Border Tensions: Afghanistan And Pakistan's History Of Clashes

The Afghanistan-Pakistan border has been the site of numerous clashes and skirmishes since 1949. The border, known as the Durand Line, was established in 1893 between the British Empire and Afghanistan but has never been recognised by any Afghan government. Afghanistan has long advocated for the independence of its northwest frontier, which was historically a part of Afghanistan but is now part of Pakistan. The Durand Line has been a source of tension between the two countries, with Afghanistan refusing to accept it as the international border and occasionally attempting to seize Pakistan's western provinces. The border region is also a haven for terrorist groups such as the Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan, which has carried out attacks on both sides of the border. In recent years, there have been efforts by Pakistan to erect fencing along the border to control the movement of goods and people, which has been met with resistance from the Taliban administration. Clashes between Afghan and Pakistani security forces have resulted in casualties on both sides, with each side blaming the other for initiating the conflict. These border clashes continue to strain the bilateral ties between Afghanistan and Pakistan.

Border clashes have occurred since 1949, with the latest hostilities beginning in April 2007

Border clashes between Afghanistan and Pakistan have occurred since 1949, with the latest hostilities beginning in April 2007. The conflict can be traced back to the Durand Line Agreement of 1893, which established the international border between the Emirate of Afghanistan and the British Indian Empire. The agreement was inherited by Pakistan upon its independence in 1947, but Afghanistan has never recognised the Durand Line as its international border.

The refusal to recognise the Durand Line stems from Afghanistan's desire to claim the Pashtun territories in Pakistan, which comprise the Federally Administered Tribal Areas (FATA) and parts of Khyber Pakhtunkhwa province. The Pashtun people, who live on both sides of the border, have historically advocated for a united Afghanistan, and some Pashtun nationalists continue to demand an independent state of Pashtunistan. This dispute has fuelled tensions between the two countries, with Afghanistan accusing Pakistan of supporting Islamist militias among the Pashtun to counter Baloch and Pashtun nationalism within its borders.

In 1949, the Pakistan Air Force bombed Afghan-sponsored militant camps in border areas, leading to the first reported border clashes between the two countries in 1949-1950. Since then, there have been numerous skirmishes and military confrontations, with both sides accusing each other of initiating the violence. These clashes have resulted in casualties on both sides, including civilian deaths.

In recent years, Afghanistan's Taliban government has attempted to block Pakistan's plans to erect fencing along their shared border, with Taliban forces intervening to dismantle the fence on multiple occasions. The Taliban's repudiation of Pakistan's position on the Durand Line has challenged a pillar of Pakistan's security policy and strained their bilateral relationship.

The border region remains a site of major conflict, housing some of the world's most dangerous militants. The porous border has facilitated the cross-border movement of goods, people, and militants, contributing to instability in the region. Both countries have attempted to increase border security and control the movement of insurgents, but the frequent clashes continue to pose a challenge to their relations.

Afghanistan has never recognised the Durand Line as an international border

The Durand Line is a 2,640-kilometre (1,640-mile) border between Afghanistan and Pakistan, established in 1893 as the border between British India and the Emirate of Afghanistan. The Durand Line was the result of an agreement between Sir Mortimer Durand, a secretary of the British Indian government, and Abdur Rahman Khan, the emir, or ruler, of Afghanistan.

The Durand Line was established without any consideration of the ethnicity, language, values and desires of the tribal population. The British Empire technically contributed to the present-day hostilities and skirmishes between the two countries. The Durand Line has been described as one of the most dangerous borders in the world.

The Durand Line has been a source of tension between the governments of Pakistan and Afghanistan. In 2017, Pakistan began constructing a fence along the border, which has physically split communities and led to increased hostilities. Afghanistan continues to seek the return of Pashtun territories, as well as Balochistan, which would provide it with access to the Arabian Sea.

Pakistan's fencing project has restricted civilian movement to declared border crossings

Pakistan's fencing project along the Durand Line, the border between Afghanistan and Pakistan, has been a source of tension between the two countries. The fencing project aims to improve border security and prevent cross-border militant attacks, arms, and drug smuggling. While Pakistan claims that the fencing will curb illegal activities and improve security in the region, critics argue that it will disrupt the lives of civilians living in the area, particularly those with relatives on both sides of the border.

The fencing project has restricted civilian movement across the border, limiting travel to designated crossing points. Previously, families and traders could move freely between the two countries, but now they need passports, visas, and customs clearances, which has made crossing the border a lengthy and costly process. This has negatively impacted businesses and separated families, as people can no longer easily visit their relatives on the other side of the border.

The fencing project has also triggered condemnation from Afghanistan, which disputes the Durand Line as the legitimate border between the two countries. Afghanistan claims sovereignty over the Pashtun territories on the Pakistani side of the border and argues that the agreement establishing the Durand Line had a 100-year time limit that expired in 1993. Pakistan, however, maintains that the Durand Line is the legal and final international border between the two countries.

The fencing project has also led to deadly clashes between Afghan and Pakistani forces along the border, with both sides accusing each other of initiating the conflict. The fencing has also been targeted by militants, who have released videos of themselves tearing down sections of the fence and seizing construction supplies. Despite these challenges, Pakistan's military has stated that the fencing project is almost complete, with only 10% remaining as of early 2024.

Border clashes have disrupted trade and supply chains

Border clashes between Afghanistan and Pakistan have disrupted trade and supply chains, causing economic losses for both countries. The Torkham border crossing, the main transit point for travellers and goods between the two countries, has been closed multiple times due to clashes, resulting in a backlog of trucks carrying goods. In March 2024, Pakistan launched airstrikes targeting militant hideouts in Afghanistan, which led to the death of civilians, according to the Taliban-led Afghan government. This prompted the Afghan army to target Pakistani troops at the border, leading to the death of a Pakistani officer and injuries to several soldiers and civilians.

The conflict between the two countries has deep roots in their shared history. Afghanistan has never recognised the Durand Line, the international border between the two countries, and has attempted to claim the Pashtun territories in Pakistan. Pakistan, on the other hand, has tried to exert control over the border region through fencing and military operations, which has led to clashes with the Afghan Taliban forces. The fencing project has been a central part of Pakistan's security policy, aiming to control the movement of goods and people across the border. However, the Taliban's repudiation of this project has created tensions and challenged a key aspect of Pakistan's security strategy.

The economic impact of the border clashes is significant. Hundreds of trucks carrying goods have been stranded on both sides of the border during closures, causing losses for traders. The entire flow of trade has been affected, including the loading of goods in ports such as Karachi. The disruptions to supply chains have had a ripple effect on businesses and consumers in both countries, highlighting the interdependence of Afghanistan and Pakistan's economies.

The border clashes have also had a human toll, with casualties reported on both sides, including civilian deaths. The conflict has forced people to flee their homes and seek refuge in safer areas, contributing to the region's instability. The involvement of officials from both countries has been crucial in reducing tensions after such incidents, but the underlying causes of the conflict remain unresolved.

The complex dynamics between Afghanistan and Pakistan, shaped by historical, ethnic, and geopolitical factors, continue to influence their relationship. The border clashes have disrupted trade and supply chains, causing economic and human losses. The recent incidents highlight the ongoing tensions and the need for a long-term resolution to the border dispute, which has plagued the region for decades.

Both sides blame each other for initiating conflict

Border clashes between Afghanistan and Pakistan have been ongoing since 1949. The conflict is rooted in territorial disputes, with Afghanistan refusing to recognise the Durand Line Agreement that demarcates the border between the two countries. Afghanistan has also laid claim to Pakistani territory, which it argues is part of the traditional homeland of "Pashtunistan" for the Pashtun people.

In recent years, the conflict has been exacerbated by the presence of terrorist groups operating along the border, such as Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan and Jamaat-ul-Ahrar. These groups have carried out attacks on both sides of the border, leading to retaliatory strikes by Pakistani and Afghan security forces.

Both sides blame each other for initiating the conflict. Afghan officials have accused Pakistan of shelling Afghan villages and targeting civilians. They argue that Pakistan is attempting to exert control over disputed territories and crack down on Pashtun nationalist movements. On the other hand, Pakistani officials claim that Afghan forces have fired on Pakistani border posts and provided support to terrorist groups operating in the region.

The conflict has resulted in numerous casualties on both sides and has led to a breakdown in diplomatic relations between the two countries. Efforts to resolve the dispute through diplomacy have been unsuccessful, and the situation remains tense.

Frequently asked questions