The Complex Identity Politics Of The Taliban: Afghan Nationalism In Question

The Taliban is a predominantly Pashtun, Islamic fundamentalist group that returned to power in Afghanistan in 2021 after waging an insurgency against the U.S.-backed government in Kabul since 2001. The Taliban first rose to power in the 1990s, capturing the capital city of Kabul in 1996 and establishing the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan. They ruled most of Afghanistan until they were overthrown by U.S.-led forces in 2001.

The Taliban's ideology is rooted in Pashtun tribal culture and a strict interpretation of Sharia law, or Islamic law. They have been widely condemned for their harsh treatment of Afghans, particularly women, and for committing massacres, denying humanitarian aid, and destroying cultural heritage.

The Taliban's resurgence in 2021 has led to a deterioration of human rights in Afghanistan. They have imposed severe restrictions on women and girls, limited freedom of expression, and committed extrajudicial killings and other human rights abuses. The international community has not recognized the Taliban government and has frozen billions of dollars in Afghan assets.

The Taliban's treatment of women and girls

Since retaking control of Afghanistan in 2021, the Taliban have imposed a series of restrictions on women's rights and freedoms. Women have been banned from working in most sectors, from leaving their homes without a male relative, from accessing public baths, parks, and gyms, and from moving freely around the country. They have also been banned from attending secondary school and university, and from participating in sports.

Women who violate these rules face punishments such as flogging, stoning, and worse.

The Taliban's restrictions have had a severe impact on women's mental health, with widespread reports of depression and suicide, particularly among adolescent girls.

The Taliban's treatment of women has been internationally condemned as a violation of human rights.

The Taliban's relationship with Pakistan

Historical Context

The Taliban, a predominantly Pashtun, Islamic fundamentalist group, rose to power in Afghanistan in the 1990s after waging an insurgency against the US-backed government. Pakistan played a significant role in the Taliban's rise, providing support and safe havens across the porous border. The Taliban's movement grew out of religious students who joined the anti-Communist uprising and were integrated into provincial organizations as separate "fronts" inside Afghanistan.

Strategic Asset

Pakistan's security establishment viewed the Taliban as a valuable strategic asset in its anti-India policies. The Taliban's Islamic ideology and Pashtun nationalism aligned with Pakistan's interests in the region. Pakistan's support included soliciting funding, providing diplomatic backing, arranging training, and facilitating shipments of ammunition.

Changing Dynamics

However, the dynamics between the two have changed since the Taliban regained control of Afghanistan in 2021. The Taliban's military victory has inspired those seeking to impose Sharia law in Pakistan, causing concern within the Pakistani state about blowback. The Taliban's relationship with Pakistan is also affected by the presence of other regional powers, such as Russia, China, and Qatar, who played a role in bringing the Taliban to the negotiating table.

Tensions and Clashes

Tensions between the two have risen due to border disputes, with the Taliban refusing to accept the Durand Line as the international border. Clashes along this disputed border have become more frequent, and the Taliban's refusal to take action against the Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan (TTP), an anti-Pakistan insurgent group, has further strained relations. The TTP has launched escalating terror campaigns inside Pakistan, and the Pakistani government has accused the Afghan Taliban of providing safe havens for these militants.

Future Prospects

The future of the Taliban-Pakistan relationship is uncertain. Pakistan's unpopularity in Afghanistan has made the Taliban cautious about being perceived as puppets of Islamabad. At the same time, Pakistan's leadership had expected the Taliban to help control the TTP but has been disappointed in this regard. Pakistan's influence over the Taliban seems to be waning, and the Taliban are sending signals that they may be less amenable to receiving instructions from Pakistan.

In conclusion, the Taliban-Pakistan relationship is complex and evolving. While Pakistan has been a key supporter of the Taliban, the dynamics between the two are changing as the Taliban consolidates power and pursues its own interests in the region. The future of this relationship will have significant implications for both countries and the broader region.

The Taliban's treatment of ethnic minorities

The Taliban have been accused of committing massacres against Shi'ite Hazaras, and enforcing harsh rules on the group. In 1998, the Taliban were accused of slaughtering thousands of Shi'ite Hazaras in Mazar-e-Sharif. The Taliban also enforced rules that Sikhs and Hindus had to wear yellow badges for identification, and pay jizya taxes for not being Muslim.

The Taliban have also been accused of discrimination against Shi'ites in the education system, banning Shi'ite teachings at universities, and banning marriages between Shi'ites and Sunnis in Badakhshan province.

The Taliban have also been accused of discrimination against other ethnic minorities. They have been accused of evicting people from the Hazara ethnic group from their homes and land, and settling disputes over land and livestock in favour of Pashtun communities. They have also been accused of forcibly disappearing and detaining members of the Baloch community.

The Taliban have also been accused of discrimination against women, banning them from most forms of employment, and severely restricting their access to education.

The Taliban's treatment of the media

1996-2001: Maximum Control

During their first period of rule from 1996 to 2001, the Taliban imposed strict bans on various forms of media and entertainment. They banned the internet, dismantled state-run television stations, criminalized watching television, and prohibited music. They also enforced censorship and propaganda in the remaining state-run radio stations. The Taliban's moral police, known as the Promotion of Virtue and Prevention of Vice (PVPV), enforced these laws, and offenders were punished with jail time or public humiliation. As a result, international and regional media had limited to no presence in the country, and local media was under the Taliban's control.

2001-2021: An Insurgent Media

After being dislodged from power following the 2001 US intervention, the Taliban's approach to media changed significantly. They adapted to the evolving media landscape and took advantage of new technologies, such as social media platforms and encrypted messaging applications. The Taliban utilized a decentralized media strategy, creating a strong online presence on platforms like Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, Telegram, and TikTok. They also established themselves as a nationalist group fighting against foreign invaders, bolstering their legitimacy and appealing to the local population.

August 2021-Present: Media Blackout and Social Control

Since regaining control of Afghanistan in August 2021, the Taliban have implemented regulatory restrictions and punitive measures to limit free speech and control the media. They have shut down many TV and radio channels, imposed strict regulations and censorship on remaining outlets, and restricted female journalists. The Taliban have also threatened and persecuted journalists who criticize their government or leadership. At the same time, they have tried to project an image of moderation and control the flow of information into and out of the country.

While the Taliban have allowed some media operations to continue, their approach is largely characterized by strict control and censorship. They have banned and expelled several national and international news services and imposed vague guidelines and restrictions on journalists. As a result, many media outlets have been forced to close, and a significant number of journalists have lost their jobs or practiced self-censorship to avoid retribution.

In conclusion, the Taliban's treatment of the media has evolved over time, ranging from maximum control during their first period of rule to a more adaptive and decentralized strategy during their insurgency. Since regaining power, they have opted for a mix of accommodation and tight control, seeking to project an image of moderation while restricting free speech and independent media.

The Taliban's treatment of the LGBTQ+ community

Afghanistan's LGBTQ+ community has always lived in fear of persecution and violence, but the situation has become increasingly dire since the Taliban takeover in 2021. The Taliban's interpretation of Sharia law deems homosexuality a crime punishable by death, and they have a history of brutally enforcing this through public executions. While the previous government also criminalised same-sex relations, the Taliban have taken a harder line, with reports of LGBTQ+ Afghans being targeted, attacked, and killed.

Under the Taliban regime, LGBTQ+ Afghans face the constant threat of violence and discrimination from not only the Taliban but also their own families, neighbours, and romantic partners. Many have been forced to conceal their identities, living in constant fear of being outed. Those who do not conform to rigid gender norms, such as transgender individuals, are particularly vulnerable to abuse.

The Taliban's strict religious views on homosexuality have limited any opportunity for public discussion, with the topic remaining a taboo in Afghan society. This has made it difficult for the LGBTQ+ community to organise and seek help. Additionally, the lack of recognition for same-sex relationships and the absence of anti-discrimination laws further exacerbate the situation.

The situation has led to a surge in requests for help from organisations like Rainbow Railroad, which assists at-risk LGBTQ+ individuals in finding refuge and resettling in safer countries. However, even fleeing the country is challenging due to border restrictions and the risk of being turned in by family or acquaintances trying to curry favour with the Taliban.

The treatment of the LGBTQ+ community by the Taliban has been characterised by widespread human rights abuses, including revenge killings, systematic discrimination, and severe restrictions on freedom of expression. The Taliban's leaders have vowed to take a hard line against LGBTQ+ rights, and their actions have made it clear that the community faces an even more dangerous and uncertain future under their rule.

Frequently asked questions