The Geography Gap: Locating Afghanistan On A Map Challenges Americans

Geographic literacy is a significant concern in the United States, with many Americans struggling to locate countries on a map, including Afghanistan. A 2002 National Geographic-Roper survey found that only 17% of young Americans could identify Afghanistan on a map, despite the country being frequently in the news. This issue is not unique to the US, as similar surveys have shown that young people in other countries also lack basic geographic knowledge. However, the low geographic literacy rates among Americans have raised concerns about their understanding of global issues and their ability to navigate an increasingly interconnected world.

Young Americans' geographical knowledge

Despite being labelled the world's superpower, the United States has seen its young citizens struggle with geographical knowledge. In a 2002 National Geographic-Roper survey, only 17% of young Americans could find Afghanistan on a map, with 83% of those surveyed unable to locate the country. This is despite the US being involved in a war in Afghanistan at the time.

Poor Performance

The survey, which polled over 3,000 18- to 24-year-olds in nine countries, ranked the US second to last, with Sweden coming out on top and Mexico last. Young Americans also struggled to locate other countries, with only 15% able to find Iraq and less than 25% able to identify Israel.

Lack of Awareness

National Geographic Society President John Fahey expressed concern over the findings, questioning how young Americans can understand global issues if they lack basic geographical knowledge. The survey also revealed that a third of young Americans greatly overestimated the US population, with one in three believing it to be between one and two billion, when the actual figure is around 289 million.

Education and Travel

The survey highlighted the lack of emphasis on geography in US schools, with geography often not included in the curriculum. However, there has been an increase in the number of young Americans taking geography courses, which has led to improved performance. Additionally, factors such as international travel and language proficiency have been found to enhance geographical knowledge.

Global Perspective

While young Americans' geographical literacy may be lacking, they are not alone. The survey showed that young adults worldwide also struggle with geographical knowledge. On average, less than 25% could locate Israel, and only about 20% could identify countries like Afghanistan, Iran, and Iraq.

National Geographic surveys

Another National Geographic survey from 2006, the National Geographic-Roper Public Affairs 2006 Geographic Literacy Study, found similar results. This study surveyed 510 young Americans, and 88% of respondents could not find Afghanistan on a map of Asia. This was despite widespread media coverage of the U.S.-led overthrow of the Taliban in Afghanistan in 2001. The study also revealed that 63% could not find Iraq or Saudi Arabia on a map of the Middle East, and 75% could not locate Iran or Israel.

These surveys highlight a concerning trend among young Americans, with the 2006 study suggesting that "young people in the United States ... are unprepared for an increasingly global future." The inability to locate countries on a map can indicate a lack of awareness about current events and cultural, economic, and natural resource issues worldwide.

However, it is important to note that geographic literacy is not just an issue in the United States. The 2002 National Geographic survey found that young adults worldwide struggled with geographic knowledge. On average, less than 25% of young people across the surveyed countries could locate Israel on a map, and only about 20% could identify countries like Afghanistan, Iran, and Iraq.

To address this geographic illiteracy, organizations like the National Geographic Society have taken initiatives to improve geographic education and awareness among young people. These efforts aim to provide parents, educators, and policymakers with the tools and resources necessary to combat geographic ignorance and foster a more globally conscious generation.

The US education system

Primary and Secondary Education

US children typically start primary or elementary education around the age of six. This level of schooling lasts for five or six years and forms the foundation of their academic journey. Middle school or junior high school follows, spanning two to three years, and marks a transitional phase with a more specialised curriculum. Students then progress to high school, which covers grades 9 to 12 and is a critical phase that culminates in a high school diploma.

Post-Secondary Education

After completing secondary education, students have the option to pursue post-secondary education, which encompasses a diverse array of institutions and programs. This level typically includes undergraduate and graduate studies, with the former lasting four years and resulting in a bachelor's degree. Graduate studies lead to master's or doctoral degrees and can span one to several years, depending on the field of study.

Institution Types

The US higher education system offers a wide range of institution types, each with its unique characteristics:

• State Colleges and Universities: These are public institutions funded and managed by state governments. They offer a more affordable option for students and often have a broad range of degree programs. State colleges also provide vibrant campus life, extracurricular activities, and modern teaching facilities.
• Private Colleges and Universities: Private colleges are privately funded and managed, and they usually have higher tuition fees. They tend to be smaller in size and may have religious affiliations. Private colleges offer more intimate class sizes, fostering closer relationships between students and faculty.
• Community Colleges: Community colleges provide two-year associate degree programs that can serve as a stepping stone to a four-year bachelor's degree or prepare students for immediate employment. They offer affordable tuition, flexible education, and a range of academic and vocational programs.
• Institutes of Technology: These institutions focus on science, technology, engineering, and applied sciences. They offer bachelor's degrees and sometimes graduate programs, along with short-term courses.

Curriculum and Classroom Environment

The US curriculum varies across states and institutions but generally aims to provide a well-rounded education. In addition to core subjects, students are exposed to extracurricular activities, sports, and clubs that foster personal growth and career exploration.

The classroom environment in US higher education is dynamic and encourages active participation. Students are expected to share their opinions, engage in discussions, and give presentations. Professors utilise a range of teaching methods, including lectures, seminars, laboratory work, and assignments.

Grading System

The US grading system can be confusing, especially for international students. It typically follows a four-point scale, with letter grades assigned based on percentages. For example, an 'A' grade represents excellent performance, while an 'F' indicates failure.

Accreditation

Accreditation plays a crucial role in the US education system, ensuring that institutions meet minimum quality standards. Various independent accrediting bodies operate at the national or regional level to evaluate and certify schools, colleges, and universities.

Challenges and Criticisms

While the US education system offers flexibility and diversity, it also faces challenges. These include funding disparities, unequal access to quality education, and the impact of socioeconomic factors on student achievement. Additionally, the system has been criticised for its emphasis on standardised testing and its failure to adequately support teachers.

The impact of entertainment alternatives

The National Geographic Society's president, John Fahey, expressed concern about the impact of entertainment alternatives on young Americans' geographical knowledge. In a survey, he noted that young people are ''highly skilled at tuning out'' information they feel is unnecessary, including knowledge about the world they live in. This generation has grown up in the Information Age, bombarded with information and entertainment options. As a result, they may prioritize entertainment over learning about geography and current events.

The survey revealed that only 17% of young Americans could locate Afghanistan on a map, despite the country being in the news due to the US-led overthrow of the Taliban. This lack of geographic literacy is not an isolated issue. Young Americans also struggled to identify other countries in the news, such as Iraq and Israel.

Entertainment alternatives may contribute to this knowledge gap by providing distractions and competing for attention. With so many entertainment options available, young people may spend more time engaging with entertainment media than learning about the world. This can lead to a lack of interest in geography and current events, affecting their ability to understand global issues and make informed political choices.

However, it is important to note that the issue is not solely due to entertainment alternatives. The survey also highlighted the role of education and cultural factors. Geography is often not prioritized in the US curriculum, and it is sometimes taught as part of social studies rather than as a separate subject. This can dilute the focus on geography, and students may not receive sufficient instruction in this area. Additionally, factors such as international travel and language skills can influence geographic literacy, and these factors vary across countries.

To address the impact of entertainment alternatives and improve geographic knowledge, a multi-faceted approach is needed. This includes enhancing geography education in schools, promoting the importance of geographic literacy, and encouraging engagement with current events and the world beyond entertainment. By doing so, young Americans can develop a better understanding of their place in the world and make more informed decisions.

The link between geographical knowledge and opinions on airstrikes

It is a well-known fact that geographical knowledge is often lacking among Americans, with many unable to locate countries on a map, including Afghanistan. This lack of geographic literacy has raised concerns, especially in light of the United States' involvement in military conflicts around the world. One aspect that has received less attention is the potential link between geographical knowledge and opinions on airstrikes. This article will explore this connection, examining the impact of geographic literacy on public support for airstrikes and the role of media and education in shaping geographic knowledge.

Geographic Literacy and Public Opinion on Airstrikes

Several studies have found a positive correlation between a lack of geographic knowledge and support for military interventions. For example, in a survey conducted by Morning Consult, only 23% of American voters could correctly identify Iran on a world map. Interestingly, those who could not locate Iran were more likely to favor airstrikes or the deployment of US troops to the region. This trend was also observed in similar surveys regarding North Korea and Ukraine. The link between geographic literacy and opinions on airstrikes suggests that individuals who lack basic geographic knowledge may be more susceptible to supporting military actions without fully understanding the cultural, economic, and humanitarian implications.

The Role of Media and Education

The media plays a significant role in shaping public opinion and geographic knowledge. In the case of Iran, the coverage of the drone strike ordered by President Trump received widespread attention, yet many Americans still struggled to locate the country on a map. This disconnect highlights the need for media outlets to provide contextual information and encourage geographic literacy among their audiences. Additionally, educational institutions play a crucial role in promoting geographic literacy. However, geography is often overlooked or taught superficially in schools, contributing to the lack of geographic knowledge among young Americans.

The Impact of Geographic Literacy on Policy Decisions

Geographic literacy not only influences public opinion but also has implications for policy decisions. Policymakers rely on public support when considering military interventions, and a lack of geographic knowledge can lead to misguided decisions. For example, in the lead-up to the Iraq War, nearly two-thirds of Americans aged 18 to 24 could not find Iraq on a map, yet the United States proceeded with the invasion. This disconnect between geographic literacy and policy decisions underscores the importance of ensuring that policymakers and the public have a basic understanding of geography to make informed choices.

Frequently asked questions