates as far out as 2026.

The US withdrawal from Afghanistan has left a void that leaders on both sides say could be crippling to Afghan forces as they face the Taliban alone.

The impact of contractors on the US military

The US military's reliance on private contractors to fight its wars has been described as a strategic vulnerability. Contractors are considered indispensable, and they can sometimes be used to circumvent policy restrictions on military deployments. They are also used to obscure the true number of US personnel on the ground, allowing policymakers to wage war outside of the public eye.

The Benefits of Contractors

Private military contractors are seen as having inherent advantages over militaries in resource constraints, manpower, and flexibility. They can be used to substitute for US military forces, minimising the military footprint in the operational area, reducing force operational tempo, and improving domestic US political support or buy-in.

The Risks of Contractors

The use of contractors comes with a number of risks. Firstly, there is the potential for shortfalls in mission success, as well as concerns over the safety of contractors. There is also the risk of losing resources because a capability is outsourced, loss of total force management, and problems of compliance with administrative law.

The use of contractors may also result in a loss of accountability and increased waste, fraud, and abuse. The US Department of Defense has acknowledged that the procurement of supplies and services in support of military operations can be prone to fraud, waste, and abuse, especially in foreign contingencies where there are many contracts with local firms.

Impact on the US Military

On the other hand, the use of contractors can lead to an unhealthy over-reliance on private companies, overwhelming the US government's ability to effectively oversee or manage them. This can result in waste, fraud, and abuse, as well as a lack of accountability for abuses perpetrated by contractors.

Additionally, the use of contractors can obscure the true number of US personnel on the ground and the true cost of war, both in human and economic terms. This can make it difficult for the public to understand the human cost of America's long-term deployments and can lead to a lack of public scrutiny of military operations.

In conclusion, the impact of contractors on the US military is multifaceted. While contractors can provide valuable support and flexibility, their use also comes with a number of risks and can lead to a lack of accountability and oversight. As the US continues to rely on private contractors to support its military operations, it is important to carefully assess the risks and benefits of their use and to ensure effective oversight and transparency in the contracting process.

Frequently asked questions