The Poppy Problem: Afghanistan's Historical Relationship With Opium

Afghanistan has long been the world's largest producer of opium, with the country's poppy fields supplying around 90% of the world's opium. Opium cultivation has been an epidemic in Afghanistan for decades, with production steadily rising since the fall of the Taliban in 2002. Despite the Taliban's public opposition to opium production on religious grounds, the group has profited from the trade, reportedly imposing taxes on poppy farmers to fund their operations. While the US and coalition forces have spent billions of dollars trying to eradicate poppy cultivation in Afghanistan, these efforts have largely been unsuccessful, with production continuing to rise.

Opium poppy cultivation in Afghanistan has been declining

The decline in poppy cultivation can be attributed to various factors, including the saturation of global and local drug markets, poppy crop disease, drought, and temporary coercive measures in certain parts of Afghanistan. The Taliban's ban on poppy cultivation in 2000 also contributed to the reduction, but it was not sustainable, and cultivation resumed by 2001.

Despite the decline in poppy cultivation, opium production in Afghanistan remains a significant issue. Afghanistan is the world's largest producer of opium, and the drug trade has been a source of income for various groups, including the Taliban, criminal gangs, and government officials. The profits from the opium trade have fueled instability and corruption in the country, undermining rule of law and good governance.

Eradication and counter-narcotics policies have had limited success and often come with counterproductive effects. Efforts to eradicate poppy fields have faced strong resistance from farmers, who depend on the crop for their livelihood, and have driven economic refugees into the hands of the Taliban. Alternative livelihood programs have also fallen short, failing to provide sustainable and attractive alternatives for farmers.

The complex dynamics between poverty, instability, and drug production in Afghanistan present a significant challenge for addressing the country's opium problem. Breaking the cycle of illicit opium production and establishing security and good governance will require a comprehensive approach that addresses the root causes and provides viable alternatives for those involved in the drug trade.

The Taliban banned poppy cultivation in April 2022

Afghanistan has long been the world's largest producer of opium, with the country's opium output exceeding that of all other opium-producing countries combined. Opium poppy cultivation in Afghanistan has been a significant issue for decades, with the country capturing over 90% of the world's opiate trade.

In April 2022, the Taliban, Afghanistan's de-facto rulers, banned all cultivation of opium poppy under strict new laws. The ban was announced by the Taliban's supreme leader, Haibatullah Akhundzada, who stated that "all Afghans are informed that from now on, cultivation of poppy has been strictly prohibited across the country." The Taliban's interior ministry spokesman, Abdul Nafi Takor, affirmed their commitment, stating, "We are committed to bringing poppy cultivation to zero."

The ban on opium poppy cultivation in Afghanistan had far-reaching consequences for the many farmers who relied on the crop for their livelihood. Afghanistan's economy was already facing challenges due to international sanctions and a severe drought, and the ban further impacted the farmers' ability to earn a living. Poppy farmers expressed their concerns about the lack of profitability in alternative crops and the difficulty of surviving without the income from opium.

The United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) reported that opium cultivation in Afghanistan fell by 95% from 2022 to 2023, decreasing from 233,000 hectares to 10,800 hectares. This sharp decline put pressure on farmers and could have major consequences for the country's economy, where around two-thirds of the population depend on humanitarian aid.

While the Taliban previously banned poppy cultivation during their first rule in the late 1990s, they later relied on the crop for funding after being ousted in 2001. The group's complicated relationship with opium cultivation continued during their second rule, as they faced the challenge of enforcing the ban while also addressing the economic needs of the country.

Opium is the essential ingredient for heroin

Opium is a depressant drug derived from the opium poppy (Papaver somniferum L.). It is a sticky, dark-brown gum with a strong odour and can also be manufactured into a liquid or powder. It is often smoked, eaten raw, made into a pill, or drunk as a tincture.

Opium is the essential ingredient for manufacturing heroin. Heroin is a synthetic substance that uses opium as its primary active ingredient. The manufacturing process involves converting the opium into pure morphine, which is then chemically altered to become heroin. This process produces a substance with a higher level of potency than opium extract, resulting in more euphoria and, eventually, more significant problems.

Heroin is an opioid, and there are places in the United States where it is cheaper to buy than prescription opioids. Surveys indicate that approximately 5% of people who abuse prescription drugs progress to heroin use. Heroin abuse has doubled in the past decade, and it is very much in demand on the streets due to its potency.

Afghanistan is the world's largest producer of opium, and its production has steadily increased over the past two decades, despite billions of dollars spent by the US to eradicate poppy cultivation. Opium revenues, all unofficial, illegal, and untaxed, are estimated to account for half of Afghanistan's gross national product.

In April 2022, the Taliban banned poppy cultivation in Afghanistan, aiming to wipe out the country's massive production of opium and heroin. However, this ban poses significant challenges for impoverished farmers and day labourers who rely on the crop for their livelihoods, especially amid the country's economic collapse and severe drought.

The US spent over $8 billion trying to eradicate poppy production

Afghanistan has been growing opium poppies for many years, and the trade has only increased over time. The country is the world's largest producer of opium, and it is a major source of heroin in Europe and Asia.

The US has spent over $8 billion trying to eradicate poppy production in Afghanistan. Despite this massive investment, Afghanistan remains the world's largest opium producer, and opium poppy is the country's largest cash crop. The US counter-narcotics efforts included eradication initiatives, alternative development programs, interdiction operations, and counterdrug law enforcement. However, these programs failed to achieve lasting reductions in poppy cultivation or opium production.

One of the main issues with the US-led counter-narcotics efforts was the lack of coordination and consistent implementation. Eradication and development assistance efforts were often not conducted in the same geographic locations, and there was a lack of sustained commitment to narcotics issues at senior levels of the US and Afghan governments. Additionally, the focus on eradication was based on flawed assumptions and poor data, and it often alienated rural communities whose livelihoods depended on poppy cultivation.

Alternative development programs were also too short-term and narrowly focused on crop substitution, which contributed to the displacement of people and the relocation of poppy cultivation to areas outside government control. These programs failed to provide sustainable alternatives to poppy cultivation and sometimes even inadvertently contributed to increased poppy production.

The failure of the US-led counter-narcotics efforts can also be attributed to the complex nature of the illicit drug economy in Afghanistan, which involves multiple groups such as farmers, middlemen (traffickers and refiners), insurgents, the Afghan government, and coalition forces. The Taliban, for example, have been involved in the narcotics trade and have profited from it through taxes and fees.

Furthermore, the counter-narcotics efforts were operating in a challenging security and economic environment, with widespread insecurity, lack of licit economic opportunities, and limited government presence in areas where drug production was concentrated. Without improved security, governance, and economic growth, it will be difficult to achieve sustained reductions in Afghan poppy cultivation and drug production.

Opium cultivation in Afghanistan is driven by poverty and instability

Afghanistan has long had a history of opium poppy cultivation and harvest. The country has been the world's leading illicit drug producer since 2001. In 2007, 93% of the non-pharmaceutical-grade opiates on the world market originated in Afghanistan. By 2019, Afghanistan still produced about 84% of the world market.

The dry climate and difficulty of transporting fresh produce make export agriculture hard in Afghanistan. The opium poppy, however, is drought-tolerant, doesn't spoil on long voyages, is easy to transport and store, and sells for a premium. With a farm gate price of approximately $125 per kilogram for dry opium (2007 prices), an Afghan farmer can make 17 times more profit growing opium poppy ($4,622 per hectare) than by growing wheat ($266 per hectare).

The UK government's approach in Afghanistan is based on the recognition that poverty and instability continue to drive farmers to produce opium. The insurgency in the south prevents access to agricultural commodity and labour markets, so crops other than opium are not practical to produce. With a swift turnover and high returns, opium gets farmers the best credit, access, and influence.

The Taliban, who took power in Afghanistan in 2021, issued an edict in early April banning poppy cultivation throughout the country. The ban will likely strike a heavy blow to millions of impoverished farmers and day laborers who rely on proceeds from the crop to survive. The ban comes as Afghanistan's economy has collapsed, cut off from international funding in the wake of the Taliban takeover. Most of the population struggles to afford food, and the country has been suffering under its worst drought in years.

Afghan farmers claim that "government officials take bribes for turning a blind eye to the drug trade while punishing poor opium growers." The Taliban, as well as warlords and various other criminal elements, are known to be involved in the opium trade, and making a handsome profit from it.

In 2022, the opium crop in Afghanistan was the most profitable in years, with cultivation up by nearly a third amid soaring prices, and despite the multiple humanitarian and economic crises facing the country. Opium prices soared following the announcement of the cultivation ban in April. Income made by Afghan farmers from opium sales more than tripled, from $425 million in 2021 to $1.4 billion in 2022.

In 2023, opium poppy cultivation in Afghanistan plunged by an estimated 95% following the drug ban imposed by the de facto authorities in April 2022. Opium cultivation fell across all parts of the country, from 233,000 hectares to just 10,800 hectares in 2023. The decrease has led to a corresponding 95% drop in the supply of opium, from 6,200 tons in 2022 to just 333 tons in 2023.

The sharp reduction has had immediate humanitarian consequences for many vulnerable rural communities who relied on income from cultivating opium. Farmers’ income from selling the 2023 opium harvest to traders fell by more than 92% from an estimated US$1,360 million for the 2022 harvest to US$110 million in 2023.

Frequently asked questions